2024-06-11 VII.A. Ex.4 Exhibit 4
VII. A. Exhibit #4
Case #240514003
Spirit CV Okeechobee FL, LLC, CVE Health Corp, c/o Altus Group US Inc.
Exhibit 4
Code Enforcement Hearing June 11 , 2024
Case Number, Name and Address:
Case#240514003, Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC, CVS Health Corp c/o Altus Group US Inc, 106
N Parrott Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34974
Code Section Violated Description of Violation
Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances Overgrown shrubs and bushes, dead shrubs and
and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification bushes, trash and debris in the plant beds, and a
fallen parking lot light.
Photos:
See attached
Is respondent a Repeat Violator?
Yes: Previous Case#210317014, Chapter 30-44 General cleaning, and beautification.
Summary:
• The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s).
Date of Type of notice Received Date
notice by received
/returned
May 13, 2024 Code Officer Smith received a complaint from Jeff Newell that this property has
overgrown vegetation, trash and debris in the plant beds, dead shrubs all over the
property and a fallen light.
May 14,2024 SOV/NOH, photos and a copy of the city ordinances mailed via USPS certified return Victor May 20,
receipt for the June 11th Hearing. Hand delivered SOV/NOH, photos, and a copy of Daveiga 2024.
the city ordinances to the Store Manager.
May 17, 2024 Code Officer Curl received a call from Mike Pasquence with All Florida Looks Inc.,who
will be taking care of all the landscaping. He stated that his irrigation tech would be
there today to look at the irrigation system and he would put in a work order to getting
the overgrown vegetation and trash taken care of.
June 4, 2024 Code Officer Smith inspected the property; still non-compliant,the parking lot light has
not been repaired, and the dead shrubs/bushes have not been replaced at this time.
However, they made great progress with the property: cleaned the trash from the
flower beds,trimmed, shaped and cleaned up the small trees in the beds, washed and
panted the building. Photos in file.
• To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to complete the repairs to the
irrigation system and the broken parking lot light.
City Recommendation:
The city recommends in accordance with the City's fine schedule of$150.00 per day to begin on
June 12, 2024, until the property is brought into compliance, plus $100.00 administration fee.
Chronology attached
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 4
Case #240514003, Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC
Date Event/Document
May 13, 2024 Property owner: Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC CVS Health Corp c/o Altus Group US Inc
Property address: 106 N Parrott Ave, Okeechobee
Mailing address: Cockeysville, MD 21030/ 1 CVS Drive Woonsocket, RI 02895-6146
Parcel ID: 3-15-37-35-0010-01540-0010 (33966)
Legal Description: Lots 1-3 & 6. Block 154, TOGETHER WITH A PORTION OF THAT CERTAIN
ALLEY IN BLOCK 154. RUNNING N & S, BOUNDED BY LOTS 3 ON THE E & Okeechobee
County public records.
kepeat Violator: Previous Case #210317014, Chapter 30-44 General cleaning, and
beautification.
Code Officer Smith received a complaint from Jeff Newell that this property has overgrown
vegetation, trash and debris in the plant bed, dead shrubs all over the property and a fallen light.
Code Officer Smith observed the above-mentioned property to be in violation of the Code
of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances and 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification: overgrown shrubs and bushes, dead shrubs and bushes, trash and debris
in the plant beds, and a fallen parking lot light.
May 14, 2024 SOV/NOH, photos and a copy of the city ordinances mailed via USPS certified return receipt
for the June 11'h Hearing. Hand delivered SOV/NOH, photos, and a copy of the city ordinances
to the Store Manager. Hand Receipt in file. Received by Victor Daveiga on May 20, 2024.
May 17, 2024 Code Officer Curl received a call from Mike Pasquence with All Florida Looks Inc., 772-626-4455,
who will be taking care of all the landscaping. He stated that his irrigation tech would be there
today to look at the irrigation system and he would put in a work order to getting the overgrown
vegetation and trash taken care of.
June 4, 2024 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, the parking lot light has not been
repaired. and the dead shrubs/bushes have not been replaced at this time. However. they made
great progress with the property: cleaned the trash from the flower beds, trimmed, shaped and
cleaned up the small trees in the beds, washed and panted the building. Photos in file.
Page 1 of 1
`exhibit 4
...... , t. .., 1.6.1 ill, II Ir..., , ,,,.... ,„ 0, ,
,„ , , . . ,
i.,.,_ • t .. , ..,,,. 1
1;, I.` lie. "�
1• � 1. MI,
I :rl -..-"s• �` _ (.
14:101 + f I tip• '.' `I _. _ 1
_ +'rill ! r' Icy - '. it t !r
rn
4 A� - ?fill- �, .) f� MD ST 1 .1ais
; . . • • #1 32.
•
Mil Ale 1 f ill 1
rrl i - • i0 'x - 4t 1 ct
& 41l�11 a , ' —
_ ., ' 4 , {{ .1 -
ill ;I IP,I. . •tal 11 8:' 1 Pt _...a/AA.maLmmmgpm ' i i . ••
•
a ts.., . _ !. .
..., , f?,„,:i., , ...• :, • . . -'..A„ ,. : , 4 f . I. 1 ,. .1 ., . . ,.,,,
"`-. • i w y _ la
.
' -.,..I .1 i ...... -• .'I .! tir.. 4 Ir ; z., 9 '.
7 ilimpplp mia
4: .'11 1,04 • 111 " 0
WV-:: , .- :i• ,
r i a aver::, i s i 1 'st•\ ',liaia'A1a�. _
„Sy/PARK ST SE PARK ST 1 E
��) '�:,`�.`.. ' `' �1d1 1 �,il . iaj\ M\tea 1 -mitaii" i A
rn
._ _ ?.
1M
j •
' ! 1110.4141— - 1, 1 .. -Iii .tri-
f m:IP- rtl • Ip� f • .� • ? i i , rYR
fir , . or, - —_ , j1-- r�
_ 2 ; s ,, ti
i
.MO..IIMS. N
0 100 200 300 400 500 500 700 800 900 1000 ft
Okeechobee County Property Appraiser
Mickey L.Bandi,CFA I Okeechobee,Florida 1863-763-4422
PARCEL: 3-15-37-35-0010-01540-0010 (33966) I STORES/1 STORY(1100)1 1.71 AC NOTES:
Okeechobee County,FL
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE LOTS 1,2,3&6,BLOCK 154;TOGETHER WITH A PORTION OF THAT CERTAIN ALLEY IN
BLOCK 154,RUNNING N&S,BOUNDED BY LOT 3 ON THEE&
SPIRIT CV OKEECHOBEE FL LLC 2023 Certified Values
Owner:CVS HEALTH CORP Mkt Lnd $1,117,384 Appraised $2.127,745
C/O ALTUS GROUP US IINC Ag Lnd $0 Assessed $2,127,745
COCKEYSVILLE,MD 21030 Bldg $847,407 Exempt SO N
Site. 106 N PARROTT AVE OKEECHOBEE XFOB $162,954 county:$2,049,584 _.,►G_
Sales 7/18/2013 50 1(u) lust$2,127,745 Total city:$2,049,584 1
1n3/2006 36270.000 I(U) Taxable other:52,049,584
Info 8/4/2000 3499,000 I(U) school:$2,127,745
The Information presented on this website was derived from data which was compiled by the Okeechobee County Property Appraiser Office solely for the governmental purpose of property
assessment.This information should not be retied upon by anyone as a determination of the ownership of property or market value.No warranties.expressed or implied.are provided for the
accuracy of the data herein,it's use,or it's interpretation.This website was last updated:5/9/2024 and may not reflect the data currently on file at our office. GrizzlyLogic.corn
Exhibit 4
39
,IN OF•Ok�'y
L'1 EEVsk CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
3°: srr APRIL 13, 2021 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
'6# OFFICIAL MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on
Tuesday,April 13, 2021, at 6:35 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast 3rd
Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Magistrate
Azcona.
II. ATTENDANCE
Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll. Special Magistrate Roger
Azcona, Esquire, City Attorney Carlyn Kowalsky, Police Lieutenant Justin Bernst, Code
Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith, and Deputy City Clerk Bobbie Jenkins were present.
III. CHANGES TO AGENDA
Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred,
or withdrawn; Complied Request Item VI.E. be moved to Item V.B.as requested by City Attorney
Kowalsky.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH
A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the March 9, 2021, Hearing minutes.
B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire
collectively administered an Oath to: Code Officers Smith and Curl, and Mr. Gregory
Williams; all affirmed. Code Officer Smith stated for the record, all events regarding the
cases to be discussed occurred within the corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee. The
Officer's notes, testimony, photographs, and support documents were all entered as part
of the official record.
V. CASES COMPLIED, CONTINUED, OR AMENDED
A. Case No. 190215011; Barbara Mills, 1206 Southwest 5th Avenue [Legal Description: Lot
3, REPOGLE SUBDIVISION, Plat Book 2, Page 87, Okeechobee County public records]
has been satisfied and the settled fine reduction of $3,667.00 was approved by City
Council on April 6, 2021.
B. Case No. 200110013; Gregory and Sharon Williams, 501 Northwest 16th Street [Legal
Description: Lot 26 and the East one-half of Lot 25 of Block 52, CONNERS HIGHLANDS,
Plat Book 1, Page 21, Okeechobee County public records], Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Section 30-41 Disabled vehicle, Section 30-44 General cleaning,
and beautification.
Code Officer Smith testified property in compliance as of today. On March 18, 2020, the
owners were served with a Lien with a fine of $25.00 per day after 14-days proper
notification plus a $25.00 administrative fee. Fines accumulated to more than $9,000.00.
The City recommended reducing the number of days the property was out of compliance
to run from April 1, 2020 to October 15, 2020, totaling 197 days, due to COVID-19 and
cancelled Hearings, reducing the outstanding fine to $4,925.00. The City recommended
a 50 percent fine reduction to $2,462.50 plus a $25.00 administrative fee. Mr. Williams
submitted a fine reduction request form for the same amount as the City's
recommendation as well as a request `.o make payments. Special Magistrate Azcona
agreed and ruled to recommend the City Council approve the fine reduction, plus
administrative fee, and to grant payment arrangements.
VI. NEW CASES
A. Case No. 200226002; Doc's Auto Service, Inc, 805 North Parrott Avenue [Legal
Description: Lots 1,2, and 3 of Block 48, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5,
Okeechobee County public records].Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Section
30-4'1 Disabled vehicle, Section 30-43 Public nuisances, and Section 30-44 General
cleaning and beautification.
Code Officer Smith testified this case started February 25, 2020, requiring tires to be
removed, grass to be mowed, and an abandoned vehicle needed to be moved. Notice of
Violation was mailed via certified USPS mail, and returned unclaimed.
April 13,2021 Code Enforcement Hearing,Page 1 of 5
40 Exhibit 4
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
A. Case No. 200226002 continued.
The property was posted on August 11, 2020. Property was inspected, still not in
compliance as of July 27,2020 but was deferred due to COVID-19. The property was
posted again on August 31, 2020 for the September 8, 2020 Hearing, and continued to
be out of compliance. On September 8, 2020, the property was found in violation and a
fine of S100.00 per day to be imposed after 10-days proper notification plus a $50.00
administrative fee. A Lien/Order was recorded on October 13, 2020 and mailed on
October 16, 2020.
As of December 31, 2020, the property continued to be out of compliance. A phone
message was left on January 19, 2021 for a Michael Blackburn, due to no response, on
March 2, 2021, a 90-Day Letter was mailed via certified USPS mail. On March 8, 2021
Code Enforcement received a phone call from Angela Waldron, Registered Agent and
President of Doc's Auto Service. Staff explained to her what was required to bring the
property into compliance. Once she notified them the property would be inspected, photos
would be taken to document compliance and stop the fines. Then further she could
request a fine reduction. On March 15, 2021, the property was still out of compliance, a
Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing was mailed via certified USPS mail for the April
13, 2021 Hearing. The Notice of Hearing was received in Code Enforcement on March
20, 2021, the signature was illegible. The property was inspected again on March 22,
2021, the abandoned vehicle was removed, the grass cut, however the tires were not
removed. Code Enforcement received a call from Mrs. Waldron that she was unable to
attend tonight's Hearing. She advised her husband would be mowing again and moving
the tires today. However, she explained there were several bags of debris left on the
property from the construction company who recently installed the traffic light at North 9'h
Street and Parrott Avenue. The property was inspected before Hearing and is still not in
compliance. Special Magistrate Azcona ruled that due to the property owner
refusing to come into compliance, the amount of time given, and the nature of the
violation continues to exist, he recommended the property be foreclosed.
B. Case No. 200824010; Yvette Banner, 913 Northwest 9th Street [Legal Description: Lot 7
of Block 43, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Books 1 and 5, Pages 10 and 5, Okeechobee County
public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public
nuisances, and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification.
Code Officer Smith testified a courtesy card was mailed on August 25, 2020, for violation
of Chapter 30 Section 30-43 and Section 30-44, abandoned boat, abandoned vehicle,
overcrown weeds,trash, and debris in yard. Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing was
mailed via certified USPS mail on November 16, 2020. The Notice was received by
Michael Grosman on November 21, 2020, he was given till November 30, 2020 to correct
the violations. The property was posted on November 17, 2020 with Notice to Appear for
the December 8, 2020 Hearing. Case was not heard at the December 8, 2020 Hearing.
Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing was mailed via certified USPS mail on December
16, 2020 for the January 12, 2021 Hearing. The Notice was received by Yvette Banner
on December 21, 2020. Ms. Banner advised the Code Office that on December 31, 2020
a roll-off dumpster was being delivered on January 5, 2021. The Case was deferred to
the February 9, 2021 Hearing as Ms. Benner was working with Waste Management. The
February Hearing was cancelled. The property was inspected on March 3, 2021 and
found not in compliance. Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing was mailed via certified
USPS mail on March 15, 2021 for the April 13, 2021 Hearing. The Notice was received
by Kevin Clausell on March 18, 2021. The property was inspected on March 22, 2021
and found not in compliance as the abandoned vehicle is still there, overgrown grass and
shrubs, debris, and trash in the yard.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
200824010 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30 Section 30-44
General cleaning a beautification and Section 30-43 Public nuisances and imposed
a fine, of $50.00 per day, plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the
property owner fail to come into compliance within 14-days after proper
notification.
April 13,2021 Code Enforcement Hearing,Page 2 of 5
Exhibit 4
41
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
C. Case No. 210127006; Agustin Mendoza and Melinda Hernandez, 901 Southwest 111h
Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 9 and 10 of Block 20, SOUTHWEST ADDITION, Plat
Book 2, Page 7, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification.
Code Officer Smith testified a courtesy card was mailed via regular USPS on January 27,
2021 for violation of Chapter 30 Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and
Section 30-43 Public nuisance, active building permit required for the permanent structure
that is in the process of being built, overgrown with grass and shrubs, debris, and trash
on the property. The courtesy card provided for seven days to correct the violations; it
was returned on February 18, 2021 with no mail receptacle/unable to forward. The
property was inspected on March 4, 2021 and found not in compliance. Statement of
Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via certified USPS mail on March 15, 2021 for the April
13, 2021 Hearing. The Notice was returned on March 22, 2021 no mail receptacle/unable
to forward. The property was inspected again on March 22, 2021, not in compliance,
overgrown grass, unfinished structure, and debris. Assistant Code Officer Curl
researched the property further and discovered a Post Office Box address related to the
property owners. The Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing was remailed on March
23, 2021. The property was posted on March 30, 2021 with a Notice to Appear for the
April 13, 2021 Hearing. The property was inspected again on April 13, 2021, the
overgrown grass was mowed, some of the debris was removed, the unfinished structure
remains without a permit and overgrown weeds remained along the property facing
Southwest 11'h Avenue.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona noted he would be more
comfortable in imposing a fine in Case No. 210127006 as there is a factual basis for
the allegations of violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-43, and Section 30-44 if it had
been posted since January and all correspondences mailed had not been returned.
The violation was noted in January, only the Notice to the Post: Office Box was
delivered to the owner and the property was posted less than two weeks from
today. He ruled to defer the Case to the next hearing to allow more time for the
owners to bring the property into compliance and instructed the Code Enforcement
staff to make every attempt to obtain a mailing address to send the certified Notice.
Whether or not the certified Notice is able to be mailed, he would be more
comfortable imposing the fine at that time.
D. Case No. 191115015, Blue Springs Holdings, LLC, Northeast 9th Avenue [Legal
Description: Unplatted lands of the City, the Southwest quarter of the Northeast quarter
and North half of the Northwest quarter of the Southeast quarter South of the SAL
Railroad right-of-way; Southwest quarter of the Northwest quarter of the Southeast
quarter; the Southeast quarter of the Northwest quarter of the Southeast quarter; North
half of the Northeast quarter of the Southwest quarter; and the South half of the Northeast
quarter of the Southwest quarter lyirg East of Taylor Creek; fractional Northwest quarter
East of Taylor Creek and South of the SAL Railroad; and all that portion of land located
in the Northeast quarter of the Southwest quarter and the Southeast quarter of Northwest
quarter, South of the SAL Railroad in Section 15, Township 37 South, Ranger 35 East,
that lies East of Taylor Creek imprcved channel as recorded in Plat Book 3, Page 29,
Public Records of Okeechobee County, Florida: Less and except: a portion of the
Southeast quarter and a portion of the Southwest quarter of Section 15, Township 37
South, Range 35 East, Okeechobee County, Florida]. Violation of Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30 Section 30-43 Public nuisances and Section 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification.
Code Officer Smith testified this case started November 18, 2019. It is approximately 50
acres of vacant land [located East of Taylor Creek, North and East of River Run Mobile
Home Park,West of Northeast 12th Avenue, South of the railroad, and North of East North
Park Street(State Road 70). It is extremely overgrown, needs to be cleared and cleaned.
Notice of Violation was mailed certified USPS on November 18, 2019, property was
mowed and cleaned. However, the debris was collected into large piles throughout the
property. On April 28, 2020, an email was received from Fire Chief Smith to Code
Enforcement that the County burn-ban had been lifted.
April 13,2021 Code Enforcement Hearing,Page 3 of 5
Exhibit 4
42
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
D. Case No. 191115015 continued.
On May 1, 2020, a resident contacted Code Enforcement to report the property still had
not been cleaned. Code Officer Sterling spoke with the property owner, Mr. Gad, on May
5, 2020 in reference to the burn-ban being lifted. On May 6,2020, a Statement of Violation
and Notice of Hearing was mailed via certified USPS mail. It was returned unclaimed. Mr.
Gad contacted Code Officer Sterling and requested that he contact Mr. Philip Baughman
of B and B Site Development to inquire when the debris piles would be burned. Code
Enforcement Secretary Close contacted Mr. Baughman who advised he could not obtain
a burn permit due to the wind and he did not want to rent an $6,000.00 air curtain
destructor to be able to burn in windy conditions. Mr. Baughman was asked to keep Code
Enforcement updated on the status of this project. The property was inspected several
times and continues to be out of compliance.
The Case was found in violation of Chapter 30 Section 30-43 Public nuisance and Section
30-44 General cleaning and beautification on September 8, 2020. A fine of$100.00 per
day, beginning 14-days after proper notification, plus a $50.00 administrative fee was
imposed.The fine has accumulated to$16,400.00 plus the$50.00 administrative fee. The
City recommends foreclosure. Special Magistrate Azcona ruled, despite the attempts
to resolve the matter with the owner, seeing no progress being made, recommend
foreclosure.
E. Case No. 210210008, Sam Lane, 800 block Northwest 10th Street, [Legal Description:
Lots 1 and 2 of Block 41, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 10, Okeechobee County
public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances, Chapter 30 Section 30-44 General
cleaning and beautification and Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles.
These vacant lots are located at Northwest 10th Street and 81h Avenue, have two
abandoned vehicles parked on the property.A courtesy card was mailed on February 10,
2021, giving 10-days to correct the violations. The property inspected on March 3, 2021,
not in compliance. However, the car had been removed, the RV remained, and the grass
needed to be mowed. On March 4, 2021, a Statement of Violation and Notice of Hearing
mailed certified USPS; and received by the owner, Mr. Lane on March 5, 2021. Mr. Lane
contacted Code Officer Smith on March 22, 2021 inquiring as to best method of removing
the abandoned RV. He was advised to contact a local junk yard. On April 13, 2021, the
property was not in compliance due to overgrown grass; the RV had been removed_
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
210210008 to be in violation of Chapter 30 Section 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification and Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles and imposed a fine of $50.00
per clay, plus a one-time administrative fee of$50.00 should the property owner fail
to come into compliance within the 14-days after proper notification.
VII. REPEAT VIOLATORS
A. Case No. 210317014, Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC (CVS), 106 North Parrott Avenue,
[Legal Description: Lots 1,2,3,6, and 7 through 12, and the East to West alley between
U.S. Highway 441 on the West and Northeast 2nd Avenue on the East and lying South of
and adjacent to the South Line of Lots 1,2,3 and 6 and the South line of North/South alley
located in said Block 154 and North of and adjacent to the North line of Lots 7,8,9,10,11
and 12 of Block 154, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, according to plat thereof recorded in Plat
Book 5, Page 5, LESS AND EXCEPT that portion of said Lots 7 and 8 taken for right of
way by order of taking recorded in Official Records Book 334, Page 1449, public records
of Okeechobee County, Florida]. Violation of Code of Ordinances, Chapter 30 Section
30-44 General cleaning and beautification.
The Violation was Noticed on March 17, 2021 as a repeat violator of Chapter 30 Section
30-44 General cleaning and beautification, dead vegetation that needs to be replaced.
Given 7-days to correct. Statement of Violation and Notice of Hearing was mailed certified
USPS mail on March 17, 2021 to the Corporate Office and signed by Fosiy and COVID-
19. The property was inspected on March 24, 2021, March 31, 2021, and April 13, 2021,
found not in compliance and in the same condition as on March 17, 2021. No attempts
have been made to correct the violation The property is located within the main business
corridor of the City, the landscaping should be maintained.
April 13,2021 Code Enforcement Hearing,Page 4 of 5
Exhibit 4
43
VII. REPEAT VIOLATORS CONTINUED
A. Case No. 210317014 Continued.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
210317014 in violation of Chapter 30 Section 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification and imposed a fine of$100.00 per day, plus a one-time administrative
fee of$100.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 14-
days after proper notification.
VIII. ADJOURN MEETING
There being no further business to come before the Special Magistrate the Hearng was
adjourned at 7:40 P.M.
Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate
ATTEST:
iL, , (1'.l'1.
Christina Curl
Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special Magistrate with
respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is
made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. City Clerk media are for
the sole purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk.
April 13,2021 Code Enforcement Hearing,Page 5 of 5
Exhibit 4
�` �• r • A .'.i I I C y it
a- w _:
®�® -o4'''� ,rac-
w _ e
•r # .Y _
•
Fr v,.1i 7 77 =ti• "..; r :,2, 4 .`11, a' Af $ .•, ,,i , wT a a t,,.t� �r _
no0fi 302024 91i :52
..:4 •', •
6it ,- 'it''"t . v? „-
wf ' . .:::\.1161...t .1.: . "1 1,?',.. ..,'" ';'-‘:.1.:. ‘...' ...- --',:
-
/F. 11
ift : ' .--
got,
Ib
'r 111
v �. / +
�y�0 8, �J1r 4
Ma100J0024,1 'fill :g2
Exhibit 4
1 i. `. . ► i It1 A ice:
-I, t _ $ ' .,...... f , . ,, 1 i. • -I, '. "
.. _ _ _ _ s... .....,„ .1 . . i. ......' A 2_ „...„ • _ !IIL
.. • Mt
v ✓ 7 �, r Ilk.r,: TiL
..
u.. R ,
f.
-' 051iii .f. /rr "-Ai-. • _ `44 t.: -t ' �,` Sr(t
Og09302024 1111 :D2
PI,
l ,'F4 , } ♦ r( .A
• ::2: 1 tkt-k4's(1 . -'.if • :ay .• .. • •
4if V. ,�i 0_f y. is
:. .'> r `- 'gar a,.+s
...._ .• fir,-' �� •..> -ia,
r .
•t
Exhibit 4
1
F
u
0gg 3020024 1iil :g3
^�"` \� 1 , ' ,
f�, � N_ _"
i�/ R . . y
� , s
•
r. w :•t'� �q ► , may . ..
tZ.I.114: .`,,,.''. Vii,i:,, V.-.44 ' .:.'r;:.1 '-,Z'I\ \\ N
i 4` , \\ ,
Og0� 30204Td :03
Exhibit 4
jil OF- 1011% .,,,,N iii Mit E
7:^ r
4., d J
UM 304 1I1I :g3
11
v `1t'.... . , ,,.• M4.. ..`'S`-r4 �, t, AZ% 1.. I llllc11 /.-�y. 4,,,,....,:,• ai l /' "4
., 4.:,...-.-
. .. 0, 4 ,4,'1 lc,.T.: ,-
000 T 302O2Q 9 9 o g 3
, .
•
• ' yi "-
..-Irt•••••‘. .•:.1...44.....;•'•' • ".,.....- z. ,1
" -- .." .!I- S).• n
-•.' -.
'•-... 4.•-_--. 4:•• -•-1 -•••••• • .... ‘• ..
-,
, -••:. •-!'•. • '
„, :;•,',-,,,,,_„1..z,„..7 ,. ...,Nr. .n.), '''4 ,,,,.
e,,... 10,14.
......., 9- . ,..- --qt.. . . • ....,-,#,!... it- gi, ..14; - ..,,,... ,,,,
-,,- .
.... • . --, - - • a 1 ,..1-4.4..... . • . l •'-ft • Z ;- - -'.!•, •
- •- - 'IV 1— •-'- J
,•- ; .:•••"'‘ • -;e- - •:: .•s%4•:•-''.••Zli., ;;;•"- C
••l'.S-;...
k. • _, • , .4 .. .4. ... ...a....., . .. ).• 4
'' •'• .,r .'ii.';„- ,..c :•:*‘""- • ,-.1,7-,4`
. •' ,L. •r• -44. :. „,::.... . •-....-i, ..,
P • •s all.. i.— — •• .c.,. • t - .:.?-1-0 .3i.:1.4. " •I.
-.•.•
, -'
liCAPII.• ••••J:.•-;•;•.--•.. - 1‘. . .- . -ttiy,. ,.• 4•.:.;•": . ;25s.Apei.••-,". .
--1" ... • "' -...•. ' %•••••• '.. S.; ... 1 • .4r.
cla. ..'•••' , --irr:s.. ''. • '
n.•
• •• I. -NI.•; !•, '• f'..s'ir• ••••• , 1:St• . '
- ••Cl`' .--•" , ', . ,
••,•it , , •,,,p...„...
• •
1100'
.
AW•ir. _ , , .,...
..4..e...•
..
...". . -
00011a02024 1111 :D6
k,
, • j
...0
_ t
. . li•,1
.
...,-.. 'Li
,7W •
-.4c11/f#--",,Appi _ ,
----rd r• --4"--
. _
I i ,,' • 10. "nalb• ' . - ', •
_'i..• ... 1
*. 4.
... .V \ \ . Illk y ,
- .
t617-'2
.thi.
•00e. . f -
•
Ft i• 1 il • _ 'r.. 4,„11F-N.1
.,..,•,-. - '--7 Nikvi . 4k.. ) •.,, ,, ,t; .1- ' 4'''' Z " -
, .r•,- - 4441
...„.... . . i, ;, , ..... .,..,,I,
. t ' q N,• _
i . , i. , ..- . Attbk wi • % -.Nu
----
t, I ', • , " • •. ' -- — ' ' \ , . , 1 ....%
: ,•.1
-.
ib` ,1,'.-? --,, . \'--, .r. ,;.•;,- ,4
,'IP •- / . ,,, .‘, , .., .
‘•.4.
.5".-•• • ;" -M.'s .-111,' '-- 4
, ,t
•,, ,, t;',, ,_, \ -,,.. .'45.,/t,4-44 ...21," 01' ,f.--' . : ' r l', ' •‘ '
v.10t."
. •.',I: 44 la
•••• ." IS IV, /' kt, s••
• .7'L.••:, 1 Iltdi. •• A T6,114/4. - ,, 6 ? , , , -
iialm,,..
-;'44, " • '*- oiirvi41. .' t ' ' i r1 /
', , -, ,„air-7:. -.•• •- sik • s ' t; , _
' - -7- - ,...---....::t., •-?r..- 4vp,
.,1 , al , „, •, , .4 ,1, .,
i ik "N\• • tN k N •
snip-4.1,‘• iv • . A ‘-:. •' .-: -:.. i.,,,\ • :-.,--
. :„.,..,...... ,
As
0J811., §202:6,1 111] :U
4,.,••-•- ".410.44'.
A ' ' *
Exhibit 4
-- ';-••,.-- .40,14,-
". .'',
t d'
4 I ' Y. .s''44il:I:IL.:'.",' .:k .i 4 '.. ''..".1tjr:4 -cif 4:441' )1 .'i '..:§.40.4:;;.:s,‘-4:.:'1#:Iiii.'.-1.:*7 r': '
4 • . . .i...z.h. s ,
•. .... ,,L
A kit; ,elt. • is;Itlzt -
ki,
' . .. V.. _ ?,
0009 0020026 1111 :04
t• r *: .. ) ......... - 'fi A• -t.,, i
a
✓o, i.- t.
- �
MIIIIIIIIP Pi' - i
i . . .. _
.4w, . _ , ,
. 1 A ,,
. „lip, , . .. _
...
.,. .. 41,..-111.
� � ,°i 4 ,IL s d y 4 r -Y'!-r fig, 4
•,, sue, Y ;.. rYv3.f+,a - • .t.T- .N
040' 302026,5 ll 9 o g41
Exhibit 4
I
4,.-.
........
.. .
0 , . #1/44:Alt .I . -Alai
„ ;, -,ill,: /! .- A. A .(,:: ,...421
I Ab 1 lr ..
/ f it. s, _,_ ,.,e4111"
p- .. , , ''•'. •- -i'' , 141I6'. --4':a, 4 .,4 . - 'it . .
, . - -:.- ,k i
-4,... , • . , AN
lti,
"V ""e
.itsloe • :--, . . sP. i.r ' .4. 44t --, - : -4 We*•-•
4 ..1 p ;.'s0, „„V--,•., . ••••
, 4 ,‘, , -li ',.. . . It • . 4dPi4 a Iiii, , -r4.7 "4"- '.'
..p.
\'''' ,T 1 •4, , ... -.,,
\ 4 joi .,
•4 r po. , 0*
r ...
e .... 'JO,.. -e „ji A isir-_..
_,... ..,..„ _. ... lile.,40.4 ", .17 ,la' - —
-4,;.'-.. ., ,,•••• „fir` " ..''''• V ', s •
, . A
Is- 1,4, ,••- . ". ' - ,4„.• f •
- • -. .4 : - .- f.
•• "'
.- 1,4L. •_--` i ' . P 1)4 .
. •,
-•• r.• 1 * 0' ';-,.,/ :I 4 . •••
--t
- ' 10?" If . ‘ - -f i - '' - I ' .i . 44- 4-, • -
11. .-i. --•
..:
•
.. • ' 1 ti.t, .
i' .. . . .
.... . .... -
\
{I-'',:,‹ .- • 1 .
'" 1 .. . .. .,‘ : , L .;" _ .. • ,
n. ..04,,,,,.. ---..f.-s •
' ' ' ...,....-...: t —
;, 0 .. .„,t— • ,,
• —_
1
t
0 11 li g 11 C[1)26‘1 1)11 :146,1
%
)
.......---1
„a...1r
..„....,,,,. . .
.......___
, , ,.... ....
. .., I..:....,:: \..._...%.
Air ....., .!. ' '
,..
..—;
....rair:-.---r--. , ._. lib.&IL sr& — •
. ..,".• ' '' .. - ' —..;k* P .. • ' " .. . ...
. ,...
-— .... 4-• '--- :- '
• •
rl, .1.....40111... ".
. 1,.,-......e,
0.•
.. ...
..... ........ -. - • ......
-.... . ...-, - •
. .
'-..-........‘.A-.-..,..
-.
CQ) n _311 2q26,/ 11 11 :
-
1 ,
.
1111L__ _.,, -..._
. _
Exhibit 4
,f .
.., _
.4.,
..,,
• . ^
...
'' Af...! --:.).---..-, • -... ' ; ' - irtjtAiryjA
' •
...0.' i )tr A'''•
g70144itt "idle'
ill*. "..
1:'
... , . ' *4'!'"-' • ...
si.._
I __ - . -
.
411111""'-
.
I 4. -- ,
...
ONLY ' - ''- ' ' "4"- .'''"' ' .• • - •.--- . '• • , .. ..
.... _ 3. ). . .
2 •
,--.,-,---,.. ..N,' •:',..':.",*7'•' .'''''' .., - • " . . , ••••'4.. .A, ,i : ,,•..,
••• -7. '•- ' ".. ., ..1 21.-'' '- ---i.. ' ....r"' '.. ''• oltiste:•' A .•4144Akilk,;,),:i!,, -4;-!"
. -%,...: •''' - '''"‘. %IX/.-4" --...1%. ,.,i-' rie'Vt; ••, . ..•414E— -. • %. • 5 •,. .
..u... ..:,. . ,, . ..- .- • ,... :-, .).,,,1-.....,:lt.-`.r-;,. ,• ,.4 ...,),C-, t. • ' • '...,.:',',
-- 7 ..• . -e'"•-.; '• . ''''. • '' .4. '1444:'•4 '46t.' Ne ' .44‘ ..•z . - i i.,
.1 ,. .
. . : ... ... - . ...:, . t... : • , -..I. . . ^1 v...',.i•ri c
..-
. ' •' , , . . :-..- 14.. i'l*f:::::....- /1..,..' l'4 ':'- • ,6.:.r.... • A:, ..r.,, •.4%1 ... .-,,,..• •••,
....
•'.•
' .
e•;.
....._,.,
'***.ir.: C0011@1121D2 11V:46
.
!.....-- „i....
)'-
Zgreichobee Exhibit 4
••°• City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement ‘_
50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 F`
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR 863-763-9795 Phone
THE CITY OF 863-763-7804 FAX
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA
Petitioner,
vs
Date May 14, 2024
Respondent,
CASE NO. 240514003
Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC
STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12,Florida Statutes,and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee,I(hereinafter the"City of Okeechobee),the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code,as more particularly described herein,and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section:Chapter 30 Section 30-43, and 30-44
2. Address and Parcel#where violation exists: 106 N Parrott Ave, Okeechobee
3-15-37-35-0010-01540-0010 (33966)
3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Spirit CV Okeechobee FL LLC CVS Health Corp do Altus Group US Inc, 1 CVS Drive
4. Description of Violation:
overgrown shrubs and bushes, dead shrubs and bushes, trash abd debris in the
plant beds and a fallen parking lot lot. See Photos
5. Date violation must be corrected by: Jun 4, 2024
6. Date violation first observed on or about: May 13, 2024
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance,with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s)cited herein,you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 11 th
day June, 2024 at 6:00 P.M.,located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall,Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers.The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony,and shall make an order thereupon.You are entitled to be
represented by counsel,present evidence,and present testimony.Please be advised that any evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department.If you fail to appear at the hearing the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation,&impose a fine in your absence.
,R cShtzei
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based.Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla.Statute 162.11(2005),an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court.Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida,un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa final a la tribunal
de c rcuito.Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara.
Exhibit 4
•
`. City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement
50 SE 2nd Ave.
Okeechobee, Florida 34974
(863)763-9795
RECEIPT
(If Served by Hand Delivery)
I, / LZ c_ have received a copy of the Statement of
Vi6lation and Notice of Hearing that will be held in this case before the City of Okeechobee
Code Enforcement Special Magistrate on June 11 , 2024 at 6:00 PM., located at
Okeechobee City Hall, 55 SE 3rd Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34974 in Council Chambers.
Name of Property/Business Owner
/OY7 Y &C))
Case Number
Property/Business Owner Signature
/A 4h / �4r6 �Y
Property/Business Owner Name (Printed)
Ci)r-77‘-//
Date
rekY(Ii/-1S1 —0,f-11)
ID
DOB/EXP
Exhibit 4
U.S. Postal Service'
CERTIFIED MAIL® RECEIPT
Domestic Mail Only
1-1
For delivery information,visit our website at www.usps.com4.
cCI
_1- Certified Mail Fee
.
$ / t,/„A.,
-•".
Services&Fees(check bar.add lee es ahpropessle(
0-Return Receipt(hz,$C.P) -70' •
ru Return ReceiPt(elect.,e0) Postmadr.,
CM1
Li Certified Mall Restricted Deilvery $ Here
0 Aeult Strjrlature Requi-ed
DAduft Signature Restricted DAvery
D Postage
Total Postage and Fees
fU
11.1 Sept To
./2
• -
1:7 teei`ific7A`pt.No.,or P()gaz ftio.
rs- • ',-
city-A.3re,21P,43
PS Form 3800,April 2015 PA rszo•oa•coaso47 See Reverse for instructions
Exhibit 4
•
SENDER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY
• Complete items 1,2,and 3. A. Signature
■ Print your name and address on the reverse X \fiCtcr Dny._ ❑Agent
so that we can return the card to you. ❑Addressee
■ Attach this card to the back of the maiipiece, S. Received by(Printed Name) C. Date of Delivery
or on the front if space permits.
iv aoc„o.,, .;dress different from item 1? 0 Yes
delivery address below: p No
Spirit Cv Okeechobee FL LLC CVS Health -%Corp c/o c/o Altus Group US Inc.
1 CVS Drive -
Woonsocket, RI 02895-6146
II I'II��I I'I 1I(I III IIII 'I IIII I 1I I I I ❑Adult Signature rr ❑Priority Mail Express®
0 Registered Mail,.
❑Adult Signature Restricted Delivery 0 Registered Mail Restricted
0 Certified Mail® Delivery
9590 9402 8118 2349 5921 56 0 Certified Mail Restricted Delivery 0 Sigreture Confirmationre
❑Collect on Delivery ❑Signature Confirmation
2- Article Number(Transfer from service Iahell 0 Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery
,iail
7022 2410 0002 7643 8017 .lal Restricted Deliivery
PS Form 3811,July 2020 PSN-7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt
Exhibit 4
w,"
ip, s, ..4-.•"6"431..A.'.—
- 4,...
. i kik
". ' •••"/17-' • ' : ,)1
IL' !'
11111
-, •,..I r I ....,,I 44'.
' •••• •••'- ... ,
"•
••••• ,..-
c ;• - t •
0.,.,..so . .•-• •,; t t , 1^.0. • /
IL' ......0 _—
s, . _ ,, ,, , . :,fr4e- >•:.;'••"?'• ,•.:.."70*.i4 '''., I
• •. 4,4,, ,- , • , s •,..• 3'
•-;.,,-re......,.4; 1".•*:"•••• ..:V.4..0", "--
`, e, ':'' ••,,, •44.. .. f..1-;4:‘d: .. '-'; ..- :1%*-„'' %t,':,......,,i' -ior,-,,,--w •
---' i-,, .• . . • •..... :,....T..-1. `-_-; .. - ...:,(.•''. it
. .., .,
, .
...._
.........-
-.....4."-' .
060061120263 IVII:a0
1.... ..___ _...‘
....
..
... i N . •
A - ---t•r ".. l • ' -, ;
f.4. 4'. , 4 :AI . ..-.:"• • .i , . . .. .z- V ,. ,.:.P.,,4.: ? ;...., ,r4s-c
.1 r is....,di `(.-'3\-..,);4..i i:-.:..., , '... , .-;;...•.",";...-1..-',-t'...'..'.. 1.): ....,...;•,. • ..... .....-
......., lo...-T,,-.. .4..........:::-::.., . . :-.,,_...... • ,..• $.:,,s t.:-Ii..i,r,i iv". -.-•-•
co-,- yo -..,... . '' • .....:, ., , • -.'.',' .........-•i '.-.. qt. ,... -'',..4"." r...'•, V‘.-4'
, — 1.'• '1.1....11 • • . ..1 1-; Ir.
r
... * • *- f .1"t, ... •
'le
' `r 1 e :IA .1 •• '""4. .‘-ii.:-.17;%C..- . , ..,...i.. 9V• .. ''''• • 1
, • . %X.• 4" I tie- •,..Ir. '.".;.:. '. .4. .:• f.:•r.4." • .....›.
, c.....,,-A,%,*,.. i,,.;,... ' . ...• .... • t•..t, t•r ' •,.L. • .5.. .:, .T .+:41.4, -
* - -,*,..-ill-4 w .4",--;. " 1 ,..
o144„ „..
• t .4 • .; ••-.,„14 ..„:',...1.41 *,; ....",:-: , -•: •.--,•i , ';',,4.1 ,•• 3,4* ,Ake..,**,4.',. 4 la:-
,;i„•••*,:z, S.eat.',' 'A.'s%ii'.'".1",,• , .. •,A.,,•:. -----;:. ; 12,-, ,..!'.-;'.ifrjr.:,•••,•...- w„,_1...
c& ',,1h•po...‘,... • ,* -;Ai-•, V;;;:- ,-,:• ; --,',to. ' "",• !.4„, ,
• •f.4 ';, t•(,... . '• , , .. ..-• I •._.-t i' •1 i ,y, ' . ‘'' , f -- i " )4 14' "', . ,' • %. r I ••• ',V - - .4.4 .,:-,A,4,;bove4 A,, , •. „ : 1,1.0 "' i •, s. ,..,k4,2 . bp . ••.:,
o,„ . -.. 1,.T.,0,4 ' , .-0;?-• ./.,1 . ' '... 4.,,4.: , ‘‘ .. • ' , 1 I • ,-I*:', '
i.
.,..., ,
Og1106,102U26,1 T6,1: 3N
Exhibit 4
•
�� ^ti' IAA , .a ;
i
1r ,
ck
a ,
• rk r Rr...I � w;
c'..t�
•' z:4 •- iz._a'.' -' • �►',tI �t
-`. •. �.. - ;~1!'.,I :�r+^A' --4�P' ''f*!p'1%1;'.1 [ t o +
af •
•
W0134302026 T(2.4
11.
lil /
444.
•
4111
COOM02026 94:211
I :fall
. ‘
hi r 4 4if
...NI•
AA 40. . -
t 'z 1 ' •. ;0,4.r#' • 1,t,.1-4.4-..v... #e . • .
0-1.4•0`)0'.''..‘,-••'t • - , , ,!:".,,torgir'."..q.. it-.:.
.. ..„, 4 •' •421. ‘4:11.,..,,...bir ... .
.‘ ';' ' ;', .4." • ' - :..• ;v ,.•- .7, .„4„tAy•-,1,.- ,--.. , " •i"---`•i'".' ... '-;;;,,ikr=-
Is . .•-•A ,3. t,,-, • '••. ... .r-7•• . trifi;e4iit: ;i.;;,".. _bi-., ;',:fL_Iti%-; ..CiP'
•• t ' . - .,t, '•, . -
•,,4 v •,. •otok--OP% i l;4:;:k. t Ir., 1_,-... at".Ptl'...„‘irolir, -,,,p,,Turi G 0 V
v.. :i I" • ''',fr''' 4' '' 'l'' •••,V `•2•ci„,), , •, • IX/..06 ik,t.,,,.• .e• . J..,..2.7 ...,.,11,2....4., .,,,:. , .
• . • :. '.•.$1141 1 ).4.1 0 i'':.til‘ '1 kir/' ‘.F4:., ...'' • ' 1..!' • P'I.' . ....)17, f,,:•-
:,. , , .1i/. 1' ,iinL 01.,1.3.,,,..,.ii.....1 ,.., , ., .*, • ,-... .•-.1,i . 4 liv.,:. • 'sit( . t, y • „.. .-, )fit, .1 'V •7•Al' ".'A. ' •••% * ' ' •-• '
irk, ,., _ , • ' tt -• ' .4 •. :1.1..,L--
16 A • * 'en' '.. ' ,:t;-7"1:r•-• . - :e 1. •-•-1*. .46' % ''':11. srOrf'
'.." --' •',-AL :'f•'• •:' ,.• ' ::.t 4.'t. ...I
lar: ' ' • ''. --,+,* 'A, - ••. ...„
,....•... :.. . .: •'.'„40.4'0.14,,,k.‘,;•. ' .1. -., ---,----
.• .
-- . . • . •-- •-. ' •
.• , , . _ • - . ,
,,,, •
Viler4 "• '. ..n t....41,.4•,!..:0~A 04 i. •' , .
. -
-
- — - __
,..... L-....-..... •-•••••
a6)§U6,i ii 202(3. 11(3:g(6,
mei .40111.111 :%,
-- .
r i lie........
. "
II
millgia•- - _ t*qii, j...... , .....!_.-
r
OAL
Is -
v
• ''\ . t.
. ' - ''. 41.,.-• •• ' ;-.'- se...e.,,,. ,:.•:-,.;y'h.,_,A. •f.,..,--s;.,.."..).5.14..›I'x'?'',.. •••-••,-;''',C:i; v :' " -.•,,,, 3,C47'..'.1.4; ',' '.• *-. .''''.-it.t.zi'IC.C'''t t , -..-Nt: -,..1•.,... ....-4-.c.-- . ,:110,--,, ,,- . ... ,f,;,•>-•11.,.:!:.,' -"44..,..--..t.,1",4 ' .....,' ,hol -•t...-4,4, • -,..i.r.T.1:,rir..,* :T.' '..'-zir, ..•.-,00.,- , ,e—0 1:•,,i7`..gP 1:f. ' .,/folveiiA'' , -,.'!iii...'4g1..• 4
.? i A Ii
• , .e....r. ..*,.. 1.1.,,,, ,•.,:;......,,,,,,......t.,. ,.. ,, ,,,,,,,i,„... ...,..ta,, Itr,..„:1,,,..44,,-...,;;,:t.;,:....,-,4,.....,,,..]..s.,,./.. .. ,;.,, ,,,,_....„,...,..:,,,,e............,5„1.0:4,,,.".,,,,„ ...i.,,,... .,....;
‘. ' -.,. .,,...-- -m1,-,,. vv., 1,0 ,,,,,.• ,:_,..•Jr'1' I.1 dr x.It qt...,,,.,4.g.s.lv,.. : •-..,;_ 4..,:zitt;Ilk.*-;.."--11 i.,-, ... .
ift% ,4 .4 .- i31k12-4'• •(:‘ • :4- N'.1:i:4:•..4.'"A1Q'•-tig.,,-;', 11•.;;CiA4-*If! . .,ZL:''
'. -• sir-;4V* ''10, Nika =I:..,''' V • ;4 4,0e,. ••••..--zner. IN-St 1.,...41. vit,,,, at .;„ -,, 4, •
'' !• ,,,..P" "P'tr,'•,....,...1,111F, 4.1. '11,\ft . ' ; 4.7.31.4.r.; :?- ',',";":;',„;,,:„,, .*':,'', :...140,,7.•..:t .,;,,;.,•:•4.x._,.....,.., • ,,,,.1,',e.•,..i•Li,..., t irt.4,1,44.,,..,-•_ ' g_fiec-,11 •• ... .• -, ...44 -,'" ..t: '.._ , -,...jk"4:1 R ‘..y 7,,,r4'104 , ',7• 4k .r4,
4440
. .., .. , .. „1-,..,. ..t..., ,..,,Itoo, ...1f 61,.•• _f!".• „,,
• ;', iferif;ti•' .,' .4!''-..3' 'TA' --,17. s• .'' •••-•-1.• -0.7'1,#, ---:'-rt--..-,• -:-. ..ii--. -,--:-
*460, •% -*, 0.-1T0,-- -. . .::. ,
- •
- .. ....--- _
• .,
- . .
. - -
. .
• • .- U00063828263 9(3:gU
Exhibit 4
1, ....m.t.... Iv i M www.rIc.com
LE3119
.. • -,, , ,
. . ..., ,,, .....
1 ,-,,.; • ,,,.. ,„ ..
• r„. 40,4.0.,•,-.-....-z..,-!,..dvoi... — .....—
,... .0. 4.;
, . . ...
fr. e • i ,I
k ..':•*' ...`;'+.3. 1•gi. ':i; 'l
. 40.\\''' k.„, .It •''' -
' '''•• . -'.'VAS'' ji'Ir.'70. •'-'7 '''N *''',. ..;..",:4:14, ;',\
i .
,,,_ ,. ., ‘ .
'- '‘t. t X_r••-'-;'). i •.",•:-4 I, ..-
. ;ti.--,..,,,,- A" -. '.IN , - - .•
i ?
. —` . .,:. - ., ' .. ' -t...,. ........_
. • woo
.., ,1 .•tiii.
I. il ,
I I,
1
,
i
1
1 ::. ,.,... ..,
•fik•' \ -.•170 fyivfiit
_ ... .. ..., ..,
nsalantiidalgV fi-. ',.....!"..44/PCZ:' . ' . ' - • 104...
,, iaffittl'frW
,.. or . , ,,,.*W:-. 4a,4*!!‘t ' • , -'..-
• ..,,.„ _,,,,,, .41%. -nue
• '
. ...._ . ,,
. . .'L
•
. ..
. .
......
' ,, .,'- •
•. ., .•- ...C.i.117i1Z •
74 • lyskj".1t46. "
T.
..--
,.,
,. _. -- - , • - _ . . , .,-..
' IN.
. 'rip,!,gl I ir
, '0,.. ..•
14
. .:
•
• -
. r .
. , .
.,.
• -
. ..11
II ihni GUI -
COOCY30202c3 4 :gV
Exhibit 4
.,4-le'.'''' ?TM •
. tr.
Pk ...• ,
_.-
r •.....'--.
'\‘ % All /.7.4:•`..."'••••-..t. -. 1:;..-- --: • ,. ' : .--- liv.,4 ).-
4t..
'b
_ - .--1,-- ' '
. ...- . .. ..
,/,,,,: „.- -,..........--., I ... •.--'. ..: -i-4:-*4- • .,A .."
::
ft ic• .1s• - 8,.,-16- .
tupg'`.
• t4S4r`:. ... (,IAi.V,
,j....t..........).,," ,•.-7,.-ks....g.i.T....:-,',i."0.t...•'_. ,'
. .i
•4,1,1k ..•,.\' ,,- .i -1 N ,;. t`k.. 4-,-- - _ -- 0,, , ,: .._. - ,
' " . 4 --
01'
' ....
-- •
.•-
.00V i lipproft10111,teenz•
f.-
...,
' 0 ORJ , 1 4 0137/ •-•-. =
__•-••
-...• •
.... . .
.7.....
111610
. ‘.
I.
\ f '
11)-- :i.,‘ 49 I
i FV.
-,i.
low•i•,n',_:':4-:''-'-.`.-,.--,''--.'.'.,-•••.l _,.,_..,._...._.C,_,,.,L'7. p '.:A•`:.-.•M g. :1.'•..,1..M,1i•,.l,;7- e t\-C'.4Ai ii f l b4) -1,,: . ! 4 ''. ..4 ' 1: '1 ' • r , i47. -I...0•'t`
!„ -. , , '.
-- ...__- ••
-_-_
.
-'. -•• - '....!'fl.: \i' /
V - ." ,..K.•..,..:,it:P.-;.' . . .,--,:. .'Y -t. ----•• '`77.. • ,
_._ .. 10" ‘, '' ' ' mr, '.* 4.:,-..r::':1'•:bt•,..1. ,.,\' .*;,'L ,;-s '''',Z,,, .-:;S'z
-‘14:'.:400_,;1. -111..",0 1,kt,'';."., ' 4-_ . '. -tt,,-,,,jyt44' . ,pr-... • '7.'1- ;
..,,,,,••4=it-•••• . , ,.--, •:,.- .,. t. _,. -•_; " ,-.•., dt_ .1,,-•
41, _ _ ._. ----,,..6-4(... ...."
Mr.-4:0',A44.r.tnr• . ,4-.41• , r, -
, • ,,'---, ,t,-vi.„„.4 :',04,;-,1. ./ -."*. — -, •,414,
-- —. . , - . —
i 1
-- . )..- - -
---.-
. i. . _
_ _ • .._, . -
_
.. •: ..,,....„-• ..4-,:44..,,,
,
*Iit
..c....,
" . 1
\,
-- -2;31.—,• ,-1.,---1._i „---._ •
I 'I](r, :38
1 ' ,,--.5...• -:._ .
Exhibit 4
- -
1. .N.`413r..*w. •
1C4:1 --"81111111Alibb.-
- —
- - • 3111
• :
_ •
•Ir-- • .- r 1••-4/.4 -
Ong C6 2C)2 :
Arrt