2022-05-10 CE75
�.�.,� �.-.,
�OF•OKF
(,�1y FCS�
�, °m
� �m
° '- a
"�6
-,�� �O
�1915R
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
MAY 1 O, 2022, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
OFFICIAL MINUTES
I. CALL TO ORDER
Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on
Tuesday, May 10, 2022, at 6:15 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast 3�d
Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special Magistrate
Azcona.
II. ATTENDANCE
Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll. Special Magistrate Roger Azcona,
Esquire, City Attorney Greg Hyden, Police Lieutenant Bettye Taylor, and Code Enforcement Officer
Anthony Smith were present.
�
IV.
CHANGES TO AGENDA
Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred, or
withdrawn; there were none.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH
A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the April 12, 2022, Hearing Minutes.
B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered
an Oath to: Code Officers Smith, Curl; all affirmed. Code Officer Smith stated for the record
all events regarding the Cases to be discussed occurred within the corporate limits of the
City of Okeechobee. The Officer's notes, testimony, photographs, and support documents
were all entered as part of the official record.
V. CONTINUED CASES
A. Case No. 220222010; Carole Rosenberg LLC, 822 Southeast (SE) 8th Street [Legal
Description: Lot 9 of Block 5, WILCOX SHORES, Plat Book (PB) 3, Page (PG) 5,
Okeechobee County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for
the record to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41
Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification.
VI. NEW CASES
A. Case No. 220104005; Clifford Earl and Vicki Lynn Joiner, 309 SE 11'h Avenue [Legal
Description: �ots 22 thru 27, inclusive of Block C, OKEECHOBEE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY'S
ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, according to the plat thereof recorded in PB 1, PG 6, public records of
Okeechobee County, FL, also: the West-half of the vacated alley lying adjacent to said Lots 22 thru 27.
Together with the following: being a portion of Lots 1 thru 9 of said Block C; also: the East-half of the vacated
alley lying adjacent to said Lots 1 thru 9, and projected North to the Hopkins Meander Line of said Block C;
also: the vacated alley lying between a portion of said Lot 1 and the said Hopkins Meander Line, and being
more particularly described as follows: commence at the Southwest (SW) corner of Lot 15, of said Block C,
said corner being also the SE corner of a vacated alley lying in said Block C, and lying also on the North
right-of-way (ROW) line of SE 4th Street; thence bear South 89°34'43" West, along said North ROW Line,
for a distance of 10.00-feet to the centerline of said vacated alley; thence bear North 00°06'32" West, along
said centerline, for a distance of 150.00-feet to the point of beginning (POB); thence continue North
00°06'32" West, along said centerline and projected North, for a distance of 251.40-feet to the intersection
with said Hopkins Meander Line; thence bear South 72°07'03" East, along said Hopkins Meander Line, for
a distance of 45.50-feet to a point; thence bear South 06°23'00" West for a distance of 228.75-feet to a point;
thence bear South 02°32'33" West for a distance of 10.00-feet to the intersection with the South boundary
line of Lot 9; thence bear South 89°37'49" West, along said South boundary line and projected across said
alley or alleyway for a distance of 16.95-feet to the POB].
Code Officer Smith testified that the properry is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter
30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for
overgrown weeds, grass, trees, bushes, or shrubs. The respondent is not a repeat violator.
A Courtesy Card was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) regular mail on
December 16, 2021.The properry was inspected and found to be non-compliant on January
3, 2022. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing (SOV/NOH) was mailed via USPS
certified return receipt on January 4, 2022. The City has not received a notice of delivery as
of the date of this hearing. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on
January 25, 2022, February 16, 2022, and March 1, 2022. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS
certified return receipt on March 29, 2022. The notice was received by Vicki Joiner on April
6, 2022. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 27, 2022 and
May 3, 2022. To comply with City Ordinances, the property owner needs to cut the overgrown
trees, bushes, and shrubs. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21-days
after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner
brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
May 10, 2022, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 1 of 2
[l�:
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
A. CONTINUED: Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case
No. 220104005 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43
Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of
$50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property fail to
come into compliance within 21-days after the date of this Hearing.
B. Case No. 220329010; Tom Nguyen, 210 SE 3�d Street [Legal Description: Lot 1 of Block 208,
FIRST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, PB 1 and 5, PG 11 and 6, Okeechobee County public
records].
Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter
30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General
cleaning and beautification for disabled riding lawnmowers, untagged/disabled RV, and
overgrown vegetation, piles of wood and the front of the home and roof in need of cleaning.
The respondent is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail
on March 14, 2022. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on March
22, 2022 and March 29, 2022. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on
March 29, 2022. The notice was received by Tom Nguyen on April 5, 2022. The properry
was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 27, 2022, and May 3, 2022. To comply
with City Ordinances, the properry owner needs to clean up and/or remove junk and debris
from the properry The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21-days after the
date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the properry owner brings
the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 220329010
to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41
Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of
$50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property fail to
come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing.
C. Case No. 220405015; Mary Alice McCormack, 904 Northwest 5t'' Street [Legal Description:
Lot 24 and West half of Lot 25 of Block 99, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PB 5, PG 5,
Okeechobee Counry public records].
Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of the Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification for having junk all over the property, overgrown grass, weeds, and trash and/or
debris all over the front and side of the property. The respondent is not a repeat violator. A
Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on March 17, 2022. The property was
inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 5, 2022. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS
certified return receipt on April 5, 2022. The notice was received by Walter Piscatelli on April
13, 2022. The properry was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 27, 2022 and
May 3, 2022. To comply with City Ordinances the property owner needs to clean up and/or
remove debris from the front and side of the property and cut the overgrown vegetation. The
City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21-days after the date of the Special
Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the properry into
compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 220405015
to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public
nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of $50.00 per
day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property fail to come into
compliance within 21-days after the date of this Hearing. /%
VII. ADJOURN MEETING
There being no further business to come before the Special
at 6:43 P.M.
Roger Azcona,
A ST:
ristina Curl
Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special
Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal
is to be based. City Clerk media are for the sole purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk.
May 10, 2022, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 2 of 2
/��.//.ii.V4 �
�'� � • �
.
. �
� .
. �.
.�
.���
�,,,.���'
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
MAY 10, 2022, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
DRAFT OFFICIAL MINUTES
CALL TO ORDER
Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order
on Tuesday, May 10, 2022, at 6:15 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast
3�d Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special
Magistrate Azcona.
II. ATTENDANCE
Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll. Special Magistrate Roger
Azcona, Esquire, City Attorney Greg Hyden, Police Lieutenant Bettye Taylor, and Code
Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith were present.
�
I1��
CHANGES TO AGENDA
Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred,
or withdrawn; there were none.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH
A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the April 12, 2022, Hearing Minutes.
B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively
administered an Oath to: Code Officers Smith, Curl; all affirmed. Code Officer Smith
stated for the record all events regarding the Cases to be discussed occurred within the
corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee. The Officer's notes, testimony, photographs,
and support documents were all entered as part of the official record.
V. CONTINUED CASES
A. Case No. 220222010; Carole Rosenberg LLC, 822 Southeast 8th Street [Legal
Description: Lot 9 of Block 5, WILCOX SHORES, Plat Book 3, Page 5, Okeechobee
County public records]. No action on this matter was requested but is noted for the record
to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled
vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification.
VI. NEW CASES
A. Case No. 220104005; Clifford Earl and Vicki Lynn Joiner, 309 Southeast 11 th Avenue
[Legal Description: OKEECHOBEE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY Lots 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, and 27,
inclusive of Block C, OKEECHOBEE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY'S ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE,
according to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 6, public records of Okeechobee County, Florida.
also: the West half of the vacated alley or alleyway lying adjacent to said Lots 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, and 27,
inclusive, of Block C, OKEECHOBEE DEVELOPMENT COMPANY'S ADDITION to Okeechobee, according
to the plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 1, Page 6, public records of Okeechobee County, Florida. Together
with the following: being a portion of Lots 1 through 9 of Block C, OKEECHOBEE DEVELOPMENT
COMPANY'S ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, according to the plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 1, Page
6, of the public records of Okeechobee County, Florida. also: the East half of the vacated alley or alleyway
lying adjacent to said Lots 1 through 9, and projected North to the Hopkins Meander Line of said Block C.
also: the vacated alley or alleyway lying between a portion of said Lot 1 and the said Hopkins Meander Line
of Block C, and being more particularly described as follows: commence at the Southwest corner of Lot 15,
of said Block C, said corner being also the Southeast (SE) corner of a vacated alley or alleyway lying in said
Block C, and lying also on the North right-of-way (ROV� line of SE 4th Street; thence bear South 89°34'43"
West, along said North ROW Line, for a distance of 10.00-feet to the centerline of said vacated alley or
alleyway; thence bear North 00°06'32" West, along said centerline, for a distance of 150.00-feet to the point
of beginning (POB); thence continue North 00°06'32" West, along said centerline and projected North, for a
distance of 251.40-feet to the intersection with said Hopkins Meander Line; thence bear South 72°07'03"
East, along said Hopkins Meander Line, for a distance of 45.50-feet to a point; thence bear South 06°23'00"
West for a distance of 228.75-feet to a point; thence bear South 02°32'33" West for a distance of 10.00-feet
to the intersection with the South boundary line of Lot 9; thence bear South 89°37'49" West, along said
South boundary line and projected across said alley or alleyway for a distance of 16.95-feet to the POB].
Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification
for overgrown weeds, grass, trees, bushes, or shrubs. The respondent is not a repeat
violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) regular
mail on December 16, 2021.The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant
on January 3, 2022. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing (SOV/NOH) was mailed
via USPS certified return receipt on January 4, 2022. The city has not received anything
back as of the date of this hearing. The property was inspected and found to be non-
compliant on January 25, 2022, February 16, 2022, and March 1, 2022. A SOV/NOH
was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 29, 2022. The notice was received
by Vicki Joiner on April 6, 2022. The property was inspected and found to be non-
compliant on April 27, 2022 and May 3, 2022. To comply with City Ordinances, the
property owner needs to cut the overgrown trees, bushes, and shrubs. The City
Draft May 10, 2022, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 1 of 3
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
A. CONTINUED: recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21-days after the date of
the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the
property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
220104005 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43
Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of
$50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property
fail to come into compliance within 21-days after the date of this Hearing.
B. Case No. 220329010; Tom Nguyen, 210 Southeast 3�d Street [Legal Description: Lot 1
of Block 208, FIRST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1 and 5, Page 11 and 6,
Okeechobee County public records].
Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-
44 General cleaning and beautification for disabled riding lawnmowers,
untagged/disabled RV, and overgrown vegetation, piles of wood and the front of the
home and roof in need of cleaning. The respondent is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy
Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on March 14, 2022. The property was inspected
and found to be non-compliant on March 22, 2022 and March 29, 2022. A SOV/NOH
was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 29, 2022. The notice was received
by Tom Nguyen on April 5, 2022. The property was inspected and found to be non-
compliant on April 27, 2022, and May 3, 2022. To comply with City Ordinances, the
property owner needs to clean up and/or remove junk and debris from the property The
City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21-days after the date of the Special
Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the property into
compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
220329010 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40
Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and
imposed a fine of $50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00
should the property fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of
the Hearing.
C. Case No. 220405015; Mary Alice McCormack, 904 Northwest 5th Street [Legal
Description: Lot 24 and West half of Lot 25 of Block 99, CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, Plat
Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records].
Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of the Code of Ordinances
Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification for having junk all over the property, overgrown grass, weeds, and trash
and/or debris all over the front and side of the property. The respondent is not a repeat
violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on March 17, 2022. The
property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on April 5, 2022. A SOV/NOH
was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on April 5, 2022. The notice was received
by Walter Piscatelli on April 13, 2022. The property was inspected and found to be non-
compliant on April 27, 2022 and May 3, 2022. To comply with City Ordinances the
property owner needs to clean up and or remove debris from the front and side of the
property and cut the overgrown vegetation. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per
day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022,
unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a
$50.00 administrative fee.
Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No.
220405015 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40
Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and
imposed a fine of $50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00
should the property fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of
the Hearing.
VII. ADJOURN MEETING
There being no further business to come before the Special Magistrate, the Hearing was
adjourned at 6:43 P.M.
Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate
Draft May 10, 2022, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 2 of 3
ATTEST:
Christina Curl
Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special
Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim
record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to
be based. City Clerk media are for the sole purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk.
Draft May 10, 2022, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 3 of 3
■ �.
�.
�
NE�1aMEDIA INC. USA
Lake Okeechobee News
313 NW 4th Avenue
Okeechobee, FL 34972
863-763-3134
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF OKEECHOBEE
Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Ka-
trina Elsken Muros, who on oath says that she is Editor
in Chief of the Lake Okeechobee News, a weekly news-
paper published in Okeechobee County, Florida; that the
attached copy of advertisement, being a Public Notice in
the matter of
Public Notice
in the 19th Judicial District of the Circuit Court of
Okeechobee County, Florida, was published in said news-
paper in the issues of
04/27/22
(Print Dates)
or by publication on the newspaper's website, if authorized,
on
04/27/22. 04/28/22. 04/29/22. 04/30/22. 05/01 /22 05/02/22. 05/03/22
05/04/22
(Website Dates)
Affiant further says that the newspaper complies with all
legal requirements for publication in Chapter 50, Florida
Statutes.
�,%" c� ��
f '"� �..,``.�— t-`.` �'�/� %f /��`-'�.--`"^---
Katrina Elsken Muros
Sworn to and subscribed before me by means of
� Physical Presence �X Online Notarization
�h, s� ical �resence or online notarization, this
28th day of April. 2022.
.. __ � _.__.__.._._. b�
t�p�Fcy•., �r�1�i�f �JUF.MA�MY
`�'� �'°' i�1Y COiNMISStON # HH 129146
-"� 2Q25
'.' ,�•-p ;• e7(PIRES: 41ay 12,
'�'•S`?>,'� ��?: � Dcaded Thru Not2ry Pubfic UndevN,lters
_ _---.----- —
Q7Y OF OI�CHOBEE
PUBLIC NOTI�
CODE ENFORCEMEM SPECWL MAQSIRATE HEARING
P10fI(E S FER�Y QVEN tl�at the Gty d OI�aJnbee Cade Fidd�
ment Spa�al Mag� will cmduct a pudk hearirg on May 10, 2022, 6
PM, a as �mn thea3lW as pc�ble, at Gry I-mll, 55 g 3rd Ate, Rrt7 200,
a�d,d�, �.
m� �� ��,�ma m�d a�d � r�d «� �i rre�ms copes a u,�
w�i te a�a�ade aeuu,e ma�,y a�y �e �cvaa,�r,aadm �xm
me meeting Gom me v.�fe M�S://www.rn.ycta�.dntxamrcv���-
�,�-cor��r��„g,rru,+.
ef anvcs�n rr�e m�d ya, �r�,d ro�,o� �.,- a«»r�,e, v�, w�,
a i�rrs In tlie .:pa-ial Magatra� in suppart or oppostion In arty i�m m the
Cnde Er(� S� (or CM1yS raotds. ANY PERSOf DE�
IIJG 70 NTEAI. arry dgiam m�de by the Spaial f�6gi�ate wilh req�,t
to ary n� mr�sdaed atth's rr�rg wil naad lo aisue a eebatin rea�rd
I dtlx ryocarlirg is made ard ihe recu�d indu�tlie tatirary ard eAderice
i upon vAuh Ihe appa3l vnl be bav�. In aandarce wdh the Nrei�rs wAh
Digbdities Pct, pe�sms wiih dimbiliia r�aiing �al attormiodapm to p�-
i tio�mu,�v���,a,aca,�ta,ecaae�r«�„��o��,�
a mii ec�a�-�z, r��r� u�va��m: ao�aa affiv �-i-i r�o mr� m�, ra,�
txs� days prior m pae�ing.
Of� OR MORE QiY OF OI�EQIOBEE OOUPlCLL MEMBQLS MAY
BE IN ATfEDDAN� ATTFUS MEEflNG, 7}RS NDTDCE LS P067ED
TO M�T STATE PU&.IC NOTI� REQUIItEMFN15 AND ���E
U1VYS.
sv: an�n�ru, s�ai ru�so-a�
s�ssai �av a�vlzoz2
(Signature of Notary Public)
STAMP OF NOTARY PUBLIC
'�'��
,.. .:
. :
.
: � ;,.�
— p
I y�� �nM��l
PUBLIC NOTICE
� �._ ;. � � ..
� M � � 1 1 � 1 �,�
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement
Special Magistrate will conduct a public hearing on May 10, 2022, 6:00 PM,
or as soon thereafter as possible at City Hall, 55 SE 3rd AVE, Rm 200,
Okeechobee, Florida.
The public is invited to attend and be heard on all matters. Copies of the
agenda will be available at the Hearing or may be viewed/downloaded prior
to the Hearing from the website https://www.cityofokeechobee.com/Agenda
M i n utes-Code-E nforcement. htm I.
BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video,
or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the
agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to
the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records.
ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special
Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to
ensure a verbatim record of the proceeding is made and the record includes
the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In
accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities
needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should
contact the Code Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing
Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to
proceeding.
ONE OR MORE CITY OF OK�ECHOBEE COUNCGL MEMBEF�S MAY BE IfV
ATTENDANCE AT THIS MEETING. THIS NOTICE IS POSTED TO IVIEET STATE
PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIREMEIVTS AND SUNSHINE LAWSa
By: Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate
BB/FB/Website Notice Posted: 05/02/22 MC
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
,��m MAY 10, 2022 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
� ,e. �+ S5 SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�oR��A 34974
_ .-
~"�ao�' HANDWRITTEN MINUTES — CHRISTINA CURL
Mission Statement: The mission of the City of Okeechobee is to provide accommodating services that
enhance the quality of life for our citizens and businesses in a fiscally sound
manner.
Vision Statement: The City of Okeechobee will maintain a vibrant and prosperous community built
on our heritage, history, unique character, and small-town atmosphere.
I. CALL TO ORDER
A. Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on
Tuesday May 10, 2022, at 6:15 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southwest 3�d
Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special
Magistrate Azcona.
II. ATTENDANCE Present Absent
Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire _x_
City Attorney Greg Hyden _x_
Police Lieutenant Bettye Taylor _x_
Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith _x_
Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl x
III. CHANGES TO AGENDA
A. Requests for the addition, deferral, or withdrawal of agenda items.
There were none
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH
A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the April 12, 2022 Hearing Minutes.
B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered an
of Oath to Code Officer Anthony Smith and Christina Curl.
V. CONTINUED CASES
A. Case Number 220222010; Carole Rosenberg LLC, 822 Southeast 8t" Street, Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification (Exhibit 1).
AS-violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles, Section 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification for untagged/disabled vehicle, overgrown grass, and weeds. The respondent was
first notified on February 7, 2022 via Courtesy Card. On February 22, 2022 Code Officer Smith
inspected the property, still non-compliant. On February 22, 2022, a SOV/NOH and photos were
mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received by C. Rosenberg, COVID19 on March 4, 2022.
On March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant. However,
progress had been made, the grass and weeds had been cut. The tire still needs to be removed
and the disabled vehicle remains. On March 23, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property,
still non-compliant. On April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
compliant. On April 12, 2022, case deferred to the May 10th Hearing. On April 13, 2022, a
SOV/NOH mailed via certified return receipt for May 10th hearing. Code Officer Smith posted the
property and City Hall with Notice to Appear for the May 10th Hearing. On April 20, 2022, Code
Officer Smith inspected the property, found to be in compliance. The City recommends no action
Page 1 of 5
V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED
A. CONTINUED: on this matter, but request it be noted for the record to have been in violation of
Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification.
RA-Mr. Hyden is there anything you would like to add on behalf of the City of Okeechobee
GH-no, your honor since the property is now in compliance
RA-in the case of the City of Okeechobee vs. Carole Rosenberg LLC, Case #220222010; I will
make a finding in this case based on the testimony and the exhibits presented by the City of
Okeechobee certified Code Enforcement Officer Mr. Smith that the respondents in this case
Carole Rosenberg LLC was in violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-41 for having a disabled vehicle,
there is a untagged/disabled vehicle shown in the exhibits and also Section 30-44 General
cleaning and beautification for overgrown grass and weeds. The certified Code Enforcement
officer testified to the facts and my examination of the affidavits, exhibits and pictures taken by
the certified Code Enforcement officers shows that there is factual basis for the findings. I see
that there is a picture here of a vehicle without a tag with overgrown vegetation around it and a
lot of vegetation that is here that must have been left for at least 6 months by looking at the length
of the shrubs and the weeds that have grown around the premises. I will also make a finding in
this case that the respondent was properly served, even though the certified mail was signed
COVID19, it does say it was received by C. Rosenberg. Mr. Smith do we ever have the opportunity
to ask someone from the Post Office about how it is written COVID19? Do you have an idea of
why it was written like that?
AS-I will let Code Officer Curl elaborate on that
RA-oh okay
CC-I did make contact with the Post Office, I was advised by the Master that the respondent
received the mail even if COVID19 is written on the return receipt
RA-oh okay
CC-they didn't sign the card, but it was delivered to that address
RA-okay I see
CC-on the first one they actual signed the electronic device but refused to sign the card
RA-okay I see, in combination with that fact and I can see all through here that the property was
properly posted so and so there is proper notice in this case to give the respondent an opportunity
to be here at this hearing and to be heard and they have made a choice and decided to remain
silent in regard to the allegations in this case. So, we will take that as their choice. So, with this
case it looks like according to the certified Code Enforcement Officer that the property did come
into compliance and based on the City's recommendation there will be no further action in this
case we will find the respondents in this case in violation, and it will be noted that they were in
violation but has now come into compliance. However, they were in violation of Chapter 30
Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification but have now
come into compliance. Should they come into violation in the future they will be classified as
repeat offenders. So, under these circumstances we will make that ruling today that there will be
no further action and the city is not requesting any fees at this time
AS-that is correct
RA-alright so that will be so
VI. NEW CASES
A. Case Number 220104005; Clifford and Vicki Joiner, 309 Southeast 11 th Avenue, Violation of Code
of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification (Exhibit 2).
AS-violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification for overgrown weeds, grass, trees, bushes, or shrubs. The respondent was first
notified on December 16, 2021 via Courtesy Card. On January 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith
inspected the property, still non-compliant. On January 4, 2022 a SOV/NOH mailed via USPS
certified return receipt for the February 8'h Hearing, the city has not received anything back as of
the date of this hearing. On January 4, 2022 Code Officer Curl spoke with the property owner
Vicki Joiner who advised that they just received the notice and that they needed more time to
correct the issue. On January 25, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
compliant, however progress had been made, the grass had been cut, however, the trees,
Page 2 of 5
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
A. CONTINUED: bushes, and shrubs still in need of being cut. On February 16, 2022 Code Officer
Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant. On March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected
the property, still non-compliant. On March 29, 2022, a SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return
receipt for the May 10th Hearing. The notice was received by Vicki Joiner on April 6, 2022. On
April 8, 2022 Code Officer Curl spoke with Vicki Joiner and advised her on what needs to be done
to bring the property into compliance. On April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the
property, still non-complaint. On May 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
compliant. To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to cut the overgrown trees,
bushes, and shrubs. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the
date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the
property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
RA-Mr. Hyden is there anything else you would like to add on behalf of the city
GH-the only question I have is for the Code Enforcement Officer is the fine recommend consist
with the City's fee schedule
AS-yes, it is
GH-nothing further
RA-okay in the case of the City of Okeechobee vs. Clifford and Vicki Joiner, Case #220104005; I
will make a finding that based on testimony of the City's certified Code Enforcement Officer Mr.
Smith and the exhibits presented this hearing I will make a finding that the respondents in this
case are in violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-43 Public nuisances having overgrown weeds,
grass, trees, bushes or shrubs and Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification after
hearing the sworn testimony of the certified Code Enforcement Officer and the exhibits presented
in this case I see that there is sufficient factual basis for the city's allegations in this case and I
see that there are pictures here taken by certified Code Enforcement Officer Smith of shrubs,
overgrown vegetation clearly well beyond the fence line and creeping all the way into the streets.
Also, the respondents in this case I am satisfied that they have been properly notified of the
hearing pertaining to this case, a SOV/NOH were properly served they were sent certified mail
and it was received and it was also collaborated by Code Enforcement Officer Curl by making
contact with the respondents in this case and they are making efforts to correct this problem, and
so the respondents have clearly been notified and this looks like it has been delayed trying to
correct the problems. Since they have been properly notified about this hearing and them not
being here today and have obviously decided not to be here today, they have chosen to remain
silent taking that into consideration I will make the finding that in this case the City's
recommendation of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of today's hearing will be
assessed unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before the date plus a
$50.00 administrative fee and that is what we will do.
B. Case Number 220329010; Tom Nguyen, 210 Southeast 3�d Street, Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances,
30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 3).
AS-violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public
nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for disabled riding lawnmowers,
disabled/untagged RV and overgrown vegetation, piles of wood and the front of the home and
roof in need of being cleaned. Respondent was first notified on March 14, 2022 via Courtesy Card.
On March 18, 2022 Mr. Nguyen spoke with Code Officer Curl stating that he had corrected the
violations and asked that the property be inspected. On March 22, 2022 Code Officer Smith
inspected the property, still non-compliant. On March 29, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the
property, still non-compliant. A SOV/NOH and photos was mailed via USPS certified return
receipt, it was received by Tom Nguyen on April 5, 2022. On April 5, 2022 Mr. Nguyen spoke with
Code Officer Smith and he was advised what he needed to correct to bring the property into
compliance. On April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant, still
in need of removing the debris/junk. On May 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property,
still non-compliant. To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean up and or
remove junk and debris from the property. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to
begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the
Page 3 of 5
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
B. CONTINUED: property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00
administrative fee.
RA-Mr. Hyden is there anything you would like to add on behalf of the City of Okeechobee
GH-the only question I have is for Code Officer Smith just to ensure that the fine recommend
consist with the City's fee schedule
AS-yes, it is
GH-nothing further
RA-okay in the case of the City of Okeechobee vs. Tom Nguyen, Case #220329010; I will make
a finding in this case based on the testimony of the certified Code Enforcement Officer Mr. Smith
and exhibits presented at this hearing and that the respondent in this case, Mr. Nguyen is in
violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-40 Junk for having disabled riding lawnmowers on the
premises, Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles for having an untagged RV on the property, and
Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for having overgrown vegetation, piles of wood
and the front of the home and the roof in need of cleaning. Based on the testimony of Officer
Smith and examining the exhibits I see that there is more than sufficient factual basis for such
findings in this case. By examining the pictures, I see that there is a camper in there that has been
there for a very long time there is mold and moss growing around it, it looks like there is piles of
debris that has been stacked underneath it, it looks like this vehicle has been immobile for
probably years, it has not been maintained in anyway, it looks like the tag is expired, there is also
a picture of a lawnmower that is inoperable, both vehicles look like they are inoperable and have
been parked there for years, there is a lot of vegetation and junk being stored indefinity on the
premises and it is unsightly, and there is a building here that I can see a lot of mold on the roof,
and the respondent in this case was also properly notified and provided due process to be at this
hearing today, to appear at this hearing today and respond to the allegations in this case, but has
chosen to stay silent and chose not to be here. On the final exhibits here on April 27th, it looks like
they are still non-compliant, however some stuff has been done but a lot of stuff is still there and
evidence of the violations, there is still overgrown vegetation that is growing around the inoperable
vehicles, there is still mold and moss around buildings and a lot of stored junk/debris is being
kept. There is still vegetation up till May 3�d of this month that has not been taken care of and is
still unsightly in this case. So, there is plenty of factual basis for these allegations and I will make
the finding and follow the City's recommendation in this circumstance and fine the respondent in
this case $50.00 per day to begin 21 days after the date of this hearing today May 10, 2022,
unless the property owner brings the property into compliance plus a$50.00 administrative fee is
reasonable and that is what we will order in this case.
C. Case Number 220405015; Mary Alice McCormack, 904 Northwest 5th Street, Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning
and beautification (Exhibit 4).
AS-violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning
and beautification for junk all over the property, overgrown grass and weeds, trash, or debris all
over the front and side of the property. The respondent was first notified on March 17, 2022 via
Courtesy Card. On April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant.
On April 5, 2022, a SOV/NOH and photos were mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received
by Walter Piscatelli on April 13, 2020. On April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the
property, still non-compliant. On May 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
compliant. To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean up and or remove
debris from the front and side of the property. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to
begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the
property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative
fee.
RA-Mr. Hyden is there anything you would like to add on behalf of the City of Okeechobee
GH-the only question I have is the fine recommend consist with the City's fee schedule
AS-yes, it is
GH-nothing further
Page 4 of 5
VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED
C. CONTINUED: RA-okay, in the case of the City of Okeechobee vs. Mary Alice McCormack, Case
#220405015; I will make a finding based on the testimony of the City's certified Code Enforcement
Officer and the exhibits presented at this hearing today that the respondent in this case Ms. Mary
Alice McCormack is in violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-40 Junk, for having junk all over the
property, Section 30-43 Public nuisances for overgrown grass and weeds, and Section 30-44
General cleaning and beautification for trash or debris all over the front and side of the property,
that is from examining the exhibits in this case I can see that there is overgrown vegetation on
the side of the house and in the front of the property there is debris all over the property and on
the front porch a lot of debris that is just being left there in front of the trash can, this is sufficient
for factual basis for the allegations in this case, on the side of the property there is also vegetation
there, overgrown shrubs. I will also make a finding in this case that the respondent Ms.
McCormack has been properly notified as proof the city has presented a certified mail receipt that
is signed by Walter Piscatelli and so I will make the finding that the respondent in this case has
been properly served and I will follow the city's recommendation in this case to fine the respondent
$50.00 per day to begin 21 days after the date of the hearing today May 10, 2022, unless the
property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative
fee and that is what we will order.
VII. ADJOURN MEETING
There being no further business to come before the Special Magistrate, the Hearing was
adjourned at 6:43 P.M.
BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video, or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the
agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records.
ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to
ensure a verbatim record of the proceeding is made and the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In accordance
with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Code
Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to proceeding.
Page 5 of 5
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
S5 SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�oR��A 34974
MAY 10, 2022
6:00 P.M.
Oath
All who are intending on giving testimony please stand and raise
your right hand.
Do you solemnly swear that all the testimony you are about to give
in the matter now in hearing will be the truth, the whole truth, and
nothing but the truth, so help you God?
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
� 55 SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�oR��A 34974
� �"" o�� MAY 10, 2022
� 91 _� 3
6:00 P.M.
Sign in sheet
Name Case/Com an Phone Optional
'�N,.
��
. .. _=.
CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING
55 SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�oR��A 34974
OFFICIAL AGENDA
MAY 10, 2022
6:00 P.M.
Mission Statement: The mission of the City of Okeechobee is to provide accommodating services that
enhance the quality of life for our citizens and businesses in a fiscally sound
manner.
Vision Statement: The City of Okeechobee will maintain a vibrant and prosperous community built
on our heritage, history, unique character, and small-town atmosphere.
CALL TO ORDER
A. Pledge of Allegiance
II. ATTENDANCE
Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire
City Attorney Greg Hyden
Police Lieutenant Bettye Taylor
Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith
Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl
III. CHANGES TO AGENDA
A. Requests for the addition, deferral, or withdrawal of agenda items.
IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH
A. Approval of Minutes-April 12, 2022.
B. Administration of Oath-anyone giving testimony is required to be sworn in.
V. CONTINUED CASES
A. Case Number 220222010; Carole Rosenberg LLC, 822 Southeast 8th Street, Violation of Code
of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification (Exhibit 1).
VI. NEW CASES
A. Case Number 220104005; Clifford and Vicki Joiner, 309 Southeast 11th Avenue, Violation of Code
of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification (Exhibit 2).
B. Case Number 220329010; Tom Nguyen, 210 Southeast 3�d Street, Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisances,
30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 3).
C. Case Number 220405015; Mary Alice McCormack, 904 Northwest 5th Street, Violation of Code of
Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-40 Junk, 30-43 Public nuisances, 30-44 General cleaning
and beautification (Exhibit 4).
VII. ADJOURN MEETING
BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video, or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the
agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records.
ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to
ensure a verbatim record ofthe proceeding is made and the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In accordance
with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Code
Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to proceeding.
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 1
V.A. Exhibit #1
Case #220222010
Carole Rosenburg, LLC
Exhibit 1
Code Enforcement Hearinq Mav 10, 2022
Case Name & Number:
Carole Rosenberg LLC, Case #220222010
Code Section Violated Descri tion of Violation
Cha ter 30, Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles Unta ed/disabled vehicle
Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning Overgrown grass and weeds
and beautification
r�notos:
See attached
Is respondent a Repeat Violator?
No
Summarv:
• Respondent was first notified on February 7, 2022 via Courtesy Card.
• The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s).
Date of notice Type of notice Received by Date received/returned
February 22, Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
2022 com liant
February 22, SOV/NOH and photos mailed via USPS certified return C. Rosenberg March 4, 2022
2022 recei t for the A ril 12th Hearin COVID 19
March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
compliant. However, progress had been made, the grass
and weeds had been cut. The tire still needs to be removed
and the disabled vehicle remains
March 23, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
com liant
April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
com liant
April 12, 2022 Case deferred to May 10t'' Hearing
April 13, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via certified return receipt for May 10"' Carole April 18, 2022
hearing. Code Officer Smith posted the property and City Rosenberg
Hall with Notice to A ear for the Ma 10t'' Hearin COVID 19
April 20, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, in compliance
Citv Recommendation:
The City recommends no action on this matter, but request it be noted for the record to have
been in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification.
Chronology attached
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 1
Case #220222010; Carole Rosenberg LLC
Date Event/Document
February 7, 2022 Property owner- Carole Rosenberg LLC
Mailing Address- 5025 Fairways Cir Apt. 101 Vero Beach, FL 32967-
7387
Property Address- 822 SE 8th St., Okeechobee FL 34974
Code Officer Smith observed violations of CH 30, Sec 30-41 Disabled
vehicles and Sec 30-44 General cleaning and beautification,
overgrown weeds, and grass. Photos in file
Courtesy card mailed via regular mail, given 14 days to correct
violations.
February 22, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant. None of
the violations have been addressed. Photos in file.
February 22, 2022 SOV/NOH and photos mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the
April 12th Hearing. Received on March 4, 2022 by C. Rosenberg COVID
19.
March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant. However,
progress had been made, the grass and weeds had been cut. The tire
still needs to be removed and the disabled vehicle remains. Photos in
file.
March 23,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant: The
disabled/unregistered vehicle remains. Photos in file.
April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant: The
disabled/unregistered vehicle remains. Grass overgrown in need of
being cut. Photos in file.
April 12, 2022 Case presented to the Special Magistrate. Magistrate deferred case to
the next hearing to make sure that the property owner was properly
notified.
April 13, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the May 10tn
Hearing. Received on April 18, 2022, signed COVID 19.
April 13, 2022 Code Officer Smith posted the property and City Hall with a Notice to
Appear for the May 10th Hearing. Photos in file.
April 20, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, in compliance: the untagged
car removed, and the overgrown grass and weeds cut. Photos in file.
Case Closed.
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 1
r � ,-� B{ =r f `�� � , ��� -��..�„ ��,c .,.
' ; - �� . � , � .,�,i4 .
�y � �n'�' ����� � r � /��'..� ..T;v.s�� �
`� ' �,; � z � , �, r ,, � �� � , �: :,� . . r
` ' .�g � ' ' �r �;.__ l''-".:�-'--'.. .� y, � .
��K '�," � �� ` ,r,.:' ,� �
� �f �.�°", � � _�, •}'` ' W:
_ � �,� � �,,,.
� tF � .� ry �,T3
��1 v':b'�'' '% �*' .
p� .
} ya t
�_� 1^ + R ti��`y�,�y" �� i.��� `, f '. t�"'.F� I{�y � i, ..
_ � 3 � ��� �, � � .+k �„{� ,y��* i� ^.� . .Y � � t.,?P �
] etl
,,y,� �zr ,^�8•['��h�-'Yt �,5�' , � ^ � � �.. ',� . .. �
.. �__ i. i � � . _ 'Jr'� .. � , ` . �lY. � k V �� . �,� . . y � _ � r. "'1 syl..�� .u�rp�,s:*_r�.��.t;�,�
�a..�w.� , � . :,%i S ,' ie7?. , �.� . �
. n _ IZ`t,�i .A� r V p�' � S� { �Wt .. ..
. ' ��� � �� � � ' � y � . r . .
, . y • �`" 1�Y��. ( �y .
.. T � �.;G i� �/'$ '4!t � . ;" ,�
y
. '. . ��, . 1 J�@ �x �`i'.f 1' � , �" [ "'K'� ,�I
w � .,-y` N .~ ., ' `
., .. 5�< � � /..�` . . J• �
' L 1'�
�r,�x.�„ty 1. . ,,,� -fa L y . . . . -
... �� y , t• . 4 ,. . .
aCri . •�:� . .. .T� R;, . ' ��� 1 �w�.. � �' a*... ~ s' ,� Y 'A 9 a .. .. . ,�r �i
w+�, f u� 4' ; ,Cw�i �.. {,; !�t j i � y �^'. .a,:; .,. � r,.'ST� 'y'k�, ' �i
.�� ", t � y� a � ��,5¢-",. . } � � `E' f�r.,� .� • ♦ � µ .sw � t: � � ,�"„ 4. �i^�` �
' . � ;,� . . �1 w ,' r : ,i /+`"�,�.,� `. � a„�
� '� C'� '�+�� N,m, h . .. �
� �,. . . : . .4 y ;,,�
� �,.. x . � � �.� �f =� i -;�
t h �.«, � ,�. , �a�. ` �^ ± 7 � w. .,t,,.r. �e �'
!,�j.. W`$,_ t, n t�e..J.� r >' .t'�� � � � .. r,�:� :���ry ::� R 'o` , _ � '.�� �" . ' _ i �`` � .. . .f
,
� Ra.. "
' + � y.�. �aa. . -� .. .,..:F * '..x... .'�'' .� .
� � ' a - •
._yC. �t*'�i� r :�, t,15 . ' *
� , � � � , � "� s: .� +y *' �
a�2,: ' a : _ '. '
. ,� " n�
� , �� � t" .'� ; , � �.��. �;-� �� :� � .. - O�DO�lD�� il� �Q�
. . ��St^ .�; �,.;.y . ` . � .. �4
+ � 4 �1`!+�" , y. M,' ;t! .
�j � '�
� �' 'i.� V � ^� � �. Pi .'L '�� .. .f...:\ . '� ,
�Agy 'MKi 1M 'Ey � "4a' �} � ' �'� AkR . . 4 � � � "' 4 .
,?,,,' a.,._ � �'. � . . r ' y � .. -- . ... 3f. .. . `'i';1b f �� t.d ��r.s .. . . • �A t �' . � �� ,a Kiu: . ,. . _ . *? , r ' .
Exhibit 1
,
��ryp4�, ;
���u�� ..� �
... .-- ,w, �
_ __.-=----_._ �
�• s • a; r� � "r� ° ri
+� � .� t:.� �
`,� ,k�rr *.., .�y, Yyr , �
_ s:i� � _ t, .�� " .. _ _._ + � � �. . . �
-�. ,
.�,�,:_:
�;;�r���;
.;
./�'�'� -`h � . �v:0 � '9. ,_ ;
�� t S.. i �'�r
"�+`,,g ,.,i; �. , � ,.. `"�e. � r J Y�•�—T s .«. � c �q �. �
"''' � '"� ,�' 3 k� 4 - _ �'!o .:iw c ,T'. . ?
_ '�,�Y� �.% __- . .a _.� ._
. ��,
,,
���.
�
,�:
��., ��:
Exhibit 1
� - -- - ., �.� - �
�..:,�. r
rt x.
��' - -----�-_ 4� ` "� �� � ��:
Y � : � . . '_ �� br ,.
�se ��y,, �
,' � _ ' . ,P S 'R� f-� i - ! 4 - .
. � � . , .a � i� .
� ,, � �� � -- _ . � ���'�� ' ' .a�� .l � � � �" . .
+ � � . � .� . _ _ �� . - i� .
, (
�:k
��1 M L� . .��.
.i.. ... ..., �
t � ,� y� � ,, - �
. . �, ,r'� �,,� � .i: '�'�f:;'.. Z,• ..�`
� _ �itM u�' e +. � ._ '' ° • _ ,. c�� � . . . r � .
F T; S • � �
.4
Jk .
. � �a�$ fu ' � �RL- ` .� l �� dk ; 'p:r y � , . . ,
. ` .��?. t �� ,'.�9, ���� , ' °' , . . •d�� �v� .�.1'3-r ~ �� � . t �' '
� I. . +'� , � � �_v p �, . � ���' "t" �' . •
. . . . .. }�i��a1` R� �«g��� Y �°N:u'�^.�', �_ . .. � ',�'� . .
a k �.
. . . • � . . ..—� a`4, • . - � � I
. g o Y' .`$ �-..`�'� + . '
.. � t:4 � � ' � e �.� � .- � _ ' �M1.
a� �
ql�y��Y7rt+Y�:..*k1�e #L .I � �� '� '-a+.."'�I�.» . � `., }�- K�. �,
� � . ,.. '' � ,. . ...
..�3''' �K fY 't"' f.� p. '�° . �� !"'•' . � � _ k. ..
:
� � .. ,� ., e s.-.
.�.x: . P . v�4..Y� . � , . . ti��Tr • . :. '*'�... . .. . . . , �
'_' `1ti „yrp`� +..'b'" wa4 ��' `ig w..s� :. � ''"�' �
' �
. � i :
.�.„ # � .. � a � � �t.��€�� `' .... ' .. � �.
��� , `� � �� °=:�° �.:�;� �, y,�.��� - �- - � ��OO�lO�� il �l � Qg �
. . -:-� .: _ -
*' � t �.»� 7�M1 ..! *� ��.'Ftx rw�,n..'�Yy� 4f�r. . � . �.,�' �y,�TcY�"!1�"^:r,p�'"" .�F � 1
, ,
. � -.
..,.+ . . � . a�jr .. a. +�, 3 � • : . �.� � �a
_
,
. . •
^4„ s+
�r A '4 n +�,;w ". y i m.r. ,ire "� "'3�,�,. , .. � , 'y � � . � - . , �. , . , � '" . .+
� .
Exhibit 1
/ • D�te:��
Re: i'�.�-� , �� .� �/ �{ . ( .c,�,�, - /%�� �:�;, � ,� .�i �,� c,
1
Dear Property Owner,
This is a courtesy card requesting your assistance in alleviating the following code violation(s) at the
above address. The following violation(s) exist:
;�,:�, .-,. �; _ �-�:
(_..1'i �_),. j,� _J�. ...vy
�-'Overgrown Weeds, Grass, Bushes or Shrubs 0 Unauthorized Signs, Flags or Banners
::
0 Trash, Yard Debris or Junk 0 Operati.ng a Business Without Required License
I�''�/1 .�i;' , Jc:'�
�,'�F� Inbperable, Abaudoned or Unlicensed Vehicle 0 Pool Violation
0 International Property Maintenance Code Ch Sec
0 Other ���*^ - �-.�' � r /!� � /� .�
. _ t i �.S<.� � � ' �i�.� f�"� /�-';'?i%!� C%�/` />: � %i: �i C', � �
Please contact our office at (863) 763-9795 within ;' t/ days of receipt of this card and let us know
when violation(s) will be corrected. We appreciate your cooperation.
Exhibit 1
r�� ��� --•�-�
i � ,;� ,'� :�,'�
�� A` � � � J'- �.
�� �,�:�� �.�
�� ��`�p �
� �� �� �' w . �� . . ,
� � �qp
' ° � ,�``'t'a�t
,, �,�
.� �K. yf�� f�F ��, -, � . r`�
, • '� � � � e�J�� _ y, � 'b�v' � ��.+',
4 i .n....�� � �
_ tey � '� . y `,q�� � 4y�a � � l..
y an,.e.,« . � �. ! dJ� ;�r '� �.�J . /.
� - �� , �. k '�p .. � J+pY . " �i
)1
: �F' T ��'� aM4 '� � �4� � �
It . x' �` �I�;� �M� � �' . <fa �,�, v :'�#1' �(+,� " r.
.�°'q Ln . � . �` N . !� Yq�. � � �
� i t �� � � .. � � ��� �� ; . � ��^�
�- �„ � y k f� � t� � � �
�'�_ � , � � ��,� ` � � �
� , �,�
r a, �
•�,--...— - . ����.,',, _ ���ti � . �r', } ��
� ;,. p � � � � !� < - � -
� � �: ��""�' � - Y �, • — - _
.- � ,. .. Sa �
Q`r: +�•. ' . . .
� � � � �1 � �.�
� . Y�. � � � y
�� �
� � ` ��+�r.. �� � � � r,'a�, r� � ',k .
, , j�.r.t. / r �g � ;� ��� Y I¢E� 4
� #
,�t � i �, �- �/� ,y _ , ,,
�,.,��e a ��a r s., ' F ra� �
1, ��'� YS� y�`T (�; ° __ �i_
,�;s e�-:� v s�.;;, t
� � ti!' A►,.�►.��e �� :.a�:��.�_ .
,, MII�' � _ , J1 � '� "'^,��-
.
..". '�'• . .ahw�.,� .
�• s
r,,._�i' r ;� ' `<:y._ �-1'� _'. - _ ��� �
. �� �e; . r:�a ' ; �,w �'�
�� * � � � �.., .
: �, � '� `,�I. - J lty � � �
� .
, k ��' �
` .�
Exhibit 1
-�ry ,r. +�'}�,� -�^ �- : - -
S ( �.. , y �' � �! ! � .. � . � � $'� ` .. .
e�R�i .
� ,' ., , , . �,, � '�i -
�` t , .r �. � � : .. . � - i �..
�> . � a ` �• `�
r � �., .. � t� �� � R i.'�'
M � s v
i t . ��y. � _ . :r"�'.
' � �ti'. �r;. � .� � ! !��
�'� �Jj�y� �y i� ��=r �� . : �` . �. �..
R ;� , :., , � ,�,� ,� �jr : � _
6�,�4..r 7S � TI •�it �fi •�'� y �-�e��
� i , t * �� .�Iw �..
e '.�'�d�� �'� �,
, _ F M "'�^t^wt'
� � � °.� :-�,:-�-� :;��;.
.
` ,
` . r� .� -�� � �_ �
, � � ..._...._... _ , �� - ��
� �..b. � �� _ _
� _ �-y� -�
., , - --- _ ►`�/ 1
�Y. - , '�2.�. �
_ w,�" � e. 1 `
r
� � � #� �iMwa... . 1 I �_. `�� 9�, � �
. , . . , . , _ �1�� . ` �s ..s - „ '.3. —
. �. y� � � ... ',''� r, _�'�iti�." y k �.. ��� _ , "Ol �? ' , �
� �� ' ��... . . . -[: . � . ' . .
. . e
� ..h� �.A . '. ' _ :� �.. '�rr 4� . . .JI
.': , . -� . +�. , ��_." ', �'y . :{..,ye•. '�
. . �� � ...�" .. . i "�i''ti""_,\'V . _ �, ' . �'.. . .3. . - . �.. ��'-�.
VL7U ��I.SVL7L7 � Il � � U
,5.;..- � ,� �'. . � ' ., i� ':� �. W ; A �j�r'4 ; , .
� * . v...� ` y. . y�l+' I^P' � .� y�. ,
,1,�� q �� y Iiti ♦-C � #�, " y�'Vf � �,,r . . ,k ��,�y�,��. � V. F�,�Yi'�� .
l.' .. .4�. .�. � i0f�l�' .J I ; �� t� • %ii.� ' . . . .. i�ik. " a M " . . _ _ .. . _ . �
Exhibit 1
��aCJ ��10�
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Carole Rosenberg LLC
Date 02/22/2022
' ��Y w�
��u"-�E�'"i
�-, ��,'�,;r
'FL��
CASE NO. 220222010
STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30, SeCtions 30-41, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:822 SE 8th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34974
3-22-37-35-0270-00050-0090 (35492)
3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Carole Rosenberg LLC, 5025 Fairways Cir Apt. 101, Vero Beach, FL. 32967-7387
4. Description of Violation�vergrown weeds and grass. Disabled vehicle in the rear
5. Date violation must be corrected byMar 22, 2022
6. Date violation first obserued on or about2�7�22
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the � 2th
day April. 2022 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that a,�y evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. If u fa' p�ear at the the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. �
r
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Speciaf Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this heazing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record inc(udes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement
50 SE Znd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974
863-763-9795 Phone
863-763-7804 FAX
De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa fina( a la tribunal
de circuito . Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza.
Exhibit 1
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
m
a
0
0
0
0
�
�
0
0
ru
0
N
rxf��bit 1
w -.�^,.�--�,p"°'y, �-�r -
� • - g.� � - '- '-Y I -`— "--- Y __+ _- I .. .? _..�„ r .�`i;
_ i.
■ C� �tete items 1, �, , `: , � � ,`
■ Prini your name and Uddress on the rev2rse � X � '' � fl.P.gent
so thai we can return the card to you. �� ������` CJf' J Addressee
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B• Receyiv�ed by (Printed Name) C. D te oelivery
or on the front if space permits. �. )L �,3� f'� ��� ��'' j�=
= . , ,, . _,.:� ,._---,-,-- - -- _ _--- - ,-. _,_,,_�:.._._.,ddress differe from item 17 Yes
�'8�',��e Rosenberg LLC �r delivery address below: p No
-_ :J25 Fairways Cir. Apt. 101
�_V_ero Beach, FL. 32967-7387
_,;;.;,: .
. -�
___ �..;:.�---.__
�I �'III'� I��) ('� ��1JII �'ll�' ��I I II'I II �I I I�� �'� ❑ Ad�fiSd M t r�e Restricted Delivery
1
`� �nt� `-1-' � �� � i �� � ; _ . "' �'j.`.l"- "' = Certifie� Mail Restricted Delivery
❑ Coileci on Delivery
� Artir.la N� �mhPr ffransfer from service label) ❑ Collect on Delivery Restricted Delivery
— ' 'vtail
� a� a Ll 6 4❑ o o a 1 3 4 6$ 7 714 vlail Restricted Delivery
❑ Priority i�Aail Express@`
❑ Registered Mail�"
❑ Registered Mail Resiricte
livery
S' nature Con(irmation'"
Signature Confirtnatlon
Restricted Delivery
PS Form 3811 , JUIy 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Rereipt
Exhibit 1
F�``t � � � �,iiii►
; . �
M��4 � �
� ��'� .Jr �'+ ...� �wlr.. ..
� .
. .._ _ _ a
. _ ..
. ; . .,,,, ..: � _ . . ,. W
� -� ..:� -�... -- . �
_ _��,
� ���,, �,� _
���', " �, ���
}°`,; o.�l`d
�� ����
; y � "� �,�
9• �i
� ;� ��� 4 S�� .
.. - '.. �+. . �y4�. .. .�. .
'°R* ?�,�., �. ���"f^u�''� � �� p ��� �it "!",�,�� a'1
.
. . .. .. ... :.:, �... , . .: �. ,:'.:�.y _
,�.. ,.��. . • � ..:- �.,.
. . . t. : . �.. . .. p. x . _ . . .
ew � n ,.�.._. .ij.� . ,.. -. ... �.. . . �,. ' .: -.. �
� � � » . � . - , .
1
,�.�`r.
FKq ,
t �
�� y�
f
r�., �
� '.F�� � � � �
.i .di¢•...,.. - w . ,'S�r�� _ . . � .. . .. .. � , . . , . � ' .
.
.,, ' -;i � . . .
; � -': �• " . .. . . ,
t i � M ye x.,�,. . `... � Nirr � � . t . � , . .. - ,
��; I: f. , . �.� .+�.A.° : : . . , '� � ":
y,,�. .y .tlr * F�'..�._ � y,,� �� ' � ;� � �. ..
� .3.7► ",�, � t Y � . ..� � y°' S .+ � H Y- � t y , ... . '
.�:. . "''�s3.. -,,,,`kfi�[ an� , a�awv'�,�' � '�,`"7µ'�'�` I,: � � '
� .� y. � �� l�Jc�J�IJ� (/ LSI�J[uC fl � a ISc�J
��y��$+�p,.�d'�+ �x��s^c'Zf. , L'., ,r��v�yw � C ? �'�a ,� �A : k ...� � . �
, . x "'� � r .h!-��F �
,�; ��` , r � �,.k
�rt,� �"�� . : �fb+�` a .� '�� � ' !i".',,� a= . Fh.aj�+1F.�,�,# Y - �'
:;�.. . . .,�t _., _ .a''.� _... . y .�_.'�. . ... �'_ ..`:'�ais��:C1� . � �.� ���
- ;� w
��� t=.
�, .�
�`
_ - ,.,
�y� ^ ,'y ',�
�"���? �.�'
Exhibit 1
_ ,�.. _.
k�
: ,.._.. .�s, �
�
*' a % •. � ���4 - } � i
�fi v:.>aw �, a � � _
^d -« . a�,«e .� x�
�«.
,�
�
�
�
� ��
1
� •�
� _
.
I ,
. .
i'
�r� . . . . .� . = ..
.. _ ...
I
�:,. ♦� . 4� S""; ` �` !..y --a�.s �.�'> a � �c!•v..v �
N ^%a v
' y � ^� . , A�~'�
. .. . � �, y4 ,.
-..' .. . • .• • � �
: i lr �:. Y 7 �� �� -'[1
.h,,..li. ���,! ,..! ... � n Y * .�A., i� J„��,,i'
i
� ytf.�'o � �3E `�`�Ci 'ass°� ' F. `i� 3s', '„� ��„�" ~ ��
p r'°� 9` y �M.;" r w a�� F 14s < hv�+,� ,�, �' f • ), `�::"" �-�' s'N �:� k-� �.. ' .r v�:?
"�A`, "�C` ^C �' �& 7,� ' �. t . � � ,�{ � '. g ; � ^
� �+4�• � :;',y�. Sv . ', �S �. ^� w l4.p b� '� � :'Ys q $ F �''�'+ ?u�7�F � �,,�`.. 'w � "v� �a, f ! w. � P a'' ^'�,
t
� ' N ��' *$' ti: P � e . . � z 7 r .r , * �r p,,� yr+'",` �'it'..
s ry ♦ �'.,"`�, �" "'�,r1.,:4 °� } V� M :iL4, x ^ .,�,.c ''y�" �' `'�• �.+•- y 'e!{ � i S, Aas'4i � . ',' � t,e ��
� 7�
v �
�.'C '�,.,,r c,.�. P�� �xary e -�e �5�-� ? :. � T�, ..�� �„ ���" � � E� ,[ 4yx. 3�'
�! 01Y A , + �" t ' �- '�. i} .., �b ,K.R �i >'Ha+�'..i :4 � M � � �y 'M � � d ;r Y �l � . : �!
� s� M � al s . � � h' " �f 4..��+'�'��4� ���V� �� �r� � ; ~ 4 � '°`�,,,�,� - '�,�§ r S� ��. � 0 �.: � . .U�� ll �„�1'`�� - ". • �
i c r. . . � �M k� ,�..t t , �va�.
„ �,,,.ty, +t ,► y3�3, �s4'b� �" s l:?R 1 +�ia' i .�d� �: F . .w .a�Y-e f", y.,+
,. w+�`.'h'P .t�" �lw^x.*x�"� � � r x�F � '� , � . r.�
� =r S � '' � l.t ;� s'^.'L4�. � ��J� �r�7 '�-'f'K,:� -�y .e 1 � .. s$'�e" f% S. tiT � �, +`�
';.�,m. r.;iik ,� �ryl . * ].. �r„�Y,7*Grs.'4�l,f1�,3� a?Y.� �,Si� . �y� �:ft�,�i �.•,�. i �� , . , � • . '•�..
:��..'��. }+`�� . rM ti k��"�� lt'�(' � y�� �� � M t 3 . �„�i�, + - p . � �`�,'��'�2�,` ^�:,�..t ��.. i ��"'`,yi�f�
.� w. .
� r'r. � : , r; . . : , �' ". ,..".a! _ -_' ... ' . i.�( t ^q�
j'. '"_ 1._ �"�' '. .ri ll++ ' 4.�4ti'� sz� ty � y ..
.^ ' ..� � �; ��•k :. �._ � .i._..a:a_/ y'.,4 _.�L�_ ..'�SL`_ . '1 ...,. "._..'�
'
# e S '
F . a � !
i
Exhibit 1
-,� � r ; �; �" ;�� �+� � - b;
" �,'��; � �'
``�'' k
,
r �� �
ts};, .
�.+ � �. , , ..
r r.. ,. �.. . . ` • �,'. � .Y � 1 � .
Z� . . . . . ,. . _ � s .
�� r..�
� :� ..�...,..., -�. , . �.x �, ��.
---��. �:� �� �:::.�...� - ' �_�.� �
��Y_EcY1 � ; ; .•ry.
.� • �- z�a..�.-a�� = _ -
ir .. 1 ta f f'� ` . .
A
,-; . � i i �C � ` J ! a ,r_ c ' . _:
� •-. 'n . �.
�,�p . /
•a'fi- 3��-1- �� . i� i �y '�t a � � 1 J5 I�
��4„ . - _ � J! `, i"�" � �
-- _ _ �'� .;- �,T �", ��i , �
�����gr .�' __ ,
� r�
d y �r.� _ ....._ .h .. ��' � 1 ...
�I �t P ��wIW a � ♦���: J
,..� .._ =�.c S =�k�'1-t3d9�1k'� d'.�C�� IJf�Pf � .W�'..
�
�i����' ,: � tin = � .r--..�. . i � � . .�,,7,
:_..-. a "� � _ r r;.� � ' i .. � .:-�'-�.��
�"� �� l � , - .�,,, ` �l, . .� i'� � :a.- : .
. .. ��4 (n,
.. , . , . � � � •' !!i� � . Q � �� I111 �� p j� i' 4�.
_ � c
. . y�� � M • �f -.y����� ._ .
. . �. ..� t-- . � � . . .
_ �i �+i •��F e - �. "S M.'�� `r�QG'4� ' ..
.. _ .. . . • k :a+� ..., fir. ^y . � _ '� �' � � . �• , ` .���� �
.. _ u. �y.+t�.Y�}'i •L�. ��' �S�II�'�� i i....` a_.SO.1:11�t/ti![' � . . . L ` .-�
_ - �.-,y - �; ��';- � , � _ • `
�
� � � k '
.,�. �, e � _ p� o -..rt. �
�,�;;�� , .�,�- ; _,� ��
,., :. - _ "�
;. � .,..r . � -r.x,='"t _
�. • - _ � . �_ -- -
.ti�;. �g�.�.-_.
- - ���,�-
� �_ _ _ _ �.:.'��-:.., s.'� = - - - . � _.._- ...
Exhibit 1
µ„� , 'r� � • ' . ,.'_�oi� ' '.�- . -��, "`�'��;� �- . .
",�.
.�,:,, _ � . -,
w���` � d, � `h`'. ._ �4.wli- i • .�� � " . , �' � �.
� �,.,.. , s �. , j" s ~ - • " -.+ �fr ..:..«r: -.
. .. � . . �_� _ _. _�� _
. ,
�� J
�
♦ �
!��
�� �.
� 'i
�� T
_ ��f, 8!
,�.• . . w. ,.
��"�i�4 ��..�`...
�
f " 1 � •� �� �� � ,. ' .. t�� W � ~ � ''�`'� � �
, � -' •,.w? e� ...y wb.. .
`' � . �.�� .R' .,.rr�( . � it� � � . . z` 9
• , Y{ ..�C��Y' • � � � ~� � \ '
!��'t: � '� �^ .'�h- . . . � . c ��_� , t � ' .. . Y y�(�, % +�i �� �;�'�''.
��+ �iAy�a.i '� �j.7��Je�" ,. e `.f`* � t� AZ 'r AY�. . .. �4 �� ���A
�*��� � � ,�; �'r i+�,r.=,�, .,,. i�r��F` �.�tii�`; �,�y�,� � , �- '' ` +'� ^ ,,' .. „ �,, , : N
�,�': �� ;�.�.,yi4y,��'a1,�.r;�,y . � _ . , , n rvv ,��� ;.� � :':C �4",��fit.'i yw�w;�•, -!�`-"�
� . ' � .7" `7� �, � .. � � . . �. •a,�"".'..�ti` ".,�,�, " "! � '.,h. Y l�" 1•° ^ .. .. . . . . . . . : . ,
> " -4, . a�,� » , .,:.
��w 4�` M;a� �r;` ��'• �. w ' ty �;;ia�,,b, Q d 1/ UcJO�o�� U°� 41 U
�,• �,, rp .° r�' ` 11`� C'r.." ..
- ,� . . �' t • . - .. h� i'� � . .
. . �k. � 4� .'dG� ��, ,� �, y.,�rr� i n�..if7 f w.�`
, � ti i t'.. .'vJ+� dN^� �c . ,; .
. . .. ..::«.i:..� .�.: i�� + �a¢ y,yt4�jti�kr�lit� - ��." . . ♦
_. .. _ . . _ f �.M. [j �t� �i.{i�.i�+: " ' .. . a. . •,i' _..., .. '^`� f_ K . .... a +�il�
r .�- ��i...;�R,�
. a,;..
. w ,�;-,
' �i
� ° ������ 0 � g.�i�
T`�� ��' .. ��4: t . j � 1 �i`1 � � 1 �F� ,
� + �+ �(� . � Z� � i �. �
�'' i� �• �,� i ! ` , . �
�,� . , � �
�t
Exhibit 1
�4�4"�` 1'. . f,' � � �. �` • � �"�._.
3
�. .
,-
� ,
�
,' �
�� �9 `-
� .� �.... a�,",
_ ._ �r
� � ;�., �.
,�
u�.�.,.�°�^� �. � ..r.
�� ���� ,.��� ' �
,'�'�`�x� � � . ; ,�.
� . ... . �r � �. � _ w"(
:J "b""""-^ :� .
� �
r�
+1l�gP�,� � � i�. �
at«�k1"s yy♦ .. ....._ ,P
< i�������'�� ` i . c � �
�° � ,�; "
e
� ,
' . .�
• F, .
�_ a �.� 'T ;.
�: ; � rti _.
Y
. �hf ! ' ��, �
� " '�'i�"���' � ��>� ' �
�i ' ��
tf 1 '
e Y. . r�� � �� x.�'�[ "r+�14 �,' ' ' . 1 _ � .. � ;,
� Y. � . Y � }.'!�` �R .♦r... � ;� A -.y . 1'i1� "r` �` �¢`
. 1} i 'SI�,_-�� 4 � ,��'ti� � 5� • . . �'1�' . - �e �' " `?� . . i 1s e�� � � "
wJ'r� e ' �
"�' . . .. �+�'��'-,..:,'�:� ; 0 a ����� �� � °��
,
j�; �'�•�.y'�,T ��.�s, s. _� , ! .. - . -
V �� �. �Jy �. 'y' t" � � � . -+ ". .� �!` �� 1< • �i �"
' . y
� . �!. ...r. �'y ' •.. y J�y�/. - ,Y 4M . . .Y.� F+�ly, .. �.�.
�' r �l� A.�li'�'• �%'. ' "' :. S _ .O� S S.'�.T� w �L � a`�4j� .
, f_: 1 .l... .. . r . .. ., r�1' � � � 9 _. . . •�+f � v►r � i . _ � . � ,. _. . � . .. . . . . - �a �ii�� _ . .+
Exhibit 1
,�Okf �eechobee
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Carole Rosenberg LLC
863-763-9795 Phone
863-763-7804 FAX
. ;, ;
.: ��; �eEE=S
�:. ° . ;
_._� ..
".FL;
J�
Date 04/13/2022
CASE NO. 220222010
STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30, Sections 30-41, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:822 SE 8th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34974
3-22-37-35-0270-00050-0090 (35492)
3. Name and address of property owner or pe►•son in charge of location where violation exists:
Carole Rosenberg LLC, 5025 Fairways Cir Apt. 101, Vero Beach, FL. 32967-7387
4. Description of violationOvergrown weeds and grass need to be cut and maintained
Inoperable/untagged vehicle needs to be removed or current registration obtained
5. Date violation must be corrected byMay 3, 2022
6. Date violation ftrst observed on or about2�7�22
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the � �th
day May. 2022 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. f yo f�iYta�appea te hearing the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. )
� ;
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is �nade and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhnent.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to tlie circuit court. Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the esecution of the order to be appealed.
De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estahitos de ta Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrativa final a la tribunal
de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza.
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement
50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974
. __ � ,-, - - - _ - -- -- — - - =-
_ . - .. ___ _. --_ ` _ - -- --- -
__��� _,
.s
�o�:s,� .:.
- _ ... _ �
_ � �.` .
_� _... _ . .. ---- •-- " _ —�
- - . _ . _. _ �'�-a_:i-_,r:.••��. ��.
Exhibit 1
� %• . .
0
�
�,
17' �C:�-rtlNed Mail F
� I'��-' _-`--
ov��.�
stmark
Here
�. • � �
1�
Q I [_Ifiewmfiecelpt(hardwPY) S
� „ (_�RetumfiecelPt(Wxtlonic) S
���� �] Certiffed Mail Rsetrbted DeIIVMy 3
O � I_I��duRSlgnetureRaqu'Red S
j�.._f iWuk SlgnWura Restricted DelWery i
� li'� �fage
�,
� �:�
� � foia o�tage and Faee
� �—
N ,J�-vtt T
o r - �---- ----�
� I;r ' an � t. �OX No.
;�n �.°" � r"� .•n� , i C �
��
�
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can return the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
1. Article Addresaed t4;_ � _ ________ .� _--y.
Carole Rosenberg LLC
5025 Fairways Cir, Apt. 101
Vero Beach, FL. 32967-7387
i.�i�1
A. Signature "+' i/,,,;�
n ,. �'
�' ,; .i �`� -' � �_ Q Agent
r,� �,; ��
�Addresse:
B. Received bp{Pnnted Name) C. 4ate of Deliver
'�l 1trc.`,�. , ,.�; -., . _•�� '-4 _ �
�'- -`- -— 3ddress different from item 1? ' 0 Yes
�r delivery address below: ❑ No
.. ......�.._._. _ _ . __....+�,+i%:�;�--,�.�, ❑ priorityMail6cpress0
�� ���'I� II�� I'I I�i I I� I� �I � I��.1�� I I I�'��) I I�i� ❑ Adult Sign¢tu e Restricted Delivery ❑ Reg'stered Ma IJRestricte
{ � Certified tvlail� elivery
Certified Mail Restricted delivery �ignature ConfirmaUonTM
����-��� q ���- �� � -�+ �'� ��� � '� �='� � '� �� ❑ Collecton DQlivery Slgnature Confirmation
2. Article Number (Transfer from service labelJ ❑ Collect on Delivery Restrtcted �elivery Restricted Delivery
^ '--.. "Aail
7�2� 2450 0�0� 5699 4�$5 � p���ResMctedDelivary
._--.__ ...._..._.. .. .
; PS Form 3811 , JUIy 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt
.
�, i
I� ��_��l -��
Carole Rosenber LLC
g
R�Spoadeat
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein,
Ch�pter 30, Sections 30-�1 Dis�bled vchicics, 30-44 General cleaning �nd b�autification
Overgrown weeds aad grass ueed to be cut and maint�ined. lnoperebleJunt�gged vebicle needs to be removed or eurreat
registr�tion obtained
By the dat� set f�rth ANIa contacts the undersi�ned Cod� lnspector to verify compliance. NOT[CE TS
HEREBY GIVEN that th� alleged violation (s) will be presented in City Council Ghambers, City Halt, 55 SE
3`� Avenue, Okeechobee, FL on th� day of M�y 10, 2022, at 6:00 pm.
Dated this 1`b day uf the month of
Si�cd
APril the yeac of 2022.
Title Code Enforc�ment O�eer
�', CAse Number: 22Q222010
� Address: 822 S� 8`a St. Okeechobee, FL. 34974
City of Okeechobee
Code Enforcemeat
50 SE 2'"' Avenue, Okceehobee. FL 34974
863-763-9795
Exhibit 1
���#��tl:
�Y•,-� _�
'�--� --
�
i rt`
,�n� �,���,K
�
,�;;::.� -�- a
�...:�: _.��. _._.�
�:�:-��
,�; :
-�,>
���-��_� --
��� � :�
� R�_."` '� �_�
� ,s� =� .�:�
� �- �` `".,,�,�;
� �
_' �s��-*� .. �4 � , ' <���
�,�,� �- .� � � �s�
�'_'.�t+�-'��,� _��. _..
� ''� � �- �ii; '�
� � �Y, ,�. �� ' � �� � a�� �_
� �
� .. �.;' .. ��4 � � �, '�
� � � � ,. . s
� � ; � 4 g "�y'"`�i��
T�
'�M � y .' i
ir � � �
��, ,x��' , �W , �� ; �,�
, � o �:
:�.�
-yw. v y, . ��..
�
�= ��a..— �• y�Y�
� �t�C r�. ,�-.�
�- �'''r�y� �R ,, �� �
�.K. �". . `ti� ��a ,
��;..� _ �-�
����.,�_' .
- — _ � .�--
- �
' ?r.s R'^�L^�w r�.�
�_ ,.:��s_'J���c��
Carole Rosenber LI�C
g
�es���aent -
Unl�ss Respondent corrects the violation described herein,
Chapt�r 30, S�ctio�s 30-41� �is�bled� vehieles, 30-44 Gener�l clear�ing �nd
besutiftc�tioa
Ov��ravvn v��eda �pd �ra�s need to be cut and m�int�i�ed. lnopersbl�/unt���ed vehiele
�ee� to be rea�oved or eurrent r�istc�tion obtaioed
�y the d�te set forth A�VD contact� the undersigned Code Inspector to verify
eompjia�nc�. NOTtCE [S HEREBY GIV�iV that th� altegcd violation (s) will be
pr�sented in City Council Chambers, City Hall, 55 SE 3"� Av�nue, Oke�chobee, FL
on th� c�y vf M�y 10, 242Z' �t �:� �i�11.
Dat�d this 1� da f the month of April the year of 2022.
Si�ned 'Title Co�e �nforc�r��nt 4fficer
C�se Na�ber: 2�OaZZ010
Ad�dres,s: �aZ SE �," St, �keechobe�. �L. 34974
City vf Okeeehobee
Code Enforeement
50 SE �"� Avcnue, Ok�ecbobe�, P'L 34974
�63-i63-9795
Exhibit 1
� -
�
. x /��)j7�iC(llie)Ii �1f'<Ir/t`i�t�:�
; Fri, Ap►'i12�, 202?., A: i i f�.r�r,
�
,��; � .� � � �.,, � � � .� : � t' �' �'. � �, i
�'aral� 1�to:�cYnt�c�r� i.C,('
►tt�,,�,��<<���,{
� �� ,,.�r,�� _ .,,,�;����,�a�,�� _,; �. :.
,�:ie o#df, Snallunr 3ti-J1 l3ivabb�J oeiiki+:+, SII_ �.1 �'., ��. ,.. ,.. ,.
��rtit'v�.�1i��as
.. ,....��ratrn.�o a� anr! y{ry+� nert+l t�� Rk rna dasl muiwtriocd. Innperrblrlurrtx�gv+r.; .....
. .-�1. t.+ M re�ur�nrJ or torrrnt �aalwtratln�p uf+tuiparl
', . . .__..._. .._ ._......._, ...,._.__. ......._ ._.._._._...__._.
. . �l,�sr� +,,:�. tnflf� ��i+11 ,,�mlu�.te Ihe tululrt+i�. �u:J ( `uc4V (rtv(rt.`clqr i o y�, � �.
;.'ra�,cc VRYTIC'f' t!; Iti'I�t:ItV C:l�"F:!'�i �f�atd�s •'rlPc�e� <<M,I�runn �'4;
� .�,�.:4 �n [ ��} l��urfc�l f 3�nmkx�5. (`�ly i�i:dl. ii SI�. )'"� Av��tnte. Ok�.r.:;��,.�",
;;r aY�e+� srt 11ay' UI. 2012, aa 6:1M1 peM.
�,:.cd �}ri•. ! t�' da �( thc n�unitr uC April thc � u�e uf 211?2
�nriNdd�!5��� ".��v-- , i'IT�+P �.l�5. ( t ( ��i e�ata�� � � ri r!�. ���:
� . . ..._'�:i�.a , �i`.� i:i�i
0
n�o��a�o�
0
Exhibit 1
� � � � � _ , .� �- �, -�----
�, �y,
4 � x .;� �f '�r �Y �� �. .t ,�-' � i ,,� �i �:�,�� � �+'�
� � ,�,`N.i ,+�,a�
� � �� +� ��, ,
` ,�;c �, �. • �„ � :�
r
` � ; `.' " �' � l � � � � °�;'`' �: ' . . ' �
„� � ����,.
, f� e 4 `Y N^ �
_ � �� .:� __
� �� ..�� �, �. � �
� .,' ,,,��'� � ,
; � ,`
.i.� � � � � - �. " ` � � 1, : , .. ., `� e li 19
.+�, '' -
� .
�..
. _ ,.
� `�� ...� �'� � �
.3` �
�
'�N�,+�+-< N "�''�"` - - , � , :
t� � , , . .: _ ,� ;
��' ✓ �..... '�. ��w... , *� ,��,. z���S+e«',.r.,� "+�!I�.�'"k`. . -�.,,,u. ,�'[.., _?kaeye,d"�Y •.i'��m'Fft�
_. � * ,k�� � �,.; . . . ' � . _ . ._ . � ' . � �. � � �� :7'f f �� ' ^k +•'�i � _ r.''.^g�
.' .:.ir' ��yl"ys3e� °" Kn� . �.' , :'°,yM""" � y ... . .. . ~f .
i.„ . . . ` �� � �. �. _ .
�,� s . �� . . r%. . . ..... ^ . . . . . �
�„ �t:r, . 3 _ .. • . � t , .
�+�.1,, . .ei. �n..�-�_.'y-7��'*�., .+lqr�i:r.r�. . . . . -. . .
-� .
.
s�k..-, . : � � . . .� . :. . - . _ . `.. '^. .i
.... , . ,�.,, .
�,._ } •�.� ti ,�. . �'.'.. � . ' .. ".. .� ": . �. �
, °� �il. � ' � � " . - • . � . . . .
. . ` ' ' - � . . . . . . : }'-...
.�.� r - �..�V..� , .. f,..,, vt� � . "�;,`� �F. ,. .
- , .�.;.�
�::{.� � . _ _ .
�:� . �� _
. . � . ..�,,._..: . ' � . . �' ^ _ " � - . . � .
:' "� 5,
04/ 0/202�2 12�3
..._". "". _ __.._. . .. . �
t k'
I
yi
"}�A�t. � ;,`«
.�Y�
��
� 4�
:,��r�"' ��
t�
r.s, q
.
�u., ..��, � f{ N' . , f � w7 r � !ti . .. � .
.�_. «' i .n., t �� 'MW }.,. +i �a �- , a , ..
t :r s,ch�..�.�..$'i�i� .�'4t+.�* -� �, �`s,,.o ,^.e tldr"'�t �.k- `. .�
r' .
' � ""'� 't r. , '`�''1. s •: � ., a' . �"�yM„ � ✓ n :. �. �yr,m �. � .
' ' � r �. � "''�y- M:i�� ..._ � -. * -•,+d4s� � M h a . �+' . � �6' � �,,,y� ., � .
{ x „y +, . �F `��sy, v „# s^ ;~ ,+ P �'. `�., - ri �. � r`. , . . . . . ,.
...: w�.� ' '��.� .�.
.r
�, x . .. ,w,.y Y, , . "^„�« . -g3�'r F
� +Y, .�,
. . � � � . . . . . . � . � , .."rx . � 5 . . „ , t .
. , "„ �. � .. � . ;� . . . . . . • , .
,.. � , . � . „ . � .. ' , . , ,.i+���, y � , . � :i
,:srr.��M„�,�: .�� - . . aca: rs
� A` .
� , r.a� � .v , . . . .. _
� '. -- ' . ..�. ..� . . .
!„ � .. . . � . ... . �.
r= � ... y��i . _— - " .. - ....
� "������ �����
,�,r�� t.,,
. - � . , e • . ' ; + .r: x .� ,,s,,;.. ` �
, ., ^1^d � 9C r.�. �.. �'i�� . ::�"�'�I Y . , i+�r � �.�+ItW'
. . . � � ' y� 1 ".'.-. �.�.A�,�. � . .1.. . . � . v s.� »� . ����. � ,y i .. ..... . ~�_ .. �. ' " � '"N
Exhibit 2
VI.A. Exhibit #2
Case #220104005
Clifford and Vicki Joiner
Exhibit 2
Code Enforcement Hearinq Mav 10, 2022
Case Name 8� Number:
Clifford and Vicki Joiner Case #220104005
Photos:
See attached
Is respondent a Repeat Violator?
No
Summarv:
• Respondent was first notified on December 16, 2021 via Courtesy Card.
• The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s).
Date of notice Type of notice Received b Date received/returned
January 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant
January 4, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the Have not received
February 8, 2022 Hearing anything back as of the
date of this hearin
January 4, 2022 Code Officer Curl spoke with the property owner who advised
that they just received the notice, and they needed more time
to correct the issues
January 25, Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant.
2022 Made progress by cutting the grass, however the trees,
bushes, and shrubs still need to be cut
February 16, Code Officer Smith inspected the properly, still non-compliant
2022
March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the prope , still non-com liant
March 29, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the May Vicki Joiner April 6, 2022
10"' Hearin
April 8, 2022 Code Officer Curl made spoke with Vicki Joiner and advised
her what needs to be done to bring the property into
com liance
A ril 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith ins ected the ro e , still non-com liant
Ma 3,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the prope , still non-com liant
• To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to cut the overgrown trees, bushes,
and shrubs.
Citv Recommendation:
The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate
Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date,
plus a $50.00 administrative fee.
Chronology attached
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 2
Case #220104005, Clifford & Vicki Joiner
Date Event/Document
December 16, 2021 Property owner: Clifford & Vicki Joiner
Address-4476 61St Ct. Vero Beach, FL 32967-7810
Site Address- 309 SE 11th Ave, Okeechobee
Violation of CH 30 Sec 30-43-Public nuisances and Sec 30-44-
General cleaning and beautification: overgrown weeds, grass, trees,
bushes or shrubs. Photos in file.
Courtesy card mailed via regular mail, given 14 days to correct
violations.
January 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: not in compliance, no
violations have been addressed. Photos in file.
January 4, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the February 8,
2022 Hearing.
January 4, 2022 Assist. Code Officer Curl received a call from Vicki Joiner, contact #863-
634-9948 she stated that they just received the notice and will be working
on getting the property into compliance and asked for more time as they
have to get the gentleman that has been squatting on the property
removed. They will also be looking into getting the home demolished. I
advised her to keep in touch with us and will give them a little more time.
January 25, 2022 Assist Code Officer Curl inspected the property, the grass has been
cut. The trees, bushes, and shrubs are still in need of being cut/trimmed.
February 16, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-compliant: trees,
bushes and shrubs in need of being cut/trimmed. Photos in file.
March 1, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant. Photos
in file.
March 29, 2022 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the May 10tn
Hearing. Received by Vicki Joiner on April 6, 2022.
April 8, 2022 Assist Code Officer Curl made contact with Vicki Joiner to advise her on
what need to be done to the property to bring it into compliance. I advised
her that the trees, bushes, and shrubs along the front of the property and
near the home needed to be trimmed/cut. She stated that they would get
it done and let us know. She also stated that the property was just mowed
again on April 1, 2022.
April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, trees,
bushes and shrubs need to be trimmed/cut. The grass has recently
been cut and maintain. Photos in file.
Page 1 of 2
Exhib�t 2
Case #220104005, Clifford & Vicki Joiner
Date EvenUDocument
May 3,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, trees,
bushes and shrubs need to be trimmed/cut. Photos in file.
Page 2 of 2
Exhibit 2
�: ��
* " `e
�5�.
�t�.
r
��
�`
� , .�n
- �
Y � r �, ~ �.�
� ��:,; . �y � �a"` �, '�e� ,.; � �. . . ' �;�
r i i ` „ v�' �� ,., ,�
� ���.�, 4 �j r�t .
p �
.�� �X
.�.�V.. � d.�j'�`.. � � � �"'�'+"� „1 .. $� "ti{ t;u ..;«o- _ ��
�`�i� '74 � w,•r.y • r,y"ra�k, ��A d � < �o"�._ . .
.r � �K
� � �' � A 1 , � l� .r�yiG �' �-YY�t,` Y �{�¢', y'?1
� ar r
M �. . 7, • , . _ . � p , ;` y't �F � 2, a" ,�, ;�,�p,�, y _d .,� � � !
��y��+ \ � � ~�4� � � � � ;� '.
���� -0^�'�+ � �� �'P��a+�i :� .d -''t �� i
� -. , j�
�. � .' _ �r��� �w��='#. d' 'a .: "� � iy, .�•� �F � � .. "
X�' � • �� fi � �` � � ': a� #� �y y�;
.�
+� � . ' � � �� 1� � � � r � 1 � � ' i�i T4 ..
�...r� . . ♦ � v �`'_� ~ � 11� � 1 I R�l � �
y ! ' `k+�U�l
_ . y � ' ��`.; � < � \ � �� x � t,�, .
g� s � „ '„ r � �( �s `� � ; 1 +d �f e� �s'`.3''' �
���w«� Rr,. ' 'F ��� � ,�_� ^' �`� 1:�4' - d
. y ���� � a K � hk �� �� �
.•� . . � ' .;i� ��.� � .t�4t�����'�. {,,,.� � • ��
r�� '��� ',,f ^.,.� t �w�_ .r �,�.+ '�r"�?i� !'K . : g��Y +�i
� ��''r I
r t
�+'' ^' a � ` k
< r.tr .� � x : 1� � �� : �a � �3, x�.
� �r� � '�� �.g� �
a � �j T�M � ��'�� �e t.L.��� ���`'�"�...,� � � e� z
. S� � d, , � i� y� � t.:; ��'. k �+ � t��� !
,w�� �� , - � , � � �
. �` '�� �.. ��.'�IY' �M. y.�r � 4 � )��U�'� �R �•.. y ' .
T� �'.�j t (,'� }�w 41v. � :'�� .� I� . 'X�
' .. . r�ir N . �!�f f � � < � ti �w% a^,�` v � f`..,..
� #r � .c' ,y, �.t. � �. ,i� v,a � r
� �c L �,
�oYF� • � � � ��� �, ,,]F �'i, l;�x ��i� �� w;�q $4 a, �� � p � Ss�� � �J
X.� .. ,�� � � �x t�. � $ �" 4� � �� � 1� . �� '
• �� ��. � � S� . y '.�tr� ' ' 17ti y� . .-.� � �n� 1� ��.. t .. t „
a , � v � ^r 'Rl.s ,�t '�n� t . '�.{ > x'.,�y, ':j �, . �
r�. -� ,� . � Y .,�. ;» :. , ' ,.
,,,��� �.a , �. x �,,.� ,1� � ' � ,��,,y�c,7 r���. � �,. a�-� �
� ° . ,'. � 'Lr , '� ';'�`�'� • � , ' • UC�l����r 8 `., . '�
' r .: �- /�"� � . � � e . � � t�, 1�'� +� r w,. a •; � ~ � a� T�� .� w � r
� `�
• ���t, �� , : "` + j,r< , ll�, � �n— °�''�s� � � �''�,�t �'� ' M , � �"�;W„ � '"a �:1.. d
,��' r'' ! . �'� 9�c �yy,� �,I:` ¢; �" ai y��.� `� " .h, �.e ,�;E- � �-.,:'�
' �„ l i�3y. . � :•.` n' r ti X `Pe ' "`t; < � . . �re+�.� . .�I
* t1 ey `S �i -�6 �l t���'� � , � +y �..
� � �' aE� $ �.M� 4� �. . � . .1'•/ Jy. . - 4 • � n . , . �. _.. . ._ .I
+Ir
�. � ���
<-� +r,�a�`'` K �
M � � s!
\ �
�"� £ '�. ,TMl��,�, ��'
��'� �" ,�1, *,"
.y
lw'9� � s.�,"��cW:'�. .� ,.,.iu:i
T'j� �`
�. '�' �y � � s a.
, ..�«a'� .�a .�.
� � ,�
��
�
_. a_
�M��
eI�' � �� '', wfi'� � jIv ��, ��., s. . r��
�t8.' Y' �R
,
��:. �* ;v�i , � ' �4� �"'�T
1����3 ��' � �� �� #� Y`i,
y � E �.
�' +� � r. , � � , � -, f ai
� �Le I� .:NS' * f-
L
��������'�J�h��i� `.....
�*,. � � �:� � ,d � 4 . ..
� ,C�. �
� � Fp(,x a A �.�tr4 ' ` .
d� .R
�';�"�4+� `` ... � pii., � �yj �er�.
'.. A s'+ � , '?''f� .
�x: ,
�� ��Y 1� h.� . .
� "� A. y� O' � � . .
�� �� � � F , �. �
M
h1 . � ., � 1..�k
d �� 'n„ ��, x�� ,
� �� * �: �l ya�. �'�!�b ]�
N �' y
i�,�� �'..5!'�t'.'�. l�"� _ .i.x���3� ;�i
�' �..�,:n;
' - . � 1�.��� 1
\ r + ,.
ti �
rt � � .
� ��` � �
. I d'k }
k
�' T: `=n� �� �\ irT`i
� ! i,1:
I" - ,
.. � ,�x�,;� -
��� �� 1 ���: . � ��.'�
�
� , � �� f P.. . ., . , �' �' �4.'i v
* h E �
, � n�' , y . , � �' �( 1 ,��,, �. �r�.� ' _ . 4 t
��} I�!` A� �?���a�l�, r .. 1 i'.�.� . .�'1�5s; . � ),�'._
P ' .��. f. ..i�. M1S ,.�� �}, !� 1 �,
� � ' ' a}Y f. . d ' !'�'t ' '( � `�°"'�q C
,.r ,�''i�} ;�t''',. ,.. �'�� 3,�+' 'i.:,�� a_i �
� �., _ , � :*.
� �.
' �r � d >."' y -.�:�y � . -. ..
. 3 ..
Y �I;e��f' � J. �+�s�1!]�Z'4�"..,.t.:�:� � -
• �� .. ., � � ; .. �1�0i160��� 11����5
� .. - ' . .����! y�. ''� - � . ..
� i ' , � •q% �4i- . ,
F�. • � ,��� f� �L..x _ .It..N' • � - � '. . � . .
�� �. �� ��� i�-� �51�`�:.-!.. _�.y. � .
Exhibit 2
� � ��"� � �"� ° �a*�;r � +� r `-��. , ,
,�. ,�, �.i,� ���` ` er' ; � ; < �{ ^e ' . �
�' v 91 2r � -,Ru, :c '�}
. !� �f.� � a..}� q +. y . y• �.
�;�' . yiy r� Y C� `A� ':.wt''A ,� -`17,' 3a�. � Y� � . ^Y'• . .t
'r:+{ � � ,, {� .; � ^'��'' a .
f�
k ml� fr
�'+� :� � ��� �p�' � � �
� . � � �� . iw • . ��'3.; r1 1�'�•
��+ . �-F` ,�` `��
�'��4` ,, �arp �j'� " "� � i���a�rB + t r� .. a7�''.:°�' ��f+y11�+U'' " . �. . .
rq
�'� f �� ��� Nr ?�� �,d� � � . . w � �� L , � �, �+� _
,.._�� ..•'" t �;'�r+, i� � $ i ' .4j''M`��,i�h ' V -tt � �7_� " 5��t. �;' � � �. �c.,
+� � ` "� �l��.iA�' �} y"°� ` �i t' _ �.l�C"'�'� . �^�'7S ��� :. r �� �� .
�, � f � • : ,���', ,� �; r"`�.J � � 1 .' ,�Y��O. ' �.��
�.i'' ` � �, ��°f ;, .rs �-' C � ,� ��'. -�`` � . } � "�f..': , ,.
y :�+ � "�:�l:� �� " .��j���.q"�s K,. '�` ,� �r;,,�, , , *�.� `: � �,��''��;
�� 'rF., ; � :L�s.�.. . C- � �"��, t ,�s. �i"� ��,'�'� � ,'�!.; y�. `�' �` i� ��� �..� ��
� :�'' ?'.� ti, �A i ,rr g,
'�'i� . i '��. r 's � � .�,. �: � r
. �,� 6 ,'�Y; .,�1 .;� ,.. � =t �, �1 '�,� � � ��� ; i.`� •? � , "4_,� y'�
�. . ,
i, r ' t��.�.. \ �`4 " � �t a� Jb'' :4.�1�'
,` , r
. _
,
; . .�a � � R . '�, i.f .a a♦ ��� 7 �
, . � �
�
�- �4, � , ..::a � �r-� � " ' � ' �'i�� �`.t 'a
'�.�w A �".`rli r tiM . � 4.^ i�j 1 '' .:IF.x ._ . �+. ��C�_ �
.y�, "q�' yl�, ' . '': � . �k��,�.�,r ��,� ... "� ,� ` �11
. ''�?`- 'y 4 . .
Y���: :;� k+t' } . R�- ,.�
� S�F `� A +�� f :. } � �� . . .�
�. x a.,}... ,''�i�' p.�.. � S+�t�r` l r' t,;if � ,y�� �.�w���.
,. {,�. ,y, ww:y+".a"S' �.wu..+.-�.y" w`� .f"4`� � �
'...'" �� �• '{ ^' ' L � 1�+ � �J �, � � t . �
,' ' u, � � � t A ) . ,R � f�1'^!(� : 1 1�
}
� : a+� �� Y�M. � �� ''� � �»��,y`gt��� f'#*r� �*x
� ; , !3
�t � " � yt R'' y y�� � �4,�"� *�ti �Al' '*7� R � ti �� �ti. �.
�. �,� � � f �e .• o ?;�'.r -qq � s �� � et ,. ;r n � �+���
nwL p,� ; � 11�� Y Yli y,e y 7� y 't`�.� . :
�_ � � M, qw�� ���.��(�1�0� �'
�� �. ,�..Y�.;�b„� , .� � .�� ,y � �: :
i�.G�_ ' lS ..:uPA1� � K. Ii1'.> +J+�F� Y
1
��k ����'�
Q i
�✓h�t*ya� , �
� � �,
9 � .p�; q Y
� `d.;`�'-: �;
�.r.��. �' c�, .!
�r'�It���
i��:�
, �> y Date: °� 1 t,
Re: . �c. 'tl . �ti..+ �,� �/.f-fi.'f �//I �'T ."n i � z�'' L°lC.0 i �l�u •."'/L
Dear Property Owner,
This is a courtesy card requesting your assistance in alleviating the following code violation(s) at the
above address. The following violation(s) exist:
. �1I .� ., , � "�' .�, . • . l,
.�r''+ -�'L , S� i ��a'-� j'� �f'!` i-f • ��;,�`�:� .1� . yi`
,�-Overgrown Weeds, Grass, Bushes or Shrubs 0 Unauthorized Signs, Flags or Banners
0 Trash, Yard Debris or Junk
0 Inoperable, Abandoned or Unlicensed Vehicle
0 Operating a Business Without Required License
a Pool Violation
0 International Property Maintenance Code Ch Sec
0 Other - S.�":��
Please contact our office at (863) 763-9795 within '�� days of receipt of this card and let us know
when violation(s) will be corrected. We appreciate your cooperation.
Exhibit 2
a�..r � � :- er- � -
'It ��, je � . -�,�.: �'�"' _.
y"'?�
� .�,,. . ,�y =,� ;o�' �... �, �
� $ re . . . ,,.�" , - ''� � . 'T� �.
�� � .� . .S ' _ �
�, �� �,''Y
� :;
�.:
t!' �
, ;.2.
�'
}4
�.en ,'��'�
`� ,/R E'1;1e�'�.��... �, ; :�
T p ..
... � T . ' . y.. .'�'}. .
x �,�
'i' . ,.
�"� ��.
��� {
�,> , ,
��
`�}:.�����
�� _�
.,' .�
„ �..j�,, ,� ,
- . _k'y.',.i'y�h�5-::._i.�._�� �
i� ,.
"4 '� '
'� 'T� 'o } •�a . . .:.,.
��py, w �` !
F., 1F ��� y��� � f 5� p+� �' . . . .. . . . .. . . .
� , r. 4 . �` C ., � � �� .���u�!
` � .
�� �.�� '.+� - .� � y �
'. s. e�,�m' y �a`..: J �r+' y :
� r# S : :1.. � ��7►, "
.,r. � �Ai . �'' �� ..i::-.i7F .., _ _ z . . � �. _ . . .
��"�'s`'""y'� ' �'
I
�� .
�Y� '�
�,� , � �:
��n.�4�,�'�
f�'�
�-'"
_�
011 �O�O�V(S(S � U ° �1N1
Exhibit 2
!�" ", , �.
ti <,� :. . � . � �� . � �;.
�: �,,, � � , � �; ,
ti�,x. W' � �,
�,� ;� , .�w, q,,
1� � � � !« 61 "m ' .
� 'Y` � � . r� • '�i' ih',�r �� 1
� � '
Y
l
.. *i �r,..• '! �Fss. � ��X�e. .
�� w
,R :: V" "y�'
� ' � "'r +
� � ; � � '� � �,�
�'r �
� �
�k1l3. `1`� » i�.C. "t� . �. • " �
k� �F � , ' �".
\ , � �� �
> u
�+� rw k,, �� r ' " �z .
� ;.'���, r . r.•
;,.. «- ���;� � �
fny
� f+��F� � �N� � r,�
. J��� 1�4 � �� �� W „ ' . 3�
� +� �" e M, c�n
s
�` �r�»,� �°:
> . ;.��,,.
�. � - ,, .,
,.:aM
� , a':
n �
�Ay� _
�
• '; � � � �T�.� A �# } � ,. ,, w
��.,'{�T��rl'j� �
q�`,��.k:`. �� ��Ma� � � a M W , .. ,. �' . �'
��'FY�1 ,� JJe .; ^A�� ;{., . . .
r� z <.z`." . �
�, ; � ��
w�� `;.�� { ��� ���,����� �� 1� � �� •
`� "V � v� � � � . ,. �
r-a � - ,' ' � r '
x, 'i' ' � �� r. . s
. _ .. �+,�t� . . � . _
„ ��,,�(��10�
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Ciifford Earl & Vicki Lynn Joiner
�%.s .
%�� EeEYi
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement �:, ��.;�
50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 ��tf`F`''
863-763-9795 Phone
$63-763-7804 FAX
Date 01 /04/2022
CASE NO. 220104005
�TATEi�7ENT OF VI�LATION AND NDTIGE OF HE�RIN�G
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code ChaptedSection: CH 30, SeCtlons 30-43, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:309 SE 11th Ave, Okeechobee
3-22-37-35-0320-OOOCO-0220 (35724}
3. Name and address of properiy owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Clifford Earl & Vicki Lynn Joiner, 4476 61 st Ct, Vero Beach, FL. 32967-7810
4. Description of ViolationOvergrown weeds, grass, trees, bushes or shrubs need to cut/
mowed.
5. Date violation must be corrected by;JBn 25, 2022
6. Date violation first obserued on or about12/16/21
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the $th
day Februray. 2022 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 iu
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by couusel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Departr�ent. If you fail o-�appe r-ac-tlre-heatEng the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absenc �
� .
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement O�cer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Eaforcement Special Iviagistrate with respec[ to any matter considered at this hearing wi11
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon �vhich the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the officiaf records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005); an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
�����
De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa finat a la tribunal
de circuito . Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza.
Exhibit 2
0
N
d
�
�
.�
�
m
�
O
O
O
O
�
�
O
O
fU
O
f`-
�)<�?6�Jl�i �
�`'� , �, _ �� ; '�,��',�a.:
- � , s
�� . . �,.,� a �
r V,, ' ,.�. R . , .,�Y,,�. ' �� f,..
Yxh ' �� i y t :'1.A��� � e"R' "' • 4 ti` � ,�
+ .'� . �' i h`�' ��r � Lj ��,� . .
, ,� .. v , ; ry .�y . »
„H1a'� .�� � ��r,'" L� ' "'l.. , �,'rY��' �7�,J� f �� '4�," .:� .�.+�K+�,-,p:s
c:.�. ..e .r l�w' y" �;�n,• . .''� ..
?; "a+ . . _ � ' �,,,, `.�d,y� * . .�w3 - 1� v
�?„ r, '4L � ��' (�e� � bJ�.�eF�. .,�..yy. .� �1 , .:e " � �, t � . � �
Y � ➢ �� �, �fR �'�`� i,1
'� . !�'
� lwr � t -� ��� � � . � ,+¢�id�.`�n M1_ � � .v
w ^ .
�- hl•9r'"!�' �,r,� ��7� ,�• ":;;�y � „�� �y'� ��r' �, �;.�,7 K , :. ��!�
�i ., � � ,� w ;•.t � 4 .;�� ��rfR:�7,� � �"i � .. ..�
. . s. {_� ��..wa? ��1' 1 � -_ , � �: tii'...,YNd �. 4'rCa L. a . - _ � ^.�r�6.�
•,��' i
. k �,. � ;'� �
� � l^3 �'�� �. .*€ l:....; .
� _
. � ; �� .' j . . � � �
^ r � ''8!e�r o '' , � _, d� � �� a .
,,'S,+ ��(_ y �' s J�"� ,�� { � �_ ' � � � �T . �� ���i"'� F '�
i � � t� �, � � �c �
1F `r4 "e'�'v. ' `'�I4� i'". L s�, �.i .::
e��� s.�. , �.� . �' .•e.',,s.y�.: . . �. .. ::� a, s, .�.` . .� ��
' ' \�� �s ��.�
.�. � �
�.. ,......,. � - � _ . . .�„ ,:.,.y.Y�.�,� .� a�
�� � - a� "�'h� bi ��:i''� � . . ,. . ,C'w.^..'�". .�. ':� . '��.�:.:h
�IF.}FIAR.4'��,��70r�1��5� , , �+R.. �'4 , - . i��'
1
. � ` . a�.,.�,::: � yi<.y�T . . � •t k, r.- � � , aY : � "�.��,,.t � x
� : t . ., tj _ � . '4.f � � *3
,y.i- a 3�.��Y a, t� � h�s . , I P. �� ��' �x .�',i .. �
� � r �
(�R� , �� ��� � � �. '�...� �"�'`� .. i � ���• ��.�-+c�K'''� '. w � �-,d. �} �J�jj� �J�, (�79+�}�� � �X-J wY�.' '� ,,ti
� ��J��/�Y� '' µ ._'��v r ���r 1.r` ' i%� ���..i�� .r."�� �1' `_��F � �1,',��� l�,U,LSc�J�O��..`74�'.F' IIc�J ° � 4v� t ti
,�:�F'L ig� �,t�� �l��r •• w���� 1 { ��� �'���° ' �.". •a ,�. '� . • �,� ��
�? t � v-'.lk�� . i ."'1� �s � � `�" �' � � p � � �� � ; ��" Ke`�,� �. � �.pe ,: « � r�" � � r r�� t �j�
y � �a�, 3� a
�yyq L`""py' �;�aty.4+ • u'�.� ��T' � � �'� : �r ,� v�` k� � �" x 'f!
�J�� _ ~ ���-.♦�? i.'i'M�Y.�_�i�-��J11i�L�.l`,�i:.��!�+�s rmaa".,..a2�, . � ..� .�' ���.� . r,°,e _��A����.��'�_a�.9
��
� � �
.. '."-. . , . -
�;:, � �`';�
� �s�„� . •_ ,,#
.' ' , ti.:. .. _ . .
.. . ' . .,,� -�?.-.
`^;. :i�y��°� i
Exhibit 2
=��� :q;��,:.
` �`"'t���;
�• %
��;�:�
.
�� �
.��. ��,
� ��
�a�'�
���, :..�—�----- .��,,s;..�,s,�c;*r,r����,.��
d � ' �
��. �k��`� �' A . . � . . � . ._.. ,
�� � �"� 1� Y, �.: ' - ' . .
�� , � q _ . .
,:� , � -. Oi] J��S��,�c�� ��3 ��. � .
� , - � :,��
( .,�� '��.. , . � ` . . . . .. . . � . .
, � . � � � ._ ' ' . . i...� � '� T"
.. . . •
.r.- � .. . r. . .,, -
�
. r. . :
.
� . r-. . . � ' _ 5 . . - .
. �ti� �
, .. . _ .. . ` .�. . ��. ..: ' , . . .
+ _ • '
� „�'
.. ... ���::i. ..t .. �,[+'.M ., .w.. A.,. .'_"._ �� .:._. ' � : .. ..: .�.: -: '^ � � . ��.. . ' .
S.. ,
' . ur�.
�Wr ;,� .
6',• y
. �` � f ��7/ ,
��: r , � .. � .
...�.,,, . . . + ,�y�Y ._Y�� . ._
.
� � T -31 L ��, ..� i $ � �.�.':. � A., ::. 1 �`ri � N'� � � Y F`c�%{_.F.
1 .'� � . . A -. `� d l`� 1 '�.
S" r•�'" M� �Mr � � � �
•�g ^7, ; iM� t y . - 'iP �. { � �'\ . � � 'f
" V" i'� \4 .�� � -��, . ��, ,�` .. erI 1� 3�����' ,��
,� .t` �� �. ♦i`+� �l�
x` w �'f� [� 4 �'"� �''« '�V° � 'a � W „K!
' .i� � �'�y � � � �fY�µ�� � � �7'{ ~��, , h y \� ^"i !!� 'i � ��'' 3
�� '„� �!e�t:�� _ � {x� ir��' I� ��..;;��� y_:r
:�.. .,r"` � 1,� ... � �.[• ��� ..'e n -
` � .t _..... � . s � '������� s��`��' �i�',;-.. . . . �_a. �'i�wxX'-��A
f��,.. ' . . ... . . ..,"�a'y��
� . . .. . _ . - . � «:t - . � m :r�� 7
i .�P'
i , . , .. .. . � ` " 1 =j� � �S-,s.wy7t�1'�k��
' v j��
�.�.- ' : . � � "' . ,y.� i ��. l r ; f ,�,� !j= {X,r�:
..'.... �. .
y,, . . . " r�t � t ! ��4'i���`�
�. ♦ r: i
. . . . , +is �r��,,,, � ��a,�Ffe.� �„
_4 ,
•` _ -�'� ��� .. ... � " � � J �
. MR a� _� �
w �
i4 � " �� _ ? n' " ..+. '' t .�r"`:� .( ,k .« . .. �I�f �NY'
� ' . � . � . .....
. � .. ..,;. , . . _ . .. . .,- ; ' _'... . � . � '. . .. . _ '
.. ' ' ' ' . . ' " .._ .. .' d" . . .
_ . .. . . - _ . . . . - . .. !
�'
. �; - �, - _ . . v" . -' '
y " � - ' s
. ,. .
•
�' ., � •_ . : �-- .
.
.. ��' " . ', ' . . ' .< "
.,
„
, .� O � o .�
�� b _��1
� ... � .;� �. �i I ii�'�t �
'� � a�� 'w w�' ,�,�, a1���,"-� '.� � �: s�,,#-4 ; . ,�a?s "" "ar�, ;, �.�s'� a.�`�'.� '
�';r�;i��'4�Nf�iu'�"iL�V�r.e,t..,,.iaK.'�wl..,'s,��e.e.�re�:;�.�G%'%41i�.���'""�',` �
Exhibit 2
, �
, ;. � .. _ '� , ..
t'�..r �-� =r � . �;,, � ��, f��"`�_ �, � ..-c'jr ` �,�` ,��. .
s .�.�, � ����' . - ' .� :.; -=
r .� ry - �' • .; �rtE,�~ ° �._,�•i�_„
`t .�� �� Y' .., � 'rt
' � : t- ,� g� �.g: . .'. i ..
•� Y
Y� . � �°_ :.. . � '�' : {'� . . � �:�� � ':
� u
r �4 �� .�� ��.. t.� �. ,.ryy,��w���� .. � � .• � ..- .k,� �
� , 4 „ ,�.t. � ` �y, . - � �:, '
���`�:.P ?"� ��;A�'f�1t»�' c. 'rr�� •;�+s� ,. � � _a�.�
,� � � ,
� �a��� , ��y
t ; �.. �. � , i '^ "�, ,
g r e. �
�, . +r.. � �, ,-� ' ''9 ��'h�. ' `� �;,�wr� • �Jr ! '�y;,.. � . � ,r '..a
'�t�' .c
���w' ,5�.,� t'.. � "t im+1� „ . � . �y- . ` S:.v. '�' � . �~�;.
� �..�6 � � - . .3 � . � � *1. *_.�� � .2 v , a y. .. ". �
3 . � 4«, .� "�' �+: t� e 1 •1 , ..4 f�i r �`;•
y � �.�.� � � ' .r . 7."'� '�� ,�1Eu vr r � .� ..� � . � '�� ' tr, ?.
1 < �. a'�Ir r' "'`'+.+a.� �
� � p . � . � . j $ ' �,;' s� �� �
a`��, + , ,� t • ¢
F )I � ^ ` y 'Z"
4 1 � h
rt �'. .
g � ev, a ee • . '� R 1�? . . ., .,
� � '�' �P2, 'y• :k �.. s
yMy�..�, d. - „p , dy,�rt .. �v� ! .w �.-..,'� �'� "J
�'�,"F• :y,a. r � ^R �1'�' . y M . ' �
� . . . ' h' • .:�'•
� �� ..
, y ' * � �t : _ � ..
� �J.i � i . '6� '�S 1 e � �+ T. . ,1' ,5 a..l. - y. �- 9
.��.�•�� a.�"�`r'+L "`�,�, �:.��N > . f',tijy �'s � ��`�, � � � `z;: .., , . +� �� �.�� ~ "'�i�i+. �•� '��
�
� � � �. � r,: �� `, i;� �jj °� � ��.., 7 '� 5 :"Mi*w 15 ' � �'4_ � . . *���,�e'.
� � ��J!�;�;- � .. ,s �'a'F3a� ro r �I�� � A�`;� �'� F°�",, ,!� t •`;�' , . •,k��
- E2',- � 1,;,�7� ���� I" ss � x �� �� �1� . �. . ; � . , � �� �
' �, � �-. rw � �&:s r . � � � . � c�- ` �' � � �
M, w.. � � i-., t � . s�-.•`,�� . �"'! �'. �b � �'��� �R`��'�p*^�--.'��.�.
�ni. „t, . ; ��Y ���+ F •,�� Y �al� .
�{xi 7 S ��+y b xMje ��fa� "� ,,v ' .
�`"'�" °�"`'a0t%�%/i11�/%�zn�zl� �� ° .,
_
�
'�.��.
�i ;'.a
� _�
p�: .
� ;�
�': ,.' �a�r.
a' q4'
,
.,;1;,�
T�, p �
b R1 >''/"'� .+i�
� � ��
k f.`, { � � l .
x �
i
�i Q��S,��,:'��:
� � �
� V.a��-,�.�•y',i
`Sb"��t'M"� .. .. . .. ;. ' ��� �t':'�'i71'��•ar%iCIGYFl�'��, 1 Ej{e5� ♦T�. . S�
c
a �
l.'P ..- �. `.•�� . , � ... ' � � �Y
..,�« �� �' . . " " . : '�^�$� � i9 ..y � j
w:a+.' ,c. � . < ,.cs a, .. �wNl+wa6:s��,.;.. � 3� M�i �ti,L�� w
� r+q -� a .Y? �,��� ; , . .. ��.�J4=��'=J � . ��, �
'�� '`. � ~. .A"�- .e"is�. y '' � } � ��,.. : , ° I� - ��Y.M,�I
, � .. r :� . w �' '• :`9 Kv. , � ;, �« , �
. � ,_+t ,. ..� . _ r�. � �^ . r ,,�k�
-- A�r;� .ra ..',� W �• -�bs� ry.��.. �. �r:. �' � �Z� m `. b'Y� 5q� �, �} � � `+� , ' � �Gg ix�',
4rR p ' �
. . �V� ��• -s'.,c....�l3`^��Y-# .� . . _. e �� .. � .., ,F � _.4. 1�.. �.7r..1: � �.'1 .., _ . , l�lr � � .
�/�:.•. ��^�
;J
M'.+
xy
S �� �
LiiilfY:yd� L
�
��
.{ , .. , -�. �
�f " � R . , -. ' ��. . � �.
,''R � • , ' . � 1.>$'�'� 5� rF'+ ) '!�.� .� , �
����1 ',.• � �Av.:,� " rS � �-a` _
r.� ��;r .�� , �.a �. .�
S � r
- � ��:ar.,,, ^ ri •-'�,�. - � , . .
K . . � , �
y ��«' ;K:. :�'
� "'s�+�� w ,. (�
w � � �i` .� _ ! r
.'� w,h r�` .. � . . � .
.1� � ;T��Y��,�'_�t 1`` ���
`+ R , �: �i't�='r�'' , t
�. ��� � 4 � �ni�C �' i� .,. �"�
`�': �x � a �S r�f
;,q�, . . . � � - � '�, r:., w ,� ,i� �
. +, �y���� -� .
. � ,,� �Iy' ' � � �� �.
��4i� - ���i. "��'• 1 � � . w..7. ,
�i ..'"IR'+ ,� e. . i ' , V .
� +� �� ,�'� � :�`r..s _•
•��n � � �t '� ; '� w � ,�,,.;', � .
��2 ' ti' � ' � � 'x
fF+� r p� „X 1 " '�P� �, �; " �"�_ r
� 1 �- / � ��
���� '♦ . �'„(.- c �y, ` . ,�
t�� � r��.
"d�'��- �� �f r`. �'� � �''�
� • .:{ �. .� , y � .r• ��
� �,' �� �
`�" � v ,,1 h ,i t � �f� 7•� � a
��t �,� .�`a�.,y�'�" +^
�"��� �° i,w ��,a .�M ti i+
��.�. ` 2 � �.
1 � � j � �'y.,��,� �',;. .,•��
���� "�� `ti °.�° `` •
� :
,( y �, } r,r,...
�(� �
L'_�iA 81�y , � . ' � .
���� ����` �r�� �
1 � � , ,.
-,.� ..��� :� � -,
;,
0��960�0� 94�i1g �.;
.�
:,
, .,._:.�«.,�„��„�, t .. .
. ' _ �'� ,
�� . .» , , � , , .
� �:��.� '�r�� R� - .�, O�U�6U�� 9q��g
, � ,� ,, �,;,� , � .
.
.. . . � p.,.�
•� l�ta . J�aa''�'► ° y �r` `� i,y��4lv:
, d.
�:f3���j,r�����l�--.-.:" r 'V, F-�4,k{�S �•,"r4 . , �'� .. . _ ��..a_ � .. . _ . _. . �
' S ! 4 � �"
f�xhi�it 2
�'''�:
t�.d�"�^ ,. �;7�1y+��`�����t ~��� '_'} �� ' �, R* "'�� �. �� ,..'i5 � ..
,t i� ' � �y, � � Y�' ''r a � e� !�a � � t1 . df �1�h�� '
�t" ���,� �'�' A�j�f�. .�c,,�.�aa� � ;�ro'� ��4a''3i �„�� .` .��}g��`f ��
i�, si � � �.. � l,� .'t �a' 4 t � L ! *
. . r� ��`� t � � AA ��� 4 '7''� r.� f� �,i�
.'�..'�i�'t" �# °� � Y . �. w �i '� 4�. ��� . � ,�
� � � �►'a, w .�. 4y v.' a '�.'�, ! 'S rrr
a�� �� ° ' 'a
'� f :.
� [�� , .*
T�'H,. . �t. �N � ��.�,Y ld: '
F �,��1` R`.i"§ �q .. � �.' �k "?.� .� . ,
�i" � .�+i i ,:•� $�� b
'� �
��,�' . „ . . ; "
. , .
- :
�, {� . .,
.
�.s,�, n �.:
3:r w�� �� ��. yek .,a, , . . - .
- .:':: .� ... �. ` '.
...�'_ :t.' .
, a�i
Exhibit 2
:,„ y � �� '�^ � . � �`'3` � x � ° � �' � �,xg�
. , s, ,
4 { . t
, ��, �' '. � 'v�+ � °" � ; y �'�1" � �` p �, ="ti r� � �'- ��i
�
� '�.,y ; `� r'x, ,��� '� �, ` 6+; & t.- � , ,� r� m + �,`� . d -!w
• .v�'I� �9 �M� `� ,
��.v�� �r:�:' il � 3i..
,
v +µ �, %p� ^r � ,� . y.r� t�,.,> � ; : '�:
`w�,+� , �, ', � .�r� 6, � ,. .������������
��w�. �� * i '� S�, x 9,�::` x �: �i, ,,g �`
,� A'* � �' x � � �L; 8 .4 � �' 4 .
'�", �'+ � �aL �nit.: w F � '��•- .t ,j� i a-4 �'�
s IM }� �
-,c• '" ��W��'n1�b r.�� •t . '� .'��>ia,� ' `r �
a��S� . .K"� `�� /'�'-t K �r� '�'I"�{i` � I
� �� `���^�� �P .. _.N+,
s �;a.
�x.. ,:� >-. ,,,�� � t ,�
u' C ,^�K +. � .!' : j�.� ir �'.(�h� „�"'�� �;� ,� �. , I.
�� a . ` �r, 1i c� ��4��� +i �� :
.. `�i '�� �-n�tiC�"���� � +€ -�MK'�i'�� �`�3'�'�t t�' ` ,��
!htE .���,.�,�" ..: .��i, r � �°'�1„ � y� a
�, ,Na�r� i *' �F+k' '� '� .'�,AN.� ���,{� l��v
P'" m � '•'� ..y0 � �y t ti b" r
�� e . s e � '�9,.�� �` +,ji� �e P k1'.
s^ , t ,;e- N�'',�"' s! y�> J a �� ♦4 a� 'af Jy �'Ky A
r.. ,�, ` ic K �� t g'�^r"� ! � �` q.� }'. �,�� x�,..��
�i �a�� ����`�� ` ,.
: '�� � �� � � r �. t �
` � � . � x ", � � �q h �� y I �+'�' f � �a. yq �����, ,ti1+,
' � nb� �.,; �;k�� � k k �, � '� . �"' °� y` +� � �` 3��,� �a
,. s �4} � ��. "� , �. \
{��� f "�� '"�"'� ,:,"� � tiC}•f. =„i; i + R+ .- .c'ti'sk''`L�;7.
�5 � y�,v k'�'r�, � � t� .. tiR � ,,
$"'kd'" 'a �jp,'�Se,�ete wf�•:��.
+W� '. r �+. , . . ' . . , . w�'�F5r°.��.
,
... ' � �,.w�::.���*�.� .... '
, . _ -zi'� �='.� � `y �'� .�.. . -. . . _
p k�
.. � t+� � � ..
�� v .
. ..M �t ..�: .. � .
�a Rl�✓ �' ..� . Yru^r=�' y` � �t�v . _
�" � �� �-.:il.ypz ' � ` _ �
��' �� / • '
:;; .-�� -,
4
�.,
h�: t �
rNF./i�� �� . �..�� � _ . . ' _ _ '
���•�'k . - . ' ' > . _ .
"'Y�'� ` -. ' unc4 _ . .
� ' y s•{ ' a't _s� � �;
s' .' "�!'Y t - ' _ . : _ . . ,
.n �
� 'y=. �" * . - � st _.. ;
, � ���� �
'� '� "��� � 'd� `"�
� �� w � �y+�� '
� .- .:
b ��:',�, � -� � ���
.,� t
r:, '�w �� i a�s'�
- f��
��
i., ��� �' . .,..
. :w'+�F''^:�.. .`'''1�� .,.,'ac.;.b
'�•' �
0�300�1 ��0� � �I � �3g
VLJU U � U�UL�LS � �� VG `
Exhibit 2
��:.;. p.,�
5�Y 'e t
. .�
�r��
� ',:;
�-
°:tt P�
�. « R.r�.. . �e
�YC��
;;i ''�.��3
rs
. K . ��,y�.��..���,�G�q
. .E'v. .. - ' ` '�`r 'cs
Sna..^ l
-, �- '%���� .{yT � , ro.... . . ' ��. . R<,;�1
'1.<_�- _ ... � ' • 4 - +�"]Y'"s� � +A _ � .., "�. .�1
. . ' -' -."'J' - : � t � '` l +' V. `S. � i � n
_ . — _ _ .. , � � ., � � t. �h
_ _ _ .. -
, _. . c
,: �;
. . - �,. �_ a �. .;. ..
, . .� ..,,�, „ :
, . ` _ . F- ... y ,- . :-, . .._, "�GO V �W/ L�V� x"ll�1 �P�' `Z 'r4 .:.
. . - ` ... ' . . . a . � . . _ 4� .C.<
�__ "
_ .� . ' _ .. � _� . ..' „� , �'".�,>t
. .... . , � _ _ _. � . .�lG
. , , . . .. . . . ... , . � . �. , w .. � ,` .
Exhibit 2
. �,ok� `ecchobee
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Clifford Earl & Vicki Lynn Joiner
863-763-9795 Phone
863-763-7804 FAX
_; ;,
,�-:.
t�'=� e�::j
�. � _, : ;;
,.�.. :,
'r��'.F��: �. �
Date 03/29/2022
CASE NO. 220104005
STATEtVIEN'1 OF VIOLATI�ON AN� I�IOTiCE OF HEARING
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section:CH 30, Sections 30-43, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:309 SE 11 th AVe, Okeechobee
3-22-37-35-0320-OOOCO-0220 (35724)
3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Clifford Earl & Vicki Lynn Joiner, 4476 61 st Ct, Vero Beach, FL. 32967-7810
4. Description of Violation:
Overgrown, weeds, trees, bushes or shrubs need to be cut.
5. Date violation must be corrected b�ay 3, 2022
6. Date violation first obsented on or about12/16/21
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechabee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 10th
day May. 2022 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shal l make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. If�ou fail to appear�a�thf hearing the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence.
/;�' �. �.' �1 �
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement
50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974
De acuerdo con la seccion I62.1 I de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa final a la tribunal
de circuito . Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara.
Exhibit 2
�. -
� , ,� .
�
� .. - .
�
�, -
°' � , . ----
� i ... �rtiiied Mafl Fee —���.. � � , . . . �.. � �,\ ,/''
U] ::__. V
� oervlces & ees (cneck box, ado �w a+eaarov�ebl
�._f Retum Receipl �herdcoVy) S hg�
[� li.:u��
0';� _ � ttatum Receipt (elecfronlc) f `-� v' mark
� : J CSM1ifled Mflli Reahided DdNery 9 Hef9
[] I �_ jAdUifSlpnBtufBRequlred i /�, q�
'� I_ ) Adu1t SignatUre fleatriCted OslNery S ���y�/ � �% � V�
���. fi2 B I\�� �
^� 9
� I; � �
N �fnYal postnge an aea
� �,/l�'
. �
� . ;ant" -- V �i�_. � /-`-t/7__
p �,; - - -- - t�tt � -- - — ---------
� �.:r;�,o ---- o�i�0 �/ ��d�-_ __.__ _.
Exhibit 2
■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. � a, g, t�, ; �-- �"��-"�"�`�µ `
■ Print your name and address on tha reverse X '` W %i Rgeni
so that we can return the card to you. ❑ addressee
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, B. R ei �d by r ted Name) C. Date of Delivery
or on the front if space permits. �r b�� p�.ft.t�
„�..� —i l
i. Article Ac�,dC���e,d to: -- � m itern 7? Yes
Ciifford Joiner T .;��e�ive a� �ow: o
Vicki Joiner � , � �'�`�``� �Q
4476, 61 st Ct. j_ �
Ver- -�?�each, FL. 32967-7810 � 46'�' , , /
- . �
_ i � �__.--.v .- — _ _ 3. Service T
yp P Mail F�cpress�
�I ���� �I ���I I�I �I� I I I I�: I I�I�� �I� ,I�I II� I I� ❑ Adult S(gnatura�. Istered MaiIT"'
�� � {� I � �dult Slynature e�istered Mail Rastdcted
ertified Mail� � e6very
`�_i� ' C�;��'.) ( :'!`=; � -���=;�-`. 1 �c� ,t�.: CertifledM OStdCted�� �IgnBtUfeCOnfirrnatlonT^+
� ' �� ❑ Collect on Deifv Signature GonfirmaUon
2. Article Number tTransfer from service labell O Coltect on Delivery Restricted De(ivery Restricted Delivery
7�2Q 2450 �0�� 5699 3897 o��ir��v��eaQe���ery
_ . ___ _ .
: PS Form 38l �, July 2020 PSN 7530-02-00�-9053 Oomestic Retum Recelpt
Exhibit 2
,, n,� �
c �+ M�y+��,�y r��, jF.�}4,
�'.! 4'4 A.. . �jg-►. �'9�'i 1 S��sj. ��t S j� ��
..� � �y �F'� T � Y'
� � j � .e. ��
�'~ '�, i P :"�^J �ii �L,�i'y .
' �� ��'��34 ��a�� � ' � Q"��!
r , 'S'!� �r+`�i..�Y��- � ��.-} .
.�. �:�,,��+y`,¢,� ��..� _�i�tS�M..�+ �:�-, •
'+r t Ti ` ' > -. 'f ' �cF t : d
4. �:$�, i+; `,. + �i�� � , '4i�, r,� ^�, � `� « , u
, � �r;� i f��y,��,� � . : � •.�, ;
. . y q. 5��+�,��
�'i�rS i � '- .
.� .
� _.
•4
`�. ,A •. xi �. .�. . �.�- Tq ' �
�.~._'�. i. .j yrC'-.d11'�/C'J�"'1. .. �FA''�
S
� � �!
+r . _���
f ���� ��� � � ' � r �� ",'��� �� .A �•.,�� � � �,
- � ' .�� :. .,� ,� � t'- •-
Y � �
� � :' . .. .�, ,��j��� �� . � j • - ��
� �� � ._ �_ • ' s � :7�ly�4�i � .��: w�\� .
'�
. , • �
� �, r i - _
�'', .� - - _ -- r----�- - � --- � � � � �`
I , �" ` + ���\\�
�_`_ _ : „�-=_, �i�; � �.,� � , _.- ,,. qC. _ _ .
, .. ..A . _ : . _ �. � � �. ���?^�,1
,e;.. � . ,: � , ��.n �� �y �,; �••�� - � i► - pV"r:e � �� -. . � 'i.1P,»°�r', ��'- "' K�F �. -`' ;",, '..y`'" .
r eslt + ,� ,« - "' , � tri �y �.< ,.+� @.�7_' � d `
�' �r. a e a. ..r �' t R; „ � '
:�� �r '�s�'�• �i � y« �, � ; � . • � � � �i �.,� .�.. . '. . � s � y� �
. � �� `,^iy . � , wi 7T � i t �t�:
! .3 _.r ,d'ir � ''"'�' � `i'i ":����/t :. .>�h'�'+:. '`,', - �i'".4''
i.�. � ' �<.�� r;� ��r,. '�;• y� � �
.rf�', �.t � +Y � T �� y ;t� �d�LSff(/'7�l�JCSlS'�,��8 �'� `�
��J���t i . � . . . .p �
_ � . �:.. � ' ; i��y f` - �� � �. � �� ; , . '; � t.'�
7� ,�. �` F '. �. 3 r ..i
}� e. t �' s t. 9 � %�•_
� �' r �, i } . . �� ���.. i�4,�� 1�, �y'' � . �,i�. G(.7 �1 ft �- � . E�' `� � .:
_� R� ��i ' . �i �1/ '' , .c
''.,i'' �.�iti'YY1�;er�+_'.�1.Qir:` -�ii�.�'' .M °..:�4' :'_ � �. ,. • +� ._<-i. • t. ��_,.. �;do,'��`. • a.,.. . "r �_:
1- - , !.- i J `i
� ��
`T ' . . -. -. • k, ..
. . . ' + ;'_.'.i..�.�R�qi�Y^�i�fi`-'��!SnM�4X��i� �j � � ' .� _�,A�y
,�y�" � � . } �:.r-.: � .
. . . � ' ...{�.... .. �� ..
. ' p°YM�-' .. : ,. _ J
� � �,
'�. .`r_ � _ � � • ` : '�-: -- 040��10�0�
t,; ����,�w� n� .. . . ♦ y 1• •: �s , - , _ y , 1..�` ��,; _ �'. '
'q"_ _
�'�y rJ6�� � �.?�` . ��%j'� ,.. ��y ! "l `,t��` ._� � : ��-.i _ . ¢+'_i��ss''F r�'�
� 2 'j .. i � +� 4..+'. t,. , ;"-+`�•�,�' � r' 4 �'•�t� a 4"�� �+
�. v - t i: �� M -��; t g�l +� .r ry, � ., , r� ;
, ai'�� �` � � '� �y;~��� s� � .JE
y� "' � . � � ,� J ' ,,� .
•i�:�t�e', �� ',`�. ���,1_ ,�Y�.a a �::a'�'a�."�i'i'}�_��'ew��r'^tt�'�'. � _ a
A-•` �
� � ,;����'�"��:�
�
,�{'ry•
h:
�i=:�"' �s�
�;: ..
�-- -�. �;
... � .'i f � . . ..
, • „�„�
. �.� • �....� .
�� �
� F. .+ -•- -- �A6�r ^�� .
.,
_ _ . :, r
,.•.
s �.`� 1�a-,�'`.�t�'��'""s'�'"�: �' � �' _ , �1 v. K. :�
;c ..;:. � � � '�� y . A�
- . , ' '�.; � � . . �
i� � , . , . ' . � �' � , �'��,� -+.
r � � . i y�?�, _ `�
- p� � ,,� ~•: r � � .
"6; '. � f t . �! . r /
, R ,�
�. � �,����°, r ;�:`��' �c'�r, ' ' � �� . � ��;j � ,� • o "0����� ���q9
�4 r ti ^r d� - r 1'FJ{��� �' ��e71 it �,i'� ,.�.. �r.
�1 � � rl,/ !4`'.rt � •�.5� �T� � �.�(�' i, M1 l -1V . V p 1 V; ,� �t: �\` •-, . ..
� i��{['� ,� ��D �''f.�. ♦^Y.T � ) ��� �A. ..� '-���� : yA � ,�.h 4.� �` _,
s
� � , ���� ��, �(.� � {,, -�� '�1 « ��� ,k ��� ��y :5'�t H � ` �C`' ~�'y.���� .
�or �R .l '��� � �1� i.J� T ... � ���" �:��Y.! •
n. �
a: �,:i�� . r�r�}!d�i_t� t...- iw �:�. z.f Y.� K .t a�� C � � . .�Y: , . _
�.
�.f
7„'`..I +
�; .
._ . . ti_
s
i���a
"� � �y�� `�y ,�fi i " '�� +°4 � '+�s�s ; !.� ' �' '-"., �, _ . . . _ j : . ` . .'
�� �y�. �, t{ �. .eM . tr� ► .w7. '`� r�� � a,r . a
� :'� . . ti - z x � r ' i: . . ` yfG�'
��. . � L� 1�, � f g` j • ''F��. 11� .�� !� �7�a$ `� i;k �,..�, ; ��f '� � ...
E `�'t€. "�'�` � Dr�y���} 'k�t�i��"�+r � � .� �� Sf� ,�'° �t� - :-.��'v . �: � �� _ .
�.s,' . `.r�' �'�' r�F.. . ��� '�� . 4..' �,�,t"i' ^�p,�w - ' . .r tt
� � �' �•l �t �.
�'r ' ,� ; :L ,��;',�� t�i' —E � -:-.�,i ,�� r�iC'`•f - . � ,�;' � �!
.-.._. � ` 1`' A 1 ,,��; � -,i����,�,i ` , �, ti • '� - �! — ,,
' r�„ � .K pc'� . . , �` � , s-� , „ �e �
� � r'�f� �f .♦': ,�b \ �'L� .r�.•
.y �, . af•_:' � . r� •.,. � . . '
, << .�..;�r � �� �� �,� " i��=
�',�►<i�� ,. . � �Q, � _ °� � *� �� �,. _ . : � �'` ��
f. . ..' �'. S : :� ����d�. .. i ,� � .� : , ' 'i �►
y.. i� . I
.P. �/f .4` �t `g�'� � ��� Rt�S/�`T'� ,0'�4 "�i,/�..' '"`�f "'_ ft� . ,� .
'� t � �
� �^3 ,A� � L rY,k ' � , �� � _ �. �..
�19 A ; .,wi'a�„1� � �!��... � ���� ; .f\ 'i .�� �� ..
� � ���A � yr p..
. � �� R �ifi� � � ?�--� � S n4�. � ° ... . .. +f' �r.,, C .A�..
�j.� s i},y' ,L ' J �;T, � �� ' x'�Fw� � � • , ` "��','� ��a
�1�'+�i�;. ' ..� ' '���'�` e .� ' ��'` `,,,,�r(�t _4 ' '# .���k�� - ; i� � �' t
�y � ` ;,�r c ',,�,,r . � z ��' t 7. . � � � f ,�'�
` �' � ,� � �♦,�1> \ ;�i � ' t� �j P-, f ••{� � , ��g' � � f
: q� � - • j�� . '! a � �"k + � ,g! , �' � t _ p � . . F. G � r �•.��• : � j , �
I � + � +.'+e� �, � r: �� . ,�. �1�, �
�n k ,s� . �P u�,f; , � i
.ii �� j a�� ' � , t I � �,�' +, �
_ �P' j- : i �,� i � ` i . � t � 7 r�'f ' e� ��f -. ' I
�. ��` ! i� 6 : Y 4 �ti r � �� "` � � i qi� �� ,+,� '`_ � 1 . ` � S , �; t +�.`:`' '.�� �
1� / � � - x � � a • i•.. 1
a 1 ' � Y � � 1 i 4� � �'T.' �''.� {r�. � .t .. f � l�i . p .. ,�
,,._; _. 1 .,:�?t �y�,. � �� ��i�,s � ..%'.. � � � `i � .` � �.n t, � � ,' a � 1''�) + � �
� /1. 7�'� �.`. 'f'�', . Y j •\ . �. � a �ja. i' � � V � .,. { t � . y '�;�
���������n;;:$tr�y ����j�.�'� ���rf! ._� � ��,k b��� , i '.t �! yil,, ���� :�i`r���l ����., J
3� . y,� _ �.. � - . •
. . I} �'ry T � �1. �1 t ,U� �. . .., .. `�� 1 't '�'t..._-�
Mw' ,e" .� e. - i •' / $
. r--;. � �:; ,� �:�'�.,r`�,.�+' ;�,.� ��'��1�� �����,«
� . � . � � �� � � � ; ���
� � � � a�� �
_ , e
ti ;' � �
�,t . t �f
f Q
� «^!��-_�• ' .x - - -���; � , _ . r+ � � � - � �:.i . �:� f . .,r. � ..T'�.y
�",`t t- _� � � C,� ; ^�h �--v�' .,. +,i ' _ ;!. . '�'�''� .
,y�r�„ , `�� E�,, r '� ,' ��" • . !�+ p., ,y � j"♦ re - , "�. .. C,y `�`'m� �
» � o„� �.��'. _ t �;y. . .�.�J'*y�� > 'i . ,� � ���
�.: -.:�~ .,'�'.. ;-i� � s� ��:'� � •. .!-�'V� � .. '.��.. m� �'�..
' m . I '��� !� . ' �-y *.,i �¢ �,. � .. ' �'1�' . i. . � � . �. _'�„'� � , . ai�: Tt
p• s. � _. `; ''' i «r r � � � �r � . . ' . j� ' . x }: � "t
\�e . `� j:.�.�
4�f'�' . � . '�j. ��� , .Y�.. ' - . `'�Y P . . � 9
.� � • � `R�► i ` ! •r
_�� � - • ?'� '� �� � . �1�'a -i� �` � .� . . �. �
i� �S� +6� � � � �� �� . ;:. C - �� �c
`��, � r ' �".1' � 4 „� ��i t .:,.;.' ' � � � # ,
lil�:., � ` �� a'►< � � . � �• ' +
��� � �i�,-..,�� j� .�';.. .� �'»_ � �,.� . �,'.� �;_ �''. �� � � � `i
������ ��+��' �' �4�' ♦ ��' �. ,_ — _�, �� '`� ,4 �,��'
i �Spj:ar R � � V '� , � ;'� �'.� "`�� ' � `�,� �i .� oE
, ;
Ai � . .
$. ��, �"S � .�'.' :Z;'`+� '� ;� �, �? , � . X"4t; p',�!,� i '_1
; �'�,• �r . 7 ! � ��`,� � . 'i �.} : � +�- �. i� �.s � ��s � ��,�.. ,�' ^�� .,., •::''����yy++� �
�r' '� t �.. �� �� i . �� `�� , /�A�sj �1
�x ' • ' � � ��� �
�' � V �:y, � � � r ==e . "'.:y,.rr r � :r �.� q�� ` . �`�9 � '`'°`� • . � , ��; . ..',;
����� tk ..�l�..- I .� ' . - 1 a �:.� �eF . y•� - � -.
. � .. y,a- � c _ -F ,r � � . $L . � � .�" �"i� > i'9K. �� . �.
��-�'.� ^�( ..I i1 ��� . ]S � :. . � �!'t - � � T �° .
� � • ~ 1 ��,'� 3 ° �'��'� �`al
. � ` } • � < S'� `� ' �= �'�� Rl'
, l., �. � ��t� M k. .�E. � �
, � Ir�,�;,r �,;� - . ' ` ' �
� yi ♦ i�w., . - � � � , +'.; . . . �,.� y . . , .
.~ � � '}' � 4�• �� �. :y �»yl'� �!• a j � �. .
.. •� .� � �� `Yi�• � 1` •�.. ., �. ,.�r�
� , �, "i, "� + { ��! 'i�
f .- ; �i" . � �. � � � � . �s �4w r*� � ► r � fY+i . .
��� � ? .:��� � �� !*����;�M t .�x . . �
� y
\��
� ,
. � �. . --� i . . --- -�
Exhibit 2
,,. ,� - - - � � } � . - �: � _ ��� �� ' � � x�
� ��� /�f � � � �.,
� � � ` ���� -� �` ,, � �: � �g '� " � � ,�
- ,a ► : � .
r.�
a,
/ �
� ".� .
� - .. � ,
a
�������{� ��
� � e� ��f '� 7'� � � * � i }.�
i ' S�� -��N
>� �. f� ��,`� �.
�
� } � � , ` ��" t4t � � ��k t ;
•�ls111f � ; ' � � .
r � �� ' t� �re► .�•'�f;� � �� 1
� ,-�,,�j Y ' a��'�" i ! � �
` ��# • �i ��j�f �, �',� i
,:�. , . , t i
� , � �F �
1 ''�. `y� .� � J . . �' f �� 'd
� � .* T". i -. p': �� ' ..
i '# ,
, � • �; ,� ,�� , � � :`� .�
" � � i �x�,� � f �:. t . �, '
,�. � . / �x `'�"` ' �r � _ ,
p �' ` �,r � �' ,��,a„� ��+� �
i f � k A�s � ���� Y •
.�# T 4
� �Y
� �! i�� � � ; �; �.�� • � $ , ` � , � s � a , � :� � ,, � #�' "�e l /;
♦� ; ' � �
�! ! % ' 1�� �
� �`t•„')j - � ' ' ` �'''' 's:� � � � �, f �� !'. . ' a � ,� �
.. ��'. f. .t�(} t � �p � �'�. � �
i� <' W i'' y� � � �
1•
� �. . io ,�. �,YS �1 d' � 7 � y,��'-i_ �
� :�y t ��,� � € . � � 6 '�
� ' i 1 �� ��° � i �i . f [l��( � r�� f i�r��� � t 1 "� � ..�
,; S r ��� r�� ,�' � t �i ��
� : . �� � . � �d � y � � 1 q� � �a�,� 7 .��
� `�". ,�,�.� , �"¢�� �
. �' >� ; � Q��10�3�I�0� �I ° ��"
` ,�' h �
� ;,;��� ���
. . , �,r;�rt '� � - � : ' �j�� � j
r ` � r. . .;� C ' a-;.�� ,
'a � �j{j' + � Y a' � ,.` �(�y �, ^t�'y '
�,�. . � _ . ��' � T . . . . 41.�t��. ' " �� �.5.�'�.�' ..l .. .`Y 4* _. _i 2 i�.. .`
Exhibit 3
Code Enforcement Hearinq Mav 10, 2022
Case Name & Number:
Tom Nguyen Case #220329010
Code Section Violated Descri tion of Violation
Cha ter 30, Section 30-40 Junk Disabled ridin lawnmowers
Cha ter 30, Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles Disabled/unta ed RV
Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning Overgrown vegetation, piles of wood and the front of the
and beautification home and the roof in need of cleanin
Photos:
See attached
Is respondent a Repeat Violator?
No
Summary:
Respondent was first notified on March 14, 2022 via Courtesy Card.
The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s).
Date of notice Type of notice Received by Date
received/returned
March 18, 2022 Mr. Nguyen spoke with Code Officer Curl stating that he
had corrected the violations and asked that the property
be ins ected
March 22, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non-
com liant
March 29, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property, still non- Tom Nguyen April 5, 2022
compliant. SOV/NOH and photos mailed via USPS
certified return recei t
April 5, 2022 Mr. Nguyen spoke with Code Officer Smith, and he was
advised what he needed to correct to bring the property
into com liance
April 27,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property: not in
com liance, still in need of removin debris/'unk
May 3,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property, still non-
com liant
• To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean up and or remove
junk and debris from the property.
Citv Recommendation:
The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special
Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the property into
compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Chronology attached
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 3
Case #220329010; Tom Nguyen
Date Event/Document
March 14, 2022 Property Owner-Tom Nguyen
Address-210 SE 3�d St. Okeechobee, FL 34974
Violation of CH 30 Sec. 30-40 Junk, Sec. 30-41 Disable vehicles, Sec.
30-43 Public nuisances and Sec 30-44 General cleaning and
beautification. Junk, piles of wood, disabled lawnmowers, disabled
vehicle (RV) on the property. Debris and trash on the property, the
outside of the home and the roof in need of being cleaned,
overgrown vegetation needs to be cut. Photos in file.
Compliant was called in by Billie J. Conrad, 208 SW 3rd St. (863) 484-
8007
Courtesy Card mailed via regular mail, given 14 days to correct
violations
March 18, 2022 Mr. Nguyen came into the office and spoke with Assist Code Officer Curl
stating that he has corrected the cited violations and would like the
property inspected for compliance. Mr. Nguyen was advised that Code
Officer Smith would be out on Monday or Tuesday to inspect the property.
March 22, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property: not in compliance, disabled
vehicle remains on the property and still in need of removing debris.
Photos in file.
March 29, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property: not in compliance, disabled
vehicle remains on the property and still in need of removing debris.
Photos in file.
March 29, 2022 SOV/NOH and photos mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the May
10'h Hearing. Received by Tom Nguyen on 4/5/2022.
April 5, 2022 Mr. Nguyen came into the office and spoke with Code Officer Smith; he
was advised what he needed to correct to bring the property into
compliance.
April 27,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property: not in compliance, still in need
of removing debris/junk. Photos in file.
May 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected property: not in compliance, still in need of
removing debris/junk and cut the overgrown vegetation. Photos in file.
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 3
��`� .
�
} .. .,,,.
E
'�,_+; i
' � '- �
., - „ . `�`�
�
1 `'`-•- ��ti�--.,_,.
i . � ��
• j.
` � ��\��,,,� i �r.' .�'�,
_
z. � �'
� ' 'y I .: �.r�W�1�,��
' � _ _. ! �
C T � � �
,f i �' JL' '
� � .. a-.., :.�s i�as. � . . : � R. �
�� - , . � ��.�+��.r�"'�' ....�..• .,,� , �'.
y„ �,.�.,�„ � _ } � � y�
��� `�A�� � . / �e
r
� I � �,
'" .-a � i � �,� ' ; _..
_
_. �--. ..
y� .�y.. �:--�-..__ _.. � _.
� �r.,�' ' -
..� �_ � �
- ��
.,
�
_ -..� r :��� - �=
�' , s-�, �,
, _ � ; � ti � ,,
a• a ' ti {. w ?'i `,� � �jt i �� �`�'' ,. •� f���
�l��, � Y' �.�,, ` ��.1�; '� � �:�' Ra '�„
�,t � �1.�-F" •� a iy�� r ` - ' -.'�,�i. A
►'��'f� r r�� "�� s��,'� '� \!.� 4
� �e�,.`�� �►, �, � � ��,� �
� �� « 4 �
' [��+„e� , l • - c , i� : ,tr� 9
ir` P' '
�4�'. � `. � �.. T.—� ��' �.[: �� ��w�"
# ,�;
, e, •� � �.T
� !��' � � .�'�t� �r` ; —
�'� . � �`• . �. €�� �` 4 .o,
;\i� T✓ t4. � � a� ��. +S.-
. ' � f� � , ��� A`
. . � i.
_ Q T �'. � '�",�
�.��� ��- �
t.. � �' ; �., � ,� - `�_ •- .
. I` :.v� . �� ��"''..
'C,� ,
i� e�� 4�
� J�,...^4n ' ��:
�r� ,
' ;`�`.�. n+,o ... ,--
_ �C : � . _. � ���1
A� Y � _-- T
.
AE ,
•.—=....
� '
�. _ _ _
� _.__.
_
� _
�� : � �� �.
: �.
� �- -
�xhibi� 3
��� �
,�
Y
,� �
:;..�ii��,;'��i
,� ��ti�
��� �
< �
.0 '� �
� _
1�����
. _ -, , �
�. � � �_ �
`� . .._..._.... ,�'
��_ E �t . �,,, l,,���i : S _. i�,:
� —..�_,.� , a i
.� � _.. ��; �"`
� - — ----. , � �
___ _� fi
._ _ . ., ___.�.�.._ . _. _ _._.._,_ �aa
�M $� ` -__-- _ ,,,- �� � _� �
_. _ _ , _ , .
� " • ,
:M,,.� �- .r..+rr.r�i;.---_ . ,aS+'^-"- � :� ' .'+ l:..•' �
�� . _ — � . .,�, ` � _ ,t� . -1
,.
_. .. . ,,. ��`
�� ti.,�-��„�
z° - .'�"'���, ��
Y�.,. %�'n �..�,S,r� ^� ��_�gY`'�
... 4 .. _p_'"F�".x.a :� . 1�'_:
,. � � _ . '�` '
�, ��.� _ _ ` � t `�w�t�:� :'�' `
.� . �� -
, ��'`' ,.,, ,� � � .
. �#, '� �� J� '-�
.� . �
F � �r � �t 'y�.
�
�.- �. � �j
��} '1,! �'� � :�;F. *y Srif'�ae�..
„ � � " + . .h . 7{ T, ��,..
. � � �, ° ��1w��
,� � e��� �..
�;�' , � �
�; � e
�� �.� �� � �� ��
� � r`r ` ' ^� ��� �i �
�.�� �
z ,� • , .
�, ,
' '��"'"'�=,
� -� �
� .
f��^.�;Rfe -
- =t
�
� �� �
• - #;,
a
.. � ! +;'��'
��i���.,
��a� '.
� h
� .�
�`
� � ~�� �'
\ ..,. � ,
'� �; ___ _ --
�� ' -_
►v..3 _. ,..... '
�f � 4 *� •.
�+ .
r
` � s
� _—
�� ��
;'°�; '; �►
��� �
i���
�T � �
�F .,� ..,_.-----'-'+!w�
'M . . . . _.-.r...�,..�
_ � .�.. _,....�
. . __ ___.....,
--�-�-,�,
�qd5y� �
7� i �.�"""'Y'H+�
_ � [1 0 o+..�N .4i'�4B`�' : .
�1 � �.
� �
Exhibit 3
« < ,.. . ��'. < . � � . . . .. ..,, , . .. M� ,i;��.rve^'r!r., �',. J'. �� �
��.Y r
�� �
�
�-�"
G�, •r�..
_. � xr� � ��,;
� -�.-.._ �; , , � :
�,:,�;� .�- �;,� � � �-
' - r►��` � �`.�` . �
_ , ��.
�
Y
�a �� i
i r � K:1 �
i u :ip'� ' :�
.
, . -�
��: . ��; �_''��
��-�'� ' ����
--� _ ..��- .
��,� ;, � € .� '� ��,�
�� `
: �,
�; �
��; ����,-
��
. w .. _ � �;
— � �r ��rk;�g����
`�►' ��-�+` ��',�4,�:.�,
� i'_ __ �
'�Y �5.�'. ..
,~�• �
r_T:
���
,..., �a.. •!. - .
/� _ �
� .
_ �""`s� �� g'
: :�—,.r ,. . � _._.a,...
�
+ y'Si
._�. ._._..�....._.__'_ ....,,-. ..,_ . ..�_r7 . ....... ........ .....
i�_ , ����-�9 i
fi .1"� . _ _ _ikrE�rq�. .> . - . ..._�:.`7
, � � . . -. , � . � ..- �
�. .� . � .. - ;
,.� �
, i
' E � , ' _ � ���
, �
� , _._..
� ._,. ----
.� _ . �-,��a���,�,��
n _ ,
��., �.,�., M. _ ._ � � ��+..-_-- �`'_.
� �; o � �
;` k °�
7 ♦, � .r�4�wi�++.n� P . R . . .
.
`_ x
r
� �AR� u� �� R�., � . �� , i�.� '�* : .. _ . ' �`-'n�:�. i�r)
� -.r l f -� -. •�Y$-♦ •' •.-.'♦'��e��i�Ge*- �...:.... ,._.....
i t �s♦♦♦!♦♦♦♦♦!A�lr
� j. � s ♦ �A�t�'► ♦ ♦ ♦ �+(p �k,� ->?!1��
�r�.��� ,ny+- �
�►?;�s w .,. .� '�•�r .����'' ' �'�'��
+
Exhibit 3
�
Dear Property Owner,
,<;�
Date: . �IL`j �, :�� '-.� �
.�.�-� �,
1.�"�r� ,/�. ; �. �- ,�.�'�-,
�
This is a courtesy card requesting your assistance in alleviating the following code violation(s) at the
above address. The following violation(s) exist:
'' /•� .'_', - 4 : �:
;, �; Overgrourn Weeds, Grass, Bushes or Shrubs 0 Unauthorized Signs, Flags ar Banners
' i . -').'.;�� .J�L, . � � _S,� .:.iL-' ✓`�..lJ
��Trash, Yazd Debris or Junk 0 Operating a Business Without Required License
�:,.
� �: � -�i: , .. �,,
`0 Inoperab�e, Abandoned or Unlicensed Vehicle 0 Pool Violation
0 International
0 Other �"x. ,
l.l�l;'�'�"J/`�.'G �%J
�erty Maintenance Code Ch
., —
,, ��;
!L:�L, _l..l :��c_:')'1�'.�' _
e
Sec
� .
'1� . , .'l" Jl-"i:
Please contact our office at (863) 763-9795 within /' `j days of receipt of this card and let us know
when violation(s) will be corrected. We appreciate your cooperation.
Exhibit 3
� �
�:; .
i
� �,
' .�
.n:
� t5i
r� i
�
��
3�«%;;
��'�
�,
.. I 6 �,,. . .
9� 1��,� I..
�•� h �
,�,�1� \
� � � 0�3�15���0� 0� _ �6 ��
�, f- i"
- �► -
t.}: -�,:�-
� � _�.��
; - , �,,""'�, ,#
�� :
,p1*�
L � �
.�
f - . .. -
�
�'�� � � , .
,;, '"�� Iw►
yf .
i:.'.�.r_
- . ,,
�., -�
i � i �,,' �,
��
� ,.
w ,
� ��
� _,.. ' � >.� � .�
�� -q--r� � - i
��.; -�,� ..�;it
�.� �� _ _ ,,�'l-;:
�
�-��
�` . -
, ,..:;
,,.�,, �`;:;��- " -i
�. , . '
� `
Exhibit 3
Exhibit 3
� �. , �~ t� �,,z:
� ;� � .��� �� '�"
,:w,
; ��
�� ` "���*�, �`�
.i• � M
� '�.
1 �ttt ,. _ , . .. ,
'; p •, t.. ^ . .
'r �?. ,; _ � .
m - �
��,.�^,��, � ��� -� _ � A
p �� . : ,� �� �':+�,;^ , * .7,�
t�. R � . . � �,. •.. -. �;�(` � �
i".S ' l. � �1. ;�.�y\
ra�a,�l��`� 3r � r �M !4
.... � � ti �� ,_. , 'j �, ��.t . -���'�
�
.ie
�, . � . . . ` . � y `..
�`• • `f"• .N� % , � � �;` 3
� ? �.Y�,,.�, � , '�
1�' ���/.%• A � � � '1J� n �� �
.,�, ; . . ^�,,,�'� '�:. „�{�, ;- • � �11,
z
;�,, �^� ,:. . �.�'�� a�,'�;
�f , ,���.� �,.
�A� �=\��� ��i� .��%�� .. i, �J�. � .�,
j�� � � =+� � � .�..,
�. �' aor �' �' j► �"�''�'�
��� �,tc�. . -. � ,� . �`-.
.''\` . �'` : �1
, -�
� ,; �� '. ��� �; � ��� � -_ -
: '_
�. ,._
'� `
,: � , y _�. _: �
ry r.„ � ���.--5 z-'�°' • "�' "{
� a � �.. 1
�`iM � a^ . .. - � �w::i ,d� � -
^�'�f •'�J� �.�",X � ,f ", 1�' � �x .. pt
W�. 0 ^� }� '�^s""x -
z i_� , 3° _:+ = y,.p`, _ ,��
r�44"� �.�.^«�..
_•,:' .,t.` - .� v . :
„_, n _ ,.-__,�.,�;..�.,�,,,..,. �
��:, ,
. ,�.,;�F; ,,
�
;�
� . ��
� _.. �'. �.
�
� '# � m� + _
�
� � --- -� - - � -'-
~ . �. . _ _ .. ,,..__m�.___�._
-�. 'l'i� ,__--�-,....,,.,'"''�"„'"wi�
., �„
FU il ' ��h��Rr
�_�� v� �
�• - �
�, • , . , , .. . , . . � ,�; . -. _
.. ,�.,. � .� �
1�
�n?: . ,� ,t � ,�
�;. � �:
. . . . - �iar.s: ".,µ �' '� � •. . .
... � . � ' �� . ... ..t. � �.
� .. . ..,.. ..�.. '� ... �
�1Yli�
MN . .. . ,. . . .... . . � .. ;� .
x y�
:4
1'..' _ .. . .
�U�g0�0� o ° �9�
�
Exhibit 3
�
�
�..::1+� , � .�.. ; � :,<-�-;� �i� �"� , ,�.
—.. � - --- _ t . _
" ;� ` �
� • {
. �1 . . :'� . . � �{` r � `�
"�.., ; � �..� y>
��
� f
� � �.
i, � a'� � � �
, . _. �� �'� v .
_ ' �
A
� ,
� ... ' me �.i . , . .
__. — _ ... ��
�� � i�-
� ��� �' �; ;;
�'w"�.'�^�'
... "`- - � . i-._
�
r�� ...����' . . r €:�.
�n '
Y ,.,. . . ,.��'1" .
�
1
� I
f� � � !] �
Y
t �. . � ��...� �'1
l�
�•, �
,�„�
^,:
r ..„ ,
0� ' � �
�
��a(f �.CQCf10�
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Tom Nguyen
863-763-9795 Phone
863-763-7804 FAX
; � ): :.�':.
r�µpOli�E�4��
.r��i �..1:�.
. o:.�,. .
'FL
Date 03/29/2022
CASE NO. 220329010
STATEMENT OF VTOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section:CH 30, Sections 30-40, 30-41, 30-43, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:210 SE 3Yd St, Okeechobee, FL. 34974
3-21-37-35-0020-02080-0010 (34581)
3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Tom Nguyen, 210 SE 3rd St, Okeechobee, FL. 34974
4. Description of Violation: ,
Disabled/untagged RV on property and piles of debris that need to
be removed.
5. Date violation must be corrected b�ay 3, 2022
6. Date violation first obsenred on or abou��14/22
Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement l�iagistrate on the � �th
day May. 2022 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compiiance Department. If y u f' ttT�ap'pear at the hearing the
Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. �
�
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2U05), an aggrieved party may appeal a fina( administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal sl�all be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement
50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974
'- 4/ �'�. P �/'A V _ �.
/
De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa final a la tribunal
de circuito . Tal apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara.
Exhibit 3
o�
�- �
m
�I
Q' }Cer±ified Mail Fea
trl I� �—
❑ RoNm Recaipt (lwrticropy) S
� '-;'FatumRaceipt(clectronlc) S
Q [� ^ar[Niatl Mall ReaMctetl DeWery S
Q. LJ Ad��tt Sipnature Rpuirad , S
�� �.hduttSpnabueReeMctetlDeHvery S
� Posiage
V')
�" �D ,
� Tr tal PoltBge attd FOes
O S, ___
� iS,.
0 /
r�j',�^ l
r�- Isirc�"�!` r�r. "� Y'o,"�'��� 't
Tf
—` V�rvsuunin N '
�r� ,ere � ��y+��_.
l.�
�,l V�'„`1.9�'�
Exhibit 3
�.__
� Cornpl�sie i�errs i, 2, and 3, ! A• oignature
■ Print your name and address on the reverse X - ��9°nt
so that we can return the card to you. �-' '� � addressee
■ Attach this card to the back ofi the mailpiece, Bs RBCeiVed (Printed NameJ C. Date ot Deitvery
or on the front if space permits. � v j�^ :% � v�C <�%
1. Article Addressed to: ___ D. Is delivery address different from Item 1? ❑ Yes
�r delivery address below: p No
Tom Ngu ,-
210SE3�St
Okeechobee, FL. 34974 _
�
�-
❑ Priority Mail F�p�ess�
�� �'I�'I �'�I I I) I II f� I I I� I'II � II' �� �I I�� �) � ❑ Adult Signature ❑ Registerad MaiIT'"
I � dult Sfgnatore Rest�icted Dellvery �J Re�istered Mall Restricted
� ertifled Mtil� �e(ivery
Certifled Mail Restdcted Dellvery Signature ComhmatlonTM
' ��� �� ��� G � �' � ' '> `_"- _ � Collect on Delivery Signature Confirmallon
2. Article Num6ar lTransfer frnm swrvrr.a lahali ❑ Collect on Delivery Restricied Delivery Restricted Delivery
7 0 2 0 2 4 5 � O D � � 5 6 9 9 3 9 � 3 �ail Restrlcted Ozlivery
_ _ . _.. _ ,_. . .__�-_ " r - Mrn-w>.>O)
PS Form �8� �, JUIy 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Retum Recefpt �
Exhibit 3
�._
,�
y,� �•
.,•� - �,.
?� . u.�°,; _
. ., k! � �+�M
x � ' �
-�1�_;..r--`
. - _ �_,�•,,,.,,,,, „w,
�, k� , �. _ `'�- �;, "�
.f�
" � �. ' ..
y�a'..� :��..
^ �"a
' ,� :r--
" � - ""„'
� �, � . � ' :�-.;�
tl, ; � 4 �e �`�
♦ v ��
. � �'*� � = �x �
- .. _ �!e,�:
�
s �I�"°".�..�. �— :-""� .�.�i . � `��y'."1Q � '� ��c is � .., ��r� g(�
� �
. ..�$ ' ." , r*" .Y �� L,a r � _ '"..'
�I�} f .<, i �," A!� r �� , � � t . �- T,r.. .�� �4=,.,
_
� �, � l ,�'"" P � �,� `� � ' �! " � �r r
,,�r �
�.
� e w. "` - � , �, r•� yy pl � i�G' �� � y� '�� . .. r.�n.r�r,..». � � %� � f ,. . ..
� �
� . ��•'M..w�. Q �,y �4 �r �44 aB[. �c '#b �� � , ..... .
+9 r
F . y�`' , '�� ,,/
'�
'� �I'a'` �.+ �:'�. � ^ , a^�{MI' ' ;��. r�.. ..�,7I " . . . ��F *+.,w-
, �M�
�.� � ��; � mV J �
t - r i „ �t
.� �, ��,, '° `_.. �� � �.M�.,.
�
� i � _ y �.- _ � ' �
;F �+�'' . �'. ' i:��. . .. ` �-'
7 •
� r �. .
� �
�"°`a.sr
�a 1 . R» "°""� ��' ��I�� �': F j ��'4 � # � ��'� , ' —..,.- , . .,.,, « � �....,. -,�-�
, �g x� . . i , . � .
, , �
_. � , � >, �� � « - �'� .. . . _.
. . T, �1�.., .+�.
i
. a . � ' , �S � . . � ..............
. ; �, . � .,^ .. . i , �
.
� � ,I�. � }. `. } / ,, " �� � r ...,_ ...... .
' F i � � �� �. �`4�` ,., 3 . .
y � "1 i ��. �{ ��' � ' �il... w� '�•ww.n,- .. � i. _ - . .
�(/ _
'� . s . yt � °�"'y ';v3 _- „ .::. ...-. .,- . .... .-�r,,,,, q _..e
� .r� � . �Ji+ . 3 ` I � , ��' t a..'t .: t�.�.'r� . . ti \
y �/ ` ' �"-. ' /"/�ti'. 4 r k VR�'!�r
� jY*,. .. � . � .
`*� � '.1���,i1,?+' „ � Q <.�! ..i. �� ..... .-..--.,,�........ ,.._a
+;;�: � � w _ . , +�►
. h.. � � i'. . <� .. " y= -,. - �
�Y ; s�' � -s
(t ��,y _ ',�M� � `'' ,
�� � �"
� w �.��, - - �. - � , ,
� � .� -
S`- 1 � !�• �"� /.
,,
,.
' «.
� � . ,
• � ; � . .. � . . � � .� . .. ;.r�
�
_
_ _ -.
. r.
-� _,< � �
�--� : .
�-,� }�� - � „_•.�i•t 's� 1 , `. s �� 'S7.,. � .�
� '� � .. ._._ -�-�..
1::� > E �
y �!M�I J�
�
�
a
� ��� ���
��� � -
��
� r'���
1� �. . .y'� A ' . -_'�
.d±y S
i. Na .�. . > �J1Y�.r . �.
Exhibit 3
==�y 1,� 4`� a.. �' ` ,, �'� ,,.V�� �. e:� � ` ;�"�s r,��� �: �. �, �-r, ,;
M�Y �
� 'a . ��q���rt� •�� "�! , f 'A' ~ �� .....Z.F° . �,. -�„r�r�,,, v . �' � ;'
����u 1i � � � � _ .:Liy�.�-�.+- �-, i ;�,ri t �.j{ �1�
�IT�.41. ,;�~� *�,�� ��• �r�. s �. � � . , il r i:.. J"� + %
1,' ` � f r
* ���°� •� � � . . .. �` . � a'�,.• � �M�Y �,� . �, d _", .
;, <y` '1r�'�,� �� ���` _ �`" �4 e y � ,,�% �!`�!� o-
, +� +� / t
���.''��'�' r �yV � s � w�yy; v ..� J _ �����. , f ,� f�� �;
t;.�,*�' ,^y�� �` ,�w �'•���`;R�'� 11 ► V�" car 1` i.� r
j� a� , � � ° ,.. �,i, . :• �:.''�' , ''e�, �.� . � �,-;, � ?�"' .;�.�'�;�'�
._. . ;,�. , �,,� � . � � , -�►, .� . � ,l - �' ��► �
,. --t �.
1••�;�':�,�E✓ r�" ,�,��� ' r,`��s, '��,� ��� � . � � ; y� � ?.
'"�,,,,,,� ia�xs , -� , ,.. - �'�" � . F�',h _ �.+ .s - '�' '� ' �
'�. ; �' . _ - � - 1 1,� w.,.�-�+?- ��1 � � a �°' ,
t►. + � �i .� �l�p�., 4-.°� r `. +„ke �
, `- , �
v� g�. �(��
,� ►�'..,; ,;p�, . ., �,S'r ,�. 'M. �1�'""cQ 'f ����. �'A e' . .. �:�
r � � , �'u �. �, d '�@ � .�n'
.,, , ��'�i+ ;�n/ �'�i �..�r,,�,'" �s'�'1� � _ r. �--� � �►lI. �`�''�i�^`3; .�
� ` � �'�9�` ��"��' ?-��' '� i�'�'�, �ti`� �`� . 1�`- `��8 �'� At�" 'w �
� � � ��/j�� 1� ; ��°���+ ..F,... � �� �5 _ � �'�1�
t � �T u ��°
�`� °� +� „s t r, ��� � _ ����'�"`-`=x" ��ry �� .��r: �
V ,�'r. ''� �4/�j%%�I : '� ^ y�.Y �w �.� A� �'� . _ `�=` .
� �� .. � � . . � � � �..a�.�. — � � � . �� $ � � � . •
� 1 .' i Y �. '' �' :.� ..'�r-n '�°. ~ a.
� �:: pr Y ���� -�-- �� /i� � _� '� �-+ °-?�f,t� "\.
� •"s^� �. ♦ s ..Erl- �`4� •. r �.�w,r_ _ _ <
•,r � . ' / Y'"� `�� I . . � �,. .� .. ^ �` Y�` > >�` ' -+r-. .
, ,
. ,
�� " • ..:�.. ' �' r
�oe. y�t' . - •s �' ' .
. „� r' 1
�'�c � ,r✓'�•�k • � �� * ,a� �w°;'ys
, - �, - � �7(� ���t�rj�)
E � w i' , '' '' � '�,:� ._ ....; � �,. Q .I ��� LSIJ�� � NJ � CS ll
. •r- � '• � �e1 � . �l���f . ' .. �'i� :.-._ � . -�- ti� v.* � ... .� _
. � .. ':.: � -��
� �� � 1..M/ � � • �. ��� +.T . y. ' . � .
� �
r �
ya �/'�" { '� ���,, �`9 '��' >',��+�''�'3 'hc`? � �. � .
-- �, r r r �,�_""' � i. �_: � ��� � �_� .��A� . �..'� A:i��^�,a�
. M. _ ^':..�'"_ � �. .{ "'� '�3 . ` •c- .'�^.i`:
_ , __�.,.,..,..,,,,�
r��k �
��f
�� ,
�..__ �. ._ .i/'
- _ - _ - - '� : l"� ..,�y1, " yy �r'�
_ � � � � � �F
_ � _ .
- ,. �� �;t � f � . t�r� � �
.'' ..r , %����;s, 4 .h.� y' ' y ;
� �f+ Y^ � 3a, r , ;. , f �
� /t„� +�y�J '��' ,�s . y�� �. _"� � *
, -r , i+� '� `�,.'�. . -� 'T/Y ' A .'"i ,' . , r,,, �, � .aI �j i�a
. � � f 4�7� . � ,
�. %% � - ' � \ .� � � � • '�-�S�' . r ' � . . . + Y
. '
.� j + *- ` ="� � ^ �
� ,
,
:
.„ ; � � . . . _ � . ,
. ,=�� . � �� �,r,' t. � •~ .. L ' � � � .',r; t�
_ • ,,,. r � r.� cm,,. 5 :4+C
`� i � ,� �,- ' 'a . • � « _ /� . q. . _ � �
�4'�� � �f -i �7�.. 9 � ,a _ � :' ;�,;: , ����.��,�`�
' -� � . � JJ w :,� { .>,3 , . , � � -. j�;,,+_ �p� ,s � ; ;,�,� ^`
� � {1°a+
�.�, `,� �.-. T , .��. Xni �':"�y s �.-{'
A . f S .�r i� /? ^� / T .�t���9 ., . . . ..
%�.. �'Wi ` Z��� �'Y. ,
� l � � � � ;� X ,:�• ,,..�, Q a U f5 U � (SULS(5 � c�J � � � '�A'
_ . . . - ,a, � �
.�� �t � , �;r��.m:Fi}.. ,�r"��,,'y' ... -�.:,
'� �. � .� -
_ ���+Q < s� � � ��� dy!` . _ - '`s_
'o:w� . _ • u,"�' �f�'��. °'_... - :�.�'. -:�. . � ....
Exhibit 3
,' 'r�'�+"� �a �, `•, "` -�"c' � '
`� � �, i � � �,^:
�t.�� �
�j,\� ��.,• � �, .�.
� `.�
t.
1 ., �� .. �{ '�',�
�, �' €� `A„ �'�►� .�
F� :� ��%� ��
�� �- _ �� .�
�� ��.. - �, .�
�8 `*` : ' , -_
_ a�_ ���
. ,«�.,"' �
�, �_
l' � - •� k,�rJ'�� s _ �
`�:' � �� �"`r
� . � ��_� �
�, ,
; -
,
,-_
, _
,_
, `
� �,_.
r I . �.
�
. rl�lYll
_ � � -_=� _ _ - �^ � ��,
, �.� .
�� � � x . -_ _ .
;� , �.- z�- (f
�, .
�;
r (� �s , �1 �� � . _ _ . �'• � . �� • �, � � �. .
� �, h" �y" �' � 7 . � .. � � . � � .
�i' l, �y° � - _ • �! �,.
,1� , � iK, r�i.�Ar . y _....� � '+- '-.. ' �.. � ;
�d -�r-i . . _ .... : =�'f'.S►' - `a��'�-�S �jrn1 G���j
+ � ��= •�. ,s ��'� 8� � ISUCSL/� o °o
., � , � �
� �: � . r� . i: ` ar ti4 � y+c . - � �.h�. A �'"� � . � �^ � ' . s
''����iE�_. "' �� . `~.sA�`h.� . , � � . ` ��' ��, r — i �
ti < •�.'�.�. . i }y�;:,+ <.� Y �: �r �� �
E ' _ �
1 + k"' �
��� � � �
P � �,
, � /� � .� ��:
-� � i
� " ..- - � -` ,. �� � a
� b� 1
�'
_, ,q -py
-�s� . � ..�- , `a
sy�
t1 .nd'�f��' ....�.+^*� _ .. � 9 . d
� �
,.'��
�, . .� �r oa����z� � �,,,�
.., y �"„ so*s.:'..-..i�M
� i �„,, y�,"My`y„
r'�"" �` ++�.,
� � ~i ��'��;. � ` .�.�� .. .. .
�
Exhibit 3
., � � �,�� - , ; � .��
� � ,. '��' r � ,
. � 5 °k`L`� `� '""'A`�, w . ,_... _ "i . .,- �i . � �=����Y �aa,�� i�/!'° , ����� $A
w� , �,r.'`�„ � ��ti z' �� �'y'�c...---- t � � �=,..._., ,� , �, � , � � .,c a
� �` � �' �
'' � � � ' ' ��ir � � :'v �' _ � ` . *r °"` ` �ii,, . !v�mi: Q aa�.} y; : y,. ,,yy.,,t .�+-^ '
� a. LL _ ,- ,
s ;�ty ;
%� e�M,��� ? �� ` �L.i . ^ ,�` ` 6 '... ,�R" . k . � Ji .. p � ... y � , '
\ Mi^yt � "'� �} y. ...'1'� � �y4'w�" � '�.I+-"����( Al�"�k��� `iA!"lwiw',�s�c)'�.�.:� -ea ��ir�..�"'.�..ii'�i
��r,�,y� t
'�' 79�''�jP`" � 1 �. �' �v � LL �a � � � �;j� ��T�'� y .. . ,y,,, A -' r 1 ' . '�,y�� .
s a �y �r' ��'., � ti .,,MJ � i4
i.A' �""'� � r� �j , ��q,�. 1e,'��rF�,, � �p�yi^�`�,�,� . �dJ� �..'�H;�'�-''���' 3;.
�`� � ' � '.. � ��' �1 ' •�. ` � g„'dr � •�' y ��' � � , ,�« ' , . . �,,,� ,
i� 4 "�. . . a ., C � � ] --r—
- : � � '1. 'ik "s� �i r����' �'M7��"' ,�+ � � I�t .
r {� �, � . „� �,.����q� �i_ _ ,. ,. _ . ,._ _,
�
� �`. '•t l � .. . , a + +. +��y7 _ p�i �'" - Y � ��� " � ^�� Y,-..,*-..,,- . ,.,,.�..�... .w,....-.-.,.„„�,...
L �
. . h�` � 1 �++C�u.. ' , : � � � ,„. � *�F'�'� ~� ��..� Y# �� � . f .. _,. ...._,_„p..�... —
-�"�`� � � ; � '�
� . � .� � � �- , A .. ; � _,�
___..__..
."�..'.r �`�' ����. �'� � ��;� '•��`�' � �e�; d �� , _ �. � .::`' ��.• �. _
.. . ' :; `�� �y� 4 Yy . � � �� e..~ ' �
ff . • _ �
< ., xf � : ,
. , �„ � , � � ,� ��
�G °y` '��4. �,,� `� �' , � , � �
F �„ , ♦� ,� _
.: , � i w
„ , . ;
,
,�.
���; � -0t ;I� ,,R� �� , .��. ��;��,` ..�,t e__::!
�� ,�+� �M j),
�y� e �
� " h �j. �, � � �!1� � *�
..� ��.��. t � w� 4+` ���.'1t Y *W�v�', M +'����,'�� �/, � i:` _ �4 r,4 ,
1 {,� i �� 'p M
�i ji „%�' � t����' ..i�X ,�?';��.�, �T �m'�'`.' ixr �� .
*�i i � .,. ,� � . ^. +w -: : , .. r-a.�..�-
:,. � y � ,� r s`� .; �.� y
� ` +� •. +� i 4�+/� �����41-' � ` d "Mb' "�'y''r' m ^ q . . * �.^ ��.i�j,t�i�,�: � �
". .. • l ' 1�yj.t� S bG .�`f ". .
- �f. �i h r� .. � �.� '^� �.�� �' ��'�� �A^ . ..
, y, ./ .:�'♦' .q�1.}. � 9
".� � 'Gb i ..�� � �',.ah� a,
� `� r>"��� :- t� �,�� ���U���U� � � � �i� ;.�'"�
, ��,�y��►� �r �"� �' �'�@° � "�'� ' —
ab, . [,� �i�h' H M� � �1 �, . .i�` .
1 . ` 4 r �.:..
♦ e�y�,4 �
. /,�y ��q{)j .,' L . i � �&'F��a'�� ��, . �`'8. '
,.� M �.:v: � � �`i . +.
.
: >�� \ ( . ,
. q q
y . . �� � . Y �` �j ��'. � . .i }, { ��^ �:. '�..ti� . � � . .�
.
u.
. �� .
' .�:. _ ',J_`.is�:.,.. �:,.�,.�" ? ..rl'Ji _ '-. u..,.°�� :'5�4�� . .' • .y... ':�'�iC.i. ..♦ ��.u..;
, . ,4 �� �gSv=
,. � � s ��, �,7� \.Ie"� .- � ��'���� . � � � � :% � `/�.
��' S� - � �wtww'+,� �.� / � � �' "M""� � t ,„y"
� �,�' p�y,e:r��y"�;� � , _. .�� , �'.ti.. �� f'
'�fp-. .� t!'`A�i �i, i 'i K:'4. �,.j.�.er
. "� y� e* �!�' �b " � ����`'� 8 � � �,
w.�x...r 'P' . � � '�fM�`b�i :�� �Y e ''���� \� i,�:'r�' .. �i
.-.^+. . _ �!'y ; ".�'1f"���' :'. �� � ,{� � �ri+ i . � �� ' �� �, � ' 7
,�
� � �� � e
�4 �� �" � °� �� . . `
\ �1 ..
�
�t � R F
� y�. , " t a � � + �� ,� j � �a � d� 4 . I
��� , �, .�.� �+ µ � � ,� �
'�� '1� � .. `'b' � 7 $� "� - � w ��� '
B ^�F ,�� � , � �° �� , � ��;j�. ' � r s�'`r i
a. . '�. �,��' '�� �, �:
L `:�rrrt��r�+rta ��'µ�„�r " ✓
��► . �� � '�, w r w �
,
: e
.. <a�r� r.. M ` �
.
_
«•
" � � � . x � �`"�^�.,'� � �.:%"�:',� . � . � ���, �,��y� y r � � ����
� ,� >�! �
�,,�� �^ �� ��� p � .;�. ...,� ..r . .;r �y' I, '� . . e� �� �.z�;� Y ���•i �.,i
e.
+t�fi.' � � M.. � � � � . � ��4,; . - . . . '� M . �' . jyi, fc. * �' .O .
��
�� .
'' � "" � u'�Y'
►�►�� �✓'
. , t� ,. ,.
: �..
, � �, �+�+it''�� r'i� � ,. „� ,� _ . + "�', � 9� �,�
�� ` ,,�r
� r:
�
;. r . .
,
3g. �_ �
� � �e v u:w 'ay � � A 'r.
�
, ..
�i�+'� •�� .:,(�r'i`'' �:;. ,'e�,�,(�` . �I .. . � F !�.�;, .�� �'Oj�l�
, r ,
�. M� �� ' .w.,db"i',.� x -;'7RFh°,r �.) 'n •� .� � ��
� :
� � �, v,� r � �' f `�_'�6 ,. a % I � ./ '�
r
, � a.: .-,..,
�r ''-�p� ��, � �. r--- " ' `h�'"` � .�� �'�. y�.��� ,.��!�)�
t,ri"",;'.y'��Lt�� ' ��" c +t'"�' � # �� K� �< .: _% �g3 "� `'� �"+i�
� �� ,p�,,
xt;; ` ���_� ��,, .�•,t . , 'ry, y,, �}
� �mi �� ��rY� ,. .,... «,6.���.<,� .�'' M . a:.."rS�9 � .� t"'"�..� � �A�"� •. �+�
�,.;�. 1 � ... l*� i+i
,�1 I 1=, I�' �.'M"Yr^� a Y""_.a�` � �..* "�•�, ��.. �R �
i � v
�. ���� \t \'e� *+:;�. .�•,�"v'i1:�` �, +� .w '` � .. . . q ��i� t.
�l��� �� �z:wlm � , �If �`�.F�� .�� �.iV� ,nl� ,����
.��� MN�m+�..t f �
Ji'. ',
y�� 4�� � �".. .� ''� � �, Y" .- O O G , O
� , �*i'. �`LL� �� �S � i � + �''�R'�"�r.�,'�; _'�'� � Y �
�
.. ,�,�.T"h� -'�"�i �-� �i �.4. � y�� `ti�i«'",' .�,w.��,A,�.. � �.a r
����:Ic_ .... �.. tri�i �Y���_..J:�� .��.� .. , .,. ....'r ��� �.'a���. ���
"�,.�`, M� ° ` "*
_ _ . •..
Exhibit 3
� � -
�
� � �
.i„� „'� �
.ni��';M�ir=•.M.... _
�� �
�'��r +�
� �,
� .. _ ..__ . _.
i
�""�.��
_ ,
������ �
�'
i �:
I
1=,0�3�! 20�2 ' 13 � 5U
�
.►—
Exhibit 4
VI.C. Exhibit #4
Case #220405015
Mary Alice McCormack
Exhibit 4
Code Enforcement Hearinq Mav 10, 2022
Case Name & Number:
Mary Alice McCormack, Case #220405015
Photos:
See attached
Is respondent a Repeat Violator?
No
Summarv:
Respondent was first notified on March 17, 2022 via Courtesy Card.
The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s).
Date of notice Type of notice Received by Date received/returned
April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property,
still non-com liant
April 5, 2022 SOV/NOH and photos mailed via USPS Walter Piscatelli April 13, 2022
certified return receipt for the May 10�'
Hearin
April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property,
still non-com liant
May 3, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property,
still non-com liant
• To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean up and or remove
debris from the front and side of the property.
City Recommendation:
The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special
Magistrate Hearing on May 10, 2022, unless the property owner brings the property into
compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee.
Chronology attached
Page 1 of 1
Exhibit 4
Case #220405015; Mary Alice McCormack
Date Event/Document
March 17, 2022 Property Owner: Mary Alice McCormack
Property address: 904 NW 5th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34972
Mailing address: 904 NW 5th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34972
Violation of CH 30, Section 30-40 Junk, Section 30-43 Public
nuisances, Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Junk
trash, and debris all over the front and side of the property,
overgrown grass in need of being cut. Photos in file.
Courtesy Card mailed via regular mail, give 14 days to correct
violation.
April 5, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, debris
and trash all over the front of the property, and grass in need of
being cut. Photos in file.
April 5, 2022 SOWNOH and photos mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the May
10'h Hearing. Received by Walter Piscatelli on April 13, 2022.
April 27, 2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, debris
and trash all over the front of the property. Photos in file.
May 3,2022 Code Officer Smith inspected the property: still non-compliant, debris
and trash all over the front of the property. Photos in file.
Page 1 of 1
r�77ii��
�
,;.
�j
�
�
;,;,_•� _._�"�'-
,. � �' �; .'�;' _
`� �
��
�, � - -
��, ,
���:,__��.
"y �i!
'.�r: ��^!��'�- . , __ 1�'
� ' _ �,-rr-,;A�•..rs<,�-;�'..�' " � .
i� ♦
S ��
a� �R
a
j � � .
:.' . � :Y�"'� �c" .y�. ���,yt�.
.. �:� ;' , ti,� r
�,s�. -y;� i }�. ' ,,�; �. 4 ".' ' �
�sst�' r • .t `'� � �
� e r+i� � � � . ,��YF>+��rld ;. � �
� . � .,:Iti" � . .
__ ,
--,�
.�r s
f'""�__���—�. /�.
��� . .., - :, � �
� '� �' ,r. 'S e t�' _ .
•� �ji.
� . � � �1��� � �� B' � . , 1 . .
�y �� �� � �. { �.� �� ; . . .
. }:s x'f�'?�'wf'+"-
�_ . - � . , �' - , s � ...... �. � • - . . , � . vr �-:a
r'� � � � . . . ' . . �r. . . • . �: V
_ _ _ —
.
_' .. :_ .;.. � ..— _ .. .' '
' ' _. �'d'..: �,,. . ._,.. . ._ . _ .
— '` _ _� _ ' — —
�'= _---- �,7 � ,.�w.w..� - - �,rr�� _ _-� >�.. ��'� -
��
�,..� '�'''�� �1
, _. .. _.
_.. Y._ .__... _ .
r�-^...�,^---�-�-� I
__, �
��. � �n��
. .# ..y }
: ..
� � ` .�..�..�.�
�. ..
.. ,�,� _ . __
, _. _ : ,. ��� ��� ._: � �'�� ���
.a_____-�„ . ._ ..
,. �� r: . � ����
.
. � ____ � .
#
.,:
_ ,
_ � _ �Ly ; _ .. � 'L°� ,.._ ��,
� , _ _ ;.
� i
k
. :cea
`, _.-'_. ... _ ...
.
1. . _ _ . �., , .. �~a9ili t °u}�1,
..�.
� „, ,� .� . ,�... - �� ����� .
_.__� '
` i
.
_ _
6�, " �
�� � ' � ...�. . ... . �.
1 ` "
, . .
. —` _
1 �. `
,- � b� y'i _ . �w� �"
,_��
.
:
,Y y� � ,,� ,, / � � � ��
r...,.,m .�r.+p�rti,.i ' ' • ., _ �i;�� �;� �
. .
h • -� ..
.
.. ,�.. �'� �
� � � . � _.c�..,� r .
. ., ^ � � _ ..�: � �A . � : r �
-0W 1
. � _
�.A�c '� f �� P , � , .., g. � • . .
� �
�� k� ri �,
, r
' ��- ��� ' r�� �� �Yh..: 'i k
� �' t �.i,.r .. _.
A+ � '
"� ._ . _
•..
,
— ,� . , �, -
------ • � . ..
.�,/''.�'f' � "N , .�s � ,,� 7 -.� ' �
�.; . � � '�5.. ,�" ���v �
,
, -� �
,�,,� .. _ . .� .. �, �;-. , ,;,,�.; : .:�., `�0�30 ��1�11?�t� �1�3 ��1�
�. «�.'a:. ,. i .. 0 �;i1�r. . �� � �""'A�c&'��
�' .. � . � .:.� . ,. ' , �. �» wo.: . ,., �
y y�p�� ++e7YkL,:. .. �jy ,�'4 � r . , 'V"
, � �"`
""�1''�i'�M��s . a
..i6 .
a�X —' � �� � "
�a� a°x�' ,�,.a.. s-�
a, A
� � ;,,.. � ' � � • ., ., , . "y _ . . ` � . .
Exhibit 4
�
� ��- � � �� �� _ �� ==`-=-�
:�
�. ---- �.+�
. . ., ��
i � _ _ � �_:: -= t --- , .
-
_ - � � ._—_ -�_ ;
;_ -- _ --
..� � _ .� _ --_ _ �
______ ---_ _ - _ _ ��_
__- --- _ _
---- ...,.�.�.���.a:..��.K ,
��: . _ ,�.�.��..,.....�.,.
�
'�' J _ , � ��.�r
_ � � � `-�1l� �
��s�W'� +;, .�_,a,y+ ' ' �� �
_ ' ,4 ;,2.'� - ._"" G�
;�Yt � � � ! I
- . ; - � r. _' a „� � .i:�n � •�'2Ir
r ' •' -
'"#,,. , - , • ` . . . � 0 + ` c7r-+ .
• �
.L�:�
' . . � . . +. � . .�:+f k . ` ., ��c' ,Ar,.. .
. � �y,. . � Y�,�• .. • .� � .:fw. � . � � .�� Y �' f
1 '�' !J '� t � k� 14 �Y"�tL '
. -�`y �Y� :r. ,�. .[ � �.. ., - "
, 4s� 5 �f � . 4 .s '� � � � : . .
' e �}� '�i `' . �e +r
Z 4 � li .._ .. _g . ' M,.� . .. ... ._ "4� Y aF" _ . --. . . ' l7 u��
� � 4a,_ � "� E .aa � r �w. e.. .
1,� - i8.ri�� �•;8�?�r�,'�.:`�"-�.�i. �.'�'���� i�s ar�+�_5'� +'ti� z .:.�
i.-," ' . , . . . . . . . . . .
�' r.R.... V � ,.. . - .. .� . .. _ . ' _ . . _ . ' .. �� .
�,�� -.> ������0� ���Q�
�' �e � '' . _
St�ti:MC _ _.
��_ __ . ���,�,,.,
--- �
� f
--- _ _ _ ,,
--
____
- ,.�, _.._
- __ . .� . r , .
�i --___
_ ..
�----- ._ _ - _ . �.
� � �'
ti _.E t� -�,�.
� - � . - • - �
L �_
.._— —.___�._. .. . . . "
^_— --` �
"— ' r
r
� , � _, *
� � ����
. . :,�ti.�.v ' � . "_ . � � s�y, J�.y '
... . ._.. �'.....�' —.— .-- '
_.._.::. _ _ .. ... _. Y� ✓
� . ..__ _ . _ . _ .._� . ; .
�'
-___— .._'_."_' '�� ;;,�'.� �p "�+�- �] � '.,►y�"� . 7 � . , S �'� .. I y �
^'�`.Y
.� ,.V �R fr� ,, }� i� %��i� . .. ' ' yt T' �Y� �!!ts'�MF
;_ � M ^ h
Y '� '. , . � � ��;; ���y� .r+�' > {����,^,4 '�(�.�+'�, " .
,
�`y�� � � ��,� . . . � . . , .
� ' �x �;. +'„ . _... "' .. - . .
,�. A'+}r . .,�^"�,
�,..'. �•� . � '� . ,y ? , .
t:,:
�' , . , .
' , , �
� .. � ��U��U�U� ������
R ;t � � a .�;� - - , . � .`� � � >' ,�� � '„ '"+14- '`'';:
. ,
���_... . tF:_.i: .. . ..i+Ms- . _ _ � a..�_... .. Fu _ . a, _..a2. �_.. ... ,. . .� ... ..s.� �... ....::S.C.., 2a�.. _ � �':'� +1�..`dv`�C:Ci+�'.: .. u.aYa. . ... _�- r
Exhibit 4
�� �
; Date: /L�lyii 4 � � % 7 „��': ��
Re: f, j'/� �,�'' ,r `r
��}� 14'����/r� '7 �� .�� �/ <�-�«:i 1! f Lc.i-�.rirr3�-.�"
Dear Property Owner,
This is a courtesy card requesting your assista.nce in alleviating the following code violation(s) at the
above address. The following violation(s) exist:
�vergrown Weeds, Crrass, Bushes or Shrubs 0 Unauthorized Signs, Flags or Banners
,..----'""'
I�rash, Yazd Debris or Junk 0 Operating a Business Without Required License
0 Inoperable, Abandoned or Unlicensed Vehicle 0 Pool Yolation
0 Interna.tional Property Mai�tenance Code Ch Sec
� / l. .,f �Y . �:'� �j;� 1 '*'� ' './
�/'. S � i,e, s z� i. .•-� �:. 1� �: er,.7 :�•
,
:�
Please contact our office at (863) 763-9795 within �_ days of receipt of this card and let us know
when violation(s) will be conected. We appreciate your cooperation.
Exhibit 4
:
` �_1I �- � i� ,�,. ���► � :
�,..�� ...�
. �.- ..
.;-
� . ------_._..
_ . w. ,_.. .
_. _ .
._ - __.- -- .
;.�.:� _ ,,. _:.
...� _
- _ �� �-• -
-w
- j..E .- ,
�. . _ � �� _ ._ . . - _ - : ` :_. -- -�
r,. ,.., ��, --_ .�... _
,�¢ _. � . __ �,�► �� ��� �n _ _,._.,,n
��;,� , ■
� �
` \ �(
� .
�:.-. , _ ���
� , *:. �.�,��-�,
����.� �`'�'�, �
� , � '
•�,' � ��
��� �.�
■��I
_r �� - _..
� ��
r-.
!�..• !PN � � • �w��'.�'�
, . ' .' y/t. . .
. .<�. - � --- --- . _ , . . . . .
— ,. , ' .�;,s"� � y '"Jh�'M�'
:..� ;k.: .+w��� , , .;i ^'-'
.
...,Mn,r •— ..�'+.,,y -,,... . . .
,>+�...:.<. ., -•+S1"'... � . �� �•yw— ._ " "�.a.�,..."'F,': ` �w ''�,� .. � . ..... ,.
� �. ....�Cw-'"'�,. ���" "�"`. �;. . _.' �"' -.�`y "�` .,...w � "`-t..:' � ,µ � . .. . .,,. 'ei .....
. . Y . . • '""'ti. }''.,� n - .' , ' � ' � - .. - .. y .
_ , .
� � �,h �A" �' '�M^'tA.�' '�"' � e ~�� � ... .v � - � � -� Q d U V 'CJU � �JG o.:�J
'.. , y;. ' ' . ��tlr t t�p �
�.,, ' µ . .' ' . . , 5�� ,� � .
�. u R �� . . . . . . ' IF'y yv � �' � •.! .
.�� ''`.- ..,�, .r : � ' r ti'< o �,, ' .y� .�.. J t�y. � a / r , d • .
"����;""4'" .�v. r•?° � - rR�` �"; q x • . �°^ -
.r.>+"... . !�r � . . .�
.._ � . •�'".. . $ - .'�.�-.0 ,,. . �,. . .,. , i
�<
�---- _
�\. . ... . � �;�
��\�� .�-._ , �. .:.
�
. ..., . _. ._ . . .
� j /..._...._ ..
Exhibit 4
��:.��,�, �f (
_. :_ _ ,. . _ - -- _
__, , -;
,
- __ _ _ � i
.. __.
_._ .-
�. ... _ _
I� ��� _ �. _ ,
_. .�_. . .
_ �. _ ;
��_Pl �� , :� .__..
ii ��■ !��� ��:� � _ - _ �-- �
�
�- : �.�,.
���� ,.
�� � �
�_ ��
;
. __ ; r. ;
��:�.; .�.
, > _______ �
. __ ,
_._ �� � � � � �� . � �� u �
AY .
� ��.r!�'.`. eiY7t� �+"��3i''�`-�`r�_•- , . ....�'�y ,
?'�� �,.. A *
. ;�r� .:�> '. '"' � , • _ .
. � .
�
.. �. , _ ;
� .. .a � ... "'_ �.. ` � �A�� • . � . . ' .
. _- ' " "�ii' .. ' ' . ..✓�i y • 4..� .'F. . . � . ,.., . " . ' ' . . .
. � . _. . .. .J , T .. .. � . . '. � .. H � - . . • ` . " . , �
fY . . " . . � . . ' . . • ' '. , � '
+.r �, y.. ~ . . A � .I� � .'• p ''� .. . � .. , .� ' � � . � ' . . `I
# � : 3 ; . .. k„� :� � O�OgQ
, y,� i �.,. ... f:�, s t r r ;'. ' � d � � f0 �;o � 0' ,
, � �, ' �
f y �.� -'.. « . t
� :� , � ' . .. � S � ..� ,:) ; � y :yy (� .'f f � � . .
�.S - l . � . y ' ' ir `�1 hT N �„} . ii " ����.. , ' � ' . . '
�� � ., ` f , 1 t � � r +� t�P" �'1� `S�y�• j ,�, �M ;; " ti + �` 4�� �� � . t
k �'1j� .'•y� � /.f ..��Y ; ., pi i . ' ''� N 1yM . � � r�.. .,i ti � � .
��.��� t•TS _.��t!'lk� v,.\!��.` 1� 1'1..!.� , . . �'_�" _ " . ;�.. �t A ' • . . .
„�,Ok�eechobee
CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR
THE CITY OF
OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA.
Petitioner,
vs
Respondent,
Mary Alice McCormack
863-763-9795 Phone
863-763-7804 FAX
Date 04/05/2022
• J �
�� �p LICEFE'.�
._' q��4 _._.
FL.
CASE NO. 220405015
STATENTENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARIi�IG
Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of
Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives
notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and
hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate.
1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section:CH. 30, Sections, 30-40, 30-43, 30-44
2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:g04 NW 5th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34972
3-15-37-35-0010-00990-0240 (33732)
3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists:
Mary Alice McCormack, 904 NW 5th St, Okeechobee, FL. 34972
4. Description of Violation:
Junk, trash, and debris all over the front and side of the property.
Overgrown grass in need of being cut.
5. Date violation must be corrected b�ay 3, 2022
6. Date violation first obsenred on or about3�� ��22
Unless Respondent corrects the vio(ation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code
Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take
notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 1 �til
day May. 2d22 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in
Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and
conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be
represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that ny ev'd ceri'e presented to the
Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. If ou tl to appear at the ' g the
Magistrate may enter an Order of V iolation, & impose a fine in your absence.
�
Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer
Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will
need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will
be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department.
In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be
filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed.
Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement
50 SE Znd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974
�;:����i�: �
De acuerdo con ta seccion 162.11 de los estatums de la Plorida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar utta orden administrativa tinal a la tribunal
de circuito : Tai apelacion sera archivada en eI piazo de 30 dias de la tuma ue ia ordea yu� se apeiara. '"”'
Exhibit 4
_. --..... ....,.. ..�...� �,.
Oomestic Mall Onty
�
For delivery information, visit our we
�
�
J
� ❑ Ralurn flerefpt (harcicouY)
Q Li Hrswm Receipt (almctroNo)
� rJ Cetlifled Meil Rastdctetl �apvary
� I_f .4Uult 6lpnature Required
❑.4dult 9lpnuture Reahlcted DeMe
� Posiage
S $
� Tota'1 Postege an Faes
NSent 7u�(///qJ .._._�
� Strri�C�77'l' u., o B�ix
S
$
S
S
S
r,.�j �
_....5.✓...__..
�/���
��
Exhibit 4
■ Complete itams 1, 2, and 3.
■ Print your name and address on the reverse
so that we can retum the card to you.
■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,
or on the front if space permits.
1. ARicle Addressed to: —_.
Mary Alice McCormack
904 NW 5th St
Okeechabee, FL. 34972
A. Sigm
^,�r -r
B. Rece
V^�(��;
n
� �� ❑ Agent
% ' � �' � ❑ Addressee
by (Printad Name) C. Date of Delivery
�ca{�II `
ddress drffererrt from item 1? ❑ Yes
r delivery address below: p No
�
,s. service Type ❑ Pnoriry Mail Express�
�I � ����'! I�II J�� I �� � �� (� �� � � �� I �iI' � � �� ( I'�'I� O Adult Stgnature ❑ Registered Mail'^'
i `❑ Qdult Signature Restricted Detivery ❑ Registered Mall Restrtcted
� . �"Fartified Matl� elivery
-.-, � � .; ,��,,; , � � � 1 ; ,� iSCertitied Mail ReSMcted Oelivery �ignature ConflrmattonT"'
�� - � - `� ��`� �- ��� `�'� ❑ Collect on Delivery ❑ Signature Confirmation
2. Article Number (1'ransfer fmm servir.A lahat� O Collect on Delivery Restrictetl Dellvery Restricted Dellvery
7�21J 2450 �Q�� 5699 4Q78 �iaa��caaoar��
_ �. ., _. _ �_�_� ___ � _ ._ _ ..� _�.___ r -t.,�.>� �1)
; PS Form 3811, July 2020 Psry �sso-o2-000-so5s Domestic Return Recelpt
L�._il�^,�0+'"� /�
sAl, :JB_ .-
� r,.w.�...�,.^..��.-�....--
1.-"�"�••^"'""'�"'..
� �"�""`.w':,_.
►--.��--�---
��
; �...�.,.,_. ��:_ , , r1
; �----�-� ...
j�.... ,. ,.m
� r--x-�---� . -.
. i M�^.�...^--... . .. - ..__.e.,.�.,,
�..., �..a..—^.,..�....,�
�. � �"�
�._.-,-,. �.
{� r n,i..s�rr�'•.�'•.s s-�
� �
_.- ,. A � . 4 � .Tr.i : -M!` M
�-"�' „".,,��
�J
.�
'�'e, - g �'';- -"' •
� 1., ti ry" ' > 1
R�,� 4,
' ; fir
. X .��, .{:i�4�e
�a�r,� �
0 "�L���� ���:��
. _.____,_.....,
�
_ ----�----____
� +��r ��; �, �. �, hk y y L�, r w ..�. ."^ �� ,ar+n i � m �1k r ,X, r' � � � .
'�' � liA� . .y, . +:
.s ��, c , �- . . `�`:ly � 'o�' ,�r. `5fq..- rtE�a ;�y � ' r� ` . .
��, } � .�,,�.� ti ��r �<;: ` :��" '
. t. , , .•, a� , . . ,
,r . . � . � ;
� � � � � . � � � � � �; '�; ` - s= � . � o �� �
5"� .
, T,.
. . , ' d .... . r.� "'-��+�
�_� . ,�.. .. rr � d , �. � � R M��+ e,i�+.� �=' } ..
� " , .i +� . s r � �p x'`'S � � v �� ti 1
, .
.
"y � `� �+ lAa. �� t '�" .. �'�`'�, 9, ,ta �{� �� !t �
: . � ^' �� � �t 1� " �r�. f ., f " , � '„. � 4 �r�,
o( �
. � � . ��• ..� .� ,�
� �" "y :, .. ;` i+, � . , % � ` . ;
. fi . . < ^. � �, r y�. � �� `,' •i�,sy�3' � + v=a q � ., . - . !
- , � r} "'`� �f r � ' `' D ° '���U`2� �'� � � �,� , � -j
.. �� y � 7� K.` O � J.
'�� ' ' E.�'.e L , i���, ' ' ti � . .
-.. �e .. `C � .
�., . •� ..y c � �.�Yox . � J. � .., .'� � '.
yy.,6 '.�,+'� �:,� ,c�`m ,+� �.,��. .. ��' 'r .�.: �- '•�'4��+ ��.�,'. r '' >
.a ,wa�;r,� '.ti'. ^d . ! �. ���� ?�
x
� . • .� .�4. . .. . � . `. it . . _ . .c.. � � '' � .. � . __ . .. . . . . . . . :;R. ..... =�3
. �.�...,_...,,,:�,3 ��" �� --.......,..._..
— ._ _.,....,_......,�..,
- --..,�....._.._.
. __.--..---._
Exhibit 4
¢ � � ��� �� b � �.,�,��,r���
��r :.�. r�� �
* ' •, �` __ i
--M..,,_.�:.... '� ;e r,.n �
�..�,....,..��"-,,,� . � �.'� �' i
�. .� W .�,. . N �r �� � � �� *.;�.r�. +.>�
. - ii q� • - : •
< :
, � �wwM,r. � ,,..,. w � � ._ �,
.. � .,�� . � �:� � ,, . . � ti�� $' � } '��.
�
} ,.,.,,f. . .. .. � �� i��p�� .
Y .. 1�:��1� �..
•�` ` ' . . � .. ..
� . fltlN. � � �\� $� ' � . r"rt�
Y� �:��� .. , , � .,1 , ���
�� � � � '� � �... � .:�
� � _ r+�,�"
'� E .����..�,.,.a .;� ij � ` ✓ �� �
u'.�►.. �.,., �;; �� p . � � , "4;
, ,.,
;
� � t
r � �„ .�r �.. . _,:..�.r, � � �r
; , . �,,,+
�.�X... . .,.
�rr-��- > r. .
�, ,
+�-- .�.,�.�_. ,, _ . �
�. . - , _
� � �� � ,� w. .��
� ��
.,.�..�...�._..� _.�....�.�...� ,.y� .,,,i�
,.
.
�, .. .. . y„Yw.i�,� ,„„ . . � . -YIYS' » , ':. ;�� �w � . � ..�, . �`� q . ;. . g.
n�
• ;P ti r ��� � � .
. _ , - ,� � ..
''''�i��� �,; �� .�,�
,� _ �� _ . ,���„�,,,� o a 4���� � � ���14 � .
,
.
�;,�. ,���w . "�" � ��—� �*;:
� �.. . � � � � �� �:�:
� � ' , p.
. �. ,
�� � � .�, � �"�: , � � . ,.�rt �r�,�, ��`_, +�� , ��� a� _ �
.
, � ,
�Y 1 �'� � w�
, __ . w�' , a �`�ii ,�iEt• �.���. .. . __.
Exhibit 4
_ _ - -_�"
_ -- __ _ :-..�
.�..�
,�-. :�
�
4 �, a
_..,. J'
�!^.��..� � M
�'yY.. ,...
--- -
�_-_ - __
�. = -
- - -- _._ _—
. �w■�w�■
4 �``� x_' S ' �� �
, @� ,
' _YS — � - r
_ ...... . J� .. � � `) . .. E:1 �tl�y t � i � I'!' ��
R'
�� �' � � �3' � .e �� �,
� F� . d �
, '� � . . : � ..
•� � ��' � . _,
�� :� � '
h
�,,. + y � . ...... . n �'�.
'/
- � •
' . . .....__.,_._
o, .�i . _ _ � • "� .._ . . . __. _. .
{ t y
�Y�*' � � `�� ta'+� ,,,�hv f�I . "�
^'r�^'+"J��, ''�K��r � �y1 °4:�—� yy,k,I� '. �� �'--�J�II���. „y.+;�eX'.i.
'il 3,��:i�i" f� —.iiY ..'+"�.^ � np' }: � , .. a .
. •
i �
' -�.....�M*� � '
� , s�`.4 . , + � , a:
' �rr. � . :,r. • � _
.., .
_.
�s+�; , : .._, . ,.�;, �. �. ,,_.
. � � ..�'�" � ���D�30�C� ��1 � o 0 0
��.. � � , . - . .
, f . . ,,
.�-�- .. _ . . .
�;:.: n _ - _
__���
--
� ,
r'. "Q+'.�'. v�S r." .'�� ywYe� "^, �it,..�yj�r-"..- .�'Fy���Cyi �'t ' �„ }uW 4# '` +rlkif" �"'�o� F ..•.. ., + 7 . . .a.�.� .. � .
�
:,ti , . - . `�.s � ��JM`�:,;�r,'� � � "-twy`��. '^ � � � '�`+r.,�� ✓ r - � � . j i',
� ' ♦ y � � .,�y� yu Y
y,.�. � � ' 'A .. +A�MM�, .1 N +r'��ry�a '" YM' . . �Y1''.'A��... . �-c�f. `. . . . . �r.e i '1�'-'wlY�`�� �r� 1!�',t�'�/I ..✓ ._ ;• �,
— �,,�____.____,. ___ _
�` � �.�^--�
�-i,�! ---____ _ ��
Exhibit 4
� - -Y- �� �,,,.. � z .�,,� <
,; ����,��� �. �
�� . ��.� . , � �.,.,,,,,,,,�,� _
. �
�•.
- k . ,
,� , r
r,�„ � ti.<
�� �,— � � �' �;�;�i�
. ��� J + :1��
� � - . . . � _� � �
` '� . �''y ww.�r`�+ , � .. . ` (
. ,i a
' ' �>V 7
.. ' .?L�� . � _ 4M ��'�.
#,.+'R�.qt.��^�'2 `. � .1�'
, . t�� �� �f�y!
41!' �.
• , • ,. �' i, �S a
� 'ye-v�.. .��f'tJ.
,
0
`""'+i("' . -
O; ` {
. . �!
������ ���o a o ",M
, . {{{{'',,�� ,�
��i��`4�'��'���ri�tin��~' � /l��a . ' �
� i Y � ��
' �����( i.4 �1 `.. � �.'�. � . '��4. r'' 94'. .� '',S . . . . �:
� � ;.�.r. .• .. � • »�� ��".r � � ; - t� - � .:a. � . �, _ . . .. , _ ,. . :vF;.
y, '` r � ' ' i .i�... +i.laa.. 1•' � ,. r :`�`: . +'11� � }: ,a •.'�!