Loading...
2024-08-13 IX.D. Ex.12 Exhibit 12 IX. D. Exhibit #12 Case #240314003 Donald A. Hayes Jr. & Crystal L. Staton Exhibit 12 Code Enforcement Hearing August 13, 2024 Case Number, Name and Address: Case#240314003, Donald A Hayes Jr & Crystal L Staton, 1002 NW 6' St, Okeechobee Code Section Violated Description of Violation Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled Disabled/unregistered vehicle in the rear of the vehicles property in the alleyway,junk,trash, and debris all over the property, and being stored on an airboat. Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30- Overgrown grass, weeds, bushes, shrubs, and trees, 44 General cleaning and beautification and the exterior of the home needs to be cleaned Photos: See attached Is respondent a Repeat Violator? No Summary: • The respondent was first notified on February 14, 2024, via Courtesy Card. • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of notice Type of notice Received Date by received /returned April 9, 2024 The case was presented to the Special Magistrate, found in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. A fine of$50.00 per day, plus a one-time $50.00 administrative fee imposed to begin on April 10, 2024, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance on or before that date. April 10, 2024 Lien/Order recorded at the Okeechobee County Clerk of Court, File #2024003923, Page(s):1. April 11, 2024 Recorded Lien/Order mailed out via USPS certified return receipt. Crystal April 18, Staton 2024. May 10, 2024 Homeowner Ms. Staton called into the office and spoke with Code Officer Smith and advised that the property was compliant and ready for an inspection. I advised her that I would be out to inspect the property for compliance. Also advised the homeowner that a letter of compliance with the fine balance would be sent to them if the property is compliant. Code Officer Smith inspected the property @ 4:17pm: in compliance, the disabled vehicle removed from the property, outside of the home was cleaned and trash debris removed from the property, and overgrown vegetation was cut. Photos in file. Fine balance from April 10, 2024, to May 6, 2024, of$1350.00 plus $50.00 administration fee totaling $1400.00. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 12 Date of notice Type of notice Received Date by received /returned May 10, 2024 Compliance Letter with fine total mailed out via USPS certified return Crystal May 20, receipt. Staton 2024 City Recommendation: The City recommends no action on this matter, but requests it be noted for the record that the Lien/Order was recorded on April 11, 2024, the property came into compliance on May 10, 2024, with a lien balance of$1,350.00 plus a $50.00 administration fee. Chronology attached Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 12 Case #240314003, Donald A Hayes, Jr., & Crystal L Staton Date Event/Document February 12, 2024 Property owner: Donald A Hayes Jr & Crystal L Staton Property address: 1002 NW 6th St, Okeechobee Mailing address: 1002 NW 6th St. Okeechobee, FL 34972 Parcel ID: 3-15-37-35-0010-01310-0140 (33859) Legal Description: Lots 17 & West half of Lot 18, Block 17, NORTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE Plat Book 1 Page 25, Okeechobee County public records. Code Officer Smith and Curl observed the above-mentioned property to be in violation of the City Ordinances Chapter 30 Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification: overgrown grass, weeds, bushes, shrubs, and trees, disabled unregistered vehicle in the rear of the property in the alleyway, and junk, trash, and debris all over the property. Junk/debris stored on an airboat. The exterior of the home in need of being power washed. Photos in file. February 14, 2024 Courtesy Card, photos, and city ordinances mailed via USPS regular mail, giving the property owner 14 days to correct the violation March 11. 2024 Code Officer Smith inspected the property; still non-compliant, grass, weeds, shrubs, bushes, and trees remain overgrown. Junk, trash, and debris remain all over the property, disabled vehicle remain in the city right of way. The exterior of the home needs maintenance. Photos in the file. March 14, 2024 SOV/NOH, photos and a copy of the city ordinance mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the April 9`h Hearing. Received by Crystal Staton on March 20, 2024. April 2. 2024 Code Officer Smith inspected the property; still non-compliant, junk, trash, and debris remain all over the property, disabled vehicle remains in the city right of way. The exterior of the home needs maintenance. There has been progress made with cutting of the overgrown vegetation. Photos in file. April 9, 2024 The case was presented to the Special Magistrate, found in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. A fine of$50.00 per day, plus a one-time $50.00 administrative fee imposed to begin on April 10, 2024, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance on or before that date. April 10, 2024 Lien/Order recorded at the Okeechobee County Clerk of Court, File #2024003923, Page(s):1. April 11, 2024 Recorded Lien/Order mailed out via USPS certified return receipt. Received by Crystal Staton on April 18, 2024. May 10, 2024 Homeowner Ms. Staton called into the office and spoke with Code Officer Smith and advised that the property was compliant and ready for an inspection. I advised her that I would be out to inspect the property for compliance. Also advised the homeowner that a letter of compliance with the fine balance would be sent to them if the property is compliant. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 12 Case #240314003, Donald A Hayes, Jr., & Crystal L Staton Date Event/Document Code Officer Smith inspected the property @ 4:17pm: in compliance, the disabled vehicle removed from the property, outside of the home was cleaned and trash debris removed from the property, and overgrown vegetation was cut. Photos in file. Fine balance from April 10. 2024. to May 6, 2024. of $1350.00 plus $50.00 administration fee totaling $1400.00. May 10, 2024 Compliance Letter with fine total mailed out via USPS certified return receipt. Received by Crystal Staton on May 20, 2024. Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 12 '!i I .40f. - 4.c. a. - -- 1W.7.TH ST • Is" Aitte'. ' il . . lir . . ., ,,:...,-.. ...- , . Oliklkiiiii; S _�! G� ti� IS r, ' 7481 ... C..._ 1 V$ wf' f . it i •.1 i( { • i -- R. . -- 1._ st,--..11 11 Ait).,iot f iFi tt . . - .. ems- "�", #. • . ii: r1,,,....•.•4.N..!A.-At....::••:.':.' .,... . ,..•• ... xrf .4 r fiy�: -. . 4,.. '.:.,;...4.205.:.,Lij., ;,,,,1 •, mi.::„e. -„.•..' :::1:;:,.......... ,... . iiiiiiii ._ . , 0 10 , -,•.,I• i4- g'•a,-1r,, •. $.$o,.r frr !� '..-,..'...•-. '•'., _, • Al.' �'t .#= - T_ Jb•••4-•••,''-..- iI. .t•• .:''':*.4 r yyT !1 {•� Ijf w ! r L, ,wf -_,..11'4,, • 1 r y 11W 6TH ST '.1$111?{ ` _ _ atik: 01110 tos - , -.-— Jo: ' 1141/4, 41: Jill! C' i I I• _ • 1 i MEIN =: M11 ' p Al, , ' 4 fiitigigitaga, MIR :4- , ,L ., w. jp • •:. • ..--- .„.... „web. . '. ..t. I *144, 0 07 134 20I 268 335 402 4139 536 603 670 ft Okeechobee County Property Appraiser Mickey L.Band'.CFA I Okeechobee,Florida 1863-763-4422 PARCEL: 3-16-37-35-0160-00170-0170 (34457) (SINGLE FAMILY(0100)1 0.241 AC NOTES: Okeechobee County,FL NORTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE(PLAT BOOK 1 PAGE 25)LOT 17 8 WEST 1/2 OF LOT 18 BLOCK 17 HAYES DONALD A JR 2023 Certified Values Owner STATON CRYSTAL L Mkt Lnd $14,550 Appraised $130,025 1002 NW 6TH ST Ag Lnd $0 Assessed $130,025 OKEECHOBEE,FL 34972 Bldg $112,514 Exempt $0 Site: 1002 NW 6TH ST OKEECHOBEE r: 21712023 $100 (u) XFOB $2,961 county:$113,325 i Sales 1/24/2023 $0 I(U) Just $130,025 Total city:$113,325 Info 1/24/2023 $0 I(U) Taxable sc 1 ther: 13,325 The information presented on this website was derived from data which was compiled by the Okeechobee County Property Appraiser Office solely for the governmental purpose of property assessment.This information should not be relied upon by anyone as a determination of the ownership of property or market value.No warranties.expressed or implied,are provided for the accuracy of the data herein, is use.or it's interpretation,This website was last updated:2/8/2024 and may not reflect the data currently on file at our office. GrizzlyLogic.com Exhibit 12 Jta +£e .r' + f 1 11111%7016, - . ,t ,‘, r—w �-_ J�Jdpw+s. �— J� 1� 0 r lab flif I i 1 rtf r`# Ib+ A 01 -.4.4; F.**,\ 1,, _ .. li" ' 4.,4' ,w 4 r _,Ilc_ __ - ,--, '' a P It • 1 [ 6 ,1 E • �Sr�i_4.+ Jg \•\k i .l ` ' t-*1"d�' t "':S tip.a� 9 - f!c a� . f _ f'1,},,,k?. li .':_ 3.-.% 11� a C,� - (,t I, ..._ Ir r 1� ..w - _ - *° '�'� ,� _ ,..- .IR/•,tip.t 01' r. ~ .ti l �,-,/f 't Y '`� '!S-`yAM: ~ :.k• ,Yf'- ,.: [' r ''la •4 •i . :�)11T202042 . 9g:a3 • LI Yf `1,r2dIkr,'W. - si T ' ' -4.: i tor' • . , '• 4:44• - •47.1 tlio.,,. .11 4*"•• II. et' ^ i lb... . ..4' .,, ,10. ,, . . . ,4 ., , v • , , .,,ot , -,.... .,4,:',..1,,t . p 1.•14.• 4 t.'1• ,,t . it tit,,.. . .' ' - '. , • .* Jr'.1-- ,e,. - - , 4 :tif 17., 4 • it •••• tr f`,,,, • '•• , , '. Wr..: 4 C. •• , k...., . '444:: • . . ,, , ..,.,; ., . • •,, .• ' ,• ,.. . y• •,. ..- „,‘.4A A 0 , IA_. , • • .1 ..) ,. 4-,,, • -.‘: NI., ' ' r - gt.,, •* ,4•-,,..,11'...- -- 0 4 41 : '. 7,',', , '. .. ,„, . -• -.... . ., -- ' -• " ,,,if y , ••••''' • 440 ., ,ga - 4- — 4. • i 1 • 1 e . ;- I ;..S..1 11:' -1 _ t '• 4. , - - lir„,'"•••• , , )1, .."‘• c•K-"• •-- • r,le;i1' " '“ •7. ' I ...--.., .i I 11 ' q'er 1 - ----- .--'1 ''"---4411f.,,Ag,Abtia• - its‘, A 1 -,- ,-%ILI • ,4 .• • ••'43' A.i 1 '•*.' '' . ,k'S.WY1'•• V•••. .!r'1' li/07;tiP'r.'r :I r 41% = ••'' 011 IX'.11c4.,•-'-4:*`4*:'..;11.1"'4,."-t, s t-, _r7, ''''''Xtri,".' -1,,...4'4,4.• • •,..''"",1.e.•-•4 ;:#16e,,:I .,, t. ' 1 -, it'i. ,1 ,-,,,f a 11 , • -'''.-.''0' "10."V• — ' . *—. b ,,,. '1/4."*..,114.1Cre...,4• . II i . ;t: • . .4,„.t.14-4/ ' . D20112110261 io:a6 • • vt4,,, lik - . I. ' r... • -1. .1• • • \•- - . '- ••• •141:.'t/ . - 4.. ".'.,,.. • "1.• ..r.' VI *.. if'• ..•- 41 '• •-. '', ' i • •• •4.,..i;1 _ .„ ' ".., :stat , I, 4 . ... ,-- '1,1 4 , •' ',-, y N .... . ,L ' -, ' •-•,,,•s-P'.;1'1,4 •-,'1.‘• ••• ' . P . - ... , .... . . .. .. •-• .. ,.., ,,,,--• - „,-, . ..., 4, , . ..41<-10., , e; : '..' -".alli...4•NC' ; ' ,...... .". ;; .p3 •• 't , ...„.„ • ,....• " 1,-•%,.• yol •`-, , . ,_ .f .. . •' ___•.- • 1 •,-"4" ic i _„,...- ,‘..----__...._diT„..- ........0, . .. 4,.. „,- ,60, %, , i 04 ii p • 1 •,,,•;* , • 1., • . -411111111610rrt ;Ito-• ' ,;t.' I r '0,, ' ; m, 4 • , - ".1'llt 41;;• 'W:" ' • • . . L * .t;:: A ....'4.71 -; 1.-;-: ,.' . *P.' ..c...,,,, I., ,,,,H. La" '.r•...71,,A '"ig L, N,s ' . nil — '`-` Ott-- —',. „-jii 6 .• de..,L,tePAlir 'E.... • kt,tik,,,, • ... 1 A--'14. ef .- .*-... . •trialf tz,,t,.. . ' . ' -4' i .., , „ ...... raw, t ''' ..- • .. .sc.,cor,,--,i 4".45•;:---.... -. .4.. • :-..k..,, ,.. 14,eri,i4 , , ,-,, 3, ..*...- -t• 4t -. •,.• "' J •:-J i; -• ' :". - -...)".". .:, *,, "*"?''.' e .4.'. '-•" ..' ';':.-r! "4,O'.`.1'. , •1 1; ''',...*4".4..*•74. ,, . • 1.1 ; : ' • , . irt ii .".''''. ,%r,' '" ' " •:•5. 1--';;•' . , ,.., ,-, --' •'', - .. . , -•,, .ff.4e-i.- —4 ii-r, a t.• .,A?* *- - , . . -.,, • . . . ---- icmtit, •,,,,- " •k-,!;,- .10!- .4-4,1 -,' 7" '..-,,- . . - .. ., -.1.4 ,,.' = - -t •...,1i . ' • , . , , AA , 4,, • . , e" , . -•' 44110- ,. . • 1 -... - ' .., - I -, - U2111121120241 , TU:g4 , Exhibit 12 ••`.r} . , '`,.1..'.^ 't a ,�_' -• ,ham'?ati ,t(� 7r.,'.. ,e y' 1"` ' . kfa4, S •r 4,' i s P, ' -` - - f •!� • ►" a • 7s•. - • . r .: •` *x`, . ` 1-•• r - fl 1r • ` • -- ,1 e .. . 4.,_. ,. ,,„ti, • it `-_,#i., .: is it ....^ir.`° ,.�,'i �;.�'�. ? .,° t ..; ?-%—• � � r t'Ir ,�f. •• 'a,.,. :k r K,,- .1'„r' `j . `� .� f j 1 f.. a• '''",y•, it, , fir'' f� -i• l�.4 ,'� rA );'y 4 "-' • :.:..;,..,s...'),--'''410,",- , . '•' ',..;,4;0-Sk`n.-0•• ... •'-- • ',--•' :,.•,;41_,(4.1-,%,1 '',..-,....,:i---•„ -,..t.;-,- .- :.-; U211 1120 0241 -ii y X t i•: Y IT ma '• y. T l . ... . . ,. ..A,,,,,.I k:'p 4(,.1: 440. , , K r • 2 -- - .Iasi i ^fir 74.0 vt aR�ii.K' w; ;. rl. ` 'J t, ERR.' r- .. , 4r44 - ' ;:',-,4, . l'-.:1 le....-0,-C.:24 . .•. :,,i1j4till''''.4'-'11.111--". ,tr, .'.,!'.1 :• .fir'-tip;'• ''' ,,02/1 .24S•. 15 •3. .ate ' 41M. , eM. ._` •r`. 4 v :.. ., *_ 7;1; i_ ,-."7IC"r` '-11;,-._..._ "S'- . •r "'�._`-�'sG ":.• ire' +iL' '"' "^.•4S `- d : j:..,; ... 04,; .k,.. ,vor„.....:.4......1.:, r . .• ',... . . ., • - -.10.‘t1 LA:, • • IN - s , -, . -• , •T y '. ' - A,510...,' werkt.'r" _ '..":, i I N . .1.7V. - , .,' . . toSiOlr' . lir Ifil tr • - '." •-••• .-a, •..,.. .. .. • ....„-- " ,•,..„...• •,i-..-, -- - , -.-4.-..)0,..‘...,-- !ii-li ,0.--.4.. -.. . y,.. 0,- . ,, ..• . .._ . , .,... . .. •"fp '. # , .,.n. ,M1.° .-4,..,1: 4,•,,,,1! ;4 : v, .*. . ,,.; ,t,/ Ty 4 ''' . 60i ..., • ' " 4Lie..i..,:;" 't ' ., .i". - i., 7 , .• , •-, 'NJ.-- '_._...4 . t',' .`arr '.. , . 4.••-. . ; , 4'IF,'. k.'•.‘rir‘-'. '7".4, .. i' •-. J. ir .. 'r i ' ", • ''' • -- al ..., . ..‘:".,/, • '1/4 - `• 1 • i I ..• l / •• .. . • . .- 004000410-.- ,,, . :•••,.,. _::'*• ..-:!.jr . i ....1,4v7-704itirrod4r--•-....e.:4-1,c,_•• . . 1`. :Ai I-11I ..:,w -. •lg?iltN•0110,06/' .,A.-eit4 ,- .-: __ ..., • , ,,, 1" i ,, •7.- ,. • . , . \ . . , 1 (02§ 202026,1 'il :gg ... .. .• • , - .• •• --, .• • / - ... - _ .1.-er i- If- - • ... . ...,. .....s. ,,,:...1, ,...ii, :71iet.. .,..j... -r•r , „ ' I' '''' - — • '•.!•,-,•,ft,"' tic.,••-•.0-.; , ..-,.•• • f .• •r. liTirifN ' - 'IV.'" 4010 - ,• ,44.7,‘..r.,e ...„ .• , '„..* :.•-...„ • 144-'i••''''''''' k. .•-,,,..,• . ;•-• ,• • A. • .... ..'" 1.,, .....„... . ‘..e. : Oh''.Yk ' i‘ a, ' •:,......41'..:,,p7. -, , ,isiL ;^ ' 401° - ..:' - s . ''' , .IV. 4...:. iir? • * 4.A.1%. ,• i.o , I 12 ,.. Oks. , v T.1144,0,,,7,71,-.4 4.:,t1:4. ,• ,...,,,• ,:7,76/44110 . , •..,...",,,......- :, ,.•• • .i. - 1--:. ak .., . .71':. . ; • r ,..1...;4.1 4,. ' w 4.0 l t -- 1,00 141Cliig lia • LL:=-.T.-.1$ IrP .II iiJI ..., i'/, Ar'.. '• ..- ii-11.4•`' .- •...4i., ,71E.-7.--10001/grat§1011 11:. ''''. r• ' *1-!*!•• .,, .•rk,z74& . - . ,. * .- • 4•Or ' -- . . . ..--' - . • -'"`,--•• •''''- '541 ' . ', 'e ':: -•,`..'•'" '-IN ,..41.-- ‘...4. . •-• " •• ....t, •,-9. ',"•77t,r'....- - - ....AC:7;:N. , ..' .1'4`t, " 1 - - -0- , - , • . ,f •-•` . • • "-` - ' '..,-. ../..' •-•••••'.J.0 '. • ': .*f.:?. %3- . •.:-.... ',' 1,-.. ..,$1'4. . _. • • ...„...4i12o. - . . • -....-A-.. .,..t.y...•,!...; , .... . •• -,,,At---....,., •_,-- . „,..-.4,e.- ., 4..„. : _ .4..A. ,1 ',,• ..,.., ....- 4, "• '4-,,'- c.,,i,.1.4..•i.*1,.,•-'-L'-.?t'ti'.•-.t._..I,•,-i f•-7•-,,•_'.:-l/,'-.'2 4,•.r•.,.,„‘-,k.,..'„,.-':.....1-...•.•;,...'4...x;•.-•,l-,.t...t.;-...-t,,i--,r.-.,.'-4 4`..-..I-:.-i..i s.-..:,...-,..-,'.•.".•''. •,•.'..'•-..3.-.A-..:b4.r..•..,•s.‘'.•7-,10-,..04.,..,'.,..-.,...!1f',-'.l,-% ,...z.--••--0•.,e-O':.•1_r6--...:a-Tf,'.e .-•.1,.-•-]"•'_•.....:.._4 ...-, ,!( •: - 1 p. :. A; . . ' ' $. ; •. ..•.. '',.0 . 3.N---.S,-..'..7,- -_. •,-..-..:!-•---.i n, 02/ 1 -.- ._.,,, _ ‘ -„..:,... -.., ••,„_. . .. 7 "'elk ...,1r- .. „,.. '‘.;.., '‘Illiit".r..16.41,S.1"" -.;:,1,-.. • '':.lc... - ' ,,. .'--• -.7P.'-''',!1... -.,' . ,„,*,. - , - i -,..,, .?..." - . . •.• .14- rr: tist"4.1.' . a.t*- , • ,t, . . . , .:41;iik,-., .. ,, . 1..,.., ....LI. r.. . .‘• , .- ;?e, ‘''.., -14---- •--..4„".x. Mak. . • •• , . ... . 4.Q1 . _ .• .• _3 '' -rit.,. ••if,,..-- • - ' 1--','' •'..,,r, _s. - ,.. Exhibit 12 j - r i„,c, 1'aY•-a' ri S € ,mcgewi ;_,,- - -16: 1 - .:„. , I: -,,, .. SS4.44 i : ax• , j '1 �', .4 1 L-. .. ;..i..- .i "'ir 'mil'-4'r: ,1 .- . ...• ._.s,.. ‘. /- _ .,a ,, •a ,. 4.7*+`: � - 1� -il,,i, . , yf lw•`ice �+ •de. ''' �_'' •1 i J ljaglidIPI d_ ...__. — ~� . t / '' i Mq "wljj "1F..�✓ v , '`- Abet r+^ � t ,ffr '.% - •r , ;; , fm/ 02;/.12/2024 15 : 35 �;.: `/` 6 Exhibit 12 ., ; lc\ .V y1'• r. 1 4 ' lilts. i,, - j► alt`Sil' - w • -, — • ^� rit -.1Iiiiiiiiihrillir irsa.- ) ,L . . �it _ s2/12/2�024 �0ag gy PM ,..,L, , : "IL —I..i, a Ir...-- - ,.- ed61041 , • a. -- 4t Nits . '1;p :2 10. ` .,� - .,r,, a ��'•,! -. ,� C Mom-i to,. + ''. 4 4. Exhibit 12 • I .'� . ; ,e. `: k ,,per .a .. ; lit a ; _ . -• v -- F- `. .i j .- A.:......„ , _• / "„I F TArt4.f.a:- ,-- '�� , . 'cc �.,,?ry fi , 3 - *eowro�� - . Zt • l—� af' i j0 Ai at... rS�� �.4. ,y•1 . 4 'fir � t -d'` ,, :r, M '.y< .-1S' 5.. f. -53.."it7'!l'1,..5 .., , , i- y, �' --- '';�- -. r. 02/1'2' 20 15 • 36 !t It• -'- �y a- i: •� �' -1 '..r r �r�`f ;� I P " ' ,' •,mow * ,'ii °, r ri S a J- Y� • h tyi' I" y '�? • s. r h r 1' rt. +.: f 1 ..... .. ,............_ ... ..... . • •, „ . j� .4V. , , , ..,, , 4,, 4 y�.'l�R" _ oiev., j j - �i -T - • �� r • 11 • :TK ■rs• ` f t J'-r t >} 1 s ,,•+F•',." • ham.%++q�. -r ..a " ` y ` r - ^ i` - ' ' 0 2/ 12/2024 15 . 36 r6 .y• rs : . ,�•.. ., x • }(;. ! d"1.y �+ + 'A. t•l i,� -l , - .64 _ram -4" • 5 • '71 Attu --3,, yRN'.y. `!ti-.a, ',:- I�• . -`... ''�R'` • ` - , , - - • er, ..,`. ‘,„ ill . • .41 - .. .. • 0 N , i,I ?*•-.! 4 4 _ - , - , .... ‘,..•'''P ..1'; A Aa.,- i ... i 0 , . • m% 10 .4. g 1. -yi- '••••'4'11,1!.:4 \i" .../ '411. t t 1 411111* - - :, •.;, 'ptitir.1 tili T.(' ' ‘_ 1;',- mg '1' • - ,,,,,v,,--. , • 14,, , r- • - 4 '- a.— A - • •.*"*' Ct. ''• 4,.... _ 4 r, , • i..:21t .4 , , ,- ____ • - • . , ______ • _ P , . , r:k _4) ',14.. .....2.e17 .v - ., -— . '"L'''''-1.,:t.i.'‘.-:...i :; 'y';'-ft',. • 1 _ -i •44:61 N - -,--,._ ._ •• ••-.7-r.:;* .., , 1,- ----•.„-,, 1/4---..* , ,. - -, • ...„. N .Z.'..1.'re''.''' • 'i`q ....•'''.. .... , I ,. --. • '''„#_,:n N .', .. ..44111111-) -.1, i.,...., ' ADRON FERTErl tr-2624140 0 ,, it 'II , A' _oft,,- ' ''_0-•,:... • •• 1800 ..vs -, • "Pa AI,„, 482.0111 k ",_-1.,.400*111/0._2,----,02--,-,,,.....-/ .--ler. —. !".,---. •_ r- - .th..4%,- -. ..iss-— • . - I ..,t •,,if 8.___.,_A_-.1,---laciliiiiiirftsrit. ,._ ':_:,.. :7( - .. •- : • %.• -:.:1..- V., ... itai '.4 . 1 l3Y Exhibit 12 CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT APRIL 9, 2024, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING OFFICIAL MINUTES CALL TO ORDER Special Magistrate Roger Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on Tuesday, April 9, 2024, at 6:00 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast (SE) 3rd Avenue (AVE), Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special Magistrate Azcona. II. ATTENDANCE Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll: Special Magistrate Roger Azcona. Esquire,and Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith were present.City Attorney Stephen Conteaguero attended via Zoom. III. CHANGES TO AGENDA Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred, or withdrawn; Continued Cases Item V.B. was deferred to the next scheduled Hearing. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH A. Special Magistrate Azcona dispensed with the reading and approved the March 12,2024, Minutes. B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered an Oath to: Code Officers Smith and Curl, Mr. Benjamin Falk, and Mr. Ricardo Lane: all affirmed.Code Officers Smith and Curl stated for the record all events regarding the cases to be discussed occurred within the corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee.The Officer's notes. testimony, photographs, and support documents were all entered as part of the official record. V. CONTINUED CASES A. Case No. 24219005; Sam Lane do Richard Roberts, Northwest(NW) 10'h Street(ST). Okeechobee[Legal Description: Lots 1 and 2 of Block 41, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book (PB) 1, Page (PG) 10, and PB 5, PG 5 Okeechobee County public records]. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30. Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. The respondent is a repeat violator, previous Case No. 210210008. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing(SOV/NOH)was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) certified return receipt on February 20, 2024. The notice was returned unclaimed on March 25,2024.A Notice to Appear was posted on the property and the Public Notices Board at City Hall on February 22, 2024.The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on March 5, 2024. To comply with City Ordinances, the property owner needs to remove all the trash,junk/debris.and the disabled vehicle from the property. Mr. Lane appeared before the Special Magistrate and conveyed his explanations and reasonings for why the property was non-compliant and requested more time to bring the property into compliance due to the circumstances. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on March 12, 2024, and was deferred until the April 9, 2024, Hearing to allow the property owner more time to bring the property into compliance. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 14, 2024. The City has not received the SOV/NOH nor the receipt signature card as of the date of this Hearing. A Notice to Appear was posted on the property and the Public Notices Board at City Hall on March 14, 2024. April 9,2024, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 1 of 4 Exhibit 12 135 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED A. Case No.240219005;CONTINUED:The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 2, 2024. To comply with City Ordinances, the property owner needs to remove all the trash,junk/debris, and the disabled vehicle from the property. Mr. Lane appeared before the Special Magistrate and conveyed his explanations and reasonings for why the property was non-compliant and requested more time to bring the property into compliance due to the circumstances. The City Staff recommends in accordance with the fine schedule a fine of$100.00 per day, to begin on April 10, 2024, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance on or before that date. plus a $100.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided. Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 240219005 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of$100.00 per day plus a one-time$100.00 administrative fee should the property fail to come into compliance within 14-days after the date of this Hearing. B. Case No. 240215002; Kern Michael Othmer and Tammy Lynn Hogaboam, 1109 NW 9'h AVE, Okeechobee[Legal Description: Lots 1,2,and 3 of Block 24, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE. PB 1, PG 10 and PB 5, PG 5, Okeechobee County public records]. As requested by Code Officer Smith, the case was deferred until the next Hearing. C. Case No.230817007;Tanglewood LTD do A& M Properties, Inc.,420 NW 9'" ST, Okeechobee [Legal Description: Lots 7 to 20 Inclusive and alley between said lots of Block 38, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PB 5, PG 5, Okeechobee County public records]. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30. Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Section 304.1.1 Unsafe conditions. The respondent is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on July 19, 2023. The property was inspected and found to be non- compliant on August 3.2023 and August 17,2023.A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on August 17, 2023. The notice was received by Erin Wilson on August 21, 2023. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on October 4, 2023. To comply with City Ordinances the property owner needs to remove all the debris from the property and repair/replace all the roofs on the buildings. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on October 10, 2023, and found to be in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances. 30-44 General cleaning and beautification, IPMC Chapter 3. Section 304.1.1 Unsafe conditions. A fine of $100.00 per day, plus a one-time $50.00 administrative fee imposed to begin 45-days after the Hearing should the property fail to come into compliance. A Lien/Order was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on October 26, 2023. The notice was received by Erin Wilson on November 27, 2023. The City Staff received a letter from Benjamin D.E. Falk, General Partner's Vice President. and CFO with Tanglewood requesting a pause to the amounts already accrued and to set new timelines for completion of the roofs on February 13, 2024. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on February 15, 2024. The notice was received by Erin Wilson on February 23, 2024. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on February 27, 2024,and April 2, 2024. To comply with City Ordinances the property owner needs to replace the roofs on all buildings. Mr. Falk appeared before the Special Magistrate and conveyed his explanations and reasonings for why the property was non-compliant. He requested additional time to bring the property into compliance due to the circumstances. April 9, 2024, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 2 of 4 136 Exhibit 12 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED C. Case No. 230817007; CONTINUED: The City Staff recommends in accordance with the Special Magistrate's order issued on October 10,2023, that the Lien/Order be recorded in public records with an accrued lien balance of$13,750.00 due to failure to comply with the order. Based on the evidence provided,Special Magistrate Azcona ruled for the Lien/Order to be recorded in public records with a lien balance of $13,750.00 and for the City Staff to make a follow-up recommendation for the roof repair timeline and the delay of fine accrual. VI. NEW CASES A. Case No.240215003; Rebecca Bodey and Christina A. Rutherford, 501 SE 6th ST, Okeechobee [Legal Description: Lots 20 and 21 of Block E, CENTRAL PARK, PB 2, PG 39, Okeechobee County public records]. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30. Sections 30-43 Public nuisances. 30-44 General cleaning and beautification, IPMC Chapter 3, Section 304.1 General. The respondent is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on August 17, 2023. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on February 12,2024.A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on February 15. 2024. The notice was returned on March 8, 2024. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on March 11, 2024.A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS regular mail, and A Notice to Appear was posted on the property and the Public Notices Board at City Hall on March 14, 2024. The City Staff received a contract for the sale of the property on March 28, 2024. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 2,2024.To comply with City Ordinances, the property owner needs to remove the trash/debris and complete the maintenance to the exterior of the home. The City Staff recommends deferring the case to the next scheduled hearing to allow the new property owner a reasonable amount of time to bring the property into compliance. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona ruled to defer Case No. 240215003 to the next Special Magistrate Hearing, May 11, 2024. B. Case No. 240314003: Donald A. Hayes, Jr., and Crystal L. Staton, 1002 NW 6th ST, Okeechobee [Legal Description: Lot 17 and West half of Lot 18 of Block 17, NORTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, PB 1, PG 25, Okeechobee County public records]. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30- 43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. The respondent is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on February 14, 2024. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on March 11,2024.A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 14, 2024. The notice was received by Crystal Staton on March 20, 2024. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 2, 2024. To comply with City Ordinances, the property owner needs to remove all the trash and debris from the property, pressure wash the exterior of the home. remove the disabled vehicle from the alleyway and register the vehicle,cut the overgrown vegetation from the rear of the home. The City Staff recommends in accordance with the fine schedule a fine of$50.00 per day, to begin on April 10, 2024. unless the property owner brings the property into compliance on or before that date, plus a one-time $50.00 administrative fee. April 9, 2024, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 3 of 4 Exhibit 12 137 VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED B. Case No. 240314003; CONTINUED: Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 240314003 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30- 41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of$50.00 per day plus a one- time administrative fee of$50.00 should the property fail to come into compliance by April 10, 2024. C. Case No. 240314010; David B. May and Shawna May, 938 NW 3rd ST, Okeechobee [Legal Description: Lot 14 and West half of Lot 15 of Block 131, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PB 5, PG 5, Okeechobee County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 54, Section 54-81 Use as a residence, the property was found to be in compliance on March 25, 2024, no Lien/Order recorded, no fine accrued. D. Case No.240314012;Jeffrey James Piatti, 1018 NW 5'h AVE,Okeechobee [Legal Description: North 71.25-feet (FT) of West 28-FT of Lot 11, North 71.25-FT of Lots 12 and 13 of Block 29, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PB 1, PG 10 and PB 5, PG 5, Okeechobee County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 70, Section 70-251 Permit required, Chapter 90, Section 90-705 Temporary portable storage containers, the property was found to be in compliance on April 9,2024, no Lien/Order was recorded, no fine accrued. VII. COMPLIED CASES A. Case No.240215013;Wanda Horner,211 Northeast 4th AVE, Okeechobee [Legal Description:Lots 1 and 2 of Block 143,CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PB 5, PG 5, Okeechobee County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification, Chapter 54, Section 54-81 Use as a residence, the property was found to be in compliance on March 5, 2024, no Lien/Order was recorded, no fine accrued. B. Case No.240208005;Anne M. Land, 500 NW 16th ST, Okeechobee[Legal Description: Lot 1 and East half of Lot 2 of Block 69, CONNERS HIGHLANDS, PB 1, PG 21, Okeechobee County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances,30-44 General cleaning and beautification,Chapter 54,Sections 54-81 Use as a residence, 54-84 Parking in residential district, Chapter 58, Section 58-72(a) Use of public sewers required, the property was found to be in compliance on March 13, 2024, no Lien/Order was recorded, no fine accrued. VIII. ADJOURN MEETING There being no further business, Special Magistre cons, adjourned-the Hearing at 7:30 P.M. Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate ATTEST: Christina Curl,Code Enforcement Officer Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing,he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made,which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based.Code Enforcement media are for the sole purpose of backup for official records of Code Enforcement. April 9,2024,Special Magistrate Hearing,Page 4 of 4 Exhibit 12 Official Records File#2024003923 Page(s)1 Jerald D Bryant 'Clerk of the Circuit Court E. ptroller Prepared By/Return To: Okeechobee.FL Recorded 4/100/2024 2:28 PM City of Okeechobee Fees RECORDING 510 00 Code Enforcement Department 50 Southeast 2n°Avenue Okeechobee,Florida 34974 CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA CASE NO.240314003 CITY OF OKEECHOBEE,PETITIONER -vs- Donald A.Hayes,Jr.and Crystal L.Staton,RESPONDENT LIEN/ORDER THIS CAUSE came before the Special Magistrate,City of Okeechobee,for public hearing on April 9,2024.After due notice to the respondent, the Special Magistrate having heard evidence on the alleged violation by witnesses or affidavit makes the following findings: FINDINGS OF FACT: Property Owner: Donald A.Hayes,Jr.,and Crystal L.Staton Property Location: 1002 Northwest 6th Street,Okeechobee,FL.34972 Legal Description: Lot 17 and West half of Lot 18 of Block 7,NORTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1,Page 25,public records of Okeechobee County,Florida Parcel: 3-16-37-35-0160-00170-0170(34457) CONCLUSIONS OF LAW: The owner of the property described above has been found in violation of the following sections of the City Code of Ordinances, Code Section Violated Description of Violation Chapter 30,Section 30-40 Junk Junk,trash,and debris all over the property and stored on the airboat Chapter 30,Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles Disabled/unregistered vehicle in the rear of the property in the alleyway Chapter 30,Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, Overgrown grass,weeds,bushes,shrubs,and trees 30-44 General cleaning and beautification ORDER:The City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Special Magistrate has determined you have violated City Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification,concerning your property located at 1002 NW 6th St,Okeechobee,Florida. The Magistrate hereby imposes a fine of$50.00 per day,including a one-time administrative fee of$50.00.The imposed fine will continue to accrue daily until the City verifies that the violations are corrected. Further,this Order as a Claim of Lien,shall be recorded in the Office of the Clerk of Circuit Court, Okeechobee County,Florida, and once recorded, becomes a Lien on real and personal property pursuant to Florida Statutes Chapter 162. You have the right to appeal this finding within thirty days,and order by Writ of Certiorari to the Circuit Court,Okeechobee County,Florida.If you correct the violation,it is your obligation to contact the Code Enforcement Officer to verify such compliance. ORDERED this 9th day of April,2024. - City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Roger Azcona,Esquire ATTEST: .(1— Christina Curl,Recording Secretary 4%. ntP C sad Honda Jea o L Kovec F1Ff07pe18STATE OF FLORIDA �0,04/ noes,viormz+ COUNTY OF OKEECHOBEE The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me this day of f'prl ! ,2(k) by Roger Azcona and Christina Curl by means of I physical presence or Li online notarization,who produced as identification or is personally known to me and who did take an oath. i Signature of Notary: / pl.(dU) `�� Exhibit 12 U.S.Postal Service"' CERTIFIED MAIL®RECEIPT S Domestic Mail Only ry For delivery Information,visit our webslte nt wtvw.usps.com'. cemiednaAFee rv5 Extra'" (Meek enc.wne as*o 0t - ` 1,: O ❑mem R.wpt1.** 8 Podtmerk O ❑Creme ma Ramose n.eany a Here ❑A Some rewind a • ❑580 mono..n..ww e.emo$ =i ru NSent To / i / ireei'•8rait7AFt/No:;'ni POHo3 ."—r.�". �/.._.._..:_..t--1:::... rs- A J./ C�'t -le 2f L "r °.. ° 1 PS Form 3800 A•rll 2015 rON 7510 02 5000mu, Sec Reverse for Instructinnn Exhibit 12 SENDER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY • Complete items 1,2,and 3. A Signature • Print your name and address on the reverse X l 0 Agent so that we can return the card to you. (:' f' ❑Addressee •Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B.Regeived by(Printed Name) C.Date of Delivery or on the front if space permits. v - ddress different from item 1? ❑Yes Donald A._Hayes Jr.&Crystal L. Staten r delivery address below: ID No 1002 NW 6th St. Okeechob8. FL 34972 .1. 3. ice 11111 III I'I I II I1 I I III1II II III II I IIIIII LI 0 Adult Signature g ureeRestrlaed oeiNery 0 Registered v rid Restricted ified WOO 9590 9402 8118 2349 5922 79 O Certified Mall Restricted Delivery o Signature Confirmation"' ❑Collect on Delivery 0 Signature Confirmation 2.Article Number(Transfer from service label) 0 Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery D Insured Mad 7022 2410 0002 7643 7843 rie,1 Festdcted Delivery PS Form 3811,July 2020 PSN 7530-02.000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt Exhibit 12 ` J' Ait1 ^'j bpi •. 1 1 Tir:410 1., ti r J A, a .� 11 . lillibt •! gaitisa -.....14 4111 am•• I • . - "� T - gO o a 02024 16 17 Exhibit 12 Ititqlr's 4. e'' ....., ... . . ,_ . ‘ ,.. .-:,... ,. . 4 . . .. . _ _ ,,.. .,,,,, • , ... .. • ..,,, ,_„. . :... .. , , „....... , , „ , .. ... ,I.,.''', .--..a- ' .clif • • • . fi, N. K_-' I id err � .. r '4 ` C T pirritit,10 ljei : -, I .....,- , _ ___,„ Atlit. . t / `r ',rt - r - r1 �j . - �J '`C'��1' 4 h W • .t, i I r s a s g, 40. �1�, 4 i'�i ♦�1s.�AR� •�� �f -'t-> � . �� a fT"::itaSp ,�i�� •y. .may - .. - . OgOo 00 K,3 IIg:1U , Exhibit 12 City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Accrual of Fine 2024 Case No: 240314003 I I I . Name: Donald A.Hayes,Jr.&Crystal L.Staton Address: 1002 NW 6th St Okeechobee,FL.34972 Special Magistrate Ruling: Case presented to the Special Magistrate on April 9,2024,found in violation of Chapter 30,Sections 30-40 Junk,30-41 Disabled vehicles,30-43 Public nuisances,30-44 General cleaning and beautification.A fine of$50.00 per day,plus a one-time$50.00 administrative fee imposed to begin on April 10,2024. Fine Amount Number Week 1 Number Week 2 Number Week 3 Number Week 4 Number Week 5 Number Week 6 of days Total of Days Total of Days Total of Days Total of Days Total of days Total • $50.00 January $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 February $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 March $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 April 0 $0.00 4 $200.00 7 $350.00 7 $350.00 3 $150.00 0 $0.00 May 4 $200.00 2 $100.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 June $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 July $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 August $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 September $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 October $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 November $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 December $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Fine Total $1,350.00 Administrative Fee $50.00 Total Amount Due $1,400.00 Total Days 27 Date of Compliance Exhibit 12 City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave. Okeechobee, Florida 34974 (863)763-9795 May 10, 2024 Donald A. Hayes Jr. & Crystal L. Staton 1002 NW 6th St. Okeechobee, FL 34972 Re: 1002 NW 6th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 Case #240314003 Dear Mr. Hayes & Ms. Staton: On behalf of the City of Okeechobee, we extend our appreciation and sincerest Thank-You, for your efforts to bring the above-mentioned property into compliance with City Ordinances with the cutting of the overgrown vegetation, cleaning the exterior of the home and the removal of the disabled vehicle, and trash/debris from your property. The city has a responsibility to ensure that the ordinances enacted for the protection of life and property and for the general appearance of the city are followed by property owners in accordance with the desires of the residents of the community. Your continuing efforts, in maintaining your property are important to the City of Okeechobee. your neighbors and fellow citizens. The above-mentioned property has a Code Enforcement Lien with a fine balance of $1400.00 including the $50.00 administrative fee. Please contact our office immediately to make arrangements to pay this fine. Failure to pay this fine will result in the lien on real and personal property to remain pursuant to Florida Statutes Chapter 162 and could result in a foreclosure action being filed against the above-mentioned property. If we can be of any assistance, please do not hesitate to contact us and we can discuss the matter. Again. Thank You for your cooperation. understanding and efforts in assisting with the beautification of the city. Sincerely. Anthony Smith City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Officer 863-763-9795 asmith©cityofokeechobee.com Exhibit 12 U.S.Postal Service' CERTIFIED MAW RECEIPT P Domestic Mail Only CI For delivery Information.visit our website st www.usps.com .13 -------------fri —--------- .1 sallied MO Fee _n $ U,rwt ,rfr.',pprc: or..........., =__ , ru, 0 FriurnFWAPtlel...0 S------ Z.....,, /4 — CIDeelledieilArteleteeDeilwey t--_----- 0 OMNI OWL.Amine $.---_--.. ., . 4 °Anil Spume R•011ed D.A.,/I------- C-1 4/...,2 , . 0 PS Fern'380D,A•til 2016 PON TM, , See Revel for Instructions Exhibit 12 f ; SENDER:COMPLE7 c THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■Complete items7,2,and 3. ' • Print your nameeAd address on the reverse 0 Agent so that we can return the card to you. Eti167.:,t, _ •,,y 0 Addressee •Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, =t C.Date of Delivery or on the front if space permits. 1.Article Addressed t_o: -- __ __ a le...i"'--', dress different from Item 1? ❑Yes rr delivery address below: 0 No Do A.Hayes Jr.&Crystal L.Staton 10 ; W 6th St. rl Ok hobee, FL 34972 �1'Po ❑Priority Mai,Express® II I liii.III III I II II I I IIIIII II IIII I III I III III El Adult Signature ❑Registered Mall ❑AduAdultSignature Restricted Delivery ❑Registered Mall Restricted 9590 9402 8118 2349 5921 63 A Certified Mai ND Delivery 0 Certified Mail Restricted Delivery A Signature Confirmation. 0 Collect on Delivery 0 Signature Confirmation 9. ArNrin u...,....tn.....�--�--- •' - -- ,n Delivery Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery 7022 2410 0002 7643 8000 voiMa I roger sso Restricted Delivery PS Form 3811,July 2020 PEN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt