The URL can be used to link to this page

2021-10-12�1 ? • ;o��Fy- � �� m 0 0` i6 .� � a `.�� ao` ��,5• ��.. - CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT OCTOBER 12, 2021, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING OFFICIAL MINUTES I. CALL TO ORDER Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on Tuesday, October 12, 2021, at 6:01 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast 3�d Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special Magistrate Azcona. II. ATTENDANCE Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll. Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire, Police Lieutenant Justin Bernst and Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith were present. � IV. CHANGES TO AGENDA Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred, or withdrawn; there were none. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the September 14, 2021, Hearing minutes. B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered an Oath to: Code Officers Smith and Curl; all affirmed. Code Officer Smith stated for the record all events regarding the Cases to be discussed occurred within the corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee. The Officer's notes, testimony, photographs, and support documents were all entered as part of the official record. V. CONTINUED CASES A. Case No. 210701012; Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), 710 West North Park Street [Legal Description: The West 50-feet of Lots 5 and 6, of Block 161, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, and beginning at the SW corner of Lot 6 of Block 161, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, thence run North along the West boundary of said Block 161 to the Northwest corner of Lot 4 of said Block 161; thence run West, along the Westerly extension of the North boundary line of said Lot 4, a distance of 50-feet to the East right-of-way (ROW) line of the former Florida East Coast Railway of North Park Street; thence run East, along said North ROW line, a distance of 50-feet to the point of beginning, lying in Section 16, Township 37 South, Range 35 East, and being a part of that certain 50-foot strip of land designated as "Reserved" on the plat of Okeechobee, Plat Book 5, Page 5 Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage. Code Officer Smith testified the property is in violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage for the roof and exterior walls needing maintenance and cleaning. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) regular mail on March 17, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 22, 2021, who was advised on what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 25, 2021, who stated he was working with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting to pressure wash the roof and paint the building. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing (SOV/NOH) was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Joseph Perretta on July 8, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 8, 2021 who was advised that the painting needed to be completed and the windows uncovered along Park Street. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 27, 2021, who stated that the same company would be pressure washing the exterior of the building next week and painting it the week after. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on August 5, 2021, who stated that the building had been pressure washed and should be painted next week. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the exterior of the building still needed to be painted. However, the property owner has made progress by pressure washing the building and roof and painting the roof. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received on September 9, 2021, the signature was not legible October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 1 of 3 59 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED A. CONTINUED: The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021 and October 7, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on October 7, 2021 who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and how long he had to correct the violations before a fine was imposed. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a $50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210701012 to be in violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls, 304.7 Roof and drainage and imposed a fine of $50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. B. Case No. 210421006; Jose and Maria Cisneros, 608 SE 10th Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 8, 9, and 12 of Block 12, WRIGHT'S FIRST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 13, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property and 30-43 Public nuisance. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisance for large piles of debris and an unsecured building that all the windows are broken out of, and no front door. Correction, the property is not a repeat violator. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on April 21, 2021, for the June 8, 2021, Hearing. The noticed was received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Cisneros on May 5, 2021, who stated the debris had been put out to the road for Waste Management to pick up and the building would be demolished as soon as he had the permit to do so. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 1, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Jose Cisneros on July 6, 2021. The property was inspected on August 4, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the building remains unsecured, no door and broken out windows. However, the property owner has made progress by mowing the grass and removing the yard debris. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the building remains unsecured, no door and broken out windows. However, the property owner has made progress by mowing the grass and removing the yard debris. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received by JMC on September 27, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021 and October 7, 2021. The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a $50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210421006 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisances and imposed a fine of $25.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. VI. NEW CASES A. Case No. 210428014; Elizabeth J. Carter (Smitty's Glass and Mirror), 117 Southwest 5tn Avenue [Legal Description: The South 80.75-feet of Lots 7 and 8 of Block 166, TOWN OF OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 10, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Code Officer Smith reported that the property came into compliance October 7, 2021. No action on this matter was requested but was noted for the record to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, 30- 44 General cleaning and beautification. B. Case No. 210125009; Barry A. and Denise M. Parow, 101 Southwest 11 th Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 11, 12, 13, and 14 of Block 4, SOUTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 2, Page 7, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 2 of 3 �1 VI. NEW CASES B. CONTINUED: Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for inoperable vehicles and car parts all over the yard and carport. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on January 25, 2021. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 15, 2021, for the April 13, 2021, Hearing. The City has not received the certified return receipt back as of this Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mrs. Denise Parow on March 25, 2021, who stated that they will be cleaning up the yard and removing the vehicles next week. The property was inspected on April 5, 2021, April 27, 2021, and July 1, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. However, the property owner has made progress by removing the large pile of debris and the inoperable vehicles. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. It was returned unclaimed on July 28, 2021. The property was posted on July 27, 2021, with a Notice to Appear for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Samantha Parow on July 27, 2021, who stated that they received the posting in the yard and will be cleaning/organizing the carport. Code Officer Smith inspected the property on August 4, 2021 and reported it to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow on August 6, 2021, who stated they are still cleaning up the carport, but need more time. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the carport remains uncleaned/unorganized. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received by Russell Parow on September 8, 2021. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Barry Parow on September 8, 2021, who stated they received the notice, and are still working on cleaning and organizing the carport. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow on September 29, 2021, who stated that the property was in compliance and requested an inspection be completed on September 30, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 30, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Parow, who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and the property would be reinspected on October 5, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on October 5, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with the resident, who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210125009 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of $25.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. VII. ADJOURN MEETING There being no further business to come before the Special Ma ' trate, t Hearin was adjourned at 6:41 P.M. oger Azcona, Special gistrate AT EST: � Christina Curl Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. City Clerk media are for the sole purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk. October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 3 of 3 ,`�y.OF•�kFFCy 0 ti _ + m G �� JQ � A jn` �.. CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT OCTOBER 12, 2021, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING DRAFT OFFICIAL MINUTES I. CALL TO ORDER Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on Tuesday, October 12, 2021, at 6:01 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southeast 3�d Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special Magistrate Azcona. II. ATTENDANCE Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl called the roll. Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire, Police Lieutenant Justin Bernst and Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith were present. � I1�/ CHANGES TO AGENDA Special Magistrate Azcona asked whether there were any agenda items to be added, deferred, or withdrawn; there were none. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the September 14, 2021, Hearing minutes. B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered an Oath to: Code Officers Smith and Curl; all affirmed. Code Officer Smith stated for the record all events regarding the Cases to be discussed occurred within the corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee. The Officer's notes, testimony, photographs, and support documents were all entered as part of the official record. V. CONTINUED CASES A. Case No. 210701012; Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), 710 West North Park Street [Legal Description: The West 50-feet of Lots 5 and 6, of Block 161, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, and beginning at the SW corner of Lot 6 of Block 161, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, thence run North along the West boundary of said Block 161 to the Northwest corner of Lot 4 of said Block 161; thence run West, along the Westerly extension of the North boundary line of said Lot 4, a distance of 50-feet to the East right-of-way (ROV� line of the former Florida East Coast Railway of North Park Street; thence run East, along said North ROW line, a distance of 50-feet to the point of beginning, lying in Section 16, Township 37 South, Range 35 East, and being a part of �;° that certain 50-foot strip of land designated as "Reserved" on the plat of Okeechobee, Plat Book 5, Page 5 Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage. Code Officer Smith testified the property is in violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage for the roof and exterior walls needing maintenance and cleaning. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) regular mail on March 17, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 22, 2021, who was advised on what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 25, 2021, who stated he was working with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting to pressure wash the roof and paint the building. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing (SOV/NOH) was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Joseph Perretta on July 8, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 8, 2021 who was advised that the painting needed to be completed and the windows uncovered along Park Street. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 27, 2021, who stated that the same company would be pressure washing the exterior of the building next week and painting it the week after. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on August 5, 2021, who stated that the building had been pressure washed and should be painted next week. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the exterior of the building still needed to be painted. However, the property owner has made progress by pressure washing the building and roof and painting the roof. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received on September 9, 2021, the signature was not legible DRAFT October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 1 of 3 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED A. CONTINUED: The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021 and October 7, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on October 7, 2021 who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and how long he had to correct the violations before a fine was imposed. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a $50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210701012 to be in violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls, 304.7 Roof and drainage and imposed a fine of $50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. B. Case No. 210421006; Jose and Maria Cisneros, 608 SE 10'h Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 8, 9, and 12 of Block 12, WRIGHT'S FIRST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 13, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property and 30-43 Public nuisance. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisance for large piles of debris and an unsecured building that all the windows are broken out of, and no front door. Correction, the property is not a repeat violator. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on April 21, 2021, for the June 8, 2021, Hearing. The noticed was received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Cisneros on May 5, 2021, who stated the debris had been put out to the road for Waste Management to pick up and the building would be demolished as soon as he had the permit to do so. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 1, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Jose Cisneros on July 6, 2021. The property was inspected on August 4, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the building remains unsecured, no door and broken out windows. However, the property owner has made progress by mowing the grass and removing the yard debris. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the building remains unsecured, no door and broken out windows. However, the property owner has made progress by mowing the grass and removing the yard debris. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received by JMC on September 27, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021 and October 7, 2021. �4 The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a $50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210421006 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisances and imposed a fine of $25.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. VI. NEW CASES A. Case No. 210428014; Elizabeth J. Carter (Smitty's Glass and Mirror), 117 Southwest 5tn Avenue [Legal Description: The South 80.75-feet of Lots 7 and 8 of Block 166, TOWN OF OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 10, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Code Officer Smith reported that the property came into compliance October 7, 2021. No action on this matter was requested but was noted for the re.cord to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, 30- 44 General cleaning and beautification. B. Case No. 210125009; Barry A. and Denise M. Parow, 101 Southwest 11 th Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 11, 12, 13, and 14 of Block 4, SOUTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 2, Page 7, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. DRAFT October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 2 of 3 VI. NEW CASES B. CONTINUED: Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for inoperable vehicles and car parts all over the yard and carport. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on January 25, 2021. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 15, 2021, for the April 13, 2021, Hearing. The City has not received the certified return receipt back as of this Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mrs. Denise Parow on March 25, 2021, who stated that they will be cleaning up the yard and removing the vehicles next week. The property was inspected on April 5, 2021, April 27, 2021, and July 1, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. However, the property owner has made progress by removing the large pile of debris and the inoperable vehicles. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. It was returned unclaimed on July 28, 2021. The property was posted on July 27, 2021, with a Notice to Appear for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Samantha Parow on July 27, 2021, who stated that they received the posting in the yard and will be cleaning/organizing the carport. Code Officer Smith inspected the property on August 4, 2021 and reported it to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow on August 6, 2021, who stated they are still cleaning up the carport, but need more time. The case was presented to the Special Magistrate on August 10, 2021; Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the carport remains uncleaned/unorganized. The Special Magistrate deferred the case to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on September 3, 2021 for the October 12tn Hearing. The notice was received by Russell Parow on September 8, 2021. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Barry Parow on September 8, 2021, who stated they received the notice, and are still working on cleaning and organizing the carport. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 20, 2021. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow on September 29, 2021, who stated that the property was in compliance and requested an inspection be completed on September 30, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on September 30, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Parow, who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and the property would be reinspected on October 5, 2021. The property was inspected and found to be non-compliant on October 5, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with the resident, who was advised what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of this Hearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. .�� 210125009 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 .h., Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification and imposed a fine of $25.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. VII. ADJOURN MEETING There being no further business to come before the Special Magistrate, the Hearing was adjourned at 6:41 P.M. ATTEST: Christina Curl Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. City Clerk media are for the sole purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk. DRAFT October 12, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 3 of 3 � � NE�IiSMEDI�I INC. US�1 �o-ra-a�rnui�e �� Lake Okeechobee News 107 SW 17th Street, Suite D Okeechobee, Florida 34974 863-763-3134 STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF OKEECHOBEE Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Katrina Elsken Muros, who on oath says she is the Publisher of the Lake Okeechobee News, a weelcly Newspaper published in Okeechobee County:``��lorida, that the attached copy of an advertisement being a ii` k ti a�� . a�. '� '? r"•."� `�A a� :�� .= y �. in the matter of �,��'��__ �-; .`t�'�, LL' �.-°�•E ��-�a�'��;. •..""•• • :. N�� ., � � ,. . ..� i: "J� _4!��,d =�..: � �,� \,�`�;� _.3'�,`�``= i� ��a��. �� = tT'�-�i�—ti`�, E:•' 4_ in the 19th Judicial Dist c-�'i t of the Circuit Court of Okee�hobee County, Florida, was published in said newspaper in the issues of � �.%� �53 `a. ..,/ �'�' � Affiant further says that the said Lake Okeechobee News is a newspaper published at Okeechobee, in said Olceechobee County, Plorida, and that said newspaper has heretofore been published continuously in said Okeechobee County, Florida each week and has been entered as second class mail matter at the post office in Okeechobee, in said Okeechobee County, Florida, for a period of one year next preceding the first publication of the attached copy of advertisement, and affiant further says that she has neither paid nor promised any person, firm or corporation any discount, rebate, commission or refund for the purpose of securing this adverti ement for publication in the said newspaper. , _ �� ',�2-.�--�� Katrina Elsken Muros Sworn to and subscribed before me by means of ...gli'ysical presence or _ online notariz�tion, this � k��"dayof� ��ii=��_i�:, ,,_, '"�•�V AD Notary Public, State of Florida at Large .�. �. , . - — e ,-,,, . � �., i \ � ..4:',ffiti" _ ; y,:aw�:e<A�;., JAN�T SUE hAADRAY :*`, i"�,.. MY COMhl(SSIOi�i # f�H 129146 ="'•c-��•'�-' FXPIFZES: May'12, 2025 ;,:.��^ •, "'•%:Y,} F;��'� Bonded l'hru IJotary Put�lic Undarrrriters �ox+.2;_sa.-._'^ _ ..r.;^'= :�: • ^acs:� � cmoFo�oa}� I rua�c rio�ricE CODE ENPDR�MENTSPECdAL MAC�SfRA7E HEARING NOTI� S HQtEBY QVF1V Ue[ tl7eGry of M�� de Er�a¢'' m�t Sp� p1agNra� vrH Vmrdu� a pubSc haviiq on Oanber 17. 2D71, 6 PM, or as s�on tl�ft^_r � pc�b!e, at Cfly Ha6 55 SE 3(d Ave. Rm Z00, � �� a� �� , gv� la�d� pror ro the rteeLr�9 fiom me v.etsi� li�s/,n.,•nv.ayc�of�si,oh� , �Na9�i�{ode£"(orm rtrntMml. eE Auv15ID mat slmuu yvu mard ro 9io.v arry doarrrn4 PIQure. `A�O, or Derts h� ihe Spe� P'1a9� in s�ppat w oPP�tion m arN �in on the a�cnd�, a mp/ of tlie doarrad, p�w�e, vid�.v, or �n m�6 be qrnk� to tlie � CO[k Enfu�i�ent Sea�ry,for fhe, ,Gly''., rem�ds.lWY PERSON DEQo- � mG To Af4''etu. arN riemun rrwe U/?ix Sf',�I Nb9�� '�'�'� tn arry r�itr�mrdrk�7 at U�'s rr�tiru7 w6 nead ro er��e a �2rbathn remid � of tlie promedn9 5 rtade and tlte remid 6xiucks ttie �tirrnrN �d evider�'. upon whidi the app�31 vali 6e b�d in a�rdarioe wdh the Artr.�ioru wAh � o��s a�r. ��u, a�au;� r�� i a�rmooda��, ro w�- 6�pdYe il U16P��9�loU�d CDf1tdCCtl7EC.Od2 FII(INOLYfIg7C01�R' Yl pE'RNI a o� BCii-7G3�'�02, Fia�nng Imp�imd: Fioiida Refay 7-1-1 no @�r tlian four bua� day��' Prbr m P��9� ONE Oii MORE a'fY OF OI�106EE GOt1Nm MEMBE7tS MAY BE IId A7"fENDAN� AT TFIIS MEEiII'!G. THL+ NUR� IS POSiID iU MEEf STAiE PUBLIC NOTi� RCi2UIItFldFNISAND 9UNSHIfJE lA1NS BY � %��a, SPeda� �'ta9isira� _..... .. /. � ± ic._ �� -r... ., o.__..'„_ ' �' .,t�i:, u� _ "..� ' 1�y., .,..h l4 ��: � . •�t. •'y-...r`� j��°" :'O. �� ,��! - -, ��,;-° � ` .. '� , I' �' �„ r . "s'. � i �: ,,., �' � f' ,. �� ,�`�,:, F,4 � � ;,nN „�� /�r'' � �-.� .. . � ; . .. �'9��; Ahti.� �� ,, _ ,, ..: . , . : .: ,.�� •--•...,„,,d PU BLIC NOTICE �c�� _7 �':r'J'�_t�� _�� .] � ��_��.�J�� \.�. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Special Magistrate will conduct a public hearing on Tuesday, October 12, 2021, at 6:00 PM, or as soon thereafter as possible at City Hall, 55 SE 3ra Avenue, Council Chambers, Rm 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The public is invited to attend and be heard on all matters. Copies of the agenda will be available at the Hearing or may be viewed/downloaded prior to the Hearing from the website https://www.cityofokeechobee.com/Agenda Minutes-Code-nforcement.html. BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records. ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to ensure a verbatim record of the proceeding is made and the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Code Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to proceeding. O�VE �R �d�RE C��"`f O� OKEE��O�EE COIJ�V�I� NIEIVl�EF�S Nl�� E IN ATTENDANCE AT THIS MEETING. THIS NOTICE IS POSTED TO MEET STATE PUBLIC NOTICE REQUIREMENTS AND SUNSHINE LAW�a By: Roger Azcona, Special Magistrate Posted : 9/24/21-BJ CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT OCTOBER 12, 2021 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING SS SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�oR��A 34974 HANDWRITTEN MINUTES — CHRISTINA CURL I. CALL TO ORDER A. Special Magistrate Azcona called the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate Hearing to order on Tuesday October 12, 2021, at 6:01 P.M. in the City Council Chambers, located at 55 Southwest 3rd Avenue, Room 200, Okeechobee, Florida. The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Special Magistrate Azcona. II. ATTENDANCE Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire City Attorney Greg Hyden Police Lieutenant Justin Bernst Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl Present X X X X Absent X_ III. CHANGES TO AGENDA A. Requests for the addition, deferral, or withdrawal of agenda items. RA- any addition, deferral or withdrawal of agenda items AS- There are none IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH A. Special Magistrate Azcona approved the September 14, 2021 Hearing Minutes. B. This being a Quasi-Judicial proceeding, Special Magistrate Azcona collectively administered an of Oath to Code Officer Anthony Smith and Christina Curl. Code Officer Smith advised all events occurred within the corporate limits of the City of Okeechobee. The Officer's notes, testimony, photographs, and support documents were all entered as part of the official record. V. CONTINUED CASES A. Case Number 210701012; Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), 710 Northwest Park Street, Violation of International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls, 304.7 Roof and drainage (Exhibit 1). AS- Violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls, 304.7 Roof and drainage, the exterior of the building and the roof needs maintenance and cleaning. Respondent is not a repeat violator. Respondent was first notified on March 17, 2021 via Courtesy Card. The City also communicated with the respondent on March 22, 2021 Officer Smith spoke with the property owner J. Perretta, he was advised on what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance. On March 25, 2021 Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta, who stated that he is working with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting and that they will be pressure washing the roof and painting the building. On March 31, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, however progress had been made. On May 5, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On July 1, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On July 2, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed certified return receipt for the August 10th Hearing, received by Joseph Perretta on July 8, 2021. On July 8, 2021, Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Perretta, he was advised that he needed to complete the painting of the exterior of the building and to uncover the windows on Park Street. On July 27, 2021 Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Perretta, he advised that the same company Page 1 of 9 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED A. Case Number 210701012 would be coming to power wash the building next week and paint it the week after. On August 4, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On August 5, 2021, Asst. Code Officer Curl received a call from Mr. Perretta, he advised that the building had been power washed and should be painted within the next week. On August 10, 2021, Case presented to the Special Magistrate, deferred to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. On September 3, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received on September 9, 2021, the signature was not legible. On September 20, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, the painting on the building has been started but not completed. On September 28, 2021, Code Officer Smith received a phone call from Mr. Perretta advising that he needs two more weeks to complete the work on the property. On September 29, 2021, Code Officer Smith called Mr. Perretta to advise him that the work needed to be completed before October 8th. On October 7, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, needs to finish painting the building and remove the vegetation from the roofline. To comply with the City Ordinances, the property owner needs to finish painting the exterior of the building and remove the vegetation from the roofline. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Also, I spoke with him after that as well, he has made a lot of progress he just has a little more painting to do to bring the property into compliance before the 21 days. RA-I have few questions Mr. Smith, pictures you have taken in the exhibits and shown on the screen is this an accurate representation based on the dates in the photos? AS-yes RA- it appears you have taken photos in March, May 5, 2021 and even on July 1, 2021 all the way through August 4, 2021 and even into September 20, 2021 was there any compliance AS- he has made a lot of progress as you can see it started green and he has changed the color to a blue RA- Ah, I didn't realize that AS- yes, he changed the color to a blue and the last thing he has to do as you can see in the last few pictures up on the roofline, he has a lot of vegetation growing out the roof RA-yes AS- I asked him to get rid of that and to paint the strips up over the overhang that he did not paint yet, he said he was going to get to that he just hasn't been able to get to that yet that is what needs to be done to bring it into compliance RA- Ok, I see the wooden part so not quite in compliance the painting needs to be finished and the vegetation on the roofline AS- right RA- also there is some rust on the roof it looks like AS- yes RA- what about the issues on the side of the building is their mold on the building, is that part of the issues? AS- the mold? RA-yes, there looks like there is some dark spots at the base of the building, where those addressed? AS- ok, I see what you are talking about, it is a very old building with wood slats and there are some spaces I don't think that is really mold it is just spaces in the wooden slats RA- Ok, based on the exhibits and the testimony of the certified Code Enforcement Officer in this case of the City of Okeechobee vs Joseph Perretta, Case Number 210701012 I will find the allegations based on the City Code Sec 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage there are noticeable violations in here, there is factual basis for these allegations from the City Page 2 of 9 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED A. Case Number 210701012 as testified to by the Certified Code Enforcement Officer I can see that the pictures here do show the issues that is a concern to the City for the beautification and proper maintenance to the building and I also see that the respondent has clearly been serviced and due process has been satisfied, he has signed for two certified mail receipts and there is no allegations that he has not received the notice and he has communicated efficiently with the Certified Code Enforcement Officer Mr. Smith. I will find in this case there is a violation of those two sections and the City's recommendation is reasonable I will recommend a fine $50.00 to begin 21 days after the date of this hearing unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date also the respondent will be charged a$50.00 administration fee should the violation continue after 21 days. Anything else on this one Mr. Smith? AS-no RA- Mrs. Curl anything else CC-no GR- where is that? RA- it is right there on 70 AS-it is on 70 W CC- by Kahootz across from the Country Cooler GR- oh ok AS-across from the auto parts store RA- I think they sale prosthetics in there, right? AS-yes RA- I have been there before, not sure what I was looking for, but it is an old building, it has been there for a while. AS- yes, very old building RA- ok well hopefully he will do a little painting and fix the roof AS- he is very proud of his roof RA- ok so 21 days or $50.00 bucks a day so hopefully that will get him into compliance, but this has been since March, you have been more than reasonable. AS-yes RA- they have had more than a reasonable amount of time to comply, but they are not a repeat violator. Ok let's move on. B. Case Number 210421006; Jose and Maria Cisneros, 608 Southeast 10th Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisances (Exhibit 2). AS- Violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisance for large piles of debris and unsecured building, all windows broken out, no front door. Respondent is a repeat violator on June 1, 2020, Violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. I apologize he is not a repeat violator Respondent was first notified on April 21, 2021 via Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing, received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. The City also communicated with the respondent on May 5, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On May 5, 2021, received a call from Jose Cisneros, the property owner, they are working on getting all the debris out to the road for Waste Management to pick up and will be demolishing the building as soon as they have a permit to do so. On June 9, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On July 1, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed certified return receipt for the August 10tn Hearing due to the June Hearing being cancelled due to illness, received by Jose Cisneros on July 6, 2021. On July 19, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On August 4, 2021, Inspected the property, still non-compliant, however the grass had been cut, and the yard debris removed. The building still needs to be secured. On August 10, 2021, Case presented Page 3 of 9 V. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED B. Case Number 210421006 to the Special Magistrate, case deferred to allow more time for the property owner to come into full compliance as progress has been made. On September 3, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received by JMC on September 27, 2021. On September 20, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, the building still needs to be secured. On October 7, 2021, inspected the property, still non- compliant, the house has been demolished, but all the debris needs to be removed. To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to finish removing all the debris left over from the demolition of the building. The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. RA-in the case of City of Okeechobee vs Jose and Maria Cisneros, Case Number 210421006 allegations in this case is Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisance for unsecured building all windows broken out, no front door, obliviously no one is living there Mr. Smith. AS- no RA- so just in disrepair? AS-yes in disrepair, in real bad shape and needed to be taken down RA- so you cited him back on May 5, 2021 so it doesn't look like there was much done to the building in the pictures, you said the eventually tore it down. AS-yes, they demolished it, tore it down RA-so there is no more debris there AS- yes, there is a lot of debris still there that is why we are recommending the fine, so they will continue to clean it up RA-ok AS- you can see in the later pictures that there are big piles of debris all the bricks and a lot of windows leaned up against one of the trees RA- ok I see it is a very old building no one living there a lot of vegetation not maintained fence is broken In this case I see that there is more than sufficient factual basis for the allegations on the behalf of the City of Okeechobee and the respondent in this case due process has been satisfied that respondent has been noticed twice and properly noticed for this hearing and decided not to appear today. I will find the respondent in violation of both allegations by the City for Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisance even though some progress has been made according to the Certified Code Enforcement Officer the property is still not in compliance and the City is requesting that a fine to begin today? AS- no, 21 days RA- 21 days, ok so that is what we will do $25.00 fine 21 days after today's hearing AS-yes RA- or 21 days after they have been noticed of today's hearing or 21 days from today? AS-yes RA- so 21 days from today? AS-yes RA-21 days from today together with a$50.00 administrative fee for the City's investigation. Anything else Mr. Smith AS- no RA- anything else Mrs. Curl CC- no RA- ok, next case Page 4 of 9 VI. NEW CASES A. Case Number 210428014; Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror), 117 Southwest 5tn Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 3). AS- Violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for disabled/untagged trucks and boat, trash overflowing dumpster, junk and debris on property. Respondent is not a repeat violator. Respondent was first notified on April 28, 2021 via Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing, received by KJ-184. The City also communicated with the respondent on May 10, 2021, Code Officer Smith spoke with Kevin Carter the son of the property owner, explained violations. On May 12, 2021, Email communication with the property owner Ray Carter. On May 17, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, spoke with tenant, explained violations, the tenant asked for more time. On June 8, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On June 9, 2021, Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Carter to advise that the tenants have made no progress from the last inspection. On June 29, 2021, Code Officer Smith spoke with tenants, inspected the property, still non-compliant, however progress had been made on cleaning up the property. On August 11, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, disabled vehicles remain, and the property is filled with junk/debris. On September 3, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received by Stacy Carre/COVID-19 on September 9, 2021. On September 20, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On September 30, 2021, Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Moore and explained what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and that the property would be inspected on October 4, 2021. On October 4, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant as the disabled vehicles remain. Received an email from Mr. Moore asking for more time, he was advised that the property would be inspected on October 7, 2021. On October 6, 2021, Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Carter, Code Officer Smith explained to him that Mr. Moore was getting the property back into compliance and that he was supposed to have the property in compliance by tomorrow and I would be inspecting the property tomorrow. He advised me that he would call me to make sure the property was in compliance. On October 7, 2021, Inspected the property, still non-compliant RA- ok, alright AS- hold on, I'm sorry RA- what is the City asking for? AS- he came into compliance, correct me if I am wrong Mrs. Curl, I am reading that it is saying it is still not in compliance to and about me speaking with Mr. Moore about removing the disabled vehicles CC- yes, if you read on down, it states that the property was reinspected and found to be in compliance. AS- ok I see now, oh yes, he is still not in compliance, spoke with Mr. Moore about removing the disabled vehicles from the property he advised that he could have them removed from the property by the end of the day. Reinspected the property, found to be in compliance on October 7, 2021. RA- Mr. Smith I am looking at exhibit three the picture's way in the back on October 7, 2021. I see the boat is gone, the disabled vehicle is gone, and everything seems to be in compliance. AS- right, they did come into compliance RA-So, they did come into compliance. AS-yes, I reinspected the property on October 7, 2021, I went that morning and inspected it was still not in compliance, I was asked to come back later in the day, when I went back the property was in compliance RA- so is the City asking for anything at this point. AS- no, the City recommends no action on this matter Page 5 of 9 VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED A. Case Number 210428014 RA- are they asking for it to be noted for the record to have been in violation then they came into compliance AS- yes, but request it be noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. RA- so they can become a repeat violator if they do it again AS-yes RA Alright in the case of the City of Okeechobee vs Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror), Case Number 210428014 I will find that in this case based on the testimony and the exhibits presented by the certified Code Enforcement Officer that on or about May 10, 2021 and all the way through October 7, 2021 the respondent in this case was in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles for having disabled vehicles on the property, 30- 43 Public nuisance for having trash overflowing the dumpster and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for having junk and debris on the property. I see based on the evidence presented by the certified Code Enforcement Officer, the pictures presented having a disabled vehicle without a tag there is also a boat that appears it is not being used as there is a lot of stuff on top of it and there is another SUV that looks like it is in disrepair with probably an old tag on there, there is a lot of vegetation, trash and debris all over the place so there is sufficient factual basis for finding a violation in this case and even though the property has come into compliance and found to be in compliance by the certified Code Enforcement Officer it will be noted that the respondent was in violation until October 7, 2021 so any events in the future they will be classified as repeat violator. So, under the circumstance I will follow the recommendation of the City of no further action on this matter as the property has come into compliance AS-yes RA-anything further from the City? AS-no RA- Mrs. Curl CC-no RA-alright sounds good, next case. B. Case Number 210125009; Barry and Denise Parow, 101 Southwest 11t" Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 4). AS- Violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for inoperable vehicles and car parts all over the yard. The respondent is not a repeat violator. The respondent was first notified on January 25, 2021 via Courtesy Card. The City also communicated with the respondent on March4, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On March 15, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return receipt, we have not received anything back. On March 25, 2021, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow, she advised that they will be working on the yard and removing the vehicles, but they would need more time as her husband is going through cancer treatments. On April 5, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, however progress has been made. On April 27, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On July 1, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant. On July 2, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing, mailed via USPS certified return receipt, returned unclaimed on July 28, 2021. On July 27, 2021, posted property with Notice to Appear. On July 27, 2021, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Samantha Parow, she advised they received the posting in the yard, and they will be working on cleaning up the carport. On August 4, 2021, inspected the property, still non- compliant. On August 6, 2021, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow, she advised Page 6 of 9 VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED B. Case Number 210125009 they are still working on the carport but still need more time. On August 10, 2021, Case presented to the Special Magistrate, deferred to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. On September 3, 2021, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return receipt, received by Russell Parow on September 8, 2021. On September 8, 2021, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Barry Parow, he advised that they received the notice for the Hearing, and they are still working on getting the carport cleaned and organized. On September 20, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, however they are making progress on getting the carport cleaned up. On September 29, 2021. Asst. Code Officer Curl received a call from Denise Parow advising the property is in compliance and would like it inspected tomorrow. On September 30, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, spoke with Mr. Parow and explained what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and that the property would be reinspected on October 5, 2021. On October 5, 2021, inspected the property, still non-compliant, spoke with resident and explained again what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance. To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean and organize the carport. The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. RA-I have a few questions on the photos that were submitted by the City in this case I see the violations alleged here is Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification the allegations were car parts all over the yard and inoperable vehicle so looking at, I do find that the respondents in this case have received due process and you have been communicating with them and they are aware of the alleged violations by the City and when I look at the photos in this case I can see the factual basis especially in regards to the exhibit dated January 20, 2021 I can see the pieces of cars in the yard, it looks like there is an inoperable vehicle in the picture taken on January 20, 2021 and again on March 4, 2021 in the colored photos I can see that there is a part of a door together sitting on top of a trailer with a steering wheel on top of it which is certainly in the parameters of the alleged violations. On the picture taken on April 27, 2021 at 8:57 am, I can see that there is a dolly in there and across the fence there is some miscellaneous items in there. Where they already there Mr. Smith or was that after? AS- are you talking about stuff up on the car port? RA- no, this picture with the dolly in it AS-you said the photo from April, let me look at that photo RA- if it is just personal effects just been placed as it does not look like trash or inoperable vehicle parts, they just don't look like vehicle parts to me, but it could just be some personal effects AS- ok RA-so that picture I am not sure, unless you can tell me how that violates but with regards to the picture on July 1, 2021, I am looking at a photo of the yard and a black SUV on the left, this is on the July 1, 2021 picture taken at 12:04 pm that vehicle on the left is this the one you alleging that is an inoperable vehicle? AS- no, the one at the bottom, see the one at the bottom on the same date RA-yes, AS- that vehicle right there is the inoperable vehicle RA- oh, you mean the white one in the back. AS- yes RA-alright I see that, because the one in front AS-no, not that one Page 7 of 9 VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED B. Case Number 210125009 RA-ok then I do not find factual basis on the picture above but I do find factual basis based on the vehicle in the back as that one appears to be inoperable sitting in the back and there is a lot of debris sitting right in front of it, it looks like a gas tank or something and a trailer with a lot of stuff, that would seem to satisfy the allegations of that code, I see that you also posted a Notice to Appear, that is very good to post a notice and on the picture taken on August 4, 2021 there is a lot of stuff under the roof probably personal effects, it might not be junk, but it needs to be kept orderly AS- yes RA- the trailer it looks �ike metal stuff on there could be car parts I would say and wood leaning in the back. AS-yes, a wood fence RA-yes, they need to clean that part up and then the last photos taken on September 20, 2021 there might have been some slight progress. AS-yes, on the side the first picture of the wood pile, they have cleaned up on the side, I told them that is great they are starting to bring it into compliance, however on the carport itself they had did very little. RA- yes, on the picture on September 30, 2021 the gentleman is working on his vehicle inside the porch it looks like he has a lot of tools in the shed together with his zero-turn mower. AS- yeah, I told him that the one side really wasn't that bad RA- is there any violation? I do see any car parts too much in here AS- there is a car engine back in the back believe it or not, and the white truck the disabled vehicle is still there in the back RA- oh the truck is still back there and the picture below that also dated September 30, 2021 10:03 am the trailer is still there and still seeing some stuff on it, are you alleging that would be part of the violation AS- yes because they had cleaned all that away, that was completely clean right there, then they put another trailer and just started putting stuff on top of it again. RA- on the next picture, which is the picture of the truck in the back, and you are saying that is an inoperable vehicle. AS-yes, it is RA- and the tag is not current AS- right RA-that would satisfy the violation the picture of the back and the picture of the shed, I am examining this picture other than the tire in there, there are some tools in there, which seem to be ok, some parts have gotten a little better but there is still an inoperable vehicle and some stuff on the property still that should not be there as far as it is debris and trash. You are asking for $25.00 per day 21 days after Mr. Smith for the City. AS- yes RA- Alright I will find in the Case of the City of Okeechobee vs. Barry and Denise Parow, Case Number 210125009 I find that the respondents in this case based on the exhibits presented by the certified Code Enforcement Officer and his testimony that the respondents in this case Barry and Denise Parow are in violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-41 for having a disabled vehicle from March 4, 2021 all the way through October 5, 2021 that is an inoperable vehicle on the property that has not been address and also Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification by having car parts and debris all over the yard even though we can see in some of the pictures they have be remediated there is still parts of the property where debris and trash is still being kept on the property, practically the inoperable vehicle the white truck with tires in the back and car parts, the shed is cleaned some but I don't know what the condition of the tire on the right is or how long it's been there but we can see from the yard that there is still a trailer with debris on top of it and I will agree with the certified Code Officer Page 8 of 9 VI. NEW CASES CONTINUED B. Case Number 210125009 that looks to be debris and that satisfies the requirements and there seems to be a violation in this case I'll agree to that and the respondents in this case have been properly served with due process in regard to the compliant in this case and given substantial amount of time to come into compliance. I will find the City's recommendation in this case is $25.00 per day 21 days after the date of this Hearing the fine will be assessed together with a$50.00 administrative fee. Are you requesting anything other than that Mr. Smith? AS- no I am not RA- Mrs. Curl anything else CC-no VII. ADJOURN MEETING There being no further business to come before the Special Magistrate, the Hearing was adjourned at 6:41 P.M. BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video, or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records. ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to ensure a verbatim record of the proceeding is made and the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Code Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to proceeding. Page 9 of 9 � � CITY OF OKEECHOBEE CODE ENFORCEMENT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING 55 SOUTHEAST THIRD AVENUE, OKEECHOBEE, F�ort�oA 34974 OFFICIAL AGENDA OCTOBER 12, 2021 6:00 P.M. I. CALL TO ORDER A. Pledge of Allegiance II. ATTENDANCE Special Magistrate Roger Azcona, Esquire City Attorney Greg Hyden Police Lieutenant Justin Bernst Code Enforcement Officer Anthony Smith Assistant Code Enforcement Officer Christina Curl III. CHANGES TO AGENDA A. Requests for the addition, deferral, or withdrawal of agenda items. IV. APPROVAL OF MINUTES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH A. Approval of Minutes-September 14, 2021. B. Administration of Oath-anyone giving testimony is required to be sworn in. V. CONTINUED CASES A. Case Number 210701012; Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), 710 Northwest Park Street, Violation of International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls, 304.7 Roof and drainage (Exhibit 1). B. Case Number 210421006; Jose and Maria Cisneros, 608 Southeast 10th Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property, 30-43 Public nuisances (Exhibit 2). VI. NEW CASES A. Case Number 210428014; Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror), 117 Southwest 5th Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 3). B. Case Number 210125009; Barry and Denise Parow, 101 Southwest 11 t'' Avenue, Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-44 General cleaning and beautification (Exhibit 4). VII. ADJOURN MEETING BE ADVISED that should you intend to show any document, picture, video, or items to the Special Magistrate in support or opposition to any item on the agenda, a copy of the document, picture, video, or item must be provided to the Code Enforcement Secretary for the City's records. ANY PERSON DECIDING TO APPEAL any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this meeting will need to ensure a verbatim record of the proceeding is made and the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. In accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, persons with disabilities needing special accommodation to participate in this proceeding should contact the Code Enforcement Office in person or call 863-763-9802, Hearing Impaired: Florida Relay 7-1-1 no later than four business days prior to proceeding. Page 1 of 1 Exhibit 1 V. A.-Exhibit #1 Case #210701012 Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace) Exhibit 1 Code Enforcement Hearinq October 12, 2021 Case Name � Number: Photos: See attached Is_respondent a Repeat Violator? No Summarv: • Respondent was first notified on March 17, 2021 via Courtesy Card. • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of event Type of event Date Received received b March 22, Officer Smith spoke with property owner J. Perretta, he was advised what 2021 needed to be done to brin the ro e into com liance. March 25, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta who stated that he is working 2021 with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting. They will be pressure washin the roof and aintin the buildin March 31, Inspected property, still non-compliant, however progress has been made 2021 May 5, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant. July 1, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant. July 2, 2021 Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed certified return receipt for the July 8, Joseph Au ust 10t" Hearin 2021 Perretta July 8, 2021 Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Perretta, he was advised that he needed to complete the painting of the exterior of the building and to uncover the windows on Park Street July 27, 2021 Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Perretta, he advised that the same company would be coming to power wash the building next week and paint it the week after. August 4, Inspected property, still non-compliant. 2021 August 5, Asst. Code Officer Curl received a call from Mr. Perretta, he advised that the 2021 buildin had been ower washed and should be ainted within the next week. August 10, Case presented to the Special Magistrate, deferred to allow the property 2021 owner more time to come into full com liance as ro ress has been made. September 3, Statement of ViolationlNotice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return September Signature 2021 recei t 9, 2021 not le ible. September Inspected property, still non-compliant, painting of the building has been 20, 2021 started but not com leted. September Code Officer Smith received a phone call from Mr. Perretta advising that he 28, 2021 needs two more weeks to com lete the work on his ro e September Code Officer Smith called Mr. Perretta to advise him that the work needed to 29, 2021 be com leted before October 8t'' October 7, Inspected property, still non-compliant, needs to finish the painting on the 2021 buildin and remove the ve etation from the roofline. PAGE 1 OF 2 Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), Case #210701012 Exhibit 1 • To comply with the City ordinances, the properly owner needs to finish painting the exterior of the building and remove the vegetation from the roof line. Citv Recommendation: The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Chronology attached PAGE20F2 Exhibit 1 Case # 210701012, Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs & Brace) Date Event/Document March 17, 2021 Property Owner- Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs & Brace) Address- 510 SW Port St Lucie Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL. 34953 Site Address- 710 NW Park St, Okeechobee, FL. 34974 Violation of IPMC CH 3 Sec 304.6 Exterior walls & 304.7 Roof and drainage. Exterior of the building and roof needs maintenance and cleaning. Photos in file. March 17, 2021 Courtesy Card sent given 14 days to correct violation. March 22, 2021 Code Officer Smith spoke with property owner (J. Perretta) who asked what he needed to do to get the property in compliance. Advised him to pressure wash the roof and some painting to the exterior. March 25, 2021 Assistant Code Officer Curl received a call from Joseph Perretta who stated that he is working with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting. They will be pressure washing the roof tomorrow and painting this weekend weather permitting. March 31, 2021 Inspected the property: property in progress of coming into compliance. Photos in file. May 5, 2021 Inspected the property: No progress made since last inspection. Building in need of painting, the boards pull off the windows. July 1, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, photos in file. No change from last inspection. July 2, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed USPS certified return receipt for the August 10tn Hearing. Received on July 8, 2021, signed by Joseph Perretta. July 8, 2021 Received a call from Joseph Perretta, advised him that he need to complete the painting of the outside of the building and to uncover the window on Park St. July 27, 2021 Received a call from Joseph Perretta, he advised me (A. Smith) that had a company coming to power wash the building next week and that a painting company to come and paint the building the week after. August 4, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, photos in file. August 5, 2021 Officer Curl received a call from Joseph Perretta, stating that the building has been power washed and should be painted within the next week. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 1 Case # 210701012, Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs & Brace) Date Event/Document August 10, 2021 Case presented to the Special Magistrate; case deferred one more time to all the property owner more time to come into compliance. September 3, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the October 12tn Hearing. Given till October 1 St to correct violations. Received on September 9, 2021, signature not legible. September 20, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, continues to paint the building making progress. Photos in file. September 28, 2021 I Code Officer Smith received a phone call from Mr. Perretta advising that he needs 2 weeks to complete the work on his property. September 29, 2021 I Code Officer Smith called Mr. Perretta and advised that him that he needed to get work completed before the 8'h of October. October 7, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, have made great strides in bringing the property into compliance: painted the roof and 95% of the building, and took down the boards from the front windows. Just needs to finish painting the building and remove the vegetation from the roofline. Photos in the file. Spoke with Mr. Perretta and advised him what was needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and how much time he had to get it completed before a fine is imposed. Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 'i � �t� �� . , � �x. ; � i � � .. a �, t, �� ' � ' _�nv � � �� t � '� .y � ,�` � � '� �' �T� �i 1`- :, � �� ., . � ,,.:: .. , �- _ ��;;�F�.�ti.��#��,�,�� -_ , �, , , �, .� .� � ��t . ; �,; ;,� `��; - � - "�� ` . �` { , , � 0�� 0�� , `_� , . , , � j �,� ..� . .a -� txnibii 'i . _ �� k' t��, 0'`�'OOgr7�0�1� il � � �J� 8,� � �� # � � t -.f �. i , � � �� "' "' ` ry�� a�f. COASTAL LIMBS 6 BRACE -- . . . 3,.�:��;, y ,. ,..ci- �� .,�<r,. -�, 8 �. . .., � �9"" ($G:i� 35?-U079 ,,. .i�.._�. -- .._��w-��r � �,� �, . •� � . : / . ;� �:� . _ _ � � smaccrs,,x-.aH'. ��r �i �� :�,---. ; � ;a k'?�ii�r�"r" `'> . ,�� , �. . ��,�,'� :�� , �,D l-� . y� . � �� {r�.�,� i ,j��'�f ►�'�� f` �. � � . 1�� JIFf.i �� SY t:�� :�.:.... � a� � � . . F`LOW�A )UTAAi£! .. .. . _.. ._ ��,_ _ , __.... __ _ _.. ._ .�. ::_.�.: � . i �� : .: { f, � �► 0��0��0�� 3��1f� Exhibit 1 .� .} �� ,: „ Y .i" . ,... � � � � � � � � ' t t � = 1 f k � ` � t � � � t:�e.� O�r7�0�S0�ii �1 � a �� , �� .� � �� LX�iICJii 1 MK ' Y .:M� . .�.r.� _ �. 'als'- }'i � , � o• �� r l " �, ��^��,� . . � .. ^. ' .:t . .legc �E �:;�y: � � � . ,�; A � � .n �.�' � � .. E —�"+—..L._U v_ t., �4� � I' � s'��. , { '� �- , � ; � : !. � (8631 357.ry0 x:3 i ,. � 7 ,i . ; ; � '� j��: I � . � � . ��.� � � � � i, j f . �_�- � . �<_�*�;;�,�.. . . , R� �:�-:-:� ;� ,�.� r . ��-�� 07700i10�0�� i ��,.:�� ,:�� .,:, �.� , _ _ � .�,.,w.' . , . . ' ' , I wt' .. , _ .. . . . . . � � I .,.. . .,..,- . � : ^� � . .�. . . � : � ^`..._ ..w:..�.:�5►4w; �� - .:��.....:! Exhibit 1 �< � � 1�I+M!`""�'�y�"' ` . �-e-�«p:!"�•"�F•..�.�,��;��,a.r-�+�C: ift" � � i � � ' f _-- � ' �: � �..� �.. .a..,. +s... a.; +.cee�_ �° " � �• ��' � � , �,-�,,,..,a�.,,..- __ . .-»�'.'� � � � �:. 6 � �`AL � "'�`'•, � � i , �� .'�. '�. +u ,. w. =-----•-..___-.�.... ........_,__ .._,,.,,,,_..,_� ,'� � c;r.. �. . .._....__�,.,_.,,.._,,,�.�,._.._._ ' j' � , � ��__ O�lUJ�� 0�0�� i)� � i10 t �i ��x ��,�=„i„ ; x �� • . �. ,� � ., . , ��r�� .�� .��'' ' ,� . , ,�: M,�� .� .,� .,-a. -� -,. �.� �..� ..,�, ...,- .�. _ ,� ' ; --�-- "�i....�. . .!_ ...�. _�. .��..�. ...�.. _� _...t -�. -� ..,�, � ��.�'��e�°`.,.e�''""..�,�'""��.,�;�"`�:�' `' '` � __�__ _ '""' r �..�°''`�� "".��' � . .. � � _ ,. � . .._. � _ _ __ _ ._, �_... 1 _ � . _..t .�_ _ }..^� _ _. . �_. _{,. � - � >:=�w i ' l ..:. , :.��:� � : ��, . ,- ��:- yw L ��• & �, I;'• � ��>�. �;. . ?tr e. ��s � .,� , i:�. � � P�M!�A Exhibit 1 , �`; � �� ' . ��,: �r �; 1, l L'1�, � � „.».� , . . �I' \ . �_�:�..?rM'py r`1A `'. , k�.mN. � . x> ^4�n.NewwJpy��„r..r.V sa . {S�wlr;l: ' .: . ' �. 1 , � . w;�°'»:�,ia�, �a:�;Ylxd:: e� �..',a.6.+t,aw, . . ��u'h�tn.i..r� .. . 4"' . n. ,..�...,._. .r.r � �, �� , ..�____. y�„� �,';:; � �:�,�,�� ti, „ ,�.; + � „I � " , � �� ,�,,� F , � �, �k�"� x�'�,a :� . �id; ' yy �_wl '�s�i�°% S< �.''. i � ~�p �.•v, �...,-....,,.- ..,,;,,�6�'" �"q�A::Of" nt .�s', ..... „ �.4... -0I «s'^ �35 �i S. n.« �;�-. ,.� �o , � .._ �., . .. ' �� V�OV��O�� u(5� u� . � .. �� ,.. �� - � '� � `. , .. . � .. .. Y � ..'. :��i .; � .' . �'�' . . . ' � '' � '. � „ � Y.. . .� , � . �- � '� . ) .' _ 1 ` :. �. � �� 4"T'� " pa ia ��_ 3 R7�.� 1 a2 ��,;de t�.�;�ka�'t'�'�^ �� ' . �. ,� u � , , � : '� 1� 4 �^ .�a _. �w # � d„ � u ��. , y '^' ',! "".�""",""� . .,'�` �" . � � . .,. . _ . . ... .., .o . ,. . ..r.ie.�ti,�,. ,� � ;'�'tA4,c''v""ks�y,p�,'Mk'"""ry„+e�"'..' �'�r. � , . , . �� . . ,. Exhibit 1 �rOlieechobee CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR TI-IE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs 8� Brace) 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 07/01 /2021 oK�o��cE � �.. ;.:. ;; : -'. F L' .' . CASE NO. 210701012 STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE O� HEARING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of CityCode Chapter/Section: IPMC CH 3 SeC 304.6 arld 304.7 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:710 NW Pa�k St 3-15-37-35-0010-01610-0050 (34008) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Joseph. Perret�� 510 SW Port St Lucie Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL. 34953 4. Descnption of Violatio - �xterior of the building and roof needs maintenance and cleaning. 5. Date violation must be conected by�ul 15, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about3/17/21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take notice that a Heazing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 10th day Auaust. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to [he Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. f you fail to appear at the heazing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record oF the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes aze for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Depazttnent. In Accordance with Fla Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved pazty may appeal a final adminishrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un paztido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrativa fmal a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza. Exhibit 1 � � a � � �- � � 0 0 0 0 0 � � N 0 � 0 N Exhibit 1 ■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. ■ Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to: Joseph Perretta 510 SW Port St Lucie Blvd Port St Lucie, FL. 34953 ��: A. Signature X � ❑ Agent ❑ Addressee B. Received by (Printed Name) G, Date of Delivery D. is delivery address different from item 1? ❑ Yes r delivery address below: p No ❑ Priority Mail Express� ��' 1 � � ( (' j':, ❑ Adult Signature ❑ Regis[ered Mailrm � �j��) �� (� � �� ( �� j Adult Signature Restricted Delivery ❑ Registered Mail Restricted � 1 �. � � . @ Certified Mail� Delivery i 7-� -; . ❑ Certified Mall Restricted Delivery T�1 Signature Canflrtnation'"' '� '' �i��-� :Z}b! ,'�' ❑CollectonDelivery Q7SlgnatureConfirmaUon 2. Articla Niimhar ITran�f r+.�..� ��.:�- �-�-�� '-' ^-"--` �n Delivery Restricted Delivery Restricted Delivery 702a 245� �d470 5696 5175 �a'' �1aii Restricted.�elivery - - � (over $500) , PS FOYm 3g11, JUIy 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt • i=X�'iiul( 1 �.. l,.o.. ,,..., ��E �`*' s � t'. ,, ;; � ��n a��i °r�;;,:�:. :�I � n ' ;i � i F'�. �.y:- Y ' • -�s...�. �. � � ` "rny� . , , i ,l 2 � � ` +� � 1 �v �:� h �,`" r^. �,''., r . . � , � . . . , t , � � . , . . - 4� �.�. .,� n.,, �. . , ; � - ,� ;�;'�i �F 1y++�+J,r+.�.l��Y =,,�;,: ..� ti .._.:;:��W:""""�7 �- �� ;; � _ �, !', "'t, . ,� i� , i: fl �::�1 � � �)�:j \ � ■Iw �I�■A110Yf �� , � � .� � r ,�. . , _ cv`^s '�`- �.,rv��,,� .� �� _ � � •?b:,� "r�'�'�t;t�. r��'''�i� �y<.: �. �..i,t�� • �� '� �� . �963) 357-0079 �85� 357-0079 . .. .. . _., , . -� .�i A . ' .,..�.�.,..... ; , �. ,, �a - f , , � . � � . ! i � .. � �• e � {� �SyRal, •a� � ..�- . �Y4+.{�, . 1 � . �. w. .'.,Ml: o:� ....s,... ew+� . .... _ .._ ..._ .. ... _. w_....._..w .___ 0 O a o° ��C�il �lU bC� . - ,. . . °_3 . ., ...a__ � k �...� *� ��OL, 4 ' . .. ..i � • . � .�,=� e �� . ., I ��:' � s�ik^ ��i.:,!'�� .... . �� .at., _ ��..�. :':�.. .'� .. ��:`*._�� _ . "9�si..:µ:y?1%4�: _,.,'arfl,. r� _� �- u y,��,... f . 'a�. txnibit � �s �� 4� ,�� .�;,.;��{�;� �� , �.� � l ` k � f ; '. � _ (, � �{ � ' � � , � ' �, � . � . . � .- � • . , . .. .� . , � : � �*: .i S � i t �� 4 1 ! t i � , � `v� . °' � � �� f �� , s� ��. � �,. � � r� � ,' . � � , , �� . ,pr ' , � . __ _ �� i�_.:.. ��,_ .-a,�. . 1 * $: a �. tYi � .1�nrt�1.iMM�M4^��1�MIq1a�r,w�IMMqMp. �F '��_-" ` � . . .- .. . .[ � i{. , ~ � � ry � �� , ` . : a ',.:j * t � - _ — —, ...,....,....,.�: � i �` � _ �, „ /� � � � � . . ' '� ."� °",E "'f ,",� ,,.� � ,�*�� • � � � ' � 0 � a ° Oc�O��l � 0 � 0� � � �� ti��,� . � �K� ..�a�.�� .� ��,: _ � � . .�. �.�..� .�� - _ � _: � ��.� �� _ _ �.__ � �.., �-�-�,, - �„�,�,�. ��. � •. . . _ �,��-.. � "' . ,� �'�� ,w. � ,, �'R:� ' '� � 't1�7` �`,� 'ii�M. e ?� ; � , � ::,�i. {, � . �'' �°' F , �. ' . $ :,�. , � ' �. �: k� �� , � .. N. � �. �. � . �' �i _,._ - -- _ ; �� .� � _� r.��'.: � �`� r �� , �. 1F�i � � �� :� A': `_ ..., � � ,�. � „ ��y, �,. Ryy� �� !. Exhibit 1 55 VII. NEW CASES CONTINUED F. Case No. 210701012; Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs and Brace), 710 West North Park Street [Legal Description: The West 50-feet of Lots 5 and 6, of Block 161, OKEECHOBEE, Piat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, and beginning at the SW corner of Lot 6 of Biock 161, OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 5, Page 5, Okeechobee County public records, thence run North along the West boundary of said Block 161 to the NW corner of Lot 4 of said Block 161; thence run West, along the Westerly extension of the North boundary line of said Lot 4, a distance of 50-feet to the East ROW line of the former Florida East Coast Raiiway of North Park Street; thence run East, along said North ROW line, a distance of 50-feet to the point of beginning, lying in Section 16, Township 37 South, Range 35 East, and being a part of that certain 50-foot strip of land designated as "Reserved" on the plat of Okeechobee, Plat Book 5, Page 5 Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of International Property Maintenance Code (IPMC) Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage. Code Officer Smith testified the property is in violation of IPMC Chapter 3, Sections 304.6 Exterior walls and 304.7 Roof and drainage for the roof and exterior walls needing maintenance and cleaning. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on March 17, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 22, 2021, who was advised on what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on March 25, 2021, who stated he was working with Donna at Big Lake Pressure Cleaning and Painting to pressure wash the roof and paint the building. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Joseph Perretta on July 8, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 8, 2021 and was advised that the painting needed to be completed and the windows uncovered along Park Street. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Perretta on July 27, 2021, wha advised that the same company would be pressure washing the exterior of the building next week and painting it the week after. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Mr. Perretta on August 5, 2021, who advised that the building had been pressure washed and should be painted next week. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the exterior of the building still needed to be painted. However, the property owner has made progress by pressure washing the building and roof and painting the roof. The City recommends an extension to the next Hearing be approved to allow the property owner the opportunity to come into full compliance. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona ruled to defer Case No. 210701012 to the next Special Magistrate Hearing to allow the property owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. VIII. PUBLIC COMMENTS: none were offered. IX. ADJOURN MEETING There being no further business to come before the Specia Ma tr�a� e H� adjourned at 6:45 P.M. ATTEST: , � � /- � ' � ,� i' �. 7 f��istina Curl er Azcona, Special Magistrate Please take notice and be advised that when a person decides to appeal any decision made by the Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this Hearing, he/she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceeding is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. City Clerk media are for the sote purpose of backup for official records of the Clerk. August 10, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 5 of 5 Exhibit 1 ,,�,okf `e�echobee CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Joseph Perretta (Coastal Limbs & Brace) 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 09/03/2021 - � :.. ��LiCEti�.. -;�r ;FL _ CASE NO. 210701012 STE1TEViE'NT OF VIOLAI�IOiv AND NOT'ICE Ul� II�ARING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncoi7ected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: I PMC CH 3 SeC 304.6 and 304.7 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:710 NW Park St 3-15-37-35-0010-01610-0050 (34008) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Joseph Perretta, 510 SW Port St Lucie Blvd, Port St Lucie, FL. 34953 4. Description of Violatio��eriar of the building and roof needs maintenance and cleaning. Painting the exterior and removing the boards from windows. 5. Date violation must be corrected by�Ct 1, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about3/17/21 Unless Respondent conects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code [nspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you aze hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 12th day October. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Deparhn . If ou fai ��e hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, 8c impose a fine in your absence. � ' Anthony Smith Code Enforcement O�cer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this heazing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes aze for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Department. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final adminishative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed withiu 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden administrariva 6na1 a la h�ibunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la fuma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 1 � � m N � a a � � 0 fl O O tr1 m 0 a � 0 � r Exhibit 1 -� . . .� F -� _-- _ ��_ .— , '� L'?`""r � f- c� "1"'i�'!'P 4 i �Y..a..� � � !-: •: s • ► i ■ Co!r.y. �.. . _. _ .. . _. �. _.., ❑ Agsnt i Print your name and aadress on the raverse �)( -, � � ❑ Addressee so that we can return the card to you. ^` ,n this card to the back of the maiipiece, B� Received by (Pnnted Narne) C. Date of Deiivery ur on the front if space oermits. 1 �,+;,,,,, �,.,,,,,,,,_,,.� ,..• L--- --- - ticidress different from itern 1? ❑ Yes - :r delivery address below; ❑ No Jose�h Perretta - 510 SW Part St Lucie Bivd Port'St Lucie, FL. 34953 �i "1'�'� I�II �'I I I�I) II II I I�� II� I I I I!,� I19 3' �erviGe Type ❑ PnorrtY Maii ExPress� ❑ Adult Signature � Regist�ed Mait^" ❑ Adult Siyneture ReStricted Delivery ❑ Registered Mail Resiricte �Certifiec tvlailRO Delivery `) ��iO ��:}��"1? :� i�`�:� i��!�'� i��1 � l': ❑ Cerlfi�d Mail ReSMcted Delivery ❑ ftetum ReceiPt ior ❑ Coll2ct or� Delivory lerchandise ❑ Collect on Uelivery Restricted Delivery �ignature Confirmation^ 2. Article Number (Trnsfer from service labe!) Mail ❑��9��atura Confirmaiion 7 0 21, � 3 5 0 � 0 a 1, 51 ], 7 7 3 5 8 0�� Restr��«a pen�ery ResMctec! DelWery � PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Re`urn Receipt Exhibit 1 � �;, ,.,��. ,r�� .,�,� „�. _ . , ,.�' � i• ` � � � ,.� � � � �� I �' ,�, � ��i.. � � � ,' �� L'�_�_�'f� LIMBS & BRACE �� , ��# ,, L�`aSTi�L_UiVISS & . �.a "IYihCi., � ,. _ _. � Or . L.�!'� -�.. Lf� . , � . � : .�. �. . . : • .. . . . . .. � �-"�.V' T � �:,rae�.�i.j.[:� �J '� } .. ( 63) 357-0079 � x ' . .°' ' ($63) 357-007� , . . • � , z _ _.._..._r.,_..____ - - h.�. � ° ��0�� C� �� _ dr�-.�.� _ _. - � . ; � . • , . ' • : '" �i . .:;, �'► :+� RK+� t . Exhibit 1 � , i y k � � �-"� � � : �� N B � + ° � `�':'� + � �. � � 3 � � � � � �i � , .� . .. - , � ff ... � '__ _ S � ; ��►�•� �---,� .. � _.. '� f • � 1 �M� k�e�A . . , . . � �, � � ti � ' �~,.. �. • �"� � _. . . •, .•_.. - . n � E ft .. . �.. � {.. '� �, �� r�- x � ,'+`�. . _ . �a-.��*iKy '�T`, .�'.��[ .,::�� v, .~ 1�4 `, c . '� '� o °0��(l�� 1�� , .. . . _ i ` �=,�,��. � � : �� ; �: , �- ; _ _ ��:., , �� ? �,:�� `4-'� ,� � �i COASi'At LlMBS_& BRACE � � f � C-t ,?;mt�s S � �a�, Or+hopc:l-r. �races r � , fi • � � �� 4.4 J . . . .` � • �. . ... (R631 357-0079 , ..� w. ..., r � ` �:+� n ;' I! LS� �U �, _ a."T .._M"' .. S • • Exhibit 1 �'QASTAL L/MBS & BRACE' : >>,,; a =�,_ . M�'�.,� l� (863) 357-0079 �. - � _. � ,�„-,;� ,� , t, � = �� x ,..r:�-�� ; � �rnw ... .. _.�. ----- � ....��M �-' - � � w _ __ ^ _ _ . . � ° �� 1 � �� - �_ . , � . c«. . �.-,�.,. . . ,wi _ ,.,r,t _ � ,. — � ... • ' r , , _ . _ -�,.- .z �t- - � �xhibit '1 �y�� „4"'�� Rek i:kb �.�1'��IR�.'�' � �;,;'.a i . � 'T"Y:qy? ._� ' ' e.�:`t 'T�,� #�` ^ �� '—�, f ��. � � r � � � , P . T tri�'. E � � r.��f >" � �� `� � Y � � � �� - �� i: y �... �,.., t .. Y �i :. � � \ � t `' _ r � � � � � ' , � "fi � � x' '.5 - . . �i : � ! ' ` ' . . . . . � � . . �, }f . . ' . � . � , „.. ...e'+� t � � � �, . . � . � �—...�� ' • ' '' . fr�.wlwM !. � � � . i �, � �., wE�' � V . �:�....,� • 9kt t � �w.�rx�o-r�s.�t�r'{��'{,'�'"�t°Tii�', �+j� 1.'f1. � j k� I��.1 � 5�� t.� 2� t �.f ��..HI { i. .-'W-i..,v,a :� � � � � � � �� : , � .. . . � . � . T .L , . '� ;.;, � � S � ri� � ,f y ^'"M:.q.. .��j V'v.j K°nqi- ' y _�f� � —#Sgr., _ � - �� , ��: _ :�.. � -- .-_. _ . .._. �=� �=� � �� + . ► _ �� V� � r �..- ' �a VR ?4e � . . . . - ! . . , . _ .. � �� .. Y �yy�qmt, � {� 1 j� d�.�= �14r a.... k� �� }�'1'.. 1' .:.; � F � �; r i. �''P Y 7:, �,� i "`. y . _. .-.-- .� � �, A , . . . �� . � . , . �. �.�N�!�.u�'.P".+n' � fa��Jb��. ��., ��,�� P � q �K: , d � t t � / 1�w,. ,., 4 , � � �. J `.'i:y��-�, . _. .. . _ _ . � ; .. 1� 0�O�7D�0�� Og � ��3 � - -. � .� Exhibit 1 �� -- — —.� ,��...�.. __ i . � .i ;�, ;.;� � � � � � r d�y ws � i :k�.d� � ; E 11I� • � _' � �. � _ . ��'� . , �.:., {. �O�O�l�� Og��C� . 4 � hf,• • ' �'}�' ,�.... yyy��... ;: '� `.' I . 4. �Y� �� r� _ _ .. . W.� �,m ., ' i !� [ 5 r616�J Exhibil: 2 V. B.-Exhibit #2 Case #210421006 Jose and Maria Cisneros Exhibit 2 Code Enforcement Hearinq October 12, 2021 Case Name.8� Number: Jose and Maria Cisneros, Case #210421006 Chapter 30, Section 30-32 Accumulations on real property � Large piles of debris Chapter 30, Section 30-43 Public nuisance Unsecured buildina, all windows broken out. no front door. Photos: See attached Is respondent a Repeat Violator? Yes 1. June 1, 2020, Violation of Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification Summarv: • Respondent was first notified on April 21, 2021 via Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of event Type of event Date received Received by May 5, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant May 5, 2021 Received a call from Jose Cisneros, property owner they are working on getting all the debris out to the road for Waste Management to pick up and will be demolishing the building as soon as they have a permit to do so. June 9, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant July 1, 2021 Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed certified return July 6, 2021 Jose Cisneros receipt for the August 10t'' Hearing due to the June Hearing being cancelled due to illness July 19, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant August 4, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant, however the grass had been cut, and the yard debris removed. The building still needs to be secured August 10, 2021 Case presented to the Special Magistrate; case deferred to allow more time for the property owner to come into full compliance as progress has been made. September 3, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified September 27, JMC 2021 return recei t 2021 September 20, Property inspected, still non-compliant, the building still needs to be 2021 secured. October 7, 2021 Inspected properly, still non-compliant, the house has been demolished, but all the debris needs to be removed. • To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to finish removing all the debris left over from the demolition of the building. Citv Recommendation: The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Chronology attached. PAGE 1 OF 1 Exhibit 2 Case #210421006, Jose, and Maria Cisneros Date Event/Document April 21, 2021 Property owner: Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros Address: 608 Southeast 10th Avenue Violation of CH 30 Sec 30-32-Accumulations on real property and Sec 30-43-Public nuisances. Unsecured building, all windows broken out, no front door, large piles of yard debris. ****REPEAT VIOLATOR**** April 21, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed certified return receipt for the June 8�' Hearing, given 14 days to correct violations. Received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. May 5, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, building not secured, piles of debris in the yard. Photos in file. May 5, 2021 Received a call from the property owner Jose Cisneros 863-634-2657. They are getting the debris out to the road and to call Waste Management to come pick it up. They are also working on demoing the building to start reconstruction. As soon as they have the permit, he will email it to us. June 9, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, Yard debris, overgrown trees, shrubs and grass. Unsecure building. Photos in file. July 1, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed USPS certified return receipt for August 10th Hearing. Received on July 6, 2021, signed by Jose Cisneros. July 19, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, Yard overgrown debris at the curb for the pass month that grass have grown up through piles and building still unsecured. Photos in file. August 4, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, Grass was cut, and the yard debris was removed, However the building needs to be secured: No door and broken out windows. Photos in file. August 10, 2021 Case presented to the Special Magistrate; case deferred to the next hearing to allow more time for the property owner to come into full compliance as progress has been made. September 3, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the October 12tn Hearing. Given till October 1 St to correct the violations. Received by JMC on September 27, 2021. September 20, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, building needs to be secured. Photos in file. Page 1 of 2 Exhibi� 2 Case #210421006, Jose, and Maria Cisneros Date Event/Document October 7, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, however great stride has been made to bring the property into compliance. The house has been torn down. Just need to finish removing all the debris and a great deal of that has happen. Photos in file. Page2of2 Exhibifi 2 t . ,�g� .. . � , .�, . , !',�".�°i;�'''.+..i,, ; ; s;: � � .� y g''�'��`� . � µy � - * , .�` �L...� � . � � . ., . ., � � . : �` _ : .. .: ,� �� 4.. . �' N . `f t .✓ w'� L � � �pr' �X': - q � .. , . =. `. � � l i. <., ' � . . ' � Y� � w . q , .G � � � r .B�`4 l � *{� . f:K f w 4 9 �i`n,! i � ' #t . .. � �' �y . � �.�, � � . ..... ,t . _.,- , a �r,:i.- t' �M '1�CAd,� . -Sr�',�,'�i�V1 t� •.7�` , . ^ 1�" , �r� •.rs,: . CP +s 'e . i� ��Yw :i�,: '!' `,'.4bF , _ . . , .,e!ny, 1,.1� ..�� , . . _,: . - . �,�E . , . .. , -.� . ,'C f?., i , . �1 � � ,. �� ' . 'iff d . , . ?:i- � . , .� . _ . . .'�--rT.. - _ ' � ' � .. - � � :' "� •- " " . -,+ - � - . � ,�� • ` • _ .�e—s.:k � ' ��''-�'�'� Y�`�.��' ""' _ O a Q O O OZSU[S� _� � ° 4�' �+.- �.y " ' . , � _ � ,'�- . '�•'L ��,,,';r. r � � � '� e , `�� , ,, �? '�.` -" �� .r` , .,v.� _� �' . - , .;, y. d'. —11N�� .�"� �� jT �3� �� V� Nx.: . . ... ,wca.dw . ��waa.wJ'M1�+..,.n+..�,.._ .... ..... ... . . .... . m, - i . . .... . . . . ., . �. ... �r�..�11wM1��✓��P ��M.�.�' �* .. . . . ..�.......lYf � f1� .�}. . 4 f ;� .r a • � .,'°� ` . ,x� ' , . . ; �"��,'``� � A '4�:. _ � . � � £ Y±' � � ' � . .. - ...`i�'� � � � �� •;,#, � .. 4 t .5.�yvzs��b! � .;3.` � � s � i , � � �j f�r i r ��5'e� ,e•. : y..a � S�l�ii. � , � . � � , . � � 'y� „�`�yW '� '� :,:,?�w"4 , r . . : . ' � , ' �: .. . . � _. � ��4��z�� ' �•�',}+",1W' � o �� r„� r,.�� ' ,. � � . ..� .4w�e.� a. .,,,�*..� . ��,qM1 � r '+� , � � ��„_. +�c � % „J ' ^�'6"W� �i�'; 7r � ,� r'; .. � - ,.► i " yy,�� .AC K, C-'.�r t .,�,. .� w `�,V�o-�.� �� `� '. . _:..� .,� - yt�"a. �`R. . ��'�Vr] "'T� ; . . . •.��P'si y �4- �:iY N �• ��«�HWjMRIY:{� �4�a - '�Y�l . • ... Y�Y r . j'l� .� � $!�• � ��`4� ' . . �,'�y�.'. �� . � ' fi • . . • e.C'�� . .� '' . ..:'�"�' �� i. ;;w: , ' ,�'� "" ; ' ` ` " � ��,f*iwk.,� . �„ �-;•�'Y � � , . .�,`y'�~? �.n . .. � � ' � , ��,N,/ , ~ '.fa ' 0 a Q 0 0 ��0�9 � � � �� `r .., �-.��G', k� � _ � � . �' : i �t ►; �' ` r " _-p;R�tl�il ��' �l # .�'� S �+4 '�1"t . � : !r �+w .. '�s�r'�'. .! » _ r�;�� :;'` -wr� "F'Rv�:r� . . » ._ ...s, ..L ' Exhibit 2 ��,-� �� .-r-,-�•�� .� � � � .'w r. ��. . .. ., . � �t'i �.,. � � � . , . � � . �y�' ` .,Y . � �`"� �. ' -.�r°� ' �4;' X m �;.� � i ,�� ;`�' r .'� �,�.. � � ��c° .� � �` 1� i +,�. f�� " �' T N-.�t � rf' � .� �° r• �� r ' +, ' � � i�:�� '"!l�!� - : , • , :;. ��M' ;- � �,.::..�, . � � ._� i � � � •k, � i x� � � . _, Y• ...'.:� n�.�. ��... .u. ... � 7 ._ � . -�+�'�i�t, �rtx�. ��. �. ��_ �+�i � �'"""�'"`"�.�."- !•Y �, •, c _ � +?' � ,_��,4' ,a..�• �°��6�� . �`.`�"' Y. WSaYv :.:i:ti � . . . .. ... ... . .. ^. � . .x � �� '.�! r�i1 �^a"' q A � a� � �� : �'��` t� �� . '' h'�" �` � i��:��'� �� t -�3X"�'� f' � � � r 7 . :y � �. �� r� '�.: �, ;�y� x . #!`? � �p�� "�w r�"` �,'� ii` "� =�'`� � � , �: � �; � � . s _,_ti. � � 4 ,,,� . .-�?� g� �l��g�3 t �'�' ,��` � A�R ` T ` r� ( `y�. � +- t - � � a Exhibit 2 a� ,�I(@CC�IOI�£ CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 04/21 /2021 _o^�L„pF�,.` : .�,. 4.F 1. -i�� I CASE NO. 210421006 STf�"CI��iVILNT OF VIOLATIUN ��ND NOTICI; OF HEARI�IU Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30 Sec 30-32 and 30-43 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists: 608 SE 10th Avenue 3-22-37-35-0230-00120-0080 (35385) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in chazge of location where violation exists: Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros, 581 NW 30th Lane, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 4. Descriprion of Violation:Unsecured building, all windows broken out, no front door, large piles of yard debris. 5. Date violation must be corrected byMay 5, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about4/21 /21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code [nspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take notice that a Heazing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the $th day June. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., (ocated at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Plorida 34974 in Counci t Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advise that any evidence presented to [he Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Deparhne t. ou a' to ear a heazing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatnn record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up far the official records of the Code Enforcement Department. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a fmal administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be fded within 30 days of the execurion of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccioa 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrariva final a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 2 �. - � , �� . . �- , , , � � - a . � Certifled MeH F9e �D $ `� Extra Ices ees (cneck eox, ade se. ms eca�w�ere, J n 1�/�• Q Q Retum Receipt (herticopy) S � �� p ❑ Rotum Rece�pt (ebc+ronlc) S POShnBrk Q ❑ Certified Mall peetrictad DelNery S Hero � ❑AtluttSignalureRequlred S � � Adult SM3nature ReeVtcted DelNery f a Postage �� 10�� Tota astep� an a J�� S aSent To Z /'+,�- J _._v"_!._l� Q� hS`t�9et -- - o., Or d$ox d. �,'-"�-�---'_------ - -- --. �-----�-c.�---3�- ---��.-�----------------- �'- �t;'�°.�.� d,:,L...��, �r _, �,c�9��. Exhibit 2 ■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. ■ Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the cerd to you. ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to: Jose Cisneros Maria Cisneras 581 NW 30th Lane Okeechob�-; FL. 34972_ X ' ( , ❑ Agent � ,�-��-� ❑ Addre by (Printed Name) C. Date f Deli `—� �� > � i D. ts delivery address differerrt from item 1? � u Ya �/ ' delivery address below: No � rn D � � � � � ❑ Priori y I E:cpress� �1'�1��II��II�I�I� II� ({i�I�) II�I ��I��1� ❑AdultSignature � agi MaiIT'" � 1 , I I ❑ Adutt Signature ResVlcted De vary e�isio M2il Restricted �'Q, Certlfied Mall� � ol v �.. i a:��.:: (�;�, r� i> -� .�. +��,� O Certifled Mail P.estricYed Deiiv ey Signa onflttnaUonTM � ❑ Collect on Delivery nfirmatlon 2. Artir.ic N��mt,o. rr.�,,.,r , a..� ---_.:.-- . . �� . � . . . . ^ - � �. '�'AeHelNery Reatricted e0 ' i�. Delivery 7 019 2 9 7 � � 0 0 0 1811 � 7 2 4__-_ -Aali Restricted Delivery __ _. - � �over ssoo> _ -- Ps Form 3811, JUIy 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Retum Receipt ; txhibit 2 �';�y.;�� . � -��,:, . ��.� �.� � ,`� . �.. � y� 4�' � Li� ,C � �M�!�� n�� `'�• M�*1� � �+��'l' ��-v �. • 4 � y'� �f+�i �yY ��+Y�� ,�,� y�''9�"� Trp 3�,� ��1 f k, r*' �� _ , ��.tF'=° � �' �a �� " � �•�(� ``��.L 4 s#4'„i� M i lf,� 3M; �`�.��,•�.rr g�•� �ti� •�� 'f� M �`• „'� � . � �� k ` A 4�kiqr � ';�� r.� �i�: '�1�L,�, !� "� .. �' .�..�� .. .- .> �•' �'� : ,� A r 4` J- i��. � s.:., , i� � �'C't �` ., t ii�' `'3�,'� � � � t � � � ��'� �' ; � � * ��i% i f t,,.,,, � +;13�.,..,, y,�;., %�w�'t ^a 'L K � . .. , . . �� j �" . �` �' • � � ♦ t �",` s-.:x'�'�t � � �~'�.:: ,,��`��,�, - ' � ;� .r -.,d,� _ `,� , � ;��,� � ��. �`''°� �,�- �:= _ ��1I0��0�� g �� *�;y ��:.w J SY� v .. � f�y��7 � �,�.,4.0 ,� E, �•. .. fi.w �+�, �y � P i a:�nri � A �L� "�+'Cs�'► "'rh:. �,4,� �%".` ylk��+�'t.*` �7'"�-!�� . . -r.* ' . � ' , ' � .��+� ;,�, . .. . . �-• ,.�� .� • '�;<,� � . � : ,,�r,�, _.,,;., . -� ;� �r. �qa : f.: -. � t. ti`+� A R �� « � . Y� r �', _ j �� }{ %� � 1/i , • � �. � � •.�i'� .:f �� i�1� b y . � .. '� ��. �� = R %.: y� w x . �.,�`� ♦ T�.� � �9�'�` 8 � . �.(ir' A � -. .�'- "rs .,, +r �. ,� � r'�- . r' . `t ;x.r. y'�� .� .... �. +� A f...,. � � . . ..r�' J �: � � tJ( � S � �f .r e•� �+�� 1 � �i. �la' . ., j y�.. • +,. y . . ";�, , , 1 T�'�''�''�. ,1 i^:,� ' �*�ii� ��'.:�'+i��*f �'►� � `., � , � � {jt i. � . ` �• .. � �� `�t", �Mw'.� . = t � 'f -. e,`i��•` � . k#+' `�- �w. ..��Y' t � ! ' � s . :/�. _ . 1 ` .� � ^. . . . ' � � , r� � . . C�� - � t � - ..riy[. ' � , �'i 'R +.. . . , ,�e. .� � •• ..`'�',: � � . _ �. .'�5�. i . s R`� a� : �� '�ry ,. � '; _ -.� '�`° , , ,; � �. ��,�.� � !� �,, � ��z� . M�t �. -. � __ rc - � �'ir =e�.�[ +t�.h7 (� M "� 7k5�_ "��" . ' . . '� . _.� � . ,�� T•� I^: 1 :�� .�Ez3 ^" . ' y _�—... • � �. .�;.�� ` `� ��v��.�,�.�:�:�� . �. y ,y. 'r �� ""?�'r` e , ,;,,�' �`. �� *, A� � �� .F� _. � . aM' . �W �E�, ��, �� ^ � j '�ir�� f+�'! ' ^ �,f�� =C7o�+Y4 . ' �.�� 'y,,, -Lw �4`�f /r A +•��. `�,,�� y�m.rw .+�= -:'�S:a�', r"— _ w� . _ d� . . �'�ID'� . . . ,� __ . `x�i.� . , ` 1 . ' :.= � � �� -. � �� ` � . .� ', � �� .. a��=.. •.h � r � f�._. � . y . , . . � - . . a - . . - � .. �+ .s+ � �.$ � � . ,ryfr ' y*f � . . � .. � � � , *� ^g: , t �`z,�« • �,y� , , -. � �� i ,- iT .i-.} � � +' , � �,} � �t .t,: r.�� r�' -• �.., �xhi�it 2 � .� • �� f�' �� N .�. �"`� :� �� . �� : -�t ra� � . �; . �� " .� %"��, �� _ �a��o�� c� � �.c . . ...,..� �.� - . y _ �.�. .. , _.. . � �,�M�;,r . . ` ' '"^� . ��.. _ .. . ' ��. t .� ' .• �.' 3� � .. '✓ �� . .�r. '�� ' : .,._ . �, � i � � . _ _. � . . � � `K . ' F � � � ._� ' ' .. .'. j��.' �p1{,[�. �tin • � LL � � ��. �P •�• �N ( �'` �'.�RY� ,' ; ' �N � �J. �' n' + A iwx }4�� . �� .t., a. ;; _ �" x �+.' � � ..� lrt.�, � r �� .. +��,,y4 . ��,�y �;f'" �y.ii i.� �FNN2k�Ptv.�r • '4 . ��[��'. } ; r 1�,. . .S , i � ,�� • a h��ry +,�� . . `-k+✓._i . i �� i.� "�b . �}�� . � .. . . . „T. . ..�... . � � .. ., .......«. _.,,,�rr .... ,.,�., .,,.��' " .. . � .. , a . . .:,,.�„:-�^,.. � _' ._, .,.. .. �U�U��Z�I� ; � � � 6 4 � ,. _. ��+�,.�._� . : . � �- �� , � � � � � �-�� ,. � � . :,i�"�;��i�i11�1�'�t'�;: : � � "' �"i Exhibit 2 �` . - r� �,� �....�,.�� ......+.. ,. • I � P . i � t` � � (" � �:� I - . �� . �-�. �� . ,: �� '`� ��_. __ : i� �' -�� . � .�. �.�_. _ --�.�---.- . ; _ _ ��- . _ _ _-�� . _ ,. � _.. .__ . _ . � .� �.� �.. _. �� .. . Y�i�i•`�7M►i/Mk.. �" " . ..-.. 7�'ws � .. " � .� �w+ � .. �..�..s� :.=:�. . _.. �. _ . >..... - - 0 0 � o ° a�a�il � 2�� ° � �..;��.` �.-� ..� • �n�s �. . ��'+MIBMIIM►:�"� ri�, • ..x�::�;n«;'�'��'r��►i.\"�:�.'�ra.rCsl.Au� . � ,.�,,.. . . . . � f. • . ♦ , . , . . r r. tpY,_"1, •t' ��,�� . � � ,� '. +�� ' �� .f � - .. ; r e�,'� � �' <�♦ j�� I 1 � YJ �,..wflW',� . � k� �':� r �i � ..`+4�. � �r�,f `1 7 �;�� I� �,��,; �.:��;�, ��. �,�;rt�.'�:;e "i'a �,�'� , ~`'" . . �+, ` � � �� ".!i►:. �,�t' �: i ��- 1`� \ ,�,. 1� ♦ � r.y 1 �� r _,,.#{�� ' �`C'�� a,�� i'� N+ f. "d'�'S �i�•,- � a`r,�,' , � �t. iW F^_ . .�_ �� ~, a�`I�St. +{. .� � . � . � * * .� ♦ . �� "��tf•�' ,� ��,A. , . �i•... . � . ` � •� J ;"�,�.f�R� '` vy� � �,i�.",�, , A . ,`,� •� , i ' � �� ' 4� '�r�„'r�`y� + ;, rm �'�' ,�, ,' . .r. �a�.� ,,� ,.o,' ;;. o� �.� .. . '�,'� ts ..�?t�a+;r ,�f �� ,sn- y � �. t'�,; . �- ' +' W � �-� ��. . �n'�i - t�" ;a. �, +`� � ' . . r. ' J's j � . •' '. . . . (� . �a . � :�� „� - . ' r � � ,_ e ' � � :�.� ��:; . �•....�. .^�a'� ls�M � ,: ' ``� E.z:t�`-• } •` ,�`„�, ..�: � +�,�r a� ,. , f",,� a'.. : � � . . ; ' .. � , +� ' � � � ,� � ,.� � "` , '', ., �,� '..�� , .� �`*w��...� �F ,.s ' slr�� s'y ere`I \�\i�'#. ,� O O.0 O..oO,�V(Sll �Il(S�� ..a�'� 1'�Cte' .r'+t,,, t e+^cs'e! <� �i'•a, ��:�rr+- . �k ��:�� Sr•!`.`{�.'(,�� ,f :.is�� _�'�. `' � � � '�ti.�� f ..� -. ��,y •. . ' � .t . . �. q � + i�. i . ,,. . � �.. �; ' _ _� T .�: y � - � .. r:�tj� 6� i,i.. a.: �'r��! ' . .. l:w�. .>. T + ., _ �. _ _ , • ,. , i ''` i . , _ . _ - + 'Z"� ` Y' ^` rry Y Exhik�it 2 � �� _ �';, �: . -'� �� { g R � �� , � �YK � � �x � '�� :�;,, �� ., .a,�� t � �' '' `, �.� ��yfa ''�' 4 ' 1 1 �� f$ �µy�,� � ��.` ��.1� . ..ii .'�� ',a{ i -p a<,a . {;� r '�i;� U?�4:5 � �y , ,�, r� � s: ry� t � �,�yk �'e,�, � R y� �*.�� J ia, � � � ,�, ��. . . .�� ,e3. � � r .s� . "•�• i , �y: 4 w� ' � � -..� y,��t, � � ti . �. , .. '.'t��.� � * + µ.- ��,, �a: � �y' , I�1lw�Yw�... .wt�lYrnwl�� . ... �AW I - � � � �r�' ��~ ' ' G�� t � .�,� k ��•t.. 6 i 1� � � y, .:,�.. . .. .« . ,r� .�^s t,�y�, +� y , ...�. ,�i., � ,�♦ . � �r. , " t , • , .. ` � . ti t '.{i,,��e �4',� i - i ° �4 Si � � '►��'��` �'r� ♦@ W � _ -4��t."��., � ,.m. "�H��. . . • i.r �..��r r ' • k ;g,..,�'}' `� Yi�tp. �F.'�.,. ., � � � • ^• i� !� h . � Ar ' ti' �' V .�. e� � � .. , ,° �t � a,f��r�� "�,�'-. �r � �" �,' .a'+t' f��t. 1 'li� y r. .�1 ��er'` 1 ' . . ` 'A Y "�R_ . � �+ . � . ',�i� � ; a yyy�.�+ ��i'Su. 1• . . -,{ y� �f+ . . ��.. k : .�..i•% 'Vt��,� .,>. � .. ' r' . . � . ,�'� , `�:�.� ti�v �_�,.. �,�;} . -�'- � � ar � '. �`�. : � „�J,►�o�� "i'j��+ Y'�`�� '�, ��, � . . '3 � i �;,� � a � � �,. . (� 'n , . ' • - t . . ♦ y .�. �. . �� a s�` c�} � t n ' .��'7." 4 ; y y r y' +► � ♦ � ic. , �' . ' � w . . �ah�l��' � � � M ' � d. y� .�,? . .i: Ak. � �h N�•, � � f; ��%�y��J^�r� '��y� , =i 'i;�'. , � . . � ��l. r^.,j � `R� .*: �i 0 �IU�� !/ L'-�"JCS Il Il•C��" � 7 � . t.74.if ��,:;! , �. . , . • . � � "�. .'� ^ ,.t, v� � . . . � . . ... , ' . � �. , . � � . , • �. <v' � ' �y�'k , CaY��4.T�� , ^s�{�� ,..,. , � � � . ,i' _ ., � _ .,,�_ ��•l� ' 'I . . ry r ,� , , , �• - . . � . , ,a. �^ . '� � . _ �_ �. . _ � �K ,..�:., . ... �. _... _. �:,_ �,� .�.a : . _ . ,.. . . ' A . - „„� ,. �� . _. . � . .,,... ' - . _ . -.- . . _ . . . - .. ' _�. ,<. .. . . . ... , , _. . . ' _._.. ..' . ' '- ._ . ' ' __ _ .__.. __ ,_�_ _ __. ..,. ... � .. -�--��_.� _�.__. _ ,._.a . ._• t �+' r} �� . ... _. ,._.....,., - ��wr. .} ^� w....��.. �.•, � ♦ �''��° . . • ,.., �. .; +.�. .-'. .n:� . �y�'5r �.�'• � ,1. G" *`�*. �� . v ._ _ . �4,� �R� � _� ,h,� � � � . � i,,� � ♦ 'i ,.... "._ ,.. i��S?��- �' � .�_ 1 s._ . ? � . - __.,... ...,.. . { ��+.-.-" __" e , , y� -__._...,.z-___._ "' � ' I _ �� , � - -. ___._ _ _ . . _ .. , . .�.�... _ .�- , _ -- � _ � . _ � r��'°-.at'�._4 _.«... _ . � � '. .�Y ^ �..�a�.a��. '� � .t t :.. � � . -�� . —�-.� r+�r---�. . .. ..� .._ .... - , S ... y �_.._ _ . "_..._.. ._ _. . .. . , " . � .. . ,. . � _ _ • � !. - - .I ." ..•A 00��°�� '.2`�: .., ,y _ �' '`1 R . � .. �« �� . � , . �+Nh+ . � r � +:•a�'�� Y � �' ;.)"�" w '� ' �y '�. q�.3 J�: �l' e1F'• t � r�� t"7�+ Fa�t�� .S �.�:�� ,ir ��i y/'.s„n ",J .•+�A SbtlW_....z. M�/y , . � � . �i1 .�f167 �a � 4�IYw .�y �*'-_�Y./�� . Exhil�it 2 �,��,a(/�C�IO�EE.' CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 07/01 /2021 CASE NO. 210421006 ST�1"CLti1ENT OF VIOLATION AN D NOTIC�E Ol� 1-IEARING �yOi�CEte�•.. FL � Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncon•ected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30 Sec 30-32 and 30-43 2. Address and Parcel# where violation eacists:608 SE 10th Ave 3-22-37-35-0230-00120-0080 (35385) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros, 581 NW 30th Lane, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 4. Description of Violatio • �Jnsecured building, all the windows are broken out, no front door, large pile of yard debris 5. Date violation must be corrected by�ul 15, 2021 6. Date violation first observEd on or aboutA4/21 /21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you aze hereby called upon to take notice that a Heazing wil( be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 10th day Auqust. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City IIall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of la�v as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Deparhn . If yo il-to-appear at the hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. .Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magishate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhnent. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.1 I(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrativa final a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza. Exhibit 2 a � � � � 0' � �1 0 0 0 0 Q u'i � f1J O tZ.! O N ,� � 3 u �. � ;ertified Mail Fae� � :xtraSetViCe9& 9es(ctredcbnr,add/eaaeaopvopdetef ❑ Retum ReCelpt (iterdcoPYl a ❑ Retum R�capt (ebchordc) 4 ❑ cd�ur.a r�i �+�eed a��«y s ❑naw�sp�aw.aoa�rea s ❑ Adult Sl�ature ResMctod DelNary $ 'ostage 'afal Postags s�s �ent To =ire h._ -D--o -��-�� - - �-, ; �� U � � PI.�D�a� Here C'rCJ� `A D n Exhibit 2 ■ Complete items 1, 2, and 3. ■ Print your name and address on the reverse so that we can return the card to you. ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to: Jose Cisneras Maria Cisneros 581 NW 30th Lane Okeechobee, FL. 34972 A. Signature ❑ Agent X � �' " " "" . i ❑ Addressee e. _ ,(Pnnted Name) C. ,pate of Delivery , �, . �� ( 1 _ _ _ �, D_ Is iie' ery address different from ftem 1? ❑ es / 3r delivery address below: ❑ No {_ ' ❑ Friority Mail Expressm I j ��"j ' � � � I � Adult Signature O Registered MaiITM� � � �� 4Adult Si nature Restricted Delive O Re istered Mail Restricted � I ! �� ° � � � �': � � � � � � � � �� ?, �1, Certified MailO ry AeWery ; _�; -;,,, , �d�CertifiedMallRestrictedDelivery �I.;SlgnatureConfittnallonrm - � � � ` � � '� - - - � - � � -�- ❑ Collect on �elivery ❑ Slgnaturo Confirmation 2. Article Number (Transfer from service label} ❑ Collect on 7elivery Restrtetetl Dellvery Restr�cted oeuvary " 1ai1 7 0 2 a 2 4 5 0 ❑ � Q � S 6 9 8 51, 51, 7ail Restrlcted Oellvery : PS Form 3811 , July 2020 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt ; Exhibit 2 . �'r•'f �; ��H'��"-.`ii� �; �� . - r � �+`P'� ' �' '�' 'S' �,� ,r, "'1 , 4 � L* ' �� ypr�� t' . :t � �v c i; �,P� s y`� �� ,'�' � . SL i �#t�� '' a� � r �' y ` d�- � • ' v`' ,�a' �'` F, a- . �.y� S�i ` Y'`. . � -.!� l�' . . �c 2, s � Ya \ -+ � . (+ r�_.. i � i rg:a� ' ..+�J �'�` � �Fi��i�� .��+ ��f � �� - t�. M c ` +R'�." . . . � , � � i ;w � ,y � , *: r�I 1i +� �� ,' _ ,F.�=f" . +, .r '1 .� rv� � � yy � ' � ♦.r . � a, i i . �� 4�Le.y��..`�y" � � ': -•� .?i �i. T._ �.�I ,C"- �.;'� S 'S . � ',' i+ -r I V ,�Ic:��f�. " u - ' �.�",:-'i¢�T`' .- ,6 �"" a�i'. S e c�-> , fi �q �� ,_'_ .k' ��1. ! ��v,�^ o ff�' � F��A' a . • �. r� . ae _�w ,ti i Y.1� x�, �T �i. - �'= �� '�+ ? �'� 3 � ..-.;;r � � ,��- r. a �.�� . �� _ . .. ..ti� .. ��.. 1 .y� , h . � 4�. 1 °7 T •• s , . � _Uibib- . ).y;�" , � . � �.F' ' . . " � _ c'' .,�,E e.:. i�:. r s. r' x � � } . ', . � . - �: �. � { '� `;C,.� � . . . �.s. `:�i , ir _��. � 'a-r"��`� �� , � . � : . , - ,y . ,. �.T' �r rr ;_ - . ! .,,. . ;».. �,� � sM':�:� •,y�K• .. � `¢ ,i y . , . , . , ..� � ;.� '.p: > 1-a „ ; --r�i. � � �y_ - " � �_9 � O�lIl1��J//�0�� 0 � �6 ;.�: �e� wr.��:'. � - A�y�n � ��''� I'ir' . -.. . � µ .. . .� � , . - .. . . .. ,�� . .'1,' . . � . ., ' '. .. .' "' '�• .. .. , . � . � ' , . � �" ' . . . . "M . ' ' .. '� , . . " .. .,. t'� .. ... . . . •• .�� . � � � .. ... . � �. . - . 1 - , ¢� . - .., � , ,* .. .. ' �� _ . . ' ."'", �. -�� ..�� . � . �� k- .. �n�^y � . �'..,`� ,.r. ' . '��r $'��J i ,�'r. '�: ''i.� -�n.s. >.Y� . _ �... i}�- . .N'y L �' i+� - ' !l: �-� ��i:�dv , .: a - ..r � �.'r,� o -�`'`."d , - - 'X„ � r ., ais .':,�� ' . _ � .� . �„ € �` , ` �, ' - . � �� c � �.a,�6 � a � � •. 'c.si! � �, }'- S _ : x.�i '� . .o�.. .''�.r ti' � " .'. �. , s- . �� . - -� • . . . ... .�.. � n +i ii. � .. � � � � - . . : .' . . . � . . ..� , T � . _ - Exhibit 2 1 i �' �� ` � �*' :�;+�'„ �. `, ^ '�s� - " "�' . .. _ - 7`e►.. �h - ,� �► i � . � _ . i '�: � � . �� ..ma. .,. , Q � , � `'� �.� �� '�' , �.,._ � ,. ._..... , . :;* � .. . � ._.. ' �ti : . y.:= !� y� • „ � � .. _ ..l 4 �+ �'i � ' e. . . � �t,�.... _ � _'' , t_ ._, - _ � , — . . -- • . � '" � f� .+: � f , t,+ � .. . . � � � � � : � '. , ' i s.. ` a • �. _ � . _p. , . ___. . _.. _._.,. .... � / �` . . . . . �� p�� .. � / ,/�� ' � . . ,,j . � '� ' � �� ' �g��.��}�,� , %��'� .'f�� . �'� � 4 ��': �' � � �.��1 4� �fy��- -. '�� A4�': R � , r ..Y+ F1` ��i ," . �r. � (r� , � � � � - � .� r'a '',. iR. '� * F ��` � � � ' y�Li ^., . Li , ° � 'J 1r �, ' � ' , y `. +. P'�,�'� S�.t P�•',�l.y'�,,�1�'�,•'°7� ��``� p . .gL' . ,.r! '�d, � � �fr '�t 6:' : �,� . � S n � �,� A . � �•��1� � p � ?�,�- - � �� '.r �� { ,'yt- �� .,5 i9% ,- . . '� •.. !.4';.i"a.'i�`Y�ia. 1,�1�'R� A• q; / / �� ' �f,��, y�1 /• '�i '°+n� ��1�i� `t"'� f'�'g � � p�fiF `�� - a�� r� ..,. ., ,,�, ,� ' �'�� ;+.,.� `. ` i '.�'�+. i� ' �'. , f� c��.�� ;:,��, �, ,. ,-, . ; � ` �'' � \ � " � d � _ . . :,o 1,; • ,r ,, . . f � / � � �'" .��. �� l' . ,% �i � t �' ' ' ' � �i*'� j'�' 'i'`�a "= : �t� '� , �+� � � ! �� . w��;� . S � ��r _ c �+s,�� JA� � �' • , ��w , ..:�i "�:�.�"� � . 1 � :*,`r",a,-�-+: , ,. " �x �P'�t, , � �� r1"i:. �� '*.r +�i � � �b �� t��, � a �. � sJF �7�ii c � � . �N 3� s,� �iw . y� �c.- �� .. . . i s.e 'rr • t�ryr/�,'E :' g �e !�`, �,� ';c ' ' °�'}� *lq�a .+. !`is' t tu�' ' �.• t �°,. . ,•'� ~ *� �� . . � `'r/ 6�'. . ; ��.� .�f� �� .T ��`. ..�., . �r�'.,+u i l' � r � r� I � , � .i . � ♦ �� ( .yy� )�� . � . . `+� � � �:ljl�,T� }7ti :IL"'��' ��!'� ��. , � ,� _r� ��:,.;. ' :�i .&3"�Y�� + �Zi''� w' `` *� �� o i M y � +s i. ... . 1 /�t i 3 �,,it` �,�;J? t� - • �s�s ��,/,� ��`1{ � �Jll CSI:KS� � � d �c1 l! ) ♦ _ � � � 3� -� I T �y �. � 76 ) L � I i - '� ` �,� !, i - � � � j R� f 1. t �. .. ,► i. „ �. 4L S! � A.. �y� .-7: . � i IR:, 1 . � ir.' '"��'�:ls"�� 14�f:. ..t ��M.��O A h► ',� s1 w��x r D°��{ t �� ir"rr i t�'e�, ��f• �i�,�rR+'�';�'��y.��, � ' }� ,..i'"�4'�''�'S..�.' � . _.. . _. y#�� .� _ . t' �!, i ��"� . 3 f�:i < ..�tt�� !�s,l .�" .�`�"'`�; -iti1"� � y ryI' � s �,,� x�zi �� 4 � . . ��,�• � �..` .�Va Vii'. R' a � v � .......,......�..�,..�w...� � .r......... E + � �. ,��_�'M �`��' t, ' � � . - , 4 " � '� 'v"� , � �. �:� „a� � � �� ``��SJ �° �� l� � e �v `�+�.�r . "� � . . f _ . . �i, . ,f`J.,, � � ^,�- ; « � �: �, , +( �� •�L'� seai�" � � .f� i.� '�. "�""""r"w ' Exhibit 2 - f .�� .� J; N •� �p ��' , �r ._; "�..,�'i� � I .. � / - ��r .y 'Y � ej{} � �q ` .ls.t�\��,� i � ' �� `�� 'Z � �""*' ,;'`��? � �", i6� «�! �` ' ►� �_ � . •`�j .., r ..�.��`'� r ` � � � , r.; � r, � � :. .� . �• � ''� a��.a�. : . p� , •`• ; � . �; � r ,,+M � ,, �� "s --' �,, � , s � � -' � . � 4;;` it�r i"�?;� �its 4 �'t�,tr"7 F' ,��+ . 4' ' +fiV „pe- ,rg.�r e '� .�sf . . ' . 3 .` r� + 1 � '` � `� '+ K � ; 'P , a` � ' ,'�� .: r+��' } . 3 y1 k' ` ' � :S��W,t . .., , _, r, � � �� 1�+: �� w4 . , . . � , � �p �,` � � - �. J�` v'.&, <sa �v , `� �` , 4 ,,�F y` Y'} � � ;��rt.i�` ,� ;� ,,�� , \r � . ��.. '� . � i � � .! i �•i� B 4�n. �r4 ,�3�� ; t �, .� .��e r ,. � � ,. . �Tx� ' `''':, t .�''. � � ..a7S+'� ". . ' � >. . .. .: �- . � ^`� �9 ••d�: �y�(' , � �� 7��, i , 1�-'i�e , ' �, , ,� - � • � , : � "s ;� ,• :t ��: . 07l•tl�t�°�DZ�� l i� �� y ,� r . ��. �� , ' R � � - �. ,� ; , . _ � � _ �� '•iY .. .-� -.�� e'"� ..�. '- . . .. . e ' . +'� - ; . . o �,.. � �. � - �- +� - = . , i .. .� ,r ?� � � ��,. ,� �� ^'`''' *;;. +.�.w. . -�:i,�M x � .. _ �, � r. - � � w.+k,. . ., � '�. � . tR,� �s�>v�.' �nr�; . . `�.: . _. . "'�^-� __ ..� -.�a� . ""�- . ,« , . . . . . '1 � " . . � � ` .. ,.. ,. . ,.._ -' � . .��. _^+r�:tr�:..Y.m,... � ,. °i'.F+w �'Fxin.. • �y� .,... - .. _ � . �� "` �� , .t � ��X, - �� j _.. � _«� � ,�. ,w. � � � .. ,. , �. ; , . . ,. , . . _ �r s , �at , .. �,„;,; „ _� _ �,,� , ,,� , : � ., _.. � .. . .. , :� . �' , . _.. ._ . �c.� ��.u�r,�, „re.rM : ., _ . . . , _ . „ .--..,s�•�. _ _�, _ ... --- . __ . � , 4 ,._.. _ , , _... � � _ , . . _. . __ _ .� _ •'� . <s . - - ._.._. -,. _ , r , X , _ _ ,.,. � - - . _ : , - '�-,.— - .: . ..._. _ � � ,�� _...T _ .---.- _ . � -.� - _ . . . _ _,. _ __. _,_ _ _ - - ----- -�---....,,�- , _ _...._. _... _ _ . �,. � _ � , t� �� •"r-ms • � {i"�'C'!'ar'e---....--.�... �,.�,�,..,.�,.,.,.,r....�,..� ,__ .._ ;t3 . � a '��+- .r,�„F"�^-,►�,�'1•.• ,�+,q�l' � a, : . � ' � - _ ��,"�, �,'li�� ►,�„ �',.�� ,� �� _ .�� - {- O�lO�sJ°D�� 0° , . .'��,,.�._, ��''-t"` ,� ,: �: . _ . _:,. � . ,�, ,� � . _ �,.� . ��°�'�,°�►.�^� '�'`�``�;�"�}t "� ` ,�'� �" �'�� ,� � -- y�" :+ � � � � , w " " . . .-u �.. � �:�:, .� :ay�rrrc � � � _ , , ... �.i�.,w�we. . , ��:�. _,�...---. ..�.::.`_ "w Exhibit 2 , � . Y� >�_., � .� a t � ` , ' �� '� w, A ��;� �'� ika� +�► .� ' v. �: .�.' �� z'�� r�„� " � � � �''��, t^ �� .. _.,.... f� �. ��t9r ..a �-�� , ._ - . _ 1c�. . "G„' ; - - _ .. • *' . ' k.�. y�•� ,6"+aY..F . . � � , . . • . . ... . �- ,. , � ✓ ,:�� 'kr»"', !� s�,,?.' 'ny � �r+" i .rc� � * ` I s,�, _ . � ' ".` �; : 'T` ' _ — .` '�, � _ '� • .�- '` �. ...� . �,'Zd"-n +' ` �.�+C K � - iK... '"�r� e . _ ' . "t � .� ..,._ . . r�-a• . .:f �w;. . . � � d ' �e. s� . ' � � � r`.j .,-.. . +r ` �'a.} w � . ' �" _ .' -.....�,� + "'z' �'�-�' ��%%�°%%.`��1� �U�`2�-�-�.— - r. �-: ��.. - -.'a' , - ��''r� - 2- �. f � � — � , T," ~ , . _ ..s. � � � - — V � .�'� . � ' " ' -� � , s . ' � �ra . ` �: i"� � '' t �t4 �,r �.*`�9 f' + : .. w� � ^. Nt. , ,�. „�.. ��, �'f "�-. .' k iF ` ';.� y .4� �:� ,d �r' ��' �� ;'.p � ��''�, ` � yr � �. +. ��F , y�j .. y ~ � j• , ��I , �'�y�'••. ,.�i,. . C .I .. �' � _ / � f"ir , ��, q w , , � �r � . iy$� .�, �� y ,�'' �." , 2'�..- ��,�.,�#.�� W ��,Z��..�.� .�..� �� x�� + y;. , � 9� ."�' " . ,�t � � "F` „'�p,, �' �� S.�:L" ....-,- ...:r•.,ww�� "�...�.,. �y�.=" � r.�i� ��K�� y ,t, �� € �`� � � � �.�� . � s � i .k ,r �yy�F, '�« s ' j'�� .."��"�S' ',t � M.;�. . ;�� '� J f ? � �Y. {� ,�`,. �;�� a�1R'.«h�', "`x� � �+ 9� m::� ��,. . �. ., . � - . ,.a►+Jw�«,.w � ... . .. . , , . .. . ' Y, . ,P`�` . ",r „�»" . ` � .. ' . � � . . " � ,' . . � i . - �t.W. ' . w . . <.. . , a ,:. . �.... � , s. .,. . � .r �'��' . . � .... � .. . .. . ... . .:.. . i ., . ... .+. . " ' a✓ : ` , . � ._s` ... �. !�. � • �'V:=. � ..JV..'M�k .y ' T�+' ' _ � = +.'� x$r _ v.. ::. + ,+�: �, 1r, *+'� att� . �' . � ,a, �, sc ,, Nf� � �i a. A..�� r . . .,'x ,.r _: �nA M~ •,;,w r � �PiA�N .'e- � :.%1'wW"4 ,� , ., r,,i' . . : b"„yM-t"`,�',�`�o. 'iwwM�#` �s �r-d`'m.�„� •a;r .�. ` �z � ,� ., +.a . }f r'v ��^— '� w!--.. ..' � � . Y . �. . � r� Y r+v 1"'" ' v.b^' � ' • , „ �,�j >�'if' ,�,. �Ywr, .�r . � � ',S � ' ,y . . ��'1� y ' F' - ' � r � Y� � `� • , n;x � � ' �t�„ '�4�;.�'� ` � "A� ..F:� 2y+vY' � o�_� ,� y �t. ,y�y 1�+W'a 'TM,:2�a.� .. '.,r �� "��-. �''� . �� • =•u� � �Y�' '5� t .. ' `7P'..�.i � ' � :t- " ' . , . ., ' � � :r� � t'i f ! .� ti � . ..•t . . � � . . �y,�a` '• . . � .::Wytl �,�.' � Wt%:�` ` V. �},� . . �:� .i�r � j�,'�' ._.�h' „w �)nrnl �rjq ,�(� � y�y ' p V tf,. " , ik� �. F _:o,. r -. • � � ' � °o � � d lI.LSU(5 U � � ° (5eJ ��~� k < w .� . �. :: +�, aa s. y . ��,� '� .�. ' . . `�'eq i '" � " ,. . . .. ' ti� .. .. �:" - - � _ . .- , r � . �r �i� � • r � a < <• �9,�, � . � � � �� f �R �^.r4 � �,� 5 jA' , + k... �' . . .y ' � F , Z � w+ �, �'�,� �.s -�-�-t�m •d°R`�^ J �� „M'i"� � �R � _ t� � , � y, '� 1 P, #�M '�1 4 �� IfM � • y � � ., . :r"' ' . _ ��r , .:.� . . �.r, a .. . _ ... � v - .. m:Cs.y^L �xhipit 2 ..«.�.�- .._ ;,. r oo00qD�� 0��6 � ... :�r _ . - � � a � , . ; ' � ' ' � ,' .. r as . ,�}_ _. � ` , .. � .... � . ... '° �. , •' .' . . , .. � „ � �� , . . . iP. . . . -, �:, •', . . . � .. _�M_ tr > .�. �_: � � ,r v:�,».df". , .. � . ; . . , .. » °.. ' . . . r.,r -.- .. ,.:v _ Y•.: ��.k�...,-.,:-��.4"�9R`,:o.�'3�, :��r��^,�� .b ...•r �;-- y�.� ^�s,. ,..:.....io.c..a.;cf4�..a6:A;,s•. � �- � . , `�,SC'�'R�:�I'�N�S3i�ii: _�Jl�I�:.�e��'�s_ ia��-58�ir.��.��.r+c '.wS�a.�.e�;',�;-W�. : ..r. --.`�.S a ,'7 {�. . ,�� ;T \ t � + � y; � l V '�� u r��,'rt 5 _ ..+ . h , � e! � � '� � ' { � �' � i 1t�� i "« � .r ' JA , ; > � bti¢ � � �'; � a» a� 14 � �.,�� ';" �t�� " r��, , '. 9x �� r . � � , h � - .ua t'! ��. � '.� `I�'. .�� d 4 �i. �,ii� .'� ^„l7��' �x� � ��.�. �oR+:'' � ,e^. e �'� 0 4 ;b�� fi �,,� � ' �. ' .. �. ��` ,�' � t, � i,�ai`F l��r ,� �i�� iia� , • - ' ;,. 5 � � , � , ;�,r� a �� 1,� �+, A ,; • � , ; s . � ,��.�4r '�SI� � � ^�'��! "" , , 3+.�� ,w,�' ; ��. � � � p � P� '. t �y f � � � h�`�; v!� �, , ^�r, ,K ; �' �r" �! n�'�- ' 1 � � > ��• 'y�;.,' ry�� , �F�, ` ��'�'��p+ 1-.,-��"'�a /`.. �K� S�-��{f„�� L+l��,� ..� �.r. �LY�;-&+�y��' ` +.�;.�1 �y � }q ., . : .. S � S 4 w . 't� � , � !Cj{� � , � F t�i � rl 1 �fw �: �� . � , rr k u y . , � � � i ` � 6 ,1� j \�y � .. G R�� :i . t��l ��:r �'�y� � � ,. . �� \' � `� ;" Y O , ` ! ?�� `.'i u �,-4+, ' �,-�'` ��& �;f �� -'�� ,e' � �� . 1 � �� .., � � i � ., �,.. , .. , ��,� , ��, ��,i � � 1 � . r � g � , � , � � . �� - ��s�•:�a�.► �.;� ��i. � �.t, �� _ ft..-•�-�' � � S,. � •, t � ,.. , � ,,, � *�.-. � � i , � ,� �� ..�..�� - f- :. ,.� , �, } ' ' � � �� "„ , r ` 4 i� 4` � .. .yc �, - . .. . ..w. - . U':a..,;, �4µ� f � �( � !� ,,' ►.�� +" � '� s;� : ' �d;: � �, � ;��',� . . .. '"„a w"','V�+N"h, ia�t.;-a3'" ,J" ' .. . �'c�','..�'w''��'�f,5,..:� .'s�. .� f �t C � �mit� . *n . y�, : �� . . � . ,��y� ;� V 4 � R, r �� "� . ! � , . ' . . � .,_ •. . ��. x ,� C ��j � . . , i� �. �'� /�� . . : , . �" ~L �A '� �. �1 � ..e+a . .. . � , +u� - . . yt d!�� ; .. . :.,� r ` . . . - *. . M"lk x �:. . ?. • ,p ` , a...�• , i � . ,r :'5r ",7�C' ;r... . . s. ..'.;�r;t,,. '"+: , '` ,�.,. . , � . �. i � � _ �; ,..w "7.;:;r `�4t_'.l., � � \ � � > . . .. , .r; �.;. �e �'-r^` - -�"'" � _ ... �'.r* .: " .y .: . . �, ',i� I y a r�E aF? �, .n�i �- ` � . �� )" � 1 � � "' � . � �.�� „X. �' ' . ? +`fi�+ti.�. ^! � ,. r■ �1� .� ' � ¢:;- . ,`�� Y � �j � / ' �- A } a . pe , ''� � Y � /-!� . . . . w �ti.'�� .: � d ti 9� � :.� • , , �' " 0 0004��0�� ,Oa�`. ,_ r r , _ ^ � d � _"1,a,,, r � w�t � a" •v - V • t �, � �� , � � _. : � ;� �;� .�/y ��,� � �.� .� ?-� i 'F � �.. � � 4 N; 5Y '. � � . 1 y� ..f i `��jn i p � ' . . _'� wes. rr �: r "" ,r ` . ..".- �,�_ � � „c t � .� a J�.,.', '� ,' "...`'�'::K+ „� _^�',mys�' _... :-+_. .�.,� , _lt� _ �+'�.�• t. �;� Ws, � �_: � ., �; . r ' - - . ,• . � � �- - -- ��.��'` . , - ,�. - _ _ .. _� . .. �_ _ . � �, , :� . �v�`w� ' l� �'.�' � . .. . Aw:.l J � .' � • 1 ... 1` �� `� ` ... _ . .__..�._ - . r �y� .,.r � � � �" . � . r . . _._,. ,,,, .__ �:, �I�. � �I. _" M1 _ -��.� . _. .. �. Ff" - •J� � __ � e � ... _ ._ . _ _.. _ .. . __— _. ' --- __ _ ___ .�yr _- _-� - - -- -- — - --� y rY +�+SY�'�°?i� -- . . .. i r .: � . * � . � _ _.. --_.--._.--_-'_ _._ _.._.. .._ __.. _ .._. .------._.— .__ ._ . .. , �- - - - � _�''gr, __ ._ . - . ,�.+�: Exhibit 2 .�aA --� ,..-.�. ..M,;x. .�,, .,: ,_-----�, _ __ : �. ,.�._._._._ ,�._ __:�.... -.. - --T---- w„�..�,w --=--:r-�:,; �A +j � _ _ .. _ _ ` 0 o004/I�0�9 90��6 � � ` � S fi i � , ��, _..�. . "'� ��4. � ,..�;r� �se :��,> �` �`ir.�,� �� `� ..�!��g ��+,�r� `��i�l,�� .�.a �`" � . - +�, . �s.r +4 � ° l +S • � -��II� -- � "e6r '� , .s``,�. . � �, � S�„�' • s^ , ��: �� -• � P 4 . „�. � M1 �+ � �� . � �*� � ir'�'eM� , �. {� ; ""'' ,k,�. '4 �` }1�, , , � •, �• : �' S n �� . ' ��. f/� , ; , yK+� X l7 '��,,, ,�'�, � - _.�` . �„� f'-+ . � ' - ! � ^.., . ,,, ....�►�.�'A�4��'t M :r� r 3 � � , � � 1 . . . � . A. ..' "- r , _s ' , tgr.:i , . '� :�,y�d'. `��., ar -�r'� � . .�`.".C4;.' ' . .. ' � . , . . .. .: �..; p,..- .. _�.. .. . - t � �r�a". . . � . . . � _ , • . .. . � .. . . ��n � ' . . . . . . . , �.. ��. � • -.. •� e �. . .'_ ..,'I,, . .. ... y . • T t,.t xf T � :� { . ._ �... .. . �+Ae� �'',w t �T'"t'R w.,,, . � • � . ' : � ��y v. � � .. e � ., � it � �� , �� y - 1 q'y' � v • � ,.++YrYt "I. " �� ' Y4y� _w._� ;w 1'3� � �i' . . .. .. ' , ; v« ",. / �l � ' ' - � , w. � � `� � . �,'�4 � ' 1.. . . . . � 1` ti 3�. . � / S�� it,�. _ �. ' � A'. .f � ^�"�•'�"rp�-+'� ' - .. '� $� .� �I, � _ A . �� J„axyy _ �.. f r. � . . e .. � ^ � ' . "� �[� ' 14�� - . ,. �','Y� r'.�{hwJ, T".,' 4�. • • � y d �'!1 v . . .. . .. ' .�, :,� `�.j, � 1.. ' ' ,�� i � J � '� �-�r�`�.. . ., I , .�` � � � ' . . ` . .. . � .�. 1!Y . _ .... ' . • �1 -'� .' � , . c � _.' � - . WG.. .. � . . , .. Y^ .:_^ .. . � . � :. ._ ..r � . . . ' �, ru - � - � � '� J t �J' ' -.� �!'n r -ti` � �U �0�� L9lJ�' �f . .'' .t. r4i�"°L � 6 `. ♦ .Mi'�" b .•f y _a d ' O O 0 O O 4 O �i r wr t � . �F ��.: � ♦` if!�f� � i .:� . �+, � . $ t �u 4 !G y� � ?" . ... � a ... � �,. � . � � s e��,� 1� � r a� "'''ra�» e �r,'1#�'� (t � e t V`. .� w� y ly� � �_.� �' ��.: .�` - .,r� .+=�d�t'd'�7r�4�, r,.'�,+1 ,`i� tq,;,' 'v9;.. +. v��IB . . �;, .�� ,-- a:..✓ ,�. . .� � T� ��t��y,�.6 'w.�� s .. '. ;. , 'J , . . . : • -.. .�„ , „�. . _. �,a�iE . �� ,::�- , . � ; . . . . , ,� ' ._ _w. ..• s . _� ,.� � �i Exhibit 2 54 VII. NEW CASES CONTINUED B. CONTINUED: A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Mrs. Sheila Bradley on July 7, 2021. The property was still non-compliant when inspected on August 4, 2021, as the debris/junk in the yard remains and the carport stil� needs to be cleaned/organized. The City recommends a fine of $50.00 per day, to begin 21 days aiter the date of th'ss Nearing, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona found Case No. 210125011 to be in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41-Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautifcation and imposed a fine of $50.00 per day plus a one-time administrative fee of $50.00 should the property owner fail to come into compliance within 21 days after the date of this Hearing. This property was also found to be a repeat violator. C. Case No. 210318010; Charfie Merry, 404 NE 8th Avenue [Legal Description: Lot 12, RIVER RUN RESORT SUBDIVISION, PHASE 11, Plat Book 6, Page 33, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Code O�cer Smith reported that the property came into compliance o� July 30, 2Q21. No action on this matter was requested but was noted for the record to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. D. Case No. 210421006; Jose and Maria Cisneros, 608 SE 10�" Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 8, 9, and 12 of Block 12, WRIGHT'S FIRST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 1, Page 13, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property and 30-43 Public nuisance. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-32 Accumulations on real property and 30-43 Public nuisance for large piles of debris and an unsecured building that all the windows are broken out of, and no front door. The properly is a repeat violator. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on April 21, 2021, for the June 8, 2021, Heari�g. The noticed was received by Jose Cisneros on April 23, 2021. Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Cisneros on May 5, 2021, who stated the debris had been put out to the road for Waste Management to pick up and the building would be demofished as soon as he had the permit to do so. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS ce�tified return receipt on July 1, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. The notice was received by Jose Cisneros on July 6, 2021. The property was inspected on August 4, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partiafly compliant as the building remains unsecured, �o door and broken out windows. However, the property ow�er has made progress by mowing the grass and removing the yard debris. The City recommends an extension to the next Hearing be approved to allow the property owner to come into fu{I compliance. Based on the evidence provided, Special Magistrate Azcona ruled to defer Case No. 210421006 to the next Special Magistrate Hearing to allow the property owner more time to came into full compliance as progress has been made. E. Case No. 210628005; Salry RR C/O CSX Corp, Highway 441 North [Legal Description: All of the Railroad as now lying and located within the City of Okeechobee]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-33 Owner to control excessive growths and unsanitary ponds and swimming pools and 30-43 Pubfic nuisance. Code Officer Smith reported that the property came into compliance on August 4, 2021. No action on this matter was requested but was noted for the record to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-33 Owner to control excessive growths and unsanitary ponds and swimming pools and 30-43 Public nuisance. August 10, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 4 of 5 Exhibit 2 e,��iCyC'EC�106(.'@ CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Jose Manuel and Maria Custodia Cisneros 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 09/03/2021 ��pOLICE�� . :_�:. _ p� ' CASE NO. 210421006 STAT��IlV1�F,NT Ol VI�LATIt)N AND NOTICE Ol� I-IEf1I�NU Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30 SeC 30-32 and 30-43 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:608 SE 10th Ave 3-22-37-35-0230-00120-0080 (35385) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in chazge of location where violation exists: Jose Manuei and Maria Custodia Cisneros, 581 NW 30th Lane, Okeechobee, FL. 34972 4. Description of Violatio : I'Unsecured building, all the windows are broken out, no front door. 5. Date violation must be corrected by�Ct 1, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about.4/21 /21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify comp(iance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you aze hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the � 2th day October. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are eniitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Dep nt. n�ail to appeaz at the hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absenc � �. Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magishate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon wluch the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes aze for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhnent. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shail be filed within 30 days of the execurion of ihe order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un paztido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrativa fuial a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la fuma de la orden que se apelaza. �xhik�it 2 � Domestic Mail Only ' For delivery informaUon, visit Our website _r3i1'r-R?3.�1L�?'7i I ❑ Rahm Recalpt (harticopy) S � ❑ flecum Rece1M ielecwnic) S � ❑ Cettif(ad Mell ResMcted DOIWery E � ❑Adult Signa[ure RequueA 3 � ❑Aduil Sipnaturo Restriotetl DNlvery S � Postaga U] g m roca� Poarags ana Fess O S Sent To � ��__ �J - ---• -- p SYreet"--- o., or A(7 $oz o. j� r� ��l VI , � �t'�' � , s�. -�U { �%� ti�' u� Postmaik �� ___ :a ,r � „�.�� • �i'.; , eit� 3. A. �: P� ir�i your name ano aadress on the reverse X so that we can return the card to you. � Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, � B� or on the front if space permits. i ��i� o,r�ie�<or1 r�• �- '._ti Jose M. Cisneros `''"-�`' Maria-�i,sneros - — 581 (�i 30th Lane Okeee�iobee, FL. 34972 ❑ Agent �� ❑ Addressee by (Printed Name) C. Date of Daliveiy addrass different from item 1? ❑ Yes ;r �elivenr address below: p No i ❑ Priority `Atil &press� �� I i ❑ Adutt Si natura d Registered Mail � I'If I'� �'i� I') I I�f I ! �� i, � � �� ! i' �II ( � ��I ❑ (�duli � 9nature Restrictc-d Delivery ❑ Registered MailTRes[riCt�d � �Certified Mail@ C�e�ivery �ayg0 g.�.Q'� �j ��.'- _��.�`-j 1 1 4�� L Certifled M2it !�astrint d oeliv�ry i�,.:turr, Raceipt �r,r 'I ❑ Cotlect on Delivery i`�1erChandise ^ ^-'- ' n Delivery Restnc �. �� '-. � 5u ��9��ature ConfirmatienTM 2. AItICIe NumFAr ?rancf r{�.r ^'^`-" na�� 'CI'Signature Coniirmation 7 � 21 � 3 5 � � � � 1 51 I� 7 7 3 6 5 nau Rdstri�ea oE��: -_.� ;�+��cav o�rvery � (over$500) ; PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 uemastic Retum R=��ioc ��---------.___�— � _______ .. __— —_ _ - -- .�... . —- , � �,� �s� _ _ _ _-- -_ � j � ( � , f � , � ;� - � t ;� � �a � —'� i . ,.1 ` t�.- � _ . Jl+�" �� ir� R . . _ . . . .... ... . :• 1�' ... ..�.�... � �If'"�-ti'' __:ar .�+.......,...... ..�� _..-..�-_. -....�v.cr� . . . _ .. _.. ,. . . �_ _ ;�, . . . �.�.a _ � . �.� � , .�:' a' � 1 i��`r` � �: .�, . ��w-�'� ,i : ...�. . � , � _..J�ww....�....-.. �. .... . -. � . � �°�� =�U ''` �- a �.,,: � ��! . .. y..<,> :.ww.+�itri�s6��- - ' "� + � ' � �� ,. s' �"' �y_ Y `�'' � -` � .. L � - l � ' '�, a�. 'M'.,'��{.� ..�� r 4 � '�� j' . �'. . � >V,. . ._4} � . � .�y. y f ,,,�_... w'-ir .. ' - �,!�' s . s- `�i, s_� :- "'; � .. . ' � K �'? �� ' , �� _ .-r._� .�., -. , . .,.� . �� ... �,,; :'s.: .... '�_':� _ s�" �. . �� .�_ + � i � ^� � �� ,�` � � � � :��_ � ' � `�� :�;� , � ; �� L `,` , 't� ` �a.w.�`'��. . � ,3#,.2'�w�*. , b ::. ::_ ��*� /i 'fw a � �,��,�, _. __.. ___�.__ ". .�'C � �"��R:+:��'i �.��'se � �� = , . - �;.; - ?„�� $�. �. - .► �r�� A�� '� . T#. 11YIili��y`�LL f � ��csu iiii��% Exhibit 2 �,'. ` . . ; �� .;� � ��,x;'�-.- � : t -.� �: ti:; Sy�;�`�,�� -� � =_=' ----. �� .A . -- - .�... +- -- �, �'^� ,.� � , ,w�,, � .� � , �� t �1i` . e!►' � ,��= , �'� 4 �. r `` � . ' 7 �� _ �� '.' _ � �' � P � „ . �/� �' � i.. _'a' T � ��. • . . ,.�,.7; . . . -un. , �� 1 ',. . V � •'f N. �'.! ��,_ . �`r ti ' _ . �' f, +. ( �, � .� �:�:�' �"" ";�q�� ;�` w' , _7x.. S , 6 � r,a . , . � ; : . �. .�, �}� .r�Ya ��5` �Y� '� � ,� �y .� � . `.�,�, F . .x�4� � y 'f tv� �'''r'' ' ~:..-...,:.• . _ + - d.�� € � iP`. �:.:a�.:....W«. ::�"�_ _' .�r ��`�� - - _ „ . � o ° O�UII �O�i) � � � �Cl _._. _,__ --- '� � � �� Fz` �► " � � aiM,` ,� �a war�:.p�, . �:Ye. 0' �" - A-f . i4 . � �M .F' � � X � � • ' � �' ., � � �t '0. ; � _.� a.�i��x . . , 5 Y'r� f� Y Y:: ,$ y,F,. h .� . ti�l'�.A '��,p ':: ' '. `� �^ i�i �� ,x�• ,, . T 4 d.t'nrca u'+ n) � ,y �.. I �1* � �-`�{� ��. a `�s ,.•�L �. . . e''�'� ' � , . . �� t �, � i � �. Y � �� :. J��, k� �4� � �.� �`: ! � � �.� �: �� a s . ) u+d �� Ga ,� y+�'' .. ,r � �• : ,i � r� �`t e t � �'". �,. P � rtt � '�f�r:, c �,��.�+''c" � � ^+F�; ...� 4 �:� � �, ; & �'� °a�?- � � S+� � �� z * f� i 'ft'�,�'�� ,� z �:� �.`*,�� c��„�� ? � . . +. . . '�` � � .��. c'�.` `utr v? ��, ,.,p. , � : . ,.;� • � �":t 1'1�%SFF . :� y� ��.: �:y "f'A . ,''B,'��D,r�� ;< b.r ,! .'�!,�tt�'�:� _ �.s.� . .. _. ,. r �� +�. . �,.'�I', � �... � . � : h'r^"^ .. .. . _ ��-�^�ww.wM� y.'^�...Wy ��PqR'f t �� ybY � �1 �(�1C � •. � �°�� L Exhibit 2 r �''S'` �k� � 4. �,� +, i �� »r'"'�try � "�x�� : �: � . � �, �,. • T �*'� ,� � �� : � ,� �.'.,� �I �- ,+�`" � � g . � � _ 6 :t%�� ` \_ '�� '� � �•�.�.- `wW ' � 7 � x .. --��w.p��is. ,..y�[. � - �.:.�A � ty�:. : � 1 i ' � : i - - �� J "^� � 3- .� � yyy� -.... - • � _ ♦ � �" �". : �`' .� � . r,i,.� . . "�4w�s'.�My�, `'t .— _ .. .. � _ ��, 1.� . `j . . ,^ �, °`-"" -?a� .._- ,.rt:.�'� ..� :n.-++ " ' . . ' .� �f .. � � "�. . .. . .. 'y�1-. � � - v j . � . - �. � � _ � • , W ._ �.M s�u ., � � t °� 66i 4 3 " 'S `�� " ha�,�#� ,�� *'�,� y�'��y � �'� a�'a epkp..�..+��,p�,1�Y ;�, �sq, ''��,� �Wn�Me�'�y .,r.,�aw R B y� #_,.: �. �`� �". -�` 1°.K" �i'�.,y' ��t��1 ""° ..+b�p "i " ,.�° �M�y` r"'� � � � ^j��w . W �.� p VF i t 4� ' �,'�{'�'IP'� `R.f��y yRa� �/ 1��'s'{ p� '/�kl�` � �p(:. .. �y �� * �., f W ��I� ��"@'`� �y,M.M��"" R b��e'�nt. �! �� . '� ,�'an � :�'p�W�lti W�jj '��yr a'il�y'�yy, . t,�,y �y,� .�' b�' 'T_ ir µ,. '�i' '�'d�" � � =Ws". �r�,d1�4 �„�+ 51 r� aT' �'i°,�„!�,.�."�,°',�.�. � ��i�4��1 . r ,<.^.� �� i , . +4,.. .. � � �yx . > � rr� �".� �. ' �tX ��. � �' ' ��' r,�'�,� m ,'�`+.�'. •. �' �' w � ,y � . �. �' �, � � , ��, i�3,��,�� ' �" �i'.�, �a�� .a`'�;,�y�. .y � •, �. , ; a, � �� :: `+� �,�''-, M" "�;` , .?�,`^ ' ' Y .N ` +�"""' .� ;'q,�r "�' �••� x`b.`�4V� ,��:�' ,,y(�'� �' w,, � a . � � '�' ,«r!�'� t. �� ,�M ; �`. a' �,p" 'p" �,' : w ��i r ` � � �� • . .�� : � r . �G m °'' � � , v, � c " `t" �, ; _ � �'� t; „#�y� ♦ *TY A..; N ' .'., ' ��,�o � � + _ �� , . �r. ''m� ^�,�....'+..,:. 'h•> ". .'�.i:8'� ,1�i _! ��l� _ ._�� .ti_�`7" �_,.dm _, 'S.'•a 1�� i� .'.i�-; . ,. .� ..��, . �.. _ �g � .., � 1� + � �,.�� 3 _ !�� ,.�,�` �` , , i �`"+i�'� �-� �, '� . y ,,; � � ' � � � "�.,+�� A � .. - , . , '1 � � '��. � .�� F � , . r y�,� . �/ �w.i+www " ' � � ;,�, � � � { � �' z .. ��. • a• (1 .�. ��e, �,�, : . . . . � k , JN'-" � � M1 ^ � ��-� ... . .. ' '�^`[ . m ' ..� �9`` �' '� t �.�A'+' '�,'� '�i.'a"' y+�..�. . t�.: ;i s y �w�ct�. ,�'- �.� . ' " .. w .. _� �'�� . "' ,,�r `�ra.��4S�' # i��y �" '+ �N��d�l� ��/ � � F.3 '� 4. i 4 4tl' *'� :.�a�i � :� � ��"� . , •R:.�'�` .*� ;� . � . �� . . P. - . ... y . �'�•4. � � g� � ' Y �..e� �� IrF` ��'� � � x."-' u.'. . .� . � .� r."•� ��;� . .._i,.17!'� ' ��Iw ^ �. i,„�. .r�..N. >ti. "� n. '�?�'' :°7. � � s " ,� .'•:Y^*+?��,1; ",q"..,:�r,a, �:«�, _ L i � �� „�� .."'`' �,�:< .. I � ��` .,��b.; . m � '� .�r. ,,� ' �� tl{� .r�R� ,��' y` � «��.# w..#� � � � w Fti ... � 7 � Hr *c': ti+i�.;+A w R' r 1X'��! 4yr�w.. w,�.� r,�^stir`I - .� , ..� �µ,`c..w +'. .,,, _ , . �'W11i',��::�"�yd� y,.r . � , .- . � ' �nt ,:qs,� , � M. t . . . . x'. �'�� p .•vt,�"' i' . '� �,� ':rr � �. .H� .m x � Y. �; « ��_"!- �» �;. . �ti a-�i_ . � _ . r� �• � l�J � lJ U OCSO� � il O� ��i1l�J Exhibit 2 �, " .�� :�� ` �„�,.�„ '��; , � - � � . _— ,� ;.,,.;.,.. ,� �;�: -� - �� . " �.. .':;.. ' �� - ",� ;,, `�'�� i" `th � ,. y . , . , . . , �:-.�y. , � r , � . +''� - �1 ii• � . , �� „ !�i"•;� '.l,Y'�'+ �y �`.v�� ,. � �. .. T,�S,��'�y• ^ *.�y,,�,��'- .. � .`''�.y�tF,'��.-.... � �' . 9000�1lI��9 0 � �46 ^ F` � �� ' �-., �.�� R�.. p �� . �� _ Tb ... � ' �, r � u:•4� �'�� + .I� . J.�'� w i V � �?� `..'.va�'. ! , "�. -�� s. t;.; � :'v ` '-� .' eY :�� i:s;� .,b�# � � . �. E " � T� { y �. * ,p�. ' F • _.�t� `` " ,-.il-,_'�, �� , �• ��-�� +%� ' ' � � .. _,,� _ _ � � � , �*�� r r: � � � �� - . �, „- �;� . �� ;� " ' _ � _. -----.. _..... �� . , . '�`'>�i �. �.. _'�� `� _•��:`t��"y"��Sr�:T,yY�" •.:,._,'�-,! r.� ` �j ]�-^� . I � � . • � • .� � > . . . - � - ., •. LT 7. �� e Y .. ,Sv .,'', �� ,.� .. , �t _ „4 . . ".� >e,��, ,..r,. � 9 .wY'�+ . � �k , -s.r:. . ,T#� �7 �/ .11�N . 'f . . � Y' ..,' rFY..;` ar. _ � i { �}' ,. �� , , � ��f�'iils"%�,1�6��•�_�d ' . . ,pr. �y, . � p„ j�p►, � t i�. � �- �� i�'g t� - • -y .�.,yr � � �'' w'�'►�.� J��F� �`,7Yy-� : � P ytF,�� ...M �� a � �°,., ,,. . s"'i' y � � Q�� ,i., � '��i �►* � � �'*.;�i d�e . ry if:'�.'� '' . � « .� C . � �.� ,� - � � a ' ; . - . � .. - *� -. � �J� - .M...,�n,,,• -'�: �r{'�ab nt: •:.,vyia.l:.-_ _ .>':�._ _. .. - , . . . _ . . �. . _ . . �il��".. . _ .. . �� " �- � - - �U�U�� 0 o a�� Exhibi��t 3 VI. A.-Exhibit #3 Case #210428014 Elizabeth J. Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror) Exhibit 3 Code Enforcement Hearinq October 12, 2021 Case Name 8 Number: Photos: See attached Is respondent a Repeat Violator? No Summarv: • Respondent was first notified on April 28, 2021 via Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing, received by KJ 184. • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of event Type of notice Date received Received by May 10, 2021 Code Officer Smith spoke with Kevin Carter the son of the ro e owner, ex lained violations. May 12, 2021 Email communication with the property owner Ray Carter May 17, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant, spoke with tenant ex lained violations, the tenant asked for more time. June 8, 2021 Inspected properly, still non-compliant June 9, 2021 Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Carter to advise that the tenants have made no ro ress from the last ins ection. June 29, 2021 Code Officer Smith spoke with tenants, inspected the property, still non-compliant, however progress had been made on cleanin u the ro e August 11, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant, disabled vehicles remain, and the ro e is filled with 'unk/debris. September 3, 2021 Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS September 9, Stacy Carre/COVID- certified return recei t 2021 19. September 20, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant. September 30, 2021 Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Moore and explained what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and that the ro e would be ins ected on October 4, 2021 October 4, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant as the disabled vehicles remain. Received an email from Mr. Moore asking for more time. He was advised thatthe propertywould be inspected on October 7, 2021 October 6, 2021 Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Carter, Code Officer Smith explained to him that Mr. Moore was getting the property back into compliance and that he was supposed to have the properly in compliance by tomorrow and that I would be inspecting the property tomorrow. He advised me that he would call me to make sure the ro e was in com liance. October 7, 2021 Inspected the property, still non-compliant. Spoke to Mr. Moore about removing the disabled vehicles from the property. He advised that he could have them moved from the property by the end of the da Reins ected ro e found to be in com liance. Page 1 of 2 Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror), Case #210428014 Exhibit 3 Citv Recommendation: The City recommends no action on this matter, but request it be noted for the record to have been in violation of Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance, and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Chronology attached. Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 3 Case #210428014, Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror) Date Event/Document April 27, 2021 Property Owner- Elizabeth J. Carter Grantor TR (Smitty's Glass & Mirror) 561-436-0395 chiefrc288 @ comcast.net Address-117 SW 5t" Ave Violation of CH 30 Sec 30-44-General cleaning and beautification, 30-43-Public nuisance and 30-41 Disable vehicle. Junk and debris on property and trash dumpster overflowing. Untagged/disable vehicle trucks and a boat. Photos in file. April 28, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed certified return receipt for the June 8t'' Hearing. Given 14 days to correct violations. Received by KJ 184. May 10, 2021 Kevin Carter the son of the property owner called and spoke to the Code Enforcement Officer (A. Smith) and explained that he has tried to contact the tenant about the cleaning up of the back of the property. Was unable to make contact currently. That he would be in town on Wednesday the 12th of May to talk to the tenant about cleaning up the property, and he will stay in contact with the code enforcement office on the progress of the cleanup. May 12, 2021 E-mail communication with property owner Ray Carter. May 17, 2021 Spoke to the property renter about the cleanup of the property. He asked for more time to clean up. Explained that as long he shows progress with the clean up the code enforcement process would stay where it is at. Property was inspected: Not in compliance, however the renter has started to clean up the property but still needs to remove the disabled vehicles and the boat. Cut the overgrown weeds and remove the junk on the fence line. Photos taken and placed in the file. June 8, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, disable vehicles remain and a lot of junk and debris. Photos in file. June 9, 2021 Called and spoke to Mr. Carter about the property and advised him that the renters have made no progress from the last inspection. Mr. Carter advised me that he would be contacting the renters and advised them that they need to continue with the cleaning up of the property. June 29, 2021 Spoke to the renters of the property and advised that progress was made on the cleaning of the property. Inspected the property: Not in compliance, however more progress had been made on cleaning up the property. More debris was removed. The disabled vehicle and debris still need to be removed. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 3 Case #210428014, Elizabeth J Carter (Smitty's Glass & Mirror) Date Event/Document August 11, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, continues with disabled vehicles and property filled with junk/debris. Photo in file. September 3, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the October 12tn Hearing, given till October 1 St to correct violations. Received on September 9, 2021, by Stacy Carre/COVID-19. September 20, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, disable vehicles remain. Photos in file. September 30, 2021 Code Officer Smith, spoke with Mike Moore on what he needed to do to bring the property into compliance, to remove the disabled vehicles. He stated that he would remove the vehicles. I advised him that I would come by and inspect the property on October 4, 2021. October 4, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, the disabled vehicles remain. Photos in file. Received an email from Mike Moore asking for more time to move the vehicles. Advised him that I could come by on Thursday 10/7/2021 to reinspect. October 6, 2021 Code Officer Smith received a call from Mr. Carter, Code Officer Smith explained to him that Mr. Moore was getting the property back into compliance and that he was suppose have the property in compliance by tomorrow and that I would be inspecting the property tomorrow. He advised me that he would call me to make sure the property was in compliance. October 7, 2021 Code Officer Smith received email correspondence from Mike Moore email asking to be giving another day while I was out of the office. I responded to the email once in the office asking him to meet. Spoke to Mr. Moore about removing the disabled vehicles from the property. He advised that he could have them moved from the property by the end of the day. Reinspected the property: In compliance, disabled vehicles removed. Photos in file. Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 3 � ��. ; _ �*_..� �� .r -,.—� � .� �_ �,, ,,..,, ._...,. . � R' ._...w.� e.�n-� .�-,.:r-..�',,,:.__ � ��11� -_ , i � i � / � �. -__ _'.�,... ... ` _ � r1r�., . A� � y - _ _— .��. � /' � _. �� t (o�goao � � �,,. �,.,...... .,. _ -- r..,. r- �R+�,M !'� �� f `� � _ . . .. • ,.-..�..�.. -� .�;._,t �,''� � � �' ,� , a ``� ;�l�j .�' ` i� `'h^;"'ti ` c a� �: .. /,. � — �#� x � >�� 4�� " .; - � o�.�. � I�t � �' �' � �5 �; ? -+-iD iR . �. > , '�� +� � . � _�_ _.. Y�— � �.l' � .a , _r- ` :i`F��; A; .- . .i �41 � . t t,}�.i `'.� 4e�� . . �, � �� 4��f � �`' e1 �� , s.'+, �, � ' •�� e� j)' � = �� —= �' +� � ~ A� � � �'. �; ;. ''�j�a � —_ , � , ,, : i,� . •: �i ^ �? �a � .! . �T�r�' �� ' � ' ;_ �p� � I � ;. � . 4 ' �� . , � � - T'!' ► �:!� 6 . • , . y� _ +!,'oi-,i � �.. � � .. � . • . - - � -- - - .. �\\a�S`�.\ � . , f ...m..:-=r.rfi�� ' ..—._-----�'-- i�±�l�' 1 ,`.,;` _� 1 i� "'! � .-- - _ - —�":...� , � j � ��'ir �'�i�� ilry 1 � _ � .. .' . � . � ' i ' . . �.1 �y fA��F ,� p` �. x �. �� '- ��. . ._. . :e t ��,.,-_ y� r y. ��y, � , • . .k . + ;� y' . 0 ° ��0�� - .. . � �;;.. � -- ' �� ` �� r'��-�.L�i�,�l' � .. .. . ...-. _�8...r �t- . . . Exhibit 3 i � � -- _ _ __ _�"''-=--� �E �.�� , ��s„� •• , _. �� , -- � � � � . s��. ',_ � �� ... - �� R� . �s �� _ � . .. , -.. .. : � 1 . .... � � j �;;.y.— �- �..�- � „�«�- _. _ � _ .... ,,,,�.--_ �� .�- _.a.�- �u „- � ,.�,�;•¢'�err�r �l�e.rin�ii� �a.c:.; . � �. - . . . . I�� . . . _ �� y x �� .�r�iG . � : ...- � �—.�..,�,�....,,;��1�'!f�R�� `+� ' i: "� � "�.b � . +.�' t'fy, r£�� , j . �. � � . {`'�t .:3 . r,., .�. .. F � �� .�'� .. 1 � '�E� � ,� 5`r.�,., r'f' �y. s� j '` -,. + -��`y §w£ '�_� y�+�A& '�� , s.A 8''ti�v�� .�F�a;r �.,��. � S. ��. 6',. '°) :� ��re.�e+www'y' � �.. . .� ,_ti.. . � . - '�. : . .� • -- . ..,,� "�� ' ia� t � �-,. , � � �� i�� . � r ' --�i� �'- r _ -r,�"`�.S ` � t_ . ' � a - • >/�� Al ��- . .."f �'�' , +� J s ,"` _�, "'� � . ��_ - � � "yr "� �''s''r _. _ • �,�� U� � 4i� `. _ t"s � ,y �4 i � � � . . , . � . . �� _ e Tw _. , .,`: � �p r, �¢+� -" _ _ _ 0" . ' � , ! � r �Y .r t`�.s ` ��'i ��k3'��il � �. � "� ��, e" ��,� ��!�i � ..i�'`I f !y j*`� '" . ' . R� . � ,� �� ` . � �i A i 9 �•�� ,, s, '*.. "Y.± .+' ' �-- � y j '� � � � �f� � j, . l,� ',,. � � . :l 3 r �/, � �'�:�"�...,`` � i y�.r!" ., y �� A�a�r ' �..e''�...�.. .,.. . � ' �f '-F � � , � i 1' b .!1' �k ��r�� +a' i+ ♦ � � � t ,, { .. v ,�p,�.+�, �� -�' _ � "� . �, . � < .,.�,. �, � I .. , F , �: .. , � � �`�?'_ , � #; , .t�t'bL`fi r` '_ f. i � �I �� ` ° �+�',w�9 ,. 1 . � �'� ► �t ` ' � ' � �'�, y' .. �A�a .� ftmm'"M�- � i� � ' . � r . : , • . � Mr� ��t �'r •'�iN� ~I , _� ; ' . .�. �,� � i ` <'�' ; . � � � �:►.��'�ri , ��'� � � t �I � � ....� �-w �f ��` �� `,1 o�' g� r �' � �� ` � i ��' �. �� r � �ws"� r,-,:; � �u .r ; � v., � � � �� . 1 ,: �� F � ��,,, �,.,,�_ � :.,�;.,,t ,� � � � ; ' ;. � � ¢� � fi � `` A � t'�`" + ~ ?� j , 1t :� Y�. �� i�.- R":�� .. r ',.{ .� 1 ,' f �'. �+.� `.:� _ , �i �' • ra � alY� ro + . � ' ' I Y.S.:. ,:.�; �, � � �; �� , .� . �� # f �'�'" „"^�,y+ i�� ,� ,.°-c� �" � I�# .�0�� r � .'� �...w;'�if�: � �� ,. Y�Z� .. _ .._.._.� r�i^•�J�l�C.. O�L��w Vc�J; �' �1 . d'�'�;. � . . � .... _ :°�4 � � _ �1 . .. - � .. " tr:. �, . - '" '-,..��_.� aih.;'� -�+t;. ^ - . ^ u`,i?.,._ ,.,;�, .-.--�_ .. _ . Exhibit 3 �c<<<; �-� }� a �-__ iJa i�.C��aly.�^.� CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Elizabeth J Carter 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 04/28/2021 �� ,-,�- �e� r,. -��,�E_ °,s T ��'- ' ;i y; �;} a ' .F _��: i'�•.^ CASE NO. 210428014 STATEMENT OF VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF HEARING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30 Sec 30-44, Sec 30-43 and Sec 30-41 2. Address and Pazcel# where violation exists:117 SW 5th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34974 3-15-37-35-0010-01660-0080 (34048) 3. Name and address of properiy owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Elizabeth J Carter, 13707 Eastpointe Way, West Palm Beach, FL. 33418 4. Description of Violation�unk/debris on the property, trash dumpster overflowing. Untagged/ disabled boat and trucks that needs to be removed. 5. Date violation must be corrected byMay 12, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about.4/27/21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you aze hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the $th day June. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hal(, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said EIearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Cade Compliance Department. If you fail to appear at aring the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. � Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision ofthe Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes aze for the sole pucpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhnent. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a£�nal administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days ofthe execution of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrativa final a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 3 � m � � o, � � � � 0 0 O 0 � � � O N O ['ti � _.� ' '.�c� . , 1,_I Retum Recelpt (heNcoPYI 5 ❑ i:ehun Haceipt (Nxwnlc) S ❑ Certifled Mall peshiCted pelivery S ❑.wun s�p�amre Reyui�en S ❑ Adurc Sqneture Restricted Oe1Nery S �l�/p�! 79flt18f1f Here �a� Exhibit 3 tomplete items 1, 2. and 3. A. Signature ., p p�nt ■ Print your name and address on the reverse X f� ,�+ ❑ Addressee so that we can return the card to you. ■ Attach this card to the back of the maiipiece, �• R�ived by (Pnnred Neme) G. Date of Deiivery or on the front if space permits. 1 a.+��o n,+.+w.��-+•-. _ tddress diffarerrt irom ftem 17 ❑ Yes 3r delivery � No Elizabeth J Carter 13707 Eastpointe Way �� N West Palm Bea�h, FL. 33418 �' N ��:. „'�' ►r-� ��` o �: . 3. Ser/ice Type riority M il Express� II I II11II III !lI l II I!I II I I II II i II I IIII I � I I III ��(�,�1rt�„;sd �„� �� Reshicted ��ellVee . MeA Restrlcted ;.�F,�arJ �"� ^ i ��i} �Z`_; ❑ Certified Maii ResU'scted DeIW��rii��yonflrtnaUon - �� ( �'^� �' , .� 17�`- �' ❑ Collec, on Oelivery ure Co�A'irtnatton 2_ prtlr�-• Numhar liransfer fr�m s_wvice laheli ❑ Coilect on Delivary Restricted Delivery ResVlctetl Ddivery .720 245� �0�0 5699 4238 oei�RestrictedDelivery PS Form 387 1, JUty 2020 PSM 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Recefpt , Exhibit 3 :,�, �::�: _ . - , ... � � . '""""'�'�_ .. _ .. _ - _ _ .. -.._ _ - - .�.. � -- -�� _ �� _ r- �� ."" �' � '�'" �'^` � � �� - _ � �, e '� ..,,.� � .S `t►. y __.._ .l" �= I �� : '..V�.> °.�'vA�• +�.` '_—a��—� _ . _ . � - _ .+r :.�'`,'. . . - _. . .i�..Y�'� .f.. ..�r _ � � .-�.. .., - - - . :..� ` .rl _ _ , y . y .. _ . .. ' -. s _.,��-'�'� � �� _� .. „�,` � . � _-� ,. '.�p^ .�^ � '`" " � . , 'y} %_ ,,,r ; � ,�y .�s '' w ,,;. � '�.�' : . . � . • '��J'Y��"a„�. e�.�rAd"_'4".J': e„�` ' �A _ — .� ,y.� .. " v � ��Y '� � � . �.W.. w� .. . � tiu' . . ,��, _ ` _ ' `' � �"�^ • �- " : O�D �1 �l ��0�� Og � g� r .. . .. . . .. . �f�;r�'/�� ' r . . � � ., .. . , ... ' ' i ! i ' • .�I► /� � �i: � ' � ._ � ..,•�� W f�� 1 .y� - �.. . �n...�..-... .. .e. a...� _..��...�.r. ..��i�—� ' � I e . .(.1�., ... ` +� , ' �c, isyi'.. _ � �� * 1•.��., { ... ' -i. . ' � C;�i , i q '-� � / •. � ... . . � J � _ _ __ .. . . ��.. :. '. � _ .. .. / 4 i, 1 � �_ � - ` -'st � -.v� . _, �,�..-.r..r. � . � � � r � , . �.� _ _ .,`yr�w.. �� , � :'':. �y. � fi�»�"""x;x, � " .. �� • , ��'"�'�: R '�t• '+' ti � ��'. . c �?; _ -3 �" � �1 � ' c w�t •-. 4.. . . � , i � . �'�': v � .., ,.'i � �+ f. � y� H ... � ^ �i.� �,�� Y:?kG��:? ��, z.i��Y' . �.�`' ' .:�f � ' A .t��. . C��"� ... ' . . . .r . ,��. _ .: I, - . , ^ - _ , �, c�.�' , �� _ . . . y r f ��.. ',m� �+ • � r r+w, �I.t..`j' -r - �� "�xw =r`� .. , , `; ' y y ,,�.�y o � . �" ', ��' -'�. • �.'t` . ' Y ' � ,� ,� - ' ;��y�`;•� � �, �*'.-,��..�. �. .. � 4.�� . , , . _ � . ��'' `� +i � y .i �r'be.<, � ��'. - � { : . ' . � ' ... �'� r�rn`, a ' • �,� jO r�� 4 `'*+�$�+�...at- "�,;� P�,,:�,,.' s �"Na ��1�` 1`�` ni': �.a. �. `� �� • +�� _,.,,a��, � '�;� �j �i, `� + �"g '''i � ` a a. ya � Y '��s ti+i#��,,� !+` � �y ^�i: , 8 , ./fs�` �:. �'1 �7�Z �+ . . ��c' �,,,n,ir � ,v�:�t . `�� 't�p.. y+ �; .,` �� . - -. Exhibit 3 �..� . � � -- �F"� �'„�ti l` � ,�:- _ �,�- ; � .. _ �,� �� :i�{��, � �. ��4•�� '. T A' k $ St t ' � � �? .� �_.. . ___�..+ ',D3Y�� '�+sJI"�i ` ��Fx " -- � �!� �i � �a`a.. 1' �, � ,Y a . ��,,,:� _ �� . '- ' r - _ ��i1��• , r.....�..........�. � � b`' : � lRL1Ri _ .. �'� , \ i ,{ _ ." 'ti�i �" ,. _.._.----- �: � 1 .. � �� .. ..--_ - � ''�QI '.� � � .c` �i' �au�r��ctas��r. ' �a�►o��►�raa�aaa� _ $,.. a" . sar��a��r.�� . ,;` � �� ',: s� +'„ ,, . �R' ► � l\l$� ;,�, $. 'ri � �� — _ -_ _ '.: - �t�1ti��. '. ,ray'�� "��s.�-�'�'� '':� � ,--- - f-,�� ` A - 1 �ar ��' �� a . �j�i �. , . _ .� �� py�. �F� � � � �' -�.�w,..r.� ' � .. . � ., y�,11 ' . �'�Y ��A '� \. _ �L, s y� �' �. . �,°M � , . ' �. � ✓.--•N � � n.t . � �v . ' �Ay � i '�i . . ` L. � V `+ +.• r � � �`�� •` � _� '; r �. -♦, }f ' . -•i' � .n . t. Y.� C 3' ,y, �� 1 1 • ± i �B . . ' . _,_y�.�� b � V •��'G i •� f� . . . :x�. .� LrJ ,z4' �' . .. _ ' ; . !.•• \• •. . � �� . _�i/ ll� ll [l 4'�0�� O� � �� , x �' ii � -r . �, �' �'� . ` ,� , �i . � � 'x.V��'.�� }:r}�� :.��_.� ��.� �.�� ..tl . . . �r�� ' ; • . � - � 4�� 1'`�,t,� � � � � i ,/ , `\ \ . `� ,' wr/�� ,. .. -`h�.k�� _,.. __'_ _�____ '� `"�e4��,4 � � h".'"�.. ��r.��r�.�w��.asaaa�r.� r` ��' ' ,�11?�' 7 s�•��.�ace��s� � �.� r�rwww��r s wrr. ,� r � ' � € +'` �'� '. � r � �yt . � - . � �. , 7,�. . k .,. �� . � � �fR1I� 4�• �. ,�` � � ��F 1 ,� . , f.a ___ -- �s.. -, . .__,.- � . ,�a*� f 1 ,��,r > , , _ _ � - � �, � . _ ""Q __ � ... _ --- - : ��.�4 ,- B �� , .� � � -. � ` �� -�' � .�.,,.- -- '� � ` �. .. _ � ,�. ____._. .:..�._.�,;.. . . �wa+�^«.,�,,. -��y� 4 e � � r � �..r . `'Miw'.<r.s--•t..,,,r,,,e„�..r�.c..�;c.� '~ '.� �OM . . I , . . a.� �? �� .. ��•e . ��O.T��• �'��. .1 � - �, � ., �' � ��ASTE M � � - � �` � ANAGFMEN•. . - - . � .�,T. �0 �� gq�� ':, `' '`�1+�" '� � ` �} � � �' A �� , � � � ��t . s, � ;� ;� � � F '� � � � � ��'� r � � �; �� t� " ' � � w�'� ��;'�..�,��a� ,. �, �,.�i .uw � `��§ .� bs3F��'a_',�,w�nd . 3 ; ��"`•' 'P � ..s` i.-��A�c�'.�c$:'t. _u,.,:., . M..i. _ t .-,"a.�` .�' .. .._ ,s , .t�•.m:.�., a,.. .'S',rn�.�L�c. . =av,,. _ �•.y ..rA �� •;'I.rs'.-.�I 4� �o ` e' � ��.,. : • . ` yfi .� � , g. ' 'SN : � � � �,f�. �• � �►•. k.,' Exhibit 3 ,0�1� ��,k :�� ,�P�� ..� : ...,: - � .�- � ��.�.I�,v', � t �ti= ��'/ � � �!� ' �.�}a' �� j I '!> /�� *. �' i' i x � � ., �� !r` . ' r � �b �� ., ( • t� s/►�y, ," .. � 3 - . �,,d .6 i , '" .� ;a'� ��` a ^ �. ' : e� �� A��'1�'::; �t�:�u _.. _ .. �.�-, : � �, , _ � _ < � �: ..�,�e,��`�.;, , r _��'; _ . w . »l , � �. - .��},..�.. :d �y,�' . �� !' �'7! . ;� M � 4 �..0 a. r._, � �! ., r . � _ ..,... _ . -t � �. �... � � � ��*�t �y ` �' � r ' � � k,. � '� ��e.��° ��Y.��.��: . t r� ir� �� - � , � d 4. , z �^`�i�,�`�► � � - . - •'�$�- IG ` .. � a � ; c 4 � y, }� ;' � � .7'� . f � 7� �` , � _, �� i��`'S �.q (: ��. �; �, j � � A`'''� � . ' � �` ' -� ' � ' �� t. * y�� , �� + k '� r . � '• . S • ,, • . � _ M. �: g• �»., yty" e i:. �� * ' �'�._.. �� ' ,�' . � ��..; .� ��y.�� —� � ' �. .•�� ',y�}* Y� ,�; � � + _ 4y,� r sy� � .•,1, ..: ;1�, . ; �,� .. R- n a� ` . I bal; h-=� �,. . . . , '+ry'�",� i. �a ;�, ` �r . /'�" .,�+.: � : �! i . '�i? . . • a �� y � ��j �� {, *�� , . � � � �, � y,`i�.Ai�. • t f � J�, �� „� �.+'eA��} �'"'A,. ,'„ . ,'". G� � s . � � . � ^�► � ' �'►��a � `f "` � /R�,. ii,.,. , . � � `�. . . � � / i �� . �`�' � i, y_ . . . � j � . �� r �' �!y. J a �,� . . .. �'! y . � _ E�; �� • �� '. .�'��`" --A ` � f�- - � 0�0�j��0��1 0� � ��l �� ya1 a1� . ' JO • . `��' �'� ' �r �• '} f� � -� W�` i. • ��.] - ' � , j . ` 1 y , ` . ' ��' . w. I�� . " � h�,: � s�. � ` -.�� . �� t • � r. ��,. � • 'I .� � tf�• � ••' .� c,. i� f .. ' f .._ ..-_.._ . . •�. . . .� i • � . * P. •'.�• "< �it• ad�. Exhibit 3 � �_—, " c� - :'�".�?.`-•cp �Ml+wr11�� .2 . .�.i 11 � : '� �� . 3"� � � � • �`� ,� � � ��,�� ,: . ��►. , �._ _._ .� - �� . �� R _ • �yye T" �� ry '�� "T�w7� �`;y�� . .�:-. r:. �j� y � w .� ' � _,� y �;�� ,�.�H �,:�- ,,,,..,:%/� .t �,. �� . + r�� ..' � A' T `; ii NYr y �a ' r: � ,.r-`�� ='o�x . '-s 0�00�0�0�� O�q�l ... _ :.� ._.. _-- --� � . . �:.... � i` � ' �. �a �Y�� ✓1�J ; �"',,.> >' �, , . �o, ' � �.?4 +�,4 '�` «�.�' ' + �� ,� � . � � . � � �� ,' . � � � � ��'-" � v ,: � • � � ! ,�; ' ., � ��/,�' � .j ,. , w.�- � - ": �--�_ _ ':� ...�-.w �or! ` ' '�,�*�- ---_ � � � y �, � . � �� ,, � ,�'� � �. � , yg�,. ;,�; � ,{� � i��r'-� A ^L C�y .� � � �� J �t ��i\ll�� " �:�....._ �� ---.... ��. � . �� 1 .�.�. �c+�,.a�<e«�',,�a,� �, -` ,;'��; �. 100�� D�Q� *4 i. ,.� ._, " • Lg�,s"" *° ``'�, ��`,> 1 , � {,�C � `�,,,;�w- _ . ,�� "�i�E�-r'a'� _ '_*�s'�� .�x..�.� . Y:"`'�'' Exhibit 3 �� u,,.�""r'r��,.,. , � � �r_ � �� ''�-.1 �� t�� ,: � � _ _ ^r. � ,�;� ... - �� "�� j�f � -- �.�.,-,�,,- '��-, , 1 ��{ ��. ; � � , ... �, � � _ , - -� I � �� _r: �,.:. f� �� r '"�'-" , �5 � a � k : e h � i r� '�i-.s�7i R :� '�' Y .. A "n� . �q��'� ... *' �',jj> 06%�08120� 1 10 �/47 �� :� � ' � �� . ~_ t Exhibut 3 � �.-�.r --- _ _ �_ -r ,,�.�-z, .,,r-�-�.-�--� N� , ��..,,�„�-- �. .. : , � �...-��. ,.. __.._. ...._..__ •� �, ` , .._. ., ��f �� 1`�;, r.... . � z.,... 't � ti s�►i y'lil`�.,� � �� 1 y� - �� j y � �� l�J� . ,. .. "'k �F`i$' d �'K �` � � �'It�'`�' � ' `.i � . � +: �^e 4 � � � t� r.....,:. � �. �r.., 1 � � ,. , ` � - . � a � .'r ,, � �� ' � � �.f��it � � ��,il►ly�Y �zf �W`�� — — y ` ��i71ai+.�.- �ey j— ` . � ' A�.i�Y� S` � A ��k` r . `�� v r � " � r � .... , ' _ . , — ��„,,,�.: �. . , ..rf�" ' ` �, -+ k, ._ .� . , ..� .. . ...^, . , f�� . o-�' -. , . �,� �.. . � . �'�,.,,ti.,.. � . _ ., _ . ... . _� , i. . � � . . .. yt . . .. . � . � . t# ' :,�%.i .._ . " 4.�. . ; } _4 . i= .- ^ � s-;;� . � . �-f ��.... . _ .'.y� .. . - = y+��.. , •`',�„y�'�� :;,� � . f!'•�. „ �.a� . . � ��` , v.f F'�`� .: •sr. } . . 'I: k`}` � 1 +� �' . � S�� . . '", � t , , . � � � ��A��'� . i # � �.d �+ ,�A r .G ,dm, � � —� �'/. � :. �� "'�'� . � tiG`{='r; , f � :`i � � :� � , � i . �n. .a+•: , �.,��... , � X +�.� , K . . �,( , � 31� ".-1�}>,� � .�.Iv!l.Ye _ i-�i.i6 ,04�: .A., i .. . . _ is:",,i� `t ...: � . ^: s .... � ' � ��l � yll � � �/ ..i� ky .. �•�yrr-.i' � .�Y.. e.' ��,n "{c �Y;� r . � `^ � . ��• ' h A. . ^ _ •a: a�,:N7.. .... �„ _..a,_ � J; . �' � � �. . '. � , . 0 � l% 9 ° i��U`Z2-li.. `�'`� o �`�j,,; �� , �; : :*tii' K . , , ,< � r•�+�. . - •�� . �. . �. , - . _;; � . . .�. � ,; . :��:�, � � . . . : . � . . � �a . . _, _, ,.- - ,_ , — � ,�� . ,. -� i • , � .. „ .. _ . �n:''� � , . . ` , - . � ` '^` �- `.� 3�v '.:1 • ' ��'; " - �i � , � �r.. . , . _ ` i ."^ . . . �'' � '*"� _ . ,Rc�" `t " '�� r.� � .. � � .r`� �{�w+.'��-� . .': � �� . : . . . `.w�_� _ ' : ' . . ' , 1�"', � a�� ,t�`�� ^ . ,�' .�� , �� ' . � .. . � . o ' r ^3 -:..� -• . . -. �'*''.�� L-_ 0 � (%��U�� l�"' _ . _ + , : .L. ` , ,, � ��Y�...,w�lY11M1�.- ; � � � ` q/J�� y j'! � \Yr �. �,y}.y��.� �.f:��. �.... � ` � . �..... ��a ��_ - .J' .. : . �_ < . �. ,y� Exhibil: 3 ,,. ._ -� ��'.,;lA - - _ -� _ ,�„ - _ ._- ___ __ __ _ _ - •+ � .__ _._. _� _ _ - - ,. ..:y-:� �+�; �.�.+�q _ _ .. k�� ' �" �. i�� 1 . .. »�� _,._.�. ,., �� ' �_ Q� ( �: . ...«< �O�il 9 � � Q � � .. 4�6,�,.. .. .., . � � � ` � ;�% � �s �,.. :�,_r .-•]i { � �"�..� u. ' .w.... ��i: ' -�, �t.. .;.,,�e: i w � 5 1\� �{\ ��- "� it .. ,_. '! ,4,!`• ,.'`�..�- •'... �' ! + ��Cmt ��1 y �.. � �k� _ y +s"�^ s,�-.r.'. �� t��l�s�e�i � tia 1� t rs' a e t . �y " j ..� ;� . `• ' ��T� _,, nY' y� ii.t. � t .. ' � ♦ • . . . #. , ��;• �1 1) 1�� 1� `-c1�:F� :,iEj ',. },r��4r�ti��Z�� f .�� ::� ,��,' i�: � - ��t�sil �1r��'1 tttt• ��1i�.w. �R*1t1 i� � y'��a. - ,� � ��i, ` �;S � t��t;�l��f��Z � �itttf� ':+\.��;y +� �... � ��•�. v.a.ri}} r� t ��,�+�:,�, �`�h�! 1��1,``�1} 1��'� t�'f�.♦. tt F�va'�;tRRI��"e,,:..�t� �,��`�� ! ��F�w S.� � .iv � � :��.� E i i � 1 : t , ` �,T� �� -° e tl . ♦ r,t.' r�., .�lp',��"� �:�V"�`��-,t��` �� ;�� ; „t ��E�1t�� ' T�� Mx a� ., 'k�':tI� . � �� ' E k � �.�� ., '��;3;�� t �Y� � `��1� t,��♦'►:`��:'�R��.�;��l�T ;��'�� -_- � u 4 ��,1' � • , - , ; , 1; � � � i � �i�'::�?� �� _'k f � 11 t ` � „�,� � � ' � `•� �.`,'�i>��` 'Rt� � �t�� ';.e'��iikt�r►i� tt,'a.� � �� ' � ) l � 1':�.t�}�� 1��1}�� '� 'tF'� � �.1�ti�i. , tt 5 1� �R�t11�� tf ' �. ' r} [ 3 �" t;�� -4i��'; �,� sl 1�':811��t ��. X''��.'�i�Ft-�'+ , �iVt,F1�i,' �'�� a9'S�r� k�� iR �#'��_ t��i �� 1. �=�i�"�`,��'��1.»s��,•�- t�' ��ttf��a°, i1��'. � � ttt! d' �� "�� , -�'�! ,y `� p � � . . I� ��,�f�"t "�"�� . `;t"t�t%ir j�r�,t }��'� :� lr: �1�d -°�, � ! � � � , . � i � { . x•.* , : �� . �� , , 't r � .. �r.e+� "� ; �:: y, • 1 t y v,� "�"v '1'V.'� �` � � 3 k � � .:. �A,'�+ e: %� ' . � _ a _ . ''�` o y a .. ;k , 3 e� ,-�p � « . wi�.." � ��4t l�,, '� t a � ,. .l�."M!�� }1'{ �� . ?1�# E . , �4te� �,�� , �a�yi*1, is�3 ��l�'R�� ♦�t�: > . '� �� i.�'1 � . �3i'�4. #i�t ., .�4Y :I �_ _ } ..'* ."+11►y '?'� �� • . a N� �'S� Y ;e , tl`'.��,a�`�.41`►"-�. �.m,aN'! Fq.. � .. .. ' � � �' f a� � � c $ . , � � !�, � • . . y � ? �� ; �,� � v , ,�,� �+� ♦ � � �,� k - . . T _ _� I•� � •�.�" � � � � ` �, s ,,,�- �r '�. -� •. "''€ r�.� '�. ;�. '"�, �-.. ,;w a P ,. _ �=� ..:.. ;= =� �. ��,.r�- aoll�ga��9`� ��q� . - - — F: : � : •,r .� � �, �. -�i �r-: _ *-= ��'--` --- _ �. - � �, r : ._ ��,-� �z _ �,,' __ _ ��_ ' _ ---�— �— - . �" _ �'� � � �:' � �ti+ " - , ��*i�'� y�, '�' ` , �"_`,.��s�il - -,� �: +L�.�,c E.,.'�` t� ac ' _ '�'��t' 1 � - .'C� - a d ' - ' s . , � - � . �' - _ . - � t + _ � v\ , ... . ` _ . � Exhibit 3 � �. , � w +�� M.V� .... . . ,'�� 1 ��!?p.� . �.� ; w �, � , . ... . ' �i#-'- E F � �, � i� ��. ,.�J � , � ��.. _ � � � � .� .. �'., .� + ,' '� .... � �+tr �� '�� +��4 . . _ � � � ��'�� _ . � . � ..�.F��..�.._....�.._�, � �� ::�:� _ _ . .. .w. . � � � �� ;: r �� ,� � ; ,�� '�1�1� � • }.� �` �-: . � _ ... � � � ��_ �..e�- -- - � � ___ ..._._ _ _. ....�ic ,ws. --�.--...----- __.»__-- ;� � �,�..,.�..�.« _ �.a..w.i :�,.: �::.ii► .r t�.. , . . _ —. � t . . , o�lli1�0�0�� Og��a �.:� �� .��. , ,+�,� � -1.'I t �; .� , ,�.. �� . , : . �.;; �� . ' �'�e'��x;, l�' ,s; .,� . f � :�� ,,. �r� - - . .�; - � . • . - .s►- + �p' " _. `, �.. , � - ��... " ... Y . .. Ni-i � `�iTV 'V �i L1 - ' F,9' 0 a 0�� OI�OL� U VG � vv �� .�, a,,�,' - �, � a� "+"�� r�l1 i ,�;`�' �) „r . r� 1i 1.; �.i� wt. �1a.r. ;r _ . . . �..>•�. , Exhibit 3 l,��OICf vCCCItO� CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, PLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Elizabeth J Carter 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 09/03/2021 oKp ��E�"i a �,, I : 'F`" -. CASE NO. 210428014 S'I'�LT'��;�/IE i�1T O�F VIC)LATION 1\ND N O"I ICE O�� I IEARINU Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: CH 30 Sec 3d-44, Sec 30-43 and Sec 30-41 2. Address and Parcel# where violation e�usts:117 SW 5th Ave, Okeechobee, FL. 34974 3-15-37-35-0010-01660-0080 (34048) 3. Name and address of property owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Elizabeth J Carter, 13707 Eastpointe Way, West Palm Beach, FL. 33418 4. Description of Violation�unk/debris on the property, trash dumpster overFlowing. Untagged/ disabled boat and trucks that needs to be removed. 5. Date violation must be corrected byOct 1, 2021 6. Date violation first obseraed on or about.4/27/21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upott to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the � 2th day October. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of facc and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Deparhnent. If you fail to appeaz at the hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. Anthany Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at tttis hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole piupose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhnent. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta eu acuerdo puede apelaz una orden adminishativa final a la tribuna( de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 3 a .. . � m t�- , , _ � :, � , t� i ' � Ceriifted aN Fee� r� ll7 EYtraServreaR A0.0l.hwr4AnrarlAh � j] Ret� ReceiPt (h��PY) $ r-1 q am�n aace��t calec+m�uo) s d i(� Certlfled Mafl ResMcted Dalivery $ Qf�]AUWtSlpneturaReq4iretl $ �[] Atlult Sipnature R�slNcted OelWery $ 0 Postage � :o frl Total Poetape and Fesa Q $ � .Sa f'LJ �, � ,,I---��,��>'I o. A� � '� r P��=/' " . ia"� "�=i � � Exhibit 3 �. , ,�+ � ` _ . :t � i y IYji 1 � j��,' Y �.:yi� � �':l 1 /� . ).''iµY t�s ..,�daN Irl��-t�..i'� '�:�wif�ilA�l�_{ � f.: . . . . F___ — ,�... __ _ _ _. _ . __ _ ___ _. . __ _ _._ _. i CU!1� �` iu'; �. = �.:. _ 3i . ■ Print your name and address on the reverse j� , �"' "J�n` so that we can retum the card to you. , �'L Addressee ■ Attach this card to the back of the : nailpiece, B• R eivefl by (Printed jVame) C. Date oi �Jetvery or on the front if space permits. ��. �- ;'-' � '�' _ , n�+��-��+-�•^r��-�='---- -- — ---- -`-- ddress diffekent from item 17 �-(�� Yes r delivery address below: � I$ No �� ;- Elizab.eth J Carter -� , ,-.,; 13707 Eastpointe Way �%�' �, G` �-��1-� �� West Palm Beach, FL 33418 ,_ � �'1 �, ; __-_ � `'�� ' ��'�'�I I'� ��I) � I� �I I I� I��II I� 1� (�� 3. Service Type O Prioriiy M2il E,epress� � M � ❑ Adult Signature ❑ Registered Mailr"' i -Adott Si�natura Restricfed Deltvary ❑ Registewd Mail Restricted t �� .� �, i G? ;, �� r i, ^ Certified Ma110 Del!very --. ��.) �� -- . C,��.� n�: l.� :�n �, I 0=1� ❑ Certified Mail Reatticted �el[very O Return Necaipt !or ❑ Collect on Delivery erchandise 9 A�t��IA ni��..�c.�. T �-+--r---- ---' ' ' " � - � � Delivery Reshicted Delivory �9nature ConfirmationT^' lail ❑ Signature Confirmation 7 � 21 � 3 5 � 0 0 01, 5117 7 3 4 I, lail Restricted Delivery �es��tw ��i��ery � (over b500) �, ; Ps Form 3811, July 20'15 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Uomestic Return Recai�t Exhibi� 3 •n►. ' � ; � � � ��r D:QT I.:CE r� : �:�-- , , �� :,. , ; _ c :� —� �` `,�� ..__.�._—- ._ �w a :�� ... � � . �, �--�--�i, �� '�y.�.(�.�t •�� , L, . . ��w �'�� • ��. � . ,.. . , , . . �- , . v � . � r . ; .. . . � � • � .,_.. ... � Y � Y . yp ' s;x ' ' .. . � �, °'i� . - ._ � � " --•..'a�.^ � �.�1�' �,.�..,. .. ...�' "��w .'� . . �.. � ,'�:�' - -� � � _ "" C . - - . ` _ � �o.�ct' - . '� ..,,�, � . �►..�r �r u. , a � 4�00�0�9 .i1� � � � � � �� f � 1 �,e . .. h , : � , .•-�• �{ z. :p} .....Yi..� ............---_...._. , a . _._ �'Y w�i f �F'klt tr, s ..�.-- __ . ,�.,�, ., '��i�'�LY�\1 6_.�'��Y v� � ..�\ ,.��1 ,.� •' ,• ��y , ' �'1 . ': .. ' . . •. �� t�:. i` ��' ;; ��.-:��;9 l 1t �� , .►�1.�=' .,��:�.�,��. .-�. � ., . �� . . . . � �, � . � , � � ... ��,�_'y�, :�- �� .� ��• �a ,��_- 'p�k«,. ��' �,> . �, ' :�` ;� r ,� . "..�i*.-" �«�`^ , � � i f � :;� "��• . � �`i r ,'�� } r ��-1,i�r�q;' . �.., i�a 'i,� ;;A ��`$ '.* 7 } �� '�',�;L � ` � r � a. _ _ _. -_.� _ . O�J°0�00�0�9 9��3g --_�.� ,.�.._ _ „ _ ,_ -�ww..��+.. Exhibit 3 � � � , . � .� : - - �-�,�.�..�iC-�,,, .�,.i..s� ..a..if ' '`�"a�....' �� ` +.• •�`r ` � �� ,. • �' w�.�.��t�� • .. � . �1d�M�.4 ..1.a' .. � w : , �`a. �Y , .AN , . .... `�,� �" , ,_..., �... , t � w il ODOq��0��1 �1 � � � 6 � 1:� � `�� i , �� ',� V' �_. ,�r�- _ :- �- � �vi. .. �.`�.��,. Y",�.0��:.Ir�.."i �\ � � `y$1 �, ` �2 �l , �� . ..-.. . �' !�. � �� .y�y. ��y}i��. �''��`� �� , j.. � }. .' . + - . . .. - , iJ u �" � -a v'.A I ' ' �'. , e H � ."c x3ir., � l` '/ � 1.�++�t'� Mv� �00040�0�9 9��96 Exhibit 3 �o �.4 , ��,�.. - �' �;{ .�� - _ �....� �� - ' :�S.S.4... , � r, . .:�'_-�,:-� � � � .�.� Y .. � ' � � ' � �._��"...,�.,,..,,-' � ..� _ . :�- ��►�,�.,. � :w, x .�. _ ....- ° � . , ... . -- .. _ � ...�� _ -- _�. .� _�. _. _ _ ; _ ,-+c.. , a.;.. r-.rn: �++�,�� , � .,s�- . � . . .. .. . ...... : ,.. � � r .� . � �+`.ri �r:a„ _ � •" ' . -r.. � ,. ._ � , V� � . �� _ _ .,._ _ � , � � � -- �- ��, -- �. �. �.; ,;.. .�,�,;i� :�" � ",,„. �- . � � � �� .. . a ,,�. - ;� �UOU7l�/��l ll�J ��5�5 . „�,,,,�. �:� j_.:a.►�°`w' `""ir" - . . � �rr . . . __ . ... '� �a � �� ` :; «ik_ �1. ,., # � . , � , __ _ _ — — - _ �n'b� �; � p, ry' . _ ; � ,� � � � ' ; ; ^`� ��` _ , " Y l , r' ` , r,r, , — � y��`:r' ' � �� A � „t �— _ ..�;, �„, , � � �� + � � � , � � , a �. � t� ,. � „�� , , :; ,� , . �. � � aua«�+a� : • .. 4 : _:. � � � j �.�..;.:--� . ...,� . . �'.� "�..-..�- � . � . 1 . ��.; � : .d�,� .. �y ' � � �� `"'jy�`c�''J n . , . Y *,:n�,' _ �� ,- d � v _ ' ,.. +^^y. .y'f .�'. RF r. 'L � �Ni ,�r�� '�.�i �� . �ty .�;^ � •'J�. � . �"'a . _ _' Y�' .i. .' .. � .. �', . � . t � .. •� ' Il�� y � e a . . . # � � � - ' '• ��.� � . . . � . . �,- a � �. ,�yy ��•w � � � ! .. " � • � . �� 5��,� a ��,: �� °� ��- r - `"a. . o., �� ' ..� �� 4, w. , ;' � � y nr'. .� :'�A� � � s,,, ,� ,; �� ,p�T , +�rr ti'��^.. . ,�.�� - , k� ' �! _� � •�'t!. r� . �� '4° .r � �r,' � ��_,_ _ "' ��{ . �*.,�di .'.�,:�� s��Rr'3�,�.4-:'.".�� Exhibkt 4 VI. B.-Exhibit #4 Case #210125009 Barry and Denise Parow Exhibit 4 Code Enforcement Hearinq October 12, 2021 Case Name & Number: Barry and Denise Parow. Case #210125009 Cha ter 30 Section 30-41 Disabled vehicles Ino erable vehicle Chapter 30, Section 30-44 General cleaning and beautification Car parts all over the Photos: See attached Is respondent a Repeat Violator? No Summarv: • Respondent was first notified on January 25, 2021 via Courtesy Card. • The City communicated with the respondent on the below occasion(s). Date of event Type of event Date Received by received March 4, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant March 15, 2021 Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return Have not received recei t an thin back March 25, 2021 Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke w/Denise Parow, she advised that they will be working on the yard and removing the vehicles, but they would need more time as her husband is oin throu h cancer treatments April 5, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant, however progress has been made. April 27, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant July 1, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant July 2, 2021 Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return Returned unclaimed recei t on Jul 28, 2021 July 27, 2021 Posted property with Notice to Appear July 27, 2021 Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Samantha Parow, she advised they received the posting in the yard, and they will be working on cleaning up the car ort. August 4, 2021 Inspected property, still non-compliant August 6, 2021 Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow, she advised they are still workin on the car ort but still need more time. August 10, 2021 Case presented to the Special Magistrate, deferred to allow the property owner more time to come into full com liance as ro ress has been made. September 3, Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing mailed via USPS certified return September Russell Parow 2021 recei t 8, 2021 September 8, Asst. Code Officer Curl spoke with Barry Parow, he advised that they 2021 received the notice for the Hearing, and they are still working on getting the car ort cleaned and or anized. September 20, Inspected property, still non-compliant, however they are making progress 2021 on ettin the car ort cleaned u. September 29, Asst. Code Officer Curl received a call from Denise Parow advising the 2021 ro e is in com liance and would like it ins ected tomorrow September 30, Inspected property, still non-compliant, spoke with Mr. Parow and explained 2021 what needed to be done to bring the property into compliance and that the ro e would be reins ected on October 5�n October 5, 2021 Inspected the property, still non-compliant, spoke with resident and explained again what needed to be done to bring the property into com liance. PAGE 1 OF 2 Exhibit 4 • To comply with City ordinances, the property owner needs to clean and organize the carport. Citv Recommendation: The City recommends a fine of $25.00 per day, to begin 21 days after the date of the Special Magistrate Hearing on October 12, 2021, unless the property owner brings the property into compliance before that date, plus a$50.00 administrative fee. Chronology attached. PAGE20F2 Exhibit 4 Case #210125009, Barry & Denise Parow Date Event/Document January 20, 2021 Property Owner-Barry & Denise Parow Address-101 SW 11'h Ave Violation observed of Ch 30 Sec 30-41- Disabled vehicles & 30-44- General cleaning and beautification Inoperable vehicle and car parts all over the yard. Photos in file January 25, 2021 Courtesy Card sent. Given 14 days to correct violation March 4, 2021 Property inspected, still not in compliance. Photos in file. March 15, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed certified return receipt for the S/M Hearing on April 13, 2021. March 25, 2021 Assistant Code Officer Curl received a call from Denise Parow (863) 801-1780 she advised that they will be working on cleaning up the yard and removing the vehicle this week and next week, her husband is going through cancer treatment and when he receives chemo it makes him sick for at least a week. I advised her to just keep in contact with us and when they make progress to let us know and we can come back out and inspect the property to show they are trying to take care of the violations and once they have it completely cleaned up to give us a call and we will inspect the property to make sure everything is in compliance and then we will be able to close the case. April 5, 2021 Inspected the Property: Not in compliance, property owner has made progress bringing in the property into compliance with the removal of pile of debris in the front yard. The carport area in need of being organized. April 27, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance carport still in need of being organized. Photos in file. July 1, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance carport still in need of being organized. Photos in file. July 2, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed certified return receipt for the August 10tn Hearing. Returned unclaimed on July 28, 2021. July 27, 2021 Posted property with Notice to Appear, photos in file. July 27, 2021 Assistant Code Officer Curl received a call from Samantha Parow advising that they received the posting in the yard, and they will be working on cleaning up the carport, but it will take time. She was advised to start making progress and to keep us informed and we can show the magistrate that progress is being made to avoid a fine. Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 4 Case #210125009, Barry & Denise Parow Date Event/Document August 4, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, carport in need of organization and removing the junk on the side of the carport. Photos in file. August 6, 2021 Officer Curl received a call from Denise Parow advising that they are still working on getting the carport cleaned. I advised her that we will defer their case at this hearing to allow them more time to come into compliance. Mrs. Parow stated that she would keep in touch with us and advise when they come into compliance. August 10, 2021 Case presented to the Special Magistrate; Case was deferred one more time to allow the property owner to come into full compliance as progress has been made. September 3, 2021 SOV/NOH mailed via USPS certified return receipt for the October 12'n Hearing. Given till October 1 St to correct violations. Received by Russell Parow on September 8, 2021. September 8, 2021 Code Officer Curl received a call from Barry Parow in reference to the notice he received. He advised that they are still working on getting the carport cleaned and organized but it has been so hot they haven't been able to get it completely done as he is fighting stage four cancer. I advised him to keep in touch with us and to let us know if they come into compliance. September 20, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, however making progress on getting the carport cleaned up. Photos in file. September 29, 2021 Code Officer Curl received a call from Denise Parow advising that the property is in compliance and would like the property inspected tomorrow. September 30, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, photos in file. Spoke with resident and explain what was needed to bring the property into compliance. Resident advised that the property would be cleaned up by Tuesday 10-5-2021. I A. Smith advised her I would come back then to see if the property was in compliance. October 5, 2021 Inspected the property: Not in compliance, photos in file. Spoke with resident and once again explained why the property was out of compliance. Also explained how long they had to bring the property into compliance before the fine would start accruing. Page 2 of 2 Exhibit 4 l:; . <, } i �:- �- �:=� 9 ;, .; ; . ; ,%�� ;;.�:� , . y. �.� ' ; `r ''� �`, � � r� Ji. {; '. ��OO'�� 3�'� .i• . _,� _. : � �. . _, �; �� i �� . , � -�� . w {�� ti �y .. � _ _ - " �t.7 e. �a4�i � ; _ _� �_.,�_�� _ _� . „ .�. 5 - :_'—:. ;•w : �-.__ --- _ . 1 I►�'---.�-�.,cy'.�i' �''� ..,� � .��3+�a1'"' ��. � , .. Exhibit 4 Re: �� Date: � 1 c�T. � Dear Property Owner, This is a courtesy card requesting your assistance in alleviating the following code violation(s) at the above address. The following violation(s) exist: 0 Overgrown Weeds, Crrass, Bushes or Shrubs 0 Trash, Yazd Debris or Junk �Inoperable, Abandoned or Unlicensed Vehicle 0 Intemational Properiy Maintenance Code Ch �Other �.�Y1 tT�' �' c..h � P�, '� P � 0 Unauthorized Signs, Flags or Banners 0 Operating a Business Without Required License 0 Pool Yolation Sec Please contact our office at (863) 763-9795 within � days of receipt of this card and let us know when violation(s) will be corrected. We appreciate your cooperation. Exhik�it 4 .1• `.� �� ... �� i i. -�. � � ��. � .,� ,��F ^�'h � �� t � • �� k III I p� ,� < t , .�3t� ;'o' w '9� _'� . � r' �� x 9�h' � "!'.y;:� � �Fjtf �, :w.J"' '�,: . F � 1 .witc'..�- .. .. , y�� . . ..A� , i.'� ;Yi � �• � �` } . ,� . �� i ,M ��.: � . . d �'�"�y`-t`'+#d- � " , . .:1 «.,,� y •' ` r;�„ i �� ,� � _ ' _ F. , - _ ,..,,_ ��s. . �+ E , � � - . t � � _...:..'.� .�+— �� , . �''r � "' . _ Ir� l � _ _.. ... _. _ ... . � _ � � �� ' i. � t�..-�� 1 li..�'. M«., " . . .. . �.. x . ..w......a.. a.. _ � ,` -_ _ _ _ .?; . � � , . ��rt �*Pi�� .v r ! � po'�a Gt� J ' .y � .. � L� � . � �.,� ... �� •� 4 i,M ' .-` � w- '� "te N � /1r�. [ . ) r ��"�'A. ��' ` �� :,� `� �� y �r�`� �.+�`�q��9v� „� � e�- '7...a. -�..v.a ,,�..c� .. , �7 r� � �. � f..� � �d �S:r w:.��.'' 44 V�y '..ai� a� .f � � �^� ��t#�� ,,,•�"r'� E'��.s"" '+!"' �g � °_'�'w4 ,`..... �-�� „_ 'a� #4��-, ..,..�a��O� . . ► ..�.la. ' � �7 T��I �I 'i � �'C s� . ►�.w��w�,.�,�.,p,�.�� "�y„�.��i 'i.�°t''`i�� _.a« ` � �. `�'�,'� i 4%: ', `r� ��..y�, , �I' n� . �i . . - • . A ' � �ay �... ., t � - � �-� 2� � � � ' R � .il .{. w'F' � . : k � N #� �� P, ' �� ' r: y� �r t < � ✓� ._ �t Y ..t' �� r �e � * . , .. �: y j � i� y `� �j /�y�p /� oiA � a t � �«'. �i6i �'� '��,^�".t�,[�,�,�6�'�°�w�� ,"', � r : �� af.�y `��J � � IJ ,CSl�KS`ll �'4?�Q�Y''� ,. � ;��" !;� t 4' y�+'� :-5��`, � :�-�,!+`• . Ak w �,''� `` •; - . Y'y"S.� �' r � Y u� � �� tl. 4 � . i'Ffi��h� � V .- ;�* .y�� '�'� � �V� "R fy'�}'� '�•. �. � � �`'�.�/ � r' ^ . `-' +► t.,� 4` NM�+`7 <.►,��1�; ' i� .. � � � • � ... ' ,'�',. +,m-!'�: � � ..,;� j�4� i� �� . ...�- -... . . f � � . '�r.��', .r . i'• 1ti }� s ° � „� +✓,r d. , , �Yr ' r ,. , .e w';P" � t ��.fi� . '-. . ��f� 4��f1 o-� . ArY�!� �';: ,� �Oo'0�9 9�1�°� - ��_.:'� .' " , � ��>�;� � A ♦ .'... h.,wF` :,�T r' �7F' ` '!�`� �� ,��,��,�� •,�� .�^.. , _..... . - . " �.. ... �,,. ,.. .�' . . ... .:......I ��,' � � ' ' ,�1 ,j i .� �0/ �W �� /�rl� � ! �/�S"oo y' 1�'oa,cy �2or,,� Exhibit 4 „�.�" `Oke�echobee ,,. CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Barry & Denise Parow 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 03/15/2021 o�«<.;o.� vo��cc j . : `p'�, !r�:: CASE NO. 210125009 STATEMENT OT VIOL�ITION AND NOTICE OF HEARING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee}, the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particu(arly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: Chapter 30 Section 30-43, 30-44 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:101 SW 11 th Ave 3-21-37-35-0170-00040-0110 3. Name and address of properiy owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Barry & Denise Parow: 101 SW 11th Ave 4. Description of ViolationCar parts and debris in front of yard and along the side of the property. Grass over grown. 5. Date violation must be conected byMar 29, 2021 6. Date violation first obserued on or about1/20/21 Unless Respondent conects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you aze hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the � 3th day Aoril at 6:30 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Deparhn t. I u'1 to appear at the heazing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Persoa desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Depazhnent. In Accordance with Fla Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. 5uch an appeal shall be filed within 3� days ofthe execution ofthe order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE Znd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden adminis�ariva final a la tribunal de circuito . Ta] apelacion sera azchivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza. Exhibit 4 �- � m c� � 0 � � 0 0 Q 0 d � � � 0 ti a N `XYili.Jll `i y� -+'i � . ..'..:-3hi� ��s..�.w.a.... ,� . i,._ � . �(�' . .:.7 . 't- •. 't' • a _ C~� � � . _' � �� * F � � . ' . � . . ' :Y r' � r..:..-., .:. y:, , � l � r:.� _.�„ , �� ,:�;,.��.` �y�-- . � .. ,� a�[ . � .._, ,''�.�� 'lr �� ''� , a �l. ��. -- � d �_ , .�-:; �. _,�, ,�; - , � � r� '� �,;�.r s, w � � �� s�:. • - . `r� �"1 /"" � � , � �,`t .'� � ', . � g . . � , �� 3 . � �'ti'i M �i4 �i�� i � � d� � �4 ��. E . .. . ... � --��+�. iF... � . - , i % c� • Y M . .. , I ��1 � �'�� ^.eA - .+s. i.r r ]�i��.� �; bpv ,� .. � ';� _ � � s. i. , .., . 111�►'�'�"�.ti�li►."#I►.t��4 t' �'"; "`�• :,� w� - � - �,� '�►,�Il�r�rN�.�•# , � . ` i., . . , � � .' � r � . ,\ � �J x . � � �� , �� t �� ,l�� , ,'�g / , ' , , ,M ,��C, � � �r'f� y r+�. � M ;;, x ` j ,, � r '✓ /' `� . \/� �� f � � k , i; la � /'� M; :: A 1'e £ -3�t w . � �, . f � � � . / � T /� \ � • C r � r ; � �, �, �, � , , �/ � =� � �! r� / t,:.w:�A�� ,?K' . �`, �° �� \ _�.� ! \i'r _ r . ' � �►M"��-�.. �..� �,�� O�lU09U2`�,Oo`'I�1� 9��04� �■�:s�i �,'!�;i� i��1► � �� '�� \`, .t`� .l ! M.- [ , . F: ` O�100�0�� 0� ,:f"`� y�'= ,.t'`. �;�, J�: ;�'� .� Exhibit 4 -��...�Ok�eect'°bee CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Barry 8� Denise Parow 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 07/01 /2021 �RFo�,�EU FL: CASE NO. 210125009 S"I'ATENIENT OF VIOLIITION �ND NOTICE OF �:tF,AR1NG Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: Chapter 30 Section 30-43, 30-44 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:101 SW 11 th Ave 3-21-37-35-0170-00040-0110 3. Name and address of properly owner or person in charge of location where violation exists: Barry & Denise Parow: 101 SW 11 th Ave 4. Description of ViolationCarport needs to be cleaned and organized. 5. Date violation must be corrected by:Jul 15, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about1 /20/21 Unless Respondent corrects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby called upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 10th day Au4ust. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., Located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of taw as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department. If you fail to appear a e hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violation, & impose a fine in your absence. Anthony Smith Code Enforcement O icer Any Person desiring to appea] any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this heazing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magish�ate tapes aze for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enfotcement Depattment. In Accordance with Fla. Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved parry may appeal a final administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed within 30 days of the execurion of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Florida, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelar una orden adminishativa final a la tribunal de circuito . Tal apelacion sera azchivada en et plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelara. Exhibit 4 �- �- � � � � � � Q n 0 0 0 u-J � tl.l � fiJ � N Exhibit 4 ._ .�. f.�1 � � �� - Okeechobee Police De artm � � �� p ` 50 S.E. 2nd Avenue • Okeechobee, Florida 34974 _� � I 7�2� 245� �L100 5698 57,99 �� a� ��'i"��!'�`�?��F_::.ic3fF '� �`�� $006.96° ��, �'�.�'.�+� TIP 34�74 ' •�,�� . - Barry Parow Denise Parow 101 SW 11th Ave Okeechobee, FL. 34974 RyT_Rt�: '[[1 C�CN_?�� irJr• rVi=� ^ ..,_A� � i.! 1: P� .: �.. _. T V - ... . �. .i r'.... � v { � � � . . . . . . _. , t ' . 1 ._ R. ' '9 _ � r _ '� . ... %'�'w%4��'��"�y� _ . �,.. � , �` � � 1 � �'.. . . ' � ,: i ; � � ! � - , � Itespondent L1nl�ss Respond�t corrr�cts th� violatian d�scribed ��in, CH 30 Sec 30-�4. Geacrr�l el��t%� �r�d be�ut�tio�, e�rp�rt in need of ele�n'tn� aod. or�ana�ed. By the dat� set forth A�lI) conta�ts the under�i�ed Code lnspectar to verify compliaatce.11T0'fICE IS �REBY GIVEN tl�t the alleged violation (s) will be presented in City Councit Chambers, City H�II; SS SE 3'� Aven�e, Qkeecliot�e, FL on th€ day of At�ust 10, 2021, at 6:00 pm. Uat�d this 2 da of thc montfi of July the year of 2021. Sign 'Iitle �Q,de Enforcemeni Qf#ice� ��se 1Vumber: 21Ui2g009 Address: 101 SW 11�' Ave. City oi Okeeehobe� C�d@ C' flfol'Celrie�� 50 SE 2"� Avenue, O�rchobee, FL 34994 f63-763-9795 Exhibi�t 4 �� ,, ,{' �f:s.5t� . � R�'a � �$�� .. ,�. .� �..� .,� ,�y� ��,, .� ,, �� ^.� ` �~ ' �` ��"� 'l. �` ��'�� '�. '�,�' . � . �'�. . . , �,; `,� �►.�'►�' '\ � � ! ° � \ ".�. . _ � � , . , . �. . '� , � ``�. � � � ;�� '�� ,CCC' � `�; � �� , � �' ' �E ;G �� R J /� � � ,, �s�. .�i ; ``\J `` \�� ` � f M • }�l � / { '`� � �� .�` ' ,' � .i: . , f � / \��, ` .'::ff.. , �� ., .�� ` ' 1 ,� f , f/ .S �/ .., ..m_. ._..,... / a, � r �` ��;�� ; �. � � � ` • � �;: � �� ,. � , , i '� � � �.. '� � �l . Fr�� ::Y'*.:. :�' �{�' _�.xr'��7�':`'" :�'`f :L�t,� ��C., , + _ .. . ._ . ;...Ik!.)i' . �r�r . . .__ A�� , �� , �_-- t �p� � a ,�t y�,,�f ��a.� ; �;, � r � ",��",�, 1 _ � y: ,�S ��•. �.....w..ywi__ i� , 2 .: . . � V . ... -. � _ _ � '"y� � _ ��`,� e ,� � ,� t y% 7, � ..'� � ��. �,'� ,6' �� '� � � � f� � ' T �' 1 .��,�: '�� `� � ��, ��'�,,,��"��`��;: �u~ � �; � . _ ,�� ,��;: ` „ '. ��,. ,. a� d4.�i�� . ", :, � `' �Vy;'�� y� � �� rl. �if�iJ,. .. � � p!!�! � .�L� P� � � ." .�° � �p o � 0 " �%�L1Z� 1 � 8 �� " � � �-"�..`. ��'"�� __.....w�►��1'i♦c ��°��'�� . ,�°: ��/► � �.��'��"�� 4 " R - ' <,.: . � t . ' .. . J 1 �� , ' �, : �� a ,� 4 � ~ ^.�y.� • 1F,; � �r � ,� �, _ � _ �.. „._._,,,. k � r- � � � . ,- �'•, "` " � -T-'^.�..�,:,----- �:, c .�;� ..... ,� . i',,'�`,,�,�� s. , . . �*s ;8,, ,�4. ,�. , �f � � r �,,�� ; ,�r,� '�,.�,A��Ti w+at ►'� . b,,.., k►�i ��i �� A..�, . S��*`b � � � _. •.,,�. . ----� �. -- . ., . �s'f•�'�'�' -.t�*�+r�.�•� �. ��IIf+��1=��i�� f� ,�� t� i�1t��'��i�� t� ,t,�1ii�� /f 1,!�,,� � �'�A�� , `�� ' �, ., ��. r� -. �;. �+ O� J �4�J �0� � 1J U� U2� `a `� - ` � .rr.� � '<y.'� "�Y. .. `�� .' . :. . � � ' � .. :� '• K � , r .- �__ .,�=:a.', s,�- ""r� _ . � �.. sit'�`_._t.'.i�...._e- .._ �i, _ '!i � � � h �,.: 4 . � � � ! ��„�s k��} >', ,�y JI � `� � �a�'. n � „ � � i , �: � �' :. _.. . � .. . _._ _ . . � ..: .. ., , _. _ .. _. _ . _ _ �♦ � +6i��, . w_ws i(; � t� "4 �r � a � �y ..... ' w'.� � � `1 � i+�< . `� .w'4 � . ►_w g��t��w�,��'.�� . ��'`; :�=��Y �'�� M1,��A��.� ii-� 1 •' .� "' ��a.� r� � _ -',;r''+� ��w ; � 1+ �v♦` , , ` ;a��.�»� �,��,�;� ��a�,��,�� . � � � . .6 1. .iA .� � J ]�"F.��,.� . . Exhibi;i 4 �I � � . �� ,�. �� , �� ' u� _ . �= ,,� "�"""= , — �� . w � , , , ... . _ _ ...�,; . ; � �. , ,.� � ��4 � . . _ . _ . .� , ! � p:' �a �� f�� M' g� `�R�� - °* ,�� ,^�� . }�' a �� i 4 . � �� v�- - �°��'�/�'t� . ' w . � M `�►f �.*,. ` i'� 4 �`�� 'r.��;°' �� e" ..e�►�'•ti":.�,1�.�A � � . _. . .� � � :'�,,�w k_ . _,.. ;,,�:w:tiy"'.�� , , ��i i �' �..�wL�+,�e�s�,r,nj ` , '� f r0 . E��. Y p��.�,'r`{"�� y�� ' i ��`�� S`S ��I ,� : ��,� ��'._�,;-„.��`,��!a!,��ir� r! � .' w�'``'��'`�'�� . � � � !' � . � 0 o��J��O�� O�f� ,- ' '':.�� . �. .,� � .� �.. . _ .'r • :` . , ` � ' , • 't. ..� � � . 'w,,," -- .. Ye . � af.i - . _ • � � :-` � �� s . ; _ ,.' � ' `� . � � _�• .� �� .... _ � 4 cr :,, � . . . . . �a.�, .�. - t • a� - a`�.s.* • .�+., .'. �"'ir. �*G J�=. �'� — � f � � "` .� +' '�. � ��..-a �` �•...i �v . > ' . - .. .A. . ..� ��' � ... .. *y . • � . + , 6 . r� � _ � . � .. . " ..e !c . _ ' .,R e ' � .d�� •�.�i � ' " i . . . . • - _ - � .. � . _ 3A ..�...��..._�ba�d . �;. ,� Exhibit 4 53 VI. CONTINUED CASES CONTINUED B. Case No. 210599011; Freddie and Ruby Minton, 302 NW 8th Avenue [Legal Description: Lot 17, RIVER RUN RESORT, Plat Book 6, Page 18, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30- 41 Disabled vehicles and 30-32 Accumulations on real property Code Officer Smith reported thatthe property came into compliance on June 1, 2021. No action on this matter was requested but was noted for the record to have been in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-32 Accumulations on real property. VII. NEW CASES A. Case No. 210125009; Barry and Denise Parow, 101 SW 11th Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 11, 12, 13, and 14 of Block 4, SOUTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 2, Page 7, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification. Code Officer Smith testified that the property is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles and 30-44 General cleaning and beautification for inoperable vehictes and car parts all over the yard and carport. The property is not a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via United States Postal Service (USPS) regular mail on January 25, 2021. A Statement of Violation/Notice of Hearing (SOV/NOH) was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 15, 2021, for the April 13, 2021, Hearing. The City has not received the certified return receipt back as of this Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke w+th Mrs. Denise Parow on March 25, 2021, who advised that they will be cleaning up the yard and removing the vehicles next week. The property was inspected on April 5, 2021, April 27, 2021, and July 1, 2021. Code Officer Smith reported the property to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. However, the property owner has made progress by removing the large pile of debris and the inoperable vehicles. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on July 2, 2021, for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. It was returned unclaimed on July 28, 2021. The property was posted on July 27, 2021, with a Notice to Appear (NTA) for the August 10, 2021, Hearing. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Samantha Parow on July 27, 2021, who advised that they had received the posting in the yard and will be cleaning up the carport. Code Officer Smith inspected the property on August 4, 2021 and reported it to be partially compliant as the carport still needed to be cleaned/organized. Assistant Code Officer Curl spoke with Denise Parow on August 6, 2021, who advised they are still cleaning up the carport but needed more time. The City recommends an extension to the next Hearing be approved to allow the property owner the opportunity to come into full compliance. Special Magistrate Azcona deferred Case No. 210125009 to the next Special Magistrate Hearing to allow the propert}r owner more time to come into full compliance as progress has been made. B. Case No. 210125011; Sheila and Frederick Bradley, 204 SW 11th Avenue [Legal Description: Lots 1 and 2, East half of Lot 3 of Block 6, SOUTHWEST ADDITION TO OKEECHOBEE, Plat Book 2, Page 7, Okeechobee County public records]. Violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beaufrfication. Code Officer Smith testified that the property owner is in violation of Code of Ordinances Chapter 30, Sections 30-41 Disabled vehicles, 30-43 Public nuisance and 30-44 General cleaning and beautifcation for a trailer that is disabled in the City's ROW, a kitchen stove in the middle of the yard, trash, yard debris and junk all over the yard and carport. The property is a repeat violator. A Courtesy Card was mailed via USPS regular mail on January 25, 2021. Code Officer Smith spoke with Mr. Bradley on March 15, 2021, who stated that he would have the property in compliance by Monday. A SOV/NOH was mailed via USPS certified return receipt on March 23, 2021, for the May 11, 2021, Hearing. The City has not received the certified return receipt back as of the date of this Hearing. August 10, 2021, Special Magistrate Hearing, Page 3 of 5 Exhibit 4 ��Okj �eedlot�ee CODE ENFORCEMENT FOR THE CITY OF OKEECHOBEE, FLORIDA. Petitioner, vs Respondent, Barry & Denise Parow 863-763-9795 Phone 863-763-7804 FAX Date 09/03I2021 ��pOL�C f[n � j ' ,. � •��_ .. , ..FL'-.'� CASE NO. 210125009 ST��T�MEN"C OF VIOLATION AND NOTICL OF �I��IRING Pursuant to Florida Statutes 162.02 and 162.12, Florida Statutes, and the Code of Ordinances of City of Okeechobee, I(hereinafter the "City of Okeechobee), the undersigned Code Enforcement Officer hereby gives notice of an uncorrected violation of the City of Okeechobee Code, as more particularly described herein, and hereby requests a Hearing before the Okeechobee City Code Enforcement Special Magistrate. 1. Violation of City Code Chapter/Section: Chapter 30 SeCtion 30-43, 30-44 2. Address and Parcel# where violation exists:101 SW 11th Ave 3-21-37-35-0170-00040-0110 3. Name and address of property owner or person in chazge of location where violation exists: Barry & Denise Parow: 101 SW 11th Ave 4. Description of ViolationCarport needs to be cleaned and organized. 5. Date violation must be corrected by�Ct 1, 2021 6. Date violation first observed on or about� �2�/2 � Unless Respondent conects the violation described herein by the date set forth above AND contacts the undersigned Code Inspector to verify compliance, with the Okeechobee City Code Section(s) cited herein, you are hereby ca(led upon to take notice that a Hearing will be held in this cause before the City of Okeechobee Code Enforcement Magistrate on the 12th day October. 2021 at 6:00 P.M., located at 55 SE 3rd Ave Okeechobee City Hall, Okeechobee Florida 34974 in Council Chambers. The Magistrate will receive testimony and evidence at said Hearing and shall make findings of fact and conclusions of law as are supported by the evidence and testimony, and shall make an order thereupon. You are entitled to be represented by counsel, present evidence, and present testimony. Please be advised that any evidence presented to the Magistrate for his consideration will be retained by Code Compliance Department� If you fail to appear at the hearing the Magistrate may enter an Order of Violarion, & impose a fine in your absence. �i / r Anthony Smith Code Enforcement Officer Any Person desiring to appeal any decision of the Code Enforcement Special Magistrate with respect to any matter considered at this hearing will need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made and that the record includes fhe testimony and evidence upon wlsich the appeal will be based. Code Enforcement Magistrate tapes are for the sole purpose of back up for the official records of the Code Enforcement Deparhment. In Accordance with Fla Statute 162.11(2005), an aggrieved party may appeal a fmal administrative order to the circuit court. Such an appeal shall be filed wiUun 30 days of the execution of the order to be appealed. Okeechobee Police Code Enforcement 50 SE 2nd Ave Okeechobee Florida 34974 De acuerdo con la seccion 162.11 de los estatutos de la Floride, un partido que no esta en acuerdo puede apelaz una orden administrariva 6na1 a la tribunal de circuito . Ta] apelacion sera archivada en el plazo de 30 dias de la firma de la orden que se apelaza. Exhibit 4 n N m N �" _ � � � � 0 � O O �j'1 m 0 � fU 0 � , � � _�:r `.�� a �.: ' / � w i�„a........� o..,,.o.. v, ,.rr-r -' � � ❑ Retum RecoiDt Qierdoopy) S � ❑ Fetum Racdpt (eleclron�cJ S ❑��M��v�„ : �,�"a� [I Atluk Signature ReQulred a [j AduH SlgnaNre ResWcted DNlvery S 'O5[eg0 'otal Poafs� and Feea � �ent ��----------•---- liree nd C'- -- b` f��"---- - 0 [..�`---1- �---------- �-"-�'-----------------------..--- Exhibil'C 4 _. . . . _ / r. .. . t ..I.� S 1 - ._.f^ .� I t -`! ` - ii.' _ ._ � i � Dll�l � 1::- } l J_ • • ! _ :_ .: I � � • -:, .� ..' _. .', `:.�I�." / /% �a Nrmt your nama ai�a address on the reverse '� ��%��r '�� y�G t _ �A9ent so that we can return the card to you. /��/'"`v� � Addressee ■ Attach this card to the back of the maiipieCe, B• eceived by tP�rinted Name) C, Daie oi Delivery or on the front if space permits. %�''1 f� l`�/"�(''a `'_ � a � idress different from item 1? Yes Barry Parow � delivery address below: � No Denise Parow 101-=�-VV 11 th Ave Okeechabee, FL. 34974 �!��'') I'�� I'llllll �� II (I � I�II'I�I�� I I'�� 3' Service'fype ❑ PriorityMall Express0 ❑ Adu�c Signature ❑ Ragistered Mail I ❑ 6�duif Signature Restrictect Delivery ❑ Aegistered Mail RzstrictE �. � „� 1� Certified iViailO 7elwary .�':'�il� gL((�? ._� � o� OOQ3 5912 0? "j� Certiiied Mail Restricted Daliven,� -' Return �;ecaipt fer �� ❑ Collect on Deiivery idarchandise — n Delivery Restricted Delivery �� 9naturo CanfirmaitonT" 2. Articla Nnmha. rr �..�E^- �--- -- -' '' " rtrul '� Signature Gonfirrnation 7 0 21 � 3 5 0 � � � 1 511, 7 7 3 7 2 .,�� aaStr�� oeii��v Pastrictad Uelivery � (over $500) , PS Form 3811, July 2015 PSN 7530-02-000-9053 Domestic Return Receipt i= i', l� . ..� ; �. !1 ��'�`��i�� , ;�; : ,V; '��'," � .. ..,, . �� ,� �� . �� " ,� � � � . � �.:. �;� ,�� .;.i�i�, g. � � ,� � �_ `� r :i � r "�'�� 4 � �. �„�.., e , ` # �. �� p „ ..-...__. .— F _ � �� . . �s� "a'i.;1�.. - r� � .,s,. , . '� ►'�� `'�'.�►,�.r.�►i'r , ��. � �» , ��"`� � .�, ,.�,�, ��^f �• � . . �i ' ,�, �..,,: ,., , y_,w..w�, . sr. , .,r��v�j . ' � � , ` �- ,e �_ i . + � ► i ;�I�i , �� . �� ,�� ,�� .,, �r..,. � � i ` � � � � 4 � �.l � � � � ��' � � -� � �� t d� i` C � f � � � 1 i . r f' ( { i, �� : `��fi ) ..� . � �� < < � � .� � t , � o � o�oo�o�� . ; r�'� �'� , � — ` • � � �= „� s �, .�� wr�'.%` .._ .q � �,��.� �' .��? ` .�"II�� k-r4�: ,;�� .��g�►•-��„R.,�,�� _ �r''�.'� � p � � : y � . '� : �, �.�:�!►"w'„�� '►r".r:iir.`�r"t�lr;r►`` � �g^ , u�. i � . � �� '*,�...I1 � ,Y ki°� , ,L` yi�'�1r � ��'-�. �, �-`�:� �, ` ` ` �� :i Y�! i �� l'l = � s�— `� � . � . .. ' � r r ��i, ��'"�1 � � � � § + � � � `,��,. a k � f��Y �..� � ; + � ..��. ,� �' �� .� j € ` �sG� *: � � i� •. - a ..•.ft �- �.�r , x" ' �y ,r": r.�,: ,.: r � . _ �'`t� fp' �•. � �7�� "s. i � � �°�� Q �:`F:� ��'' , t �,,,� � �� ,. ., , ��:�`�� °'�`� .. . �' . '�� . �� . � � �'L ' �. � � . � � • - ,�1 �— :1��_��.i._ . �y ", aC r14.,N �. � . . � � � �q,_k Y,"'��h��t>4�.. �� .. . �� WR �; ' . . . vP8 ��,�,�K�` �, "�°,�!a�'iE ': � � e '�.. -x., , � � �t � _ _ - �"� �r �;�C -c — _,. ��• :,i, • � �� . � � � .� y'. '�" _ _ i .� /�r� �'u �� ' �r� ^,., � � _ .�,.. :'� ,. ;�. aw--�. �` � . �� - . ... _-.. � ' ^ . . ' ., .,.. > • �—+� - • � , aJ „"'� '� y. t: � tA.„� ,��..��+A. , . � ��, �''. - ,;� ^ _ � "��/' '�` ^ ,�°: �,�,„d r'� f ,,:� �`" .�., � ��► `' �a�,. � �� ,k�:,=: � .M � : ti .� �IMMo+e?' n � �' 3� 7 „'!"+6�'"1:� , ' t ll , : ,�.I ' �k � '� ��-��SU�%�U�� ) � � ...,; ; •,, � �" � k . -�.�, " a. � „� ��,,, 3�; � . ' � , <� .� . m �_ r , �_ . , z. _ . : ��. s. _�.,,.,._ __ � ,, Y`,�'� - .. . __ _. .m4:"k� "��.�� ; � � . �. .. - . � � , �_" , ' " -��._�-_ �� __� �- ._I' - _ , y,�. :+""„'�.'°.;,, . �'� . . � .�. . �i. � � - .•a a�7��:� . �:i:we�d`.c. - ... r.. _ .. ,:. • ....��_�� .. . . . • ��- �- . _ . . ... .. .'��.«:... . .. � +^� .«. .. ,:�.',i;.,�sr � � . .�r� _ � _ � � - � . � � . � . . � ` � � .' p�� _ �"r' , . _ - ' `t:. _ ;.. . . � �sM �a . 0°��0��0�� d�� i'�` Exhibit 4 � ; ti . . � - . __ ... � � `'°" •;^,�t-a t.. ., a .r. i 'a�*a�»k�rw.M.� � �" �� .. � d �� ✓ d . .. _. . u,.s.. ,.,w„�'�.e'J.:ba,.; .. . . + .`�, ta .. . . � i . ..: .�.:.. � .. . ,..� . :,. -. . . ^^ , .:. , _. , �. „ ,�; �ta.�.,. . � . ....;. .,. � ,. ,w , '-��«�wn,_ ..�. . � . ,._..r.,._. � , ... _ . . y' . - � , �„F -`-�`�""" � �� '""'""" _�.....�n -ma� ... .�. .., . : . ,� `. �� ...' , . -- �. F �+��.a�.w. �.7 . � ��r".",. , �, :.,.. '3; .� - ; ,w�. -��,,, � . , . . . :� ,� . .. . � s ,D � 1 '��. '�.� � a � `~ �—l��I�l�r� �F , �,�p � W� � �! ,d� �. �� , �,��, ��,,/ � . I . � " e�. . . . r»% � � :I .�.. �� . ��.+'' �"'�", � t�: t `�i .. � s ., :... � .,� . . «:� � � a -{ •1{k a . J�y�. �� , � � __ ..,,ee�� , � 5 t f,! � �i : ,�(.t d'P.:.. A��. i .. . . . � � %�`? �. , ., .;.� 1 �; .�. �'�Iv :; �'�\ � �� . � ^� +Y'�'� � � .,, �� . � �a . � ' .. �,� . ei � r � , � § . �;g,.�r,� f' �" � , �� 4 . . . . .. : �.. .. . . .. �r..v.. w� � . s . _. , , . � � , � : �',�."�6�`4�'�'r�`�<' `�w.Rwl�! +� � � � �i�.�+F�'+h.'��,t� - �� ` � ,� � '9i.`ii w ; r i ' i� i j � / j�� .. FlM4 CJ � �:'! t� � 1 � � l� `�� 6° 1 1 J,, ,a e�. i�...� � � �' , .. ; _� �..■..��- Exhibit 4 ,� - -- ,,� ``i � ' '"�" �' � �� h, , � �� .�� '�� " "� nr;:-, 'F�'�a'°"'''6,; r,�l.r: "' `�: ,•, , ' _�;,.. , �;.:.ti i`Y o ' a,,,'`; � ,'"� -�� , - ;f'.".. '�f"• .K�`-��` . » a ...i _ Y fi� - - :.t.: �. I "",.r � ; . -' .... . . a'�. . ��+. � - ' � ' . .... .. . _ . .Y�?r:. 90DOg0�� 9 �3 a �10 , —.-, �. � . ,.,,,�-q ,.. , "w . . . . — .. . .r-�ta- +'., . � � ll oO�JOLSOLS� � � " Il0 na: �. '� ,yr'. � ,,�: �,�►�i.i�4�°��`��•`� - .. . `"�