The URL can be used to link to this page

2023-10-10 V. A. Exhibit 1, Case #230918005 Exhibit 1 V. A. Exhibit #1 Case #230918005 Freddie L. and Ruby L. Minton Exhibit 1 Code Enforcement Hearing October 10, 2023 Case Number, Name and Address: Case#230918005, Freddie L., and Ruby L. Minton, 302 NE 8th Ave Code Section Violated Description of Violation Chapter 30 Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles Several inoperable/abandoned/unlicensed vehicles on the property Chapter 30 Sections 30-43 Public nuisances and Overgrown weeds, and bushes,junk/debris all over the 30-44 General cleaning and beautification property Chapter 54, Sections 54-81 Use as a residence, A recreational vehicle being used as a residence, parked in and 54-84 Parking in residential district. a residential district without having such vehicle stored inside an enclosed garage or other structure or parked on a paved driveway or parked to the side or rear of the principal structure, with maintaining the applicable rear and side yard setbacks. Photos: See attached Is respondent a Repeat Violator? Yes, Previous Case# 220222009 Summary: • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of notice Type of notice Received Date by received /returned September 8, 2023 Code Officer Curl spoke with the property owner's son during the initial inspection of the property and explained to him what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and advised him that he had a week to remove the RV from the property. September 15, 2023 Code Officer Curl inspected the property, still non-compliant, no progress has been made. She spoke with the property owner's son again and explained to him again what needed to be addressed. He stated that he had been sick but would get everything taken care of. September 18, 2023 SOV/NOH, photos, and City Ordinances mailed via USPS certified Ruby Sept 21, return receipt for the October 10, 2023 Hearin.. Minton 2023. October 3, 2023 Code Officer Smith inspected the property; still non-compliant, several untagged/ disabled vehicles on the property, tent in the back of the property being used as a residence and overgrown grass and weeds needs to be cut, and trash debris on the property. Photos in file. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 1 • To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to cut all the overgrown vegetation, remove, or tag the disabled vehicles, and remove all the trash and debris on the property. City Recommendation: The City recommends a fine of$150.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 10, 2023, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance on or before that date, plus a $100.00 administrative fee. Chronology attached Page 2 of 2 Exhibit: 1 Case #230918005; Freddie L. & Ruby L. Minton Date Event/Document September 8, 2023 Property owner: Freddie L. & Ruby L. Minton Property address: 302 NE 8th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 Mailing address: 302 NE 8th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 Parcel ID: 3-15-37-35-021 A-00000-0170 (34310) Legal Description: Lot 17, RIVER RUN RESORT, Plat Book 6, Page 18, Okeechobee County public records. Code Officer Curl observed the above-mentioned property to be in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and Chapter 54, Sections 54-81 Use as a residence, 54-84 Parking in residential district. For having several inoperable/abandoned/unlicensed vehicles on the property, overgrown weeds and bushes, junk, and debris all over the property and a recreational vehicle being used as a residence and parked in a residential district without having such vehicle stored inside an enclosed garage or other structure or parked on a paved driveway or parked to the side or rear of the principal structure, with maintaining the applicable rear and side yard setbacks. **********Repeat violator, previous Case#220222009*********** September 8, 2023 Code Officer Curl spoke with the property owner's son during the initial inspection of the property and explained to him what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and advised him that I would give him a week to remove the RV from the property. September 15, 2023 Code Officer Curl inspected the property, still non-compliant, no progress has been made. I spoke with the property owner's son again and explained to him again what needed to be addressed. He stated that he had been sick but would get everything taken care of. September 18, 2023 SOV/NOH, photos, and City Ordinances mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the October 10, 2023 Hearing. Received by Ruby Minton on September 21, 2023. October 3, 2023 Code Officer Smith inspected the property; still non-compliant, several untagged/ disabled vehicles on the property, tent in the back of the property being used as a residence and overgrown grass and weeds and trash debris. Photos in file. Page 1 of 1 Exhibit 1 Okeechobee County Property Appraiser 2023 Preliminary Certified Mickey L.Bandi,CFA updated 9/14/2023 Parcel:Q 3-15-37-35-021A-00000-0170(34310) )) Aerial Viewer Plctometery Google Maps —_ --- _ _ Owner&Property info Result 1 of 4 0 2023 0 2022 02021 0 2020 2019 sale MINTON FREDDIE Lwri.i ' i u Owner MINTON RUBY L + - l , 302 NE 8TH AVENUE OKEECHOBEE,FL 34972 s ,yZ'' 1 , zx s - 1'' i , Site 302 NE 8TH AVE OKEECHOBEE ; J ,..N 'l 7, ....,, Description' RNER RUN RESORT(PLAT BOOK 6 PAGE 18)LOT 17 .,, `r'9 ',1 '„.- R"e'� - c r" .,�. 4'�" 0. `�t. � ,. Area 0.175AC SIT/R 15-37-35 -< �` � Use Code" MOBILE HOME(0200) Tax District 50 r t f ( .i,;r ` y ' rJ"X -The P above a not to be used as the Legal Description for this parcel in any legal transaction. y .; A�, 1 . ''''''',':1-`:::!;: ;.--. _ _ ,'4.. “The yggcagg a a Dept.of Revenue code.Please contact Okeechobee County Planning&Development at 863-763-5548 for zoning Info. fd < t4 Property&Assessment Values -in'° '* a. ' 2022 Certified Values 2023 Preliminary Certified r ,'r _ Mkt Land $7,500 Mkt Land $9,000 * I ¢ 'y St Ag Land $0 Ag Land $O �l Yi I 1-�lt I Building $67,841 Building $78,715 ��`r p t`' $, � `'r -.o.eavw + <>3 XFOB $1,602 XFOB $1,842 .'^+__,! ^ . . .— �`"' ." ."... Just $76,943 Just $89,557 P - _ Class $0 Class $0 _ q 2-15 37-35-OA00-00007-0000(36233) • Appraised $76,943 Appraised $89,557 c '.+ g t'''!",..a..-- '+1t�- 1 RACETRAC PETROLEUM INC c pr. 975 NE PARK ST SOH/10% SOH/10%Cap $59,769 i - t t '. 15/37/35(CONV STORE/GAS)121 AC i Exmpt: $48,023 Cap(7i (71 .i -' f!Ja. Txbl:$6,396,858.00 Assessed $28,920 Assessed $29,788 Exempt HX He DX $25,500 Exempt HX HB DX $29,788 >?! Total eounty:$3,420 chy:$3,420 Total county:SO dty:$0 9.>,f a Taxable other.$3,420 scnod:$3,420 Taxable other.$0 echaar$0 O r • d Note:Property ownership changes can cause the Assessed value of the property to reset to full Market value.wnich could result in higher property taxes. 'a' •a -•II':k. .. _ i 1r Sales History Sale Date Sale Price Book/Page Deed V/I Qualification(Codes) RCode 2/28/2005 $0 0555/0209 QC I U 03 11/29/2004 $0 0547/0406 QC I U 03 9/1/1986 $54,000 0281/1197 WD I 0 Building Characteristics Bldg Sketch Description' Year Blt Base SF Actual SF Bldg Value Sketch MH AV(0800) 1986 1210 2004 $78,715 *Aldo Dear determinations are used by the Property Appraisers office solely for the purpose of detenniMng a property's Just Value for ad valorem tax purposes and should not be used for any other purpose. Extra Features&Out Buildings(Codes) Code Description Year Btt Value Units Dims Condition(%Good) AFA W4 MTL FLR MTL 2005 $1,842 100.00 10 x 10 PD(75%) "r Land Breakdown Code Description Units Adjustments Elf Rate Land Value 261RR1 STAND LOT(MKT) 1.000 LT(0.175 AC) 1.0000/1.0000 1.0000// I $9,000/LT I $9,000 Search Result:1 of 4 0 Okeechobee County Property Appraiser I Mickey L.Bandl,CFA I Okeechobee,Florida 1863-783-4422 by:GnzzlyLogic.com Exhibit 1 '4• +* Y y '4 .-- • yS' fi , . c At .4 M ,fir • ., r r.. • l..,r 40 ,• ... t 1. r ,., T f f ,- =' m -.-,►r f.-.r,- .1.-, 8 ' /_OS/2023 I _:( . - �,t r,"R1W. + ii ". d t .�' - .. -. .. _ . t, �4. 'r'F ,-. . ri . as r .,�, r..'�e� ...,r . '..... .:'.! ...—, 4 . ,i„, . ., NJ , , .„:- - --..'‘'o. , ' , . , _ . , . ,..,„ . ..„. . .• - , . iYI''+: LY , •. J«,u 1,y'1'Mb •,•➢ 5.. • , `,yf;e 3 t'''.:4 o,, 1 r - 1 t,,,..,w,k.4.- • t• : 9, ,,', r.:f t i a tl $ '-` wy e 'l � ..,r is ...,,M{ .. ct�'lk:.• 1 ate;; 1 1.. � ..,d'4,4.ih r ..,t"� Exhibit 1 Pr 4 4, ?Ph • ;0414040, ;- 1 110-' 414 4004.,16106, loPmw-tioP t4,1140, 000000202@ 1113: 41 Exhibit 1 -- •. i" ` , -C• - ', ,,,•'1.* ; , ' • ‘. -, t . - .-. 4, •-• .,,„.... , .. ,„,; 'e•; • - •-.,: '";..* - : .• .' ,. ,, , • ' , - - :4•' ;-...44::.* ' • r. r ..,... .,,, f„-, ‘,.- • ,I. .-ir-. It rt :-.....- Al.:-. ,t, 4., ,N ...ow.• ,-- '14 . •• ,.-- 44g, . • - . . . , ., .„,. .•- , %. i• '!...;*.ilk-,.rt,g_iff x4. '', l•• •, •- 2-.`, -.:5, •, 4.1• qi, ; • . 4, t .. '. 47 . . ' . . . , r- s , ,0,. -,.• .t., .flit \lat. . .., .....„,,,,p. --•-••••-- ........„-: ••--. .,,,- .,-- ._ 1 -- —--- .. -4 .;•,,, -i \ •\ t,,,N,‘,,,; N ,.; . . , •e :,.< , - , •'• ' ' ttilf,;',.....,:407„,i'", i •i k , ,,,.,,,...A ,. 3.\\•;•, • '' .:1'...--- qt, ',,i . . ,,,,;.• , - , . r i‘,,,k,':•\ ,•,,,;‘,..t. 4,,t‘ ..,, Ts , '. ,424. ..,,,NA .: — . 001„,d, ' \..,,',' .,;.`,..;,"Y•:,,^N, ‘,‘,\\A A. ; ‘ ' , ••.••••." !RFT ... .. , - ,” - — 1,,,,, ils.,..4.,,;,.. \:,,,,,:* ,.., ‘,. , -,, .4.4.2),-, I ig.„..1.,•;) ,- 7 .4, ''=1** . ---;:, • I -,..:'0. .s.Y...17.:0,;.#4\ . V.,,k t:i,.- ' ie . ' w - -. .... •' ''. ° s.... , ...o. . .- . - . 1..... , $.4. C)0011611202$3 110:ffl .,A 4-k,,,,,, ,,,,,iss,4,,, , --1,40.0.-'*-- ,me) --7•1•'OP,1,. '-'!--k •, ..*, -' . •., , '. .". '.- :".• .... -'-:\'',,----, -.‹. - :d. _-,.w.71:-.n,- :::, - i,,•-.: '••••• :v•• ' I • ••.•:-•u ;*.- • _•; , .--'.! • ‘•• ."•--;t71-74, -.41/4-'• ---*.- •' it , i F.,- ^. • is;• itr....- voi,- ." ,.-• :., - 1 -, tts.iido ..`44%'.,.. . 4 -• a., • .•1 .,,. ,',,,_.— •-.•' ,..: , •• . ,•.'n,-"r,.71,-..' -__., ,-•„_,....' 'SI•••,• , ..4 ^ • .-.•f!..s --.'....:'..• ., ,A.. '1444 , • -. '- G., - '..1*,^ 4 , • ••'.•*4.':••"•., • •• '... ...• ':SfIR • '-p. P ' 1"' •••t ^, ' .• ''••1:t••go, • .II.' s p .• •• i•S':•‘•, '. ' • •i ' . ' •• •'••-'pl. • P ' ' -:,.• ._.. , 1.- ..., .. , .:-, -......f..- , 4,,, ,s; .;.- ,,Ari , - "..:4, •:0 •47 t• , ,..2.1, ,•-•••••,,q"--'., . ..„.,..- "; 4',`v%''4.fm:":.-,Nif4;.-"A•, -'t W" -14: • ,', • -, "7-,Ad ••- wi; _ -, . .-' ,• ,4",.., . it Aof-• •' '...1.,'.. 1 .. •t• v , , ,..... . V .15-. . .._,N, 3:,$,..• ,,,,,, ,,,. 4,,,,, .,.$,.• \ -. ..•e ta* I' f ' '1" ..., ..• a :2 ...,-:..,, ,.„,,,,, Ay• . _4,::A. • .a:, ,...., -. , ,.., 2 ii 4.-- .- .ii ••.10i , ' •• - ' ' la 44 : z - • ' ' ' ,,,,, ....,,,, . ,,,--- J • I '- _,/thi. „I/7n, . 1 • • 1,. _,- - • . . - ., ,110 \._„,..,,\-__.„ c.iit,...-9.-::_,,r.V. -. . ,,.... , - tgiCANY. , , . ., tvlse - ',--• . ..;.et7,..... - ‘ .,,,•,f4,.1-+ . . , , et •• -, ---.:,. -, -.. .., ', . . ,.,.. 8 Weal 2'3 . we. ,•-• _Zoe_ • -:....t:'-'. A.'`1:.`-•••t. ; •=*,'1.144' ... - -:',00%,P --4., . ';'.'•I'll'&sit,, , . :2.:-. , . # i . - •.i 4-11. , ..-5, ..- - ,•,..- , , ... ...., _,...., .., ..4... -• --..0,,.‘. .., ,- . , ;',A,-0, r ,--- ,..,11.-25„,,.,,,,„ r,:t1 i-:/t..• .6,, . • - ' '' - .!'t."+.\W*it ri't,41 -.„...t, z, , .> ••4k•,ter '`'*••••'N.A., •l'•••• :' '041`'" , • t •'-' ''fte, - -•-:&'"' '' .-`' - •"* •..i.."e ,•.;•,v, ';-_ + •• - : \^ • _ . ' , •'' 1-1,-,' " ••• .- - lr-- -* "ka- ""- . Exhibit 1 - i• * ,. .., .. ,Iii, tr . I .1°- • • •,• , , .., • .0 - .e.,....50:... ...: "Yr).• ' 417 . .1' t A I e'4. di • . . ' 3 --. . • 1-.- -•,.. - - •. ....- . . ...1. -.% - , • i . . . . . ,.. . . . .• lif 110,, .— ta . 6 . ".' ••' • Vir‘ - ..' •4 . . . . . l'" . •* -• • '-',„„lb ?A,' .4 ' : • : • . . ' . •. ii. • • , ' ;' a jpi II:.t . - •. lt• li ' . , .• , .. ,. . ., ..... .... „, lo"•. 00 . . . • . - Lo s . .I ., „,-.0'•Ad. •I ' : '• '' ., ii.' ' F ,-. .?, . :f ' A 4T , tali . —....... '• ° .4 a; 1 1 .4 ..‘••'. ..; ' 1 ' ... ._,.,. . s., i , . , : , I It. ,. .., , . 14 .4.. %- „ -......#H_ ' ' , . - -• .. •16.04 r.- •$4. (701E202a Ta:35. .,..., ; , 00 ' •.. • ti. ... _ .. .. - . _ 6, -ii. . • . • • 'Y' - .....it -.. .,-',."--.".".•WV`: ',117;7,/,ViVe''',' ' -- ' • -':. ,c,et''.,,' 4 .L..f/-';:-., i:••0.1.'- • -.,` - . ''. 1,-; -,,'...'""' '.2''' '''', ' . `'''',-."''' .c",, , ::- .•4!., V .4,,,,T,' ''..'' . ''...,'.!i,l' ,' ' • . .4, .. -'•- -• .g.--.44tP,* ''.•'• ...• ,.•••st, , -.• ,. . v ,. • :7...• - , ,I .f:4- '';'' - . .'''' • , . ••• . . 4.- Ai k 17 . • ,,N•4 • 4 - .:4-' li. - . . . ,.-... ',.'....., !e. . •.,t,..,.7.,..1..!:r. , lt ''' Ar.i. , .4:: .:.,,e..4„........4,4e...i.,...!..:...,,14, : ---,,*..-''+'.'7..,' '' '' ' •'• ' It O.?? :i• - . .226 _ .e.•.:'X;'. "•• •-4."••'A'," -,J.,`,i-:•...*:::..',,.., IV' - - .' :' ..'..,---' • . ''''. i'• '-7= 1--',..`, ..-‘- c•‘0C. .. . .. .-..,-ie•-. •.4.",,,,• ‘. • ,...-45gg*--,''., '; ' .,''',51.. : ,,': ' .,•,........,;;.. . 'Cif' ' ' '...,-,::::- .,'•••• ':•---: t:, ,,,,-,;.-,, :*At. .*4k,.‘,%• -•,A A IN,. ,i'..‘, ., .,., c r ''4 ...-'.•"" , \•'V.VAlkiN'k V$417,.:*•\'1 1••••';' . N.•$.-..-. . . i '''.'...' ''' .'. '-411‘011*•;'1" - -,,kro?"-1';44•••.,'"''. .'••';•'• , .. ... ...,•:q,.... . 1 g••••? ,6, ,!,'.4..'.. .....i....- '' ' •• •"••'''':' •s . . -',..• ••'. •'•. .. ..•..A ©011 11'0112020 .11g:M , ,.. _OP4,Isz. ', -:. 6:- °• '.. . ....As", _i _ , '1..6;7 ':'ii,_411: . • _ . Exhibit 1 - " ....;15,14 ,, -4. -` ,gr . . .,(,....,, 4 .-.. -,e--, .• . • — ,,......s,i... .t. ;',I y . N ,' . . ''''l 4,. 1;4'.. 4. ' '41,I P I°.'°1'.. ' . 4...'•y V',4 • . 4 .'1 , , ::7::,,r4::7..:(1,::::::1:5,...4t. i , ,i....:•-.4).-- ' , , . •, "...-' ),„ •q,„ 4' ''.:4 I.;+4. . .,..1.•'.',.:,• . Y. •-iiPla.-.- ,,;'",:' It' . ,,:.: • ,..,+-.,, 1 •;,, :,... . . ',,,,,,X,,.. , ••:.t•;..t st,' ',, •ewlet-.• . ' . ',',.4.•,,s% s;>. l'..;,"- 1 114. - „': . i ' A '1,1 ' —-n v !,,, A* •, I ' ',•-.,'",.1,ter,L, ,,, ''i;e " A _ - ' ' t 1,\ 11 . .,.. 1 •;:-.."..',•''' f2;.':,t't.- .4v,-- ,:,%, . li .- ."-.A., _ ii:t., ,..i'k: , i•, impf..46_,.. I i • -'-'4"s • ,..'":r:k . ' RI T„,e. , : 2S.-,,, , , , ' 0. )/0. : --- i.,... 1314 .i 411rfil!, 11:1;16,4 ACtit i i'd e ,' ; ':.. ' 1 ' j ... 1 ..i,.. .,,t , .a. ,, . 0/7111066' i, :......e:, , - it.A -.ii .e. :7 ' 1,11010., . ' • ''''''-'.i''''..:1" _....,:...,.' 110ittiPtl "..L:' . . / ,<, 09111o112on :tia:a5 .. . _ , • -, _ -- 06 Exhibit 1 .LOkeechobee. City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 _F`. 863-763-9795 Phone CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF 863-763-7804 FAX OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA Petitioner, vs Date September 18, 20 Respondent, CASE NO. 230918005 Freddie L. and Ruby L. Minton STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee),the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section:CH 30, Sections 30-41, 30-43, 30-44, CH 54, Sections 54-81, 54-84 2. Address and Parcel#where violation exists:302 NE 8th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 3-15-37-35-021 A-00000-0170 (34310) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Freddie L. and Ruby L. Minton, 302 NE 8th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 4. Description of Violation: Several inoperable/abandoned/unlicensed vehicles, overgrown weeds/bushes, junk/debris all over the property, RV being used as a residence and improperly parked 5. Date violation must be corrected by: Oct 3, 2023 6. Date violation first observed on or about: Sep 8, 2023 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance,with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s)cited herein,you are hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 10th day October, 2023 at 6:00 P.M.,located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall,Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers.The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony,and shall make an order thereupon.You are entitled to be represented by counsel,present evidence,and present testimony.Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department.If you fail to appear at the hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation,&impose a fine in your absence. l/L�sLfLCL etzhe Christina Curl Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based.Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department. In Accordance with Fla.Statute 162.11(2005),an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court.Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida,un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa final a la tribunal de circuito.Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 1 U.S. Postal Service'"' r, CERTIFIED MAIL° RECEIPT a Domestic Mail Only co co For delivery information,visit our website at www.usps.com r- ( k O Certified Mail fee $ (J Extra Services&Fees(check box,and tee as appropriate) Cl0 Return Receipt(h dccpy) $ 4 Pos� O 0 Batten Receipt(eladroMc) 1 V� t� ❑Certified ac sed Melt Res ed Delivery $ He ❑Adult Signature Required LIMO , � Signature Restricted Delivery$ �,•�—'" r— Postage .-1 s ra Total Postage and Fees Fj • f Sent o r• E1S4 Exhibit 1 SENDER:COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3. , I nat ��/ ✓� 0 Agent • Print your name and address on the reverse / ( y /! .feCJ Addressee so that we can return the card to you. 1 B e0Zriffled Name) C. to of Delivery ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, i .� or on the front if space permits. -- -- __ idress different from item 1? 0 Yes r delivery address below: ❑No Ruby Minton ^ 302 NE 8th Ave Okeechobee, FL. 34972 1111111111 111II 11'1111 111111111 i I 411III 3. Service Type 0 Priority Mail Express® I r❑Adult Signature 0 Registered MailT ❑AdultRestricted Restricted Delivery ❑Registered Mail Restricted Certified Mail® Delivery 9590 9402 8118 2349 5947 78 ci Certified Mail Restricted Delivery 0 Signature CunfirmatlonTM ❑Collect on Delivery 'Cl Signature Confirmation 9 Artir.le NI irnhor?rancfar from enndr•e lotion ❑Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery ait 7022 1670 0001, 7067 8802 fellRestrictedDelivery U PS Form 3811,July 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt Exhibit 1 ,....-.... --- ... IN. \iiir............... F �. F • t,d1 - i Ary.,.. I'z w. iirittiev: ^ i .- w . -. -1..,. . . -4 .... -or4,,'t'?.A'i,-''t's-. #/'-0*1_!-4,,2 Ar.1.,11'.',,'r'•i..';.-:....-1 1:'1 V...._4„-_k1_._-"-"-..-,:e-.a f ... , -. V it ;ft.''`411140,.,,-. ''.''",."-,l 4o.1w).e.r..__.____:.=.._- i'- ,,„ 6." ^,_ J_ ':,.,,,yn `-? `•0 nw^ ' .. ,....„1„1„....4.7., ,_. ._„_. ..... , _ ,;„..,„,,, ,..„.„.„.„:,,,,...r...... .„:3_,, °' __......44 . . . 1 ,i: i 4 mar . ' rs a . ,. tt A. r, 4 / / �,/ r.T. (( r v y Ae =S y',5 . 1' Iv.,-CeAX 10/03/2023 08 56 " � Enjoy Exhibit 1 -• ‘,... ..k , .• 'it ,., i , ,,, , .., ... s i ''' " . ..... \\ , %. . .• 1 40,A Ni.• ' '‘‘, , ••'' t•,` ,' • --'110(4rt ;- , • , •,•„'• , ., Z • , • :. v,.. • . , Nb. • , _ • ..„, • - • - ‘ 41' \' '' ‘*11‘.4' ''.•$'•114 ••N ^ , ., IL 10 ‘.1 s ' IT * •• i ' • , ,....,.,, . NI, 4 • 1/4 . ,...0 1 4'• ' t • , , • ..,, „...,) - 1 • 4 ... ,• *,..„. ' . ,.&at . • *...."' , • ',4,,.. L• •N4N§4ig lig A-A ' „ire' ' ‘%1.4.•`` ,s' . k•••,‘ ' i - • : z. • • .'i , A ;,..,k r•: , g•iiit4 . s i•t %. . r• ti.1, .‘ •A,..... , • . ..."‘ . 46. .,.. ..' .. ...--.; I k '44C'' ' lir - - ,....:.fc' "...•• ...• . '- ,i *kb i . 1. , * '''• . , ' ta. ,• '''''':"' " z•• Aft,.. - , ' - 4.-tiii - -..ir, . • Zit* -14. ''••• r--- '...• ,t t '- . 1 ,, • , - ‘ ,.... • =. - st.....1 , • -,„„•••• , , - ' ;it \ % 4 . . . • .•. "*" , ft. 4,, •ow .• s T .- - Iv et <IP , . ; k '' ' • •' .404*.' ' f • N- ' all 1110110@#202@7:07/ ..* • ' -,.1' k V . . . r. . .6- . .. ., ., . . *, i . ' *:e ,, ' ., ' .11'.*'44P,''e . • - .,... nal 4. AIIP-, NY, : • • • — . - • • '. . 4. „lit, - , ....4.*n, t•'''-f ' . • -v .,, ;' ' N iff .1:;-, -,- - • ''•iro. .., • •Aii,, e 1- , . . ), , .4.,.' ; ' 'flif-,' " .4' "---. - — '• . ,. . ...:-' •-o-....* - i .441. •,- e. --'''-- - - , - -- - , - --F. '"h* -{'' ' . _ _• -..., . • N'''-•s..,N , . 4, ",.. e , , . - - _ ... .. ..,..._ ,..,,,., . ...,'r%I... 1 i-''.• i • '1 •.% c1.4...;:iei, 1 , '42 ,\ _ .. -- „ \ )1/4, . . . .4., , ' l . . .• .4I N,.. - ''': '-0, ".:7\r• .